Build your professional network on facebook via our app Go to app
 
 
 
Created by : vijay raut, CEO/MD/Director, Synergy Marketing Advisory Services  | 06 03 2009 13:00:04 +0000
Industry : FMCG/Foods/BeverageFunctional Area : Leadership Styles(People Management)
Activity:  1936 views;  last activity : 07 06 2010 20:18:09 +0000

Now that the elections are over, the kings in place and the heir apparent's, apparent the question arises - Are leaders born or made.

Looking at history, three of the greatest leaders - Gandhi, Churchill and Hitler did not belong to any political family. Yet their status as leaders and their impact on history is undeniable.

Then why is it that in the current indian melieu we have the mantle of leadership being passed on from father to son and the same being accepted nay justified by supporsetely educated intelligent individuals. This is true in both politics and business. Are we incapable, as a nation to nurture, recognise and acknowledge true leadership?

 
 Refer 14
Share
 
 
  Rate : 
 
 
Born Vs Made
11
 
 
 
 
37
9
23
Support   Support
Top Argument
2
0

I agree that leaders emerge given a situation. But the fact is that such a situation is given very easily when one is born in a political family. For others, the path to politics will be little difficult. They have to sustain their own during the initial period. These leaders listed above were such great persons who could sustain those early stages. For those born in a political family, the base is already set and they are under the direct guidence of leaders from the childhood itself which is again helpful.


By Shaju George, Facilities/Construction Manager, IBS Software Services (P) Ltd  06 03 2009 13:22:03 +0000
 
Top Argument
9
0

There is so much that can be said about whether leaders are born or made and there has been much debate about it. Some people are born to move and shake the world; they may have great intelligence and a yearning to influence others.

Some would say that leadership qualities are innate or genetic and thus impossible to learn. Our potential for leadership is determined by a combination of genetic predispositions, psychological development and socialization experiences.

Leaders are born with potential. So it is the potential you are born with, not full scale leadership.

But the critical leadership trait is the courage to stand up and be counted, it’s a little like creativity, you might have it in a small amount, rather than large doses, but you either have it or you don't.

You can be born with the underlying traits that make you a potential leader given the right stimulus and environment. But I would have to say a mixture of the two but mostly improved upon or made.

Leadership skills can be developed and mastered; because a truly great leader is made greater through his/ her trials and tribulations. When one takes the time to learn from their or others past successes, mistakes and failures then implement needed changes that alone can lead to success in leadership.  

Failures can be turned into "how to succeed next time". Even if an heir is given a leadership role, then he/ she must work at becoming the best that they can be in that position.   

Simply what got you into a leadership role may not be enough to keep you there or get you to the next level. Some people that are in a position where their achievement or being given the position of leadership requires the support of others can play the role of a leader.

Leaders that participate in developmental programs can receive feedback from others & the follow-up with others can make them greatly become better leaders. If you are working with and through others to achieve objectives, you are already a leader.

Whether they are fantastic leaders or disastrous leaders is another issue.

With that said, depending on someone’s intelligence, aptitude & abilities, being a leader with leadership skills can be developed and mastered.


By Business Management Consultant, Business Management Consultant, Business Management Specialist & Strategic Planner  06 26 2009 18:56:25 +0000
0
1

Depends on family background,circustances,and environment surrounding the fellow of would be leader.


By SB DIKSHIT, STATE QUALITY MONITOR, U.P.R.R.D.A  | 08 06 2009 12:47:36 +0000
1
0

Leaders are BORN!

There are soem basic qualities that you can see in a person from his growing days and thats what makes his mentors look at the child differently. Preferential treatment is obvious and then you groom such people to become leaders!

Quality to lead is in born but eventually to get the TAG of being a leader is earned in the big bad world! You need to prove your qualities to get that tag!! What I want to ask here is that just because a rookie has the power to bring back the dead on a chess board have we been able to name it a knight??? A Knight remains one and a rookie remains one thats because the qualities that both posses are completely different in its attributes and its understood intelligence. Its the case of Sachin Tendulkar. He is an amazing player, has all the qualities of being the numero uno in his field of expertise but is he a good captain??

In case of Dada, he too has qualities of a great sportsman, but he had what it took to lead and his equation as a captain shows it!!

Leaders are BORN! Gandhiji was not groomed to be a leader, he chose to lead by taking the nitiative and he did it!!


By Makrand Bhave, Marketing & MICE, WIZCRAFT International  | 06 19 2009 10:51:54 +0000
1
0

I personally think that leaders are BORN n NOT MADE.A leader has sum in built quality which can not be taught.One can teach you how to speak, how to tackle but no one can teach you how to be unique amongs other so that others follow n listen to you just not because u are their leader but with respect n affection.

A Born leader has something special in them. there way of communication n handling situations etc.Somethings comes naturally, and natural things are the best.


By MD ASIF JAMAL, Staffer  | 06 19 2009 05:26:53 +0000
0
0

I agree that Leaders are Born, as they have the easy access like being from the particular family, it is always easy for them to follow the same path that all the great leaders as their elders had set as an example, and at times situation also plays one to take responsible and be a leader and lead the way, but most of them are born as leaders...


By Gargi Sinha, Senior Consultant, Hewitt Associates  | 06 04 2009 11:55:24 +0000
1
0

"Some men are born great, some achieve greatness and some have greatness thrust upon them". Same goes for some leaders they are born in a family of where the dynasty is passed down and it is expected that they will perform even better than the previous leaders.

However, in the Indian context I think I am aware that India is a democratic country and as such elections are carried out and a government is formed based on who is adjudged the winner whether by majority or by colaition. A person does not make himself a leader , so if by chance a leader who is selected comes from a family of leaders then there is two reasons for this (1) the people want  him there and (2) it is by mere coincidence he has attained that position.


By Devi Kaladeen, Audit Manager, Health Sector Development Unit  | 06 03 2009 17:33:17 +0000
1
0

GREAT LEADERS R BORN.......MEDIOCRE LEADERS can be made.......... and BAD LEADERS can grow up ANYWHERE...........GREAT LEADERS CHANGE THE WORLD...........MEDIOCRE LEADERS run the country........and BAD leaders spoils everything.....


By Yogendra Singh Chauhan, Civil Engineer-Highway Roadway, AECOM  | 06 03 2009 16:06:40 +0000
0
0

GREAT LEADERS R BORN.......MEDIOCRE LEADERS can be made.......... and BAD LEADERS can grow up ANYWHERE...........GREAT LEADERS CHANGE THE WORLD...........MEDIOCRE LEADERS run the country........and BAD leaders spoils everything.....


By Yogendra Singh Chauhan, Civil Engineer-Highway Roadway, AECOM  | 06 03 2009 16:04:55 +0000
1
0

Although this may sound pessimistic or a trite politically incorrect, strong leaders are surely born. Buddha, Mahaveer, Ashoka, Vikramaditya, Krishna Deva Raya, Churchil, Ambani, Lok Manya Tilak, Sunil Mittal, and so on - had/have leadership in their genes - so as to say. OH! YES!! MANAGERS CAN BE MADE - but pure strong leaders - it requires a lot more than making - the leadership 'bread' should be there in the person!

www.pharmaceuticalshealthcare.blogspot.com


By Sunil S Chiplunkar, General Manager - Marketing & Training, Juggat Pharma, Pharma Div of Jagdale Ind Ltd., Bangalore  | 06 03 2009 13:43:32 +0000
0
0

Leaders are made not born. When a new born baby step into the world his mind is totally blank. When he see the things around, he start interect with it . New born or a small plant are same the more u feed the more they grow . So, tomorrow's leader is today's baby. Depends on us how to mould and give a good shape that decide the leadership of the baby.


By Satpal Yadav, Freelancer, Freelancer  | 02 02 2010 07:52:45 +0000
0
0

ANY ONE WILL BE THE LEADER ONLY THROUGH HARD WORK 

Leaders are to come from people, not from their parents. nobody is born miracle persons only in some exceptional cases . leaders should born not from parents, from people, it would be possible only if/she creates awareness in any field through creativity or any leader ship qualities BY MAKING HIS/HER STEP AS FRONT STONE.  so always leaders are made by the people around them, by seeing their leadership qulities.


By purna chandra rao . s, B.E.,M.B.A  | 12 23 2009 12:30:53 +0000
0
0

Leaders are made, a person who learn through his experience, & consider the collection of mistakes as experience  - the ladder to success


By Joe Cherian, an MNC  | 08 07 2009 11:49:00 +0000
0
0

No matter there are cases are Dhirubhai Ambani who was born leader but that doesn't mean every one can't be like him,proper training and mental strength is only thing required or else MBA colleges would not have been there. Even a man like Ambani failed so many times in his early days.He learned from his mistakes.Thats called "EXPERIENCE" which is necessary in every field.In the same way, a fresh MBA graduate takes training under professionals, gains experience and slowly becomes successful in his life.


By Nikhil Jain, Senior Consultant, Hewitt Associates  | 08 06 2009 15:06:23 +0000
0
0

Leaders are of course born


By Gargi Sinha, Senior Consultant, Hewitt Associates  | 08 06 2009 14:56:51 +0000
0
0

Leadership can be situational and based on circumstances.  Every leader cannot be born, most of them are made.


By Hari Prasad K, Head - Managed Services & IT Solutions  | 08 06 2009 11:40:46 +0000
1
0

I believe that people who comes under influence of leaders, becomes leaders!
All are born, but few are made.. and that few are those who came under the exposure of such activites. It happens by choice..

For others, they are Born leaders..! somewhat like Grapes are sour!

 


By Satwinder Singh, Program Manager, Confidential  | 07 06 2009 13:08:54 +0000
1
0

very much hard fact - leaders are made. leadership is just nothing but the person who can sell him/herself well is a good leader.

as everyone in this world is a sales person but the skills and training are the only things which can make him/her as leader.


By Satyadeep , Branch Manager/Regional Manager, Kewalram Group  | 06 24 2009 09:23:04 +0000
1
0

If we read history, we will find only one quality for a leader---

Decide to be One - A person decides to be a LEADER

And rest all is crap


By Jairam Gopalan Aiyer, CEO/MD/Director Writer www.insuranceworld.co.in, Ajvmm Creative Solutions  | 06 19 2009 18:54:21 +0000
1
0

Circumstances make a minnow in to a leader we have Mahatma as example , also Winston Churchill.

Difficult and challenging times bring best of us as we have no alternate except to face and find solutions.


By Phani Mohan krishna, Head/VP/GM- Purchase/Material Mgmt, ANAGHA DATTA TRADE  | 06 19 2009 17:15:45 +0000
1
2

HAHAHA very big joke.  Gone are those days leaders were born.  Now-a-days leaders are made by the rowdies & corruptions, for the rowdies and corruptions and finally of the rowdies and corruption (simple definition of democracy).  If one has become a leader in this country, he must have two or more wives, must be involved in rape cases, murders, hooliganism, mask thief, etc.etc.,  This is the shortcut for becoming a leader.  Hope you can now understand leaders of the present day are only made not born.

the leaders who born in the yester years had gone.


By V.Chandramouli , Admin/Facilities Manager, Saimira Associates  | 06 19 2009 11:34:59 +0000
0
0

Has every one forgotten the word DETERMINATION.

Leders are the one who achieve their goals what may come..

So no ones a born leader.


By praveensomareddy , Sr. BDE, Enteg Infotech Pvt Ltd  | 06 19 2009 08:31:14 +0000
1
0

Leaders are borned, but most of the leaders have come up by hard & smart work. Mister Gandhi was not a leader, by profession he was lawyer. But he turned to a successful leader bcz of his dedication & hard work. He has never given a long speech to get attrection of croud, he just do what was in favour of public and he become father of nation. And there are many more. 

And there are many more,


By sachin , Team Leader -(NonTechnical), Infor Global Solutions  | 06 19 2009 07:03:16 +0000
2
0

“Leaders aren't born, they are made. And they are made just like anything else, through hard work. And that's the price we'll have to pay to achieve that goal, or any goal.”

 


By Paresh.Khanchandani , FCD Business Manager, ExxonMobil Company India Private Ltd.  | 06 19 2009 06:04:20 +0000
1
0

leadership is something which everyone can learn.for example people born in families of leaders learn a great deal of leadership qualities without much efforts because they see it everyday and for them it is possible.

those who are not born in families of leaders have to learn it hard way.

leadership is socialising,leadership is to be there with people when they need you.leadership is being in a position to spent your time for others.leadership is so much about giving then taking.so you shoul dbe in a position to give.

leadership is there in all aspects of our lives..so everyone is a leader in there own way may be just a bit but everyone has those qualities,few are polished leaders..others are to be leaders or do not exert there leadership qualities.if you are leading a family you are a leader in some way.if you are leading a team you are a leader in some way.there is this qualities within us we need to be aware of it.


By sandesh saboo, Research Associate/Analyst, saboo associates  | 06 19 2009 05:43:37 +0000
1
0

Though a very few people have a inbuilt qualities of leader by birth, I sitll believe the consequences in the life makes a person more and more stronger towards the leadership qualities.


By Prashanth Loke, Technical Consultant, Frontier Business Systems  | 06 19 2009 05:35:22 +0000
0
1

when a child is conceived in the womb of the mother those 9 months , i am repeating these 9 months matter a lot.

the birth of a leader is planned well before conception , he is eventually trained in the womb and later on during the formative years.

thereafter its brains software is tested in the market, and some survive and become great leaders and some just crash during the test run.


By Ajay Ziz, Dy. Registrar,, University of Jammu  | 06 19 2009 04:52:50 +0000
0
0

Most leaders come to the fore due to a situation or a critical problem affecting a large mass.  Gandhi would never have been a Mahatma + Gandhi had he not been thrown out the train in South Africa.  What IF Christ decided to double cross the CROSS ? What if the saint never saw the old people, the funeral. What if US did not slavery around the mid 1800s ? - Lincoln would have still been a would have been President fighting for a Fifth term.  In India, Jaiprakash Narayan became acknowedged a leader only after he cross 80, and that too due to the Emergency !  Datta Samant was a Doctor.

Nehru did just what Shah Rukh did. Stuck on to Gandhi and the Congress - like sticking onto the Chopras and a particular imagery about his persona. The classes he already had in the INC, the masses he got by hanging around Gandhi. The luck factor where all the Freedom   fighters died by 1950 helped.

So those out there, Name any leader - I am the eternal IconoClast :-))). It is just a matter of scratching history a little deeper than what you are told or presented in your classroom ...

After all, there is an Opposition leader as well ...


By Alexander Lewis, Marketing Manager, self  | 06 15 2009 16:10:44 +0000
1
0

The society he lives in makes him. The time circumstances maketh a man. you see any entrepreneur he is bitten by some or other problem to reach to the top. He doesnt say i was motivated since childhood. He may be intelligent since childhood.


By sujit Kumar, Marketing Manager, Wipro Peripherals  | 06 12 2009 09:34:51 +0000
0
0

How can leaders be born, leaders are made, even if they are born from a family of past leaders, untill and unless he is pushed to take up that, so leaders are made in due course of time or some situations lead to take leadership during some point of time in his or her life, so according to me leaders are made and not born...


By Mitesh Gupta, Sales/BD Manager, Reliance Retail  | 06 04 2009 11:59:27 +0000
1
0

Leaders are made and the defining qualities in aleader are

1. Having a clear vision and mission of the Aim objective and goal

2. Being passionate about it

3. Ability to convey the Aim Objective Goal down the line

4. Be enthusiatic and also act as a source of motivation by leading from the front

5. Be ethical, transparent and balanced in his approach to decision making

One can be born with a silver spoon but that does not act as guarantee of being a strong successful leader inspite of being in an advantageous position, but by possessing such qualities one can make a mark for oneself and surely become a leader on his/her own right.

Examples of great leaders

Nelson Mandela, Desmond Tutu, Margaret Thatcher, Lala bahadur Shastri, Biju Patnaik, Narayanmurthy, Sunil Mittal, L N Mittal etc....

Well my guess about the genes of these people is as good as yours that is they have etched out a path for themselves as great leaders.


By DEVRANJAN DASH, Zonal Marketing Manager, ICICI Bank  | 06 03 2009 19:14:32 +0000
5
0

I have always believed that leaders emerge given a situation. There is some thing deep within them that compels them to take charge and act. They have a deep self belief and a commitment to the cause they espouse. They are willing to gamble their very existence for their beliefs. They are great motivators and are capable if inspiring the masses to their cause. 

Can a person who has inherited "leadership" display the same traits? I think not.


By vijay raut, CEO/MD/Director, Synergy Marketing Advisory Services  | 06 03 2009 13:00:04 +0000
India's Leading executive search firm
Viewers also viewed
With over a decade in the new mellinium.  There has been a major change over in every aspect of...
 
300 referals 8 arguments, 195 views
To highlight the brand why there will be at least a Girl with brand promoting T-Shirt. Why not...
 
0 referals 16 arguments, 656 views
Income tax : First they said anyone who has annual income upto 5 lacs will not have to file IT...
 
1910 referals 17 arguments, 473 views
more...  
Recent Knowledge (4)
WE HAD A GOOD NUMBER OF INVENTORS WITH GREATER VISION ABOUT THE SOCIETY. INVENTORS HERE NEED NOT...
 
2 referals 2 arguments, 97 views
C vs B
 
0 referals 3 arguments, 51 views
MNC's should take in more freshers vs Do not take freshers
 
1 referals 2 arguments, 161 views
more...  
More From Author
This is really a non issue. The consumer is influenced through various means of communication both ATL and BTL. However, if this is not packaged to attract his attention then all efforts would be down the drain. Once attention is grabbed and desire...
No it is not the only route and may not be the easiest / cheapest route. It largely depends on the situation at a given point of time. Let's understand - strategies are based a realistic assessments of your weaknesses and the strengths of the...
Priyanka, 1. I don't support the idea of censorship. As a nation are we mature or immature? If we are immature and incapable of making decisions then we must have BIG BROTHER watching over us telling us what 2 do and what not 2 do. 2. There are no...
more...