Can private E-schools and B-schools beat the IITs, IIMs?

Being very frank the levels of education in IIT's & IIM's is falling at a rapid rate today, and their are good private institutes which preferred now a days by people against IIT's & IIM's and if HRD minister is going to force a few more unwanted minorities pointers to the Bills passed, then only GOD can help IIM's & IIT's in near future.

KAR KHUD HI KO BULAND ITNA, KI HAR TAKDEER SE PEHLE, KHUDA APNE BANDE SE KHUD POOCHE... BATAA, TERI RAZAA KYA HAIN !

YES... Private Schools & Institutions can rise up, to beat or equal the IIT's & IIM's...    BUT ?

They have to RISE IN STANDARD & STATUS... above par, to be able to do this. It calls for a lot of character & devotion & the will power to stay away from just MAD MONEY MAKING.

Happy Debating Friends !

There are three things to justify this....

1. Excellent Infrastructure,

2. World class pedagogy & teachers,

3. Quality batch-like top students that too from different platforms, experiences, background & education.

I feel with these three any institute can become international class.

Seeing the current percentage of reservation, in all government run and aided education facilities as well as job scenario, it’s the only refuge left for the deserving few.

Mr.Natteraja Tnx for ref.

Why not??

Thanks for the referral Mr. Arikrishnan :)

Yes they can. There will be lot of change in the years to come. The private universities/schools will create competition. The existing universities should change the policies to survive and compete the new schools to come. For example universities like BITS, XLRI, ISB, NALSAR, MAHE,VIT, UPES etc have already proved their existence in the private sector. In certain cases students prefer these universities/schools than IIM/IIT etc.Because there is no alternate people are prefering IIT,IIM,NIT etc.

It may taken two to three years to establish themselves, once they are full established the actual results start reaping. These universities/schools should kept out of reservation criteria to prove their talent. Further these institues should change the education culture of India from book/class room oriented  to more practical oriented

I agree with Mr.Asoke Kusari and Mr.Prodosh Sen up to some extent and they are correct. But not all the private E/B schools, and there are good B/E schools in our country. But they are charging heavily and students from middle class can not afford.

Now the Right To Education gives birth for nationalization of education. This can successfully be implemented through participation of joint venture between Private & Government. All the norms to be adopted & basic infrastructure are possible under this collaborations across the country. 

All children have the right to education and can not be denied. But, I do not know whether i am right or wrong, [ may be advised] only intelligent students can gain entries into IITs and IIMs. For example, the Premier Institutions have laid down certain norms for selection, may be of those who have scored 1000 marks and above. On the contrary, those who have scored marks between 700 to 999 can not be treated as not intelligent. Scoring high marks comes from mere rote memory.Hence others should also be given enough opportunity to showcase their efficiency and intelligence. The degree of efficiency and ability vary from individual to individual.   

definitely it happens , see the ISB hydrabad. Private and beating the all the colleges in india.

There is nothing great about IITs and IIMs anymore. Agreed that at one time they were great and served the need of the hour. Not any more. They have been diluted and poretty much destroyed. They are now as good or as bad as any other institutions.

I have always believed that the students make the institution. If the students and teachers partnership works out, there are no heights an institution cannot achieve. But let it be noted, it must be a synchronised partnership.

Yes,

The case in point is BIT, Pilani, in case of TechSchools.  And ISB, SPJAIN, XAVIOURS, IBS, et al, in case of B-Schools.

You are absolutely correct Mr.Namrata. The private E/B schools can beat the IITs & IIM provided, in case they follow the best practice of academic to create the high caliber in students capacity/ability.

Regarding private E / B Schools Beat the IITs / IIMs. It is not the competition between one institution and the other. Any institution they should follow the best practice and what is required for the for the present generation and work with leading companies and to achieve the best result.

K Rajagopalan.   

It is common knowledge that the sectors that have done well in the post-liberalization era are the ones in which the government has had little or no role to play. This applies to education as well. There is nothing wrong with the IIMs or IITs. Just as a matter of information, I graduated from one of the IITs. Unfortunately, these institutions of national eminence are riddled in politics and one-upmanship. Sometimes, one gets the feeling that these institutions feel they can do no wrong. Do a simple search of research productivity from these premier institutions. They are nowhere in the picture. They are living on past glory. Institutions, whether private or public, that can have the autonomy to adopt the best practices, have the humility to accept that we have a long way to go, and who have human resources with a passion for service, will excel. They will become world-class. Those that are looking only at the short-term or at education as a lucrative business will fall by the wayside.

It will. But not now after 10 years as now it is 50% reservation in india,after it will be 70% reservation in india,so meritious will go to the private sectors than the iit,iims. There will be lack of competion between students in the IIT,IIM so private will beat them in near future. The cream of talent is weeded out from Our colleges because of reservations and it is for sure that these univ. will be their next option and we all know students are the backbone of any institute