it's not a bad step by any means but there are few things to be taken care of...the interest of indian universities should be the first priority, foreing universities should operate under the indian supervision, and such universities should not make any loss to our domestic universitie's financial system..
By
RAMAN , LEGAL, KAPSONS AGENCIES (P) LTD.
| 07 14 2011 16:51:08 +0000
yes definetaly we should allowing foreign university due to effect of that our education system and level will be updated and we have to get the benefit of latest tech what they are adopted in edu sector.
By
piyush yadav, Project Manager, Sintex industries ltd
| 07 26 2010 10:11:32 +0000
Yes I think the forign universities should be in India to make the education entertaining and interesting along with rasiing the standered of education.
By
Rathin Deb, Freelance Retail Consultant
| 06 26 2010 07:36:01 +0000
Yes I fully support the foreign universities in India. Atleast the universities will bring the new envirnment and new education, culture and as well as strict parametre. Atleast the degrees may not be available at prices like in private universities in India.
By
Jyoti CHETANI, Freelancer, Equity Research/Analytics
| 06 25 2010 15:14:59 +0000
yes for sure, we should welcome foreign universities to set up their campuses here which helps India in retaining talent pool as students are flying every year for higher studies to different countries to experience the difference. So with this students can stay back and continue studying in foreign universities. This as well helps in improvising our universities' syllabus to gain advancement.
By
Greeshma Reddy, Regional Marketing Manager, eInflexion Pte Ltd
| 06 17 2010 05:45:07 +0000
There is nothing in allowing foreign universities in India as these universities are having maximum students which are Indian and that too after spending a huge amount of money. At least same level of studies shall be available here and will also create additional employment for deserving.
By
Vishal Jindal, Head - Operations, Globe Automobiles Pvt Ltd
| 05 19 2010 18:21:21 +0000
I think this should be viewed in the wider context of deregulation of education and allowing greater choices in terms of curriculum and achievement. While these reforms will not bring in top universities into India as promised, it will very likely expand the choices and create a more competitive landscape for private education. I also see this move bringing greater initiative to hitherto neglected areas, like vocational training. So, overall, I think we needed to do this, and the governement has done the right thing by pushing through the bill.
References :
Sunday Posts: Foreign Universities in IndiaSep 15, 2009 ... It is possible to have a 100% foreign owned education institute in India. Besides, as many as 150 foreign universities already offer degree ...sundayposts.blogspot.com
By
Supriyo Chaudhuri, Chief Academic Officer, London School of Accountancy & Management
| 03 22 2010 20:22:04 +0000
Yes & why not. Our own erstwhile great political leaders went out of India to study abroad & contributed later to the cause of India's freedom. Even today, undoubtedly their offerings in varied fields are unmatchable in course curriculum, campus & standard of life in those countries which ignited a lot of brain drain in the past. Ironically, these foreign universities have always attracted foreign students than their own countrymen. There are more than hundred Govt. universities who even do not have proper websites & curriculum in these universities are outdated & out of what is required by the Employers(mostly private ) in the present situation. Simply put, despite hue & cry, allowing foreign universities into India would only benefit India & the Indians by 1.Stopping the Indian brain drain.After all, who wish to leave one's own country ? 2.Will create competition between foreign & Indian universities resulting into a more "industry integrated & acceptable course curriculum. 3. India is a huge & untapped market in all sectors to foreign players whether education or plethora of jobs in a number of segments. India has every potential to offer openings in almost every field of study, careers or job as it is a huge country with plenty of manpower. With the coming of foreign universities into India, Off course there will be confrontations between Indian cultural ethos & their but think, this can be brought to control by means of some regulating authority.
By
NAVEEN RAJ, CEO, JOB GUROO CAREERS
| 03 19 2010 15:45:00 +0000
Dear, the quality students still come from IITs or IIMs. Atleast 50% of students who are not previlaged to get addmission through quota are having that much of talent which is enough to compete with other foreign university pass-out.
By
mahendra kumar, Design Engineer, mecon
| 03 19 2010 08:33:32 +0000
It would be better for all of us but there should be some boundation on them to spread the education in the interest of country not for earning money.
By
Nem Singh, Consultant, Consultancy Firm
| 03 18 2010 07:32:04 +0000
This is a step in the right direction for the development of education sector in our country. There are people who cant afford a degree from foreign universities due to the cost involved in education and cost of living abroad. If they setup institutes in India , these may become accessible at affordable rates and might be a boon. Also there are parents who dont wish to send their only sons are daughters away from them.
By
Krishna , Program Analyst, Cognizant
| 03 18 2010 05:13:59 +0000
Truly, a good move. Its certainly moving into the right direction as the education providers in India have taken the masses for a ride for quite some time now! With this competition, these so called TOP Univ's locally will have to pull up their socks and offer courses, infra etc., at par or better. Bottom line, everyone has the right to choose their need for education to road to success & with this initiative the many doors have opened.
By
Berzin N. Sethna, Sr. Vice President & Head New Initiatives - Technical & Functional Domain in BFSI at KCS
| 03 18 2010 02:07:42 +0000
It's indeed a good step. It will open the door for students who want/ deserve good education but unable to get due to quota system, financial problem, availability of seats ( In IIT one need 99.3% to get the admission). In Delhi 70% of students getting 80% marks attend mediocre college, due to non availability of seats. At least this will provide platform for students who want to compete with IIT'ans and FMS students. It will also help students aspiring for foreign degree.
By
Himanshu Jha, Head/VP/GM-Client Servicing, Crayons Advertising Limited
| 03 17 2010 12:43:38 +0000
history has shown that in most cases cautious opening up of sectors has helped indian counterparts to perform well. With foreign universities coming here, we will get the best of indian talent staying back in india and getting a global degree - apart from working closely with industries in the environs of these institutions.. ....its a win-win for everyone.. students get global options in india, top class researches get patrons, international teaching systems come to india.. ...except that the cost of education is likely to go up. but, i guess if you need employable graduates, you need to spend more / borrow more... ...also, since the cost of education will go up, a trend of pursuing higher education after working & saving for a few years may also start... creating a whole new social order in 15 - 20 years time..
By
aakrosh sharma, CEO/MD/Director, greenlink agri products and commodity pvt. ltd
| 03 17 2010 10:30:21 +0000
Gaurav, I understand your concern of fund drainage. But just think about how the Companies in India will be pushed to think beyond IIMs and IITs and get an opportunity to hire a Yale or Harvard grad, here in India. More quality students, means more opportunities for youth to bring fresh investments in India.
By
Kaushik Nandi, Senior Consultant, Capgemini
| 03 17 2010 10:18:10 +0000
It is a good decision. So far, all Indian universities are saying they are top on different aspects. Now all the Indian universities have to compete with the foreign universities. Definitely this improves the quality in the higher education.
By
Kumara Swamy, Project Associate, IIIT-H
| 03 17 2010 10:14:27 +0000
Thousands of Indian students go to the U.S., Britain and Australia among other countries, every year, to study in foreign universities. The effort is part of the central government's continued focus on education reform. Sibal, who sounded elated Monday, has been pushing for this since he took over the ministry last year. The minister, too, has been in touch with several top universities in the U.S. and Britain about such a move. Among the foreign universities likely to set up shop in India are Boston University, Harvard and Yale University from the U.S. The meagerly paid professors at the country's top academic institutes may soon be poached by foreign universities after the government cleared a proposal to allow foreign universities to set up campuses in India. This step is expected to provide quality education in the country and reduce the flow of Indian students abroad The bill, which will now be tabled in parliament for its approval, has provisions to regulate the entry and operation of foreign institutions, which will set up campus and offer degrees in India. "This is a milestone, which will enhance choices, increase competition, and benchmark quality," Human Resource Development Minister Kapil Sibal said after a cabinet meeting chaired by Prime Minister Manmohan Singh.
By
santoshlal , Program Manager, Wigan & Leigh College (WLC)
| 03 17 2010 08:30:58 +0000
i definately agree with you neelima it really helps to improve our indian education system..and at this point of time we really need a value education.
By
Gaurav Malviya, Manager, bentley systems
| 03 17 2010 08:10:24 +0000
hi sunil,this is Gaurav....i think foreign univerties can maintain there level of education in India also because each & every institution have there own criterias to give value education.In India also, you can not compare IIT to any local college....the same thing applies to foreign uni.,and really this is the great step taken by our govt.
By
Gaurav Malviya, Manager, bentley systems
| 03 17 2010 08:05:39 +0000
Yes, In anycase we have students going abroad for higher education.It'll be a relief to those students esp (if I can assume) apart from the course fee they will be able to control the other espenses and saved from the pain of going to another faraway country for studies.Infact it could ease up the braindrain also to an extent since it'll be more probable for them to take up jobs in India than in the otherwise case. Infact Indian economy would also gain from this by providing the services needed by the institutes and the related people.
By
Ritesh Jain, Project Leader , Siemens PLM
| 03 17 2010 07:54:47 +0000
before sending any indian abroad ... hershe may be placed in an incubator for 365 days in a 4 star hotel in pahalgam ................ their system should be clensed in a prep couse theirer .. so that no firang can dare say that indian reserchers are photocopiers ..
By
Ajay Ziz, Dy. Registrar,, University of Jammu
| 03 17 2010 07:47:51 +0000
Thousands of Indian students go to the U.S., Britain and Australia among other countries, every year, to study in foreign universities. The effort is part of the central government's continued focus on education reform. Sibal, who sounded elated Monday, has been pushing for this since he took over the ministry last year. The minister, too, has been in touch with several top universities in the U.S. and Britain about such a move. Among the foreign universities likely to set up shop in India are Boston University, Harvard and Yale University from the U.S. The meagerly paid professors at the country's top academic institutes may soon be poached by foreign universities after the government cleared a proposal to allow foreign universities to set up campuses in India. This step is expected to provide quality education in the country and reduce the flow of Indian students abroad The bill, which will now be tabled in parliament for its approval, has provisions to regulate the entry and operation of foreign institutions, which will set up campus and offer degrees in India. "This is a milestone, which will enhance choices, increase competition, and benchmark quality," Human Resource Development Minister Kapil Sibal said after a cabinet meeting chaired by Prime Minister Manmohan Singh.
By
santoshlal , Program Manager, Wigan & Leigh College (WLC)
| 03 17 2010 07:37:37 +0000
IT'S BETTER TO BE A SHARK OF THE HIGH SEAS..... RATHER THAN be A FROG in the FALUDA ... so don't repeat .. all is well...( chetan bhagat listening ) say .. she sells sea shells on the sea shore .. sea shells she sells r on the sea shore..repeat this mahamantra 1000 times for moksha of valley ..
By
Ajay Ziz, Dy. Registrar,, University of Jammu
| 03 17 2010 07:29:49 +0000
This is called true leadership. Today every one needs quality education and employment thereafter. Foreign univeristy in India will definitely serve the purpose. If you see the position of professional education in India, they are money making machines and focus only on quantity and not on quality of education imparted to students. They have lot of alternatives and options for students to get admissions in their colleges. Though they advertises that they take only CAT, MAT or any other score, but the fact is that even without any kind of score you can get admission. From faculty side, they are again not very selective.They try to hire on the lowest salary and expect faculty to be the best. How can you expect a good faculty to serve on lowest salary. Even if he get the job, he will definitely find alternatives. In fact this is very daring and praiseworthy move for the government and I appreciate Mr Kapil sibal. He has shown that one person can change the face of our country in coming years.
By
santoshlal , Program Manager, Wigan & Leigh College (WLC)
| 03 17 2010 07:27:17 +0000
Some day or the other, it had to happen. The time has come now. With Liberalization, Privatization and Globalization our country got a decent entry and recognition across the globe. However, when it comes to education, we are already doing the best. Let us not consider this as a threat to our education system, but certainly the competition will increase. Hope it will get all stakeholders a Win-Win situation!
By
Mansur Ali Khan, Vice President (M & S), ROMA Thinksoft Pvt. Ltd.
| 03 17 2010 03:38:12 +0000
I welcome the decision and it should have been done in past but this move will end the monopoly of indian universities.Our education system needs an overhaul and this cant be done by making policies and procedures.As we have seen that we indians openly defy laws and policies in every walk of life.Only this move can make us realize our loopholes and encourage practical learning instead of mugging up the theories and indulging in rote learning.Our universities can learn their teaching methodology.Also students who go outside for education will find a big relief.Many of education mafias of our country will find it a bit difficult to operate because of the better value provided by them.80% of the higher education providing instititutions solely exist for profit making and the kind of education they provide is flawed and of no avail.
By
DEEPAK SHARMA, Business Acquisition through Bidding channels, RFPs, Account Management, Relationship Management, Safaltek Software Pvt. Ltd.
| 03 17 2010 03:16:58 +0000
I myself am a BA student of Sanskrit/Jyotish of an Indian university for quite some time now, and being a non-Indian, I find this as very good news. When there is a will, there is a way - be sure about that. Having foreign students is somewhat different from having foreign investors ;)
By
Davor Virkes, Advisor, Croatian Telecom inc.
| 03 16 2010 17:27:51 +0000
Should be allowed for better education. Our institutions are capable enough to face the competition. We know that our institutions like AIIMS, IITs or IIMs are having reputations in the world level. Also will be benifitted by having educational & training exchange programs. Also one can fulfill his dream by getting foreign university degree without going there, which is very costly affair and even most of us dont know about the examinations like GRE, GMAT or TOEFL. Till now Only those who got the better primary education in English medium schools, are getting the opportunities. So, allowing foreign universities in india is the right decision.
By
mahendra kumar, Design Engineer, mecon
| 03 16 2010 16:29:58 +0000
In order to make India an economic super power by 2020, India must retain its talent while making simultaneous attempt to bring back talents. It is established that every year more than a lakh student go abroad to pusue higher studies. Therefore this bill will provide a platform not only to this category of students but the young working population in general to pursue higher studies in India at a lower cost. Further, the way post economic liberation has brought competition to ensure survival for the innovatative and efficient mind, this will also bring in competition and inprovement in knowledge investment. Therefore The Govt has taken the right decision in bringing this bill.
By
RABIN KUMAR SEN, CTO/CIO, IDEA CELLULAR LTD
| 03 16 2010 16:29:18 +0000
Obviously yes, after foreign universities setting up their campuses will help improvising our domestic universities' syllabus to gain advancement due to competition between education providers.
By
Rahul Dantkale, Software Developer, Indigo Architects
| 03 16 2010 14:50:13 +0000
The entry of foreign universities will be a great boost. It will help students who are not able to go abroad for studies grab an equivalent opportunity at home. Also it will help wake up the Indian Education system from its age old principle of spoon feeds.
By
Rahul Adhav, Software Developer, Idealake
| 03 16 2010 14:30:00 +0000
Hi..Gaurav this is Sunil..I am little bit disagree with you. and you said that india is not far away from foreign universities then my dear listen that only IIT,Bombay is in the list of top 500 universities and that is also at 461th rank. So what you will say to this my dear..:))
By
Sunil Kumar Sharma, Software Developer Trainee
| 03 16 2010 13:34:39 +0000
Kapil Sibal is on a roll these days. No boards, one-nation-one-syllabus and now foreign universities in India. Sure, great decision but few more steps to go before we actually see them here.
By
Navjeet Sood, Business Head, ADI Media Pvt Ltd
| 03 16 2010 13:20:59 +0000
Yes, its a good decision. Most of the work that Indian corporates in service sector handle today is from US or other foreign countries, whereas the education standards in most of the Indian universities are still primitive. Indian businesses including educational intstitutions will have to learn to compete globally, shift focus from protection within the country to expansion in other geographies. This will happen only when managements come out of thier lethargic attitudes. Moreover, the Indian students now need not travel to foreign countries and spend huge money on boarding and other related activities. We need to realize that India cannot remain immune from the effects of globalization whether negative or positive. In fact the government should consider opening up other sectors such as legal services as well.
By
Syed Ansari, Legal Manager, Cambridge Systems
| 03 16 2010 13:09:37 +0000
In my view, it will improve the quality and standard of Indian students, who are planning to go outside and India. They can effectively compete with the foreign education standard. However, i doubt that, it will help much of those, who don't want to leave India since the standard of education is already high. All in all its a good step.
By
Vikas Agarwal, ERP Implementation, Butterfly Informatics
| 03 16 2010 13:01:26 +0000
Neelima..I also agree with you that provide the foreign education is the milestone but the main problem is that are the universities able to provide the same level of education at here?
By
Sunil Kumar Sharma, Software Developer Trainee
| 03 16 2010 12:58:35 +0000
|
Being a foreigner...and committed to free enterprise...you would think I would be in favor of such a "move" (i.e., opening the Indian educational "market" to expatriate commercial institutions of higher learning). But that is not the case. To the contrary, I have seen what has happened to the American education system over the past 30+ years in its headlong dash to sell itself to the highest bidder. First, the overall quality of education has declined considerably. It was sad to learn in the 70's and 80's that we were graduating high schoolers who could not read, do simple arithmetic, know the capital of their own state, locate Denmark on a map or tell you what the Bill of Rights was. However, now we see that we are graduating students with Bachelors and even Masters degrees whose comprehension of simple paragraphs is below 40%, cannot balance their own checkbooks, still do not know the capital of their own states, the location of Denmark, Malaysia or Zaire, or tell you what are their First Amendment rights. Second, the cost of education has increased approximately 1,000% since 1970 and student loan indebtedness gone up 3,000% over the same time period. And third, the quality and integrity of university research & development has, in many fields, deteriorated to the point of becoming little more than spokesmen and public relations departments for their private corporate sponsors. In 1969 the U.S. put a man on the moon. In 2010 we cannot muster the technological know-how to stop an oil leak at 5,000 ft. below sea level. None of these results have anything to do with the spirit of my fellow citizens, much less their inherent intellectual capabilities. It is entirely the result of allowing the "profit motive" to become the raison d'etre of the educational process. I might add that even under the best of circumstances the American education system no longer "educates"...that is, teaches students how to think, reason and pursue their own intellectual curiosities. It only indoctrinates and trains individuals how to do certain kinds of jobs. It is a voc-tech system, at best...and otherwise a complete farse and national embarrassment. In my opinion, India's decision on this matter should not be based on nationalistic pride...and in fact, should use this opportunity to reconsider and critique its own existing education system...which (again in my opinion) produces some very fine "technocrats", but otherwise is lacking in balance and thoroughness.
By
James Hindman, Principal, The Hindquarters Group, Inc.
| 06 26 2010 17:25:22 +0000
i also thought in same way, there is no need of having foreign university when indians are working far more better here and abroad. we have lots of eco , management gurus , giving lectures and having name in world.
By
puneet , Manager Admin
| 06 26 2010 14:01:52 +0000
foreign universities just coming here to generate their income,as they also knows that Indian students are more intelligent than them!acc. to me tis wrong decision by gov. but still those who want to get in theses foreign universities can go........no restriction....
By
reena singh, Marketing, Ariisto House
| 06 26 2010 06:49:34 +0000
No government should not allow any sort of trade in education sector. By doing so, they are keeping themselves aloof from responsibilities of providing quality education to the youngsters. It seems like they want to get rid of duty of improvement in education sectors, This is clearly shown by this decission that this govrnment is elitist and working only for benifits of rich people and dominating and making fun of the poor and down trodden Indians. & which universities are going to come in india? The uni's proposed are of very poor standards. These arent like Cambridge, Oxford, California universities. These are money eating traders who arent supposed to allow to trade in country like India who worship godess of knowledge as Sarswati and call educational institutes as a temple of her.
By
Sarangpani , Freelancer, Freelancer
| 03 21 2010 15:51:30 +0000
e it is a drama for politicians to earn easy money.Ou top most noble prize winners studied in Indian universities only. It is not the universities or standard of education which brings money or intelligence inlife. Its how the person is performing while learning.TheTallest tower in the world built by Indian engineers, but supervised or designed by the forign engineers.If Indian education is poor means how we can follow that the world class superior designs and can understandthe same to construct.Our BHEL engineers got about thousands,crores of work orders competiting with world class designers.We sent space craft to moon with Indian enginners only. All those working in US Doctors who have an age of above 55 are all Indian university products. We are producing engineers doctors in Indian univesities and they are selling them selves in forign. But Indian education never below standards to them. There is an Image which created by the millioners heirs who have never earned moderate aggregares in primary education that forign education is good.the compettive degrees issued by the forign univs may for sale to the well todo people and political back round . and we may hope our film stars and cpuncillers spn will get these forign degrees for their pride.But whether the poor people from IIT can competite them. and local BAs Bscs what they have to do. A govt has to give class education and medical facility and a controlled price for food grains for the people.. Indian politiciation failed in all these basic necessaties. And the givt is thinking for the favour of millioneries who have 3% in population.
By
pandianarjunan , project manager
| 03 20 2010 04:11:14 +0000
No, It will bring only commercialisation of education system and uni's which are coming in are of far inferior in as long as quality education is concerned. It will bring only the capitalisation of education system. The use of term INVESTMENT is itself shows that they wanted to make a bussness of education. In india to raise educational institutions was only allowed to those societies who are willing to serve in goodwill people and for the national cause. Thats why, they have been regestered at the office of Registrar of Public trust and societies.
By
Sarangpani , Freelancer, Freelancer
| 03 18 2010 14:11:52 +0000
hi all,hope Govt.would have done all possible ground work before enacting this bill.now it is not correct to question the authenticity as it won't be of any use.all these days we were in a thinking that all foriegn universities are the best.but the reality is that it is the environment in that places which was attractive and nothing else.our Indian way of education is not lesser in any way and by any means.there is no need for any foriegn universities to be opened up in India.
By
jairaj shyam prasad, Production Manager, BOSCH Ltd
| 03 18 2010 13:18:52 +0000
Prime focus of this drama is Money, hence it will end up as a Business venture rather than a teaching institute. It's good as far as getting studied here and being hired by Big Paying Companies; but the Critical Motto of Universities as building next generation of cultured and smart youth lies ruined.
By
Navneet Hegde, Software Developer, Procit B.V
| 03 17 2010 14:03:08 +0000
INVESTMENT---? What the hell sort thought is this? Are you all going to be insane? Its not the field to do business of, it should not allowed to run on commercial perpose, so that one could INVEST money and think of earning profits. If it has to do that way, then i thought, Ambani brothers are the best chancellors & Ratan tata would be the best faculty to teach in.
By
Sarangpani , Freelancer, Freelancer
| 03 17 2010 08:27:21 +0000
The already established big institutions in India like IIMs & IITs will now face big competition from these universities. The quota system is not applicable on these foreign universities whereas they are applicable in the Indian universities. This will lead to quality students from those universities which will be very bad for the demand of Indian universities.
By
Deepak Kubal, Media Coresspondent, Media House
| 03 16 2010 12:31:38 +0000
|