Build your professional network on facebook via our app Go to app
 
<< Prev  3 of 12 in Topic  Next >>
Topic : Multi Level Marketing - MLM in India
  Rate : 
Associated with other topics :
Posted in Community :

Retail & Supply Chain Professionals

 
Created by : Christian Anews, Product/Brand Manager, Videocon Inds  | 11 04 2008 08:16:58 +0000
Industry : Consumer DurablesFunctional Area : Consumer Sales(Sales & Marketing)
Activity:  2246 views;  last activity : 03 04 2011 08:01:35 +0000
Multi Level Marketing (MLM) is the fastest growing sector of the direct selling industry worldwide. In India a few companies have introduced Multi level Marketing in a very large scale, by quoting and promising very high returns. A large number of the people belonging to the middle class population of India have joined into this dying business of Multi level Marketing by paying an entry fee into the business. Some of the Multi level Marketing efforts have in fact been miserable failures in spite of the fact that they offer excellent products. So, what do you say about Multi Level Marketing worth it or scam? Do you think the Multi Level Marketing model(MLM) would be successful?
 
Share
 
 
  Rate : 
 
 
Yes Vs No
12
 
 
 
 
15
14
11
Support   Support
Top Argument
2
0

I could say that many industries is running successfully, MLM doesn't necessarily make it bad or a scam but new MLM's come and go all the time, if it is new you need to do a little research before blindly jumping in, Google the program if you have doubts. The longer a program has been around the better.

Also see this awesome video below talks about Surviving the Scams in Multi Level Marketing.................... :-)


By Omkar Deshpande, Product/Brand Manager, Mirc Electronics  02 02 2009 06:55:10 +0000
 
Top Argument
4
1

Net work marketing can be successful only when the product selling is more important than net working. The MLM is having a limited growth as the projections are only based on theoretical calculations. In the real sense the equation will not be possible even for a single line as the required people will be more than the entire world population as shown below

1

2

4

8

16

32

64

128

256

512

1024

2048

4096

8192

16384

32768

65536

131072

262144

524288

1048576

2097152

4194304

8388608

16777216

33554432

67108864

134217728

268435456

536870912

1073741824

2147483648

At the 32nd down line to complete we require double the Indian population, other steps left behind. Mathematically correct but practically incorrect. Just like lottery some people in the upper line will make money majority will lose money and time.

 


By G K Thomas, Head/VP/GM-Marketing, Virgo Services  02 11 2009 10:12:22 +0000
0
0
you are no one to think about it, its already successful, every product in future will be sold over e-commerce and every co will promote this buiness model as it save them a Marketing/distribution/warehouse/ brand endrosment COST and Media will always remain againest it as they will not be needed much,
By Abhishek Gupta, Director , Skills Factory  | 03 04 2011 08:01:35 +0000
0
0

sorry to say ,you are talking about pyramid schemes, where stress is on making new partners and commission gets shared, you are not talking about network marketing co, which is legal because  70% revenue comes from sell of product only,

second as you said that to reach 32 line, you will need huge population-- every co has a model in which , they cuts u off after a certain period and give u fixed income, or else they wud go bankrupt.

Request you to research more n subject and models :)


By Abhishek Gupta, Director , Skills Factory  | 01 20 2011 18:33:31 +0000
0
0
yes
By sourab , Freelancer, Management & Strategy Consulting  | 01 13 2011 11:45:12 +0000
1
0
Direct Selling industry expected to reach Rs 53,200 million by 2012-2013 Says IDSA - Ernst & Young Annual Survey findings 2008-09. I think it is enough
By sourab , Freelancer, Management & Strategy Consulting  | 01 13 2011 11:42:40 +0000
0
0

Abhishek,

I appreciate your support for the direct selling industry . But for a better understanding of the forum am answering a basic question which is asked by all top management people we meet , which is 

How do the “Real” Direct selling businesses work?

 The working of a DIRECT SELLING company is very simple.

The company sells you a product, and also offers you a chance to join its distribution network.  However, you do not need to buy the products to join the network unless of course it is for personal use.

Consider this example. Say you (distributor) have joined the network and sold a product to person A who likes it and wants to start selling it, person A can get enrolled at a minimal cost which actually covers the cost of the training kit materials.

When he starts selling, then the company, the distributor (you) and person A all get payouts which are based on a percentage of the sales made.

If subsequent distributors have been well-trained and motivated enough to get out there and generate sales, everyone stands a chance to profit.  And when you profit, the company profits!

Direct selling is transparent and ethical with little scope for malpractices.

It can be compared to your normal 9-5 job too in many respects too. At your workplace, no matter which department you work for, the work you do adds to the value of the company. Your efforts are either equal or more than the salary you earn. So basically your boss makes money using your earned money.

Another good example is the sales force in Fast Moving Consumer Goods (FMCG), Insurance or Direct Marketing. Salesmen are normally paid a commission of 12%, and on achieving all targets are rewarded with a bonus. The sales manager who has to motivate and supervise his sales team, earns his own bonus and incentives. But guess what! He also earns 3% of all sales made from each of his sales members. And then there is the Branch Manager who reaps the highest profits for motivating his Sales Managers.

The truth is, direct selling applies in almost every business sphere but we just fail to recognize it. However, the difference is that with direct selling companies, you do not need to be at the top of the management to take home the fattest pay check. What you earn completely depends upon you; there is no cap or limit.

please keep in mind that the product should be primary and should be of actual use to the consumer (even if he is not interested in the opportunity).

if the product is not useful to the person in the business or a consumer , the business opportunity falls under pyramid scheme.

if everyone waits for the company to be 10 year old , there  would be no company .

Yes , training on products, business , etc is very important without which success is difficult.


By Daniel R Pranjal, Partner/Principal/VP - Direct selling + MLM , Strategy India  | 08 16 2010 10:23:44 +0000
1
0
  • Yes- first choose the right co with world class products
  • co should be min 10 yr old
  • they should give you form 16
  • in best possible different ranges, (not consumables) long lasting , Internationally recognized ,
  • A model that promote a team game,
  • a co which invest in lot of good quality trainings,
  • it should not be geography based, its should be empowered by internet so, if a person is sitting in Delhi, can do business in London as well, if he has contacts.
  • he can check his account an business even by Mobile.

By Abhishek Gupta, Director , Skills Factory  | 08 16 2010 08:25:31 +0000
1
0

A MLM is any day another form of business model and it is for sure a success model with win win situation to all.

However to set up a MLM should have a very level of understanding of the MLM principles and should fully adhere to the statutory norms of the government besides should have good and products and services that make a difference in the market place.

More and more co are trying to take for granted and want to exploit people for quick get rich scheme. MLM is not a quick get rich scheme.

Individuals has the responsibility to verify the credentials of the MLM Co before they get engaged.

cheers


By Chandrasekar Puvvada, Owner, evOlve business consulting  | 03 31 2010 04:17:25 +0000
0
0

Dear Pragya, This is happening in our country cause right now there are no regulations in place . Once we get the regulations for this industry which we are currently working on, there will be less people who would want to "try" this way of promotion as we will have the do's and don'ts along with the guidelines to safeguard the interests of the end consumer first before allowing corporations or individuals to intentionally or unintentionally take the plunge.

Till now ,whatever may be the intention (good or bad) people starting MLM company did not have any alternative but to shut shop because of reasons like no experience in running a business , not planning properly , copying compensation plan or pay plan of other company or companies , choosing an inexperienced software vendor (calculates the payout on basis of the complan) , improper financial management , not taking care of legal formalities , hiring inexperienced people to run the show ,etc are some main ones.

 


By Daniel R Pranjal, Partner/Principal/VP - Direct selling + MLM , Strategy India  | 02 22 2010 14:52:19 +0000
1
1
once the system process is cleared to the society, it will be easier to go through the chain, MLM is going to be an alternate distirbution system
By rajendra chaturvedi, Manager Operations , Prime Logistics  | 12 25 2009 12:41:41 +0000
1
1

Unique / good benefit to consumers, attractive remuneration to customers( propagandists), Ethical and spporting busines back up will definitely make MLM's successful, Only the duplicators with everything copied and no strenght of their own fails

 


By Manoj T P, Area Sales Manger, INALSA (Tuareg Marketing Pvt ltd)  | 12 25 2009 06:53:12 +0000
1
1

Very True . The good thing about people is that we are constantly open to growth and progress and therefore join the direct selling company when approched .

But the major problem is our human nature , which is not to recognize the potential of the business opportunity because the investment is very low as compared to traditional business ( franchisee , distributorship , etc) which runs in lacs and crores. And therefore we do not pursue the direct selling opportunity  (mlm) with the same grit and determination as we would have done in after investing lacs or crores in any other traditional business.

People( read companies too) in traditional business also fail and lose much more than in direct selling which is equally bad.

 


By Daniel R Pranjal, Partner/Principal/VP - Direct selling + MLM , Strategy India  | 11 26 2009 05:01:14 +0000
1
1
Any MLM company can be directly compared to the normal corporate structure with the exception of middle men being removed to be replaced by individual sellers.. Problem is since every1 is unable to achieve the projected success in this business..the failure rate has given the concept of Network Marketing a bad name.
By Anthony G., Freelancer, Freelancer  | 11 25 2009 17:28:58 +0000
0
1

Direct selling companies are and can have higher success ratio if they have a right balance of compensation to the networks ( right from the beginners to the leaders) and the right products at the right price.

Planning itself should have all the overheads (onetime and regular) factored in the cost of goods. The focus should be on product sales and the income generation plan should be equally rewarding for all level of distributors.

Lots of people fail in direct selling because of lack of trainings provided by the companies and less of efforts put in promoting the products available with the company .

Yes , there are many fly by night operators promoting inferior products or non existant products at very high markups - which are the type of companies where 95% people do not recover even their investment .

These types of companies should be avoided by educating the countrymen which again is a herculean task because despite of more than 10 million people from our country investing in this industry the government is not giving it an industry status.

We are very sure that till the govt. does not regulate this industry more and more of countrymen (employed and unemployed , literate or illiterate , male or female , etc) will keep on falling prey to the cheat companies.

Meanwhile , we at www.strategyindia.com are working to make this industry more organized. 


By Daniel R Pranjal, Partner/Principal/VP - Direct selling + MLM , Strategy India  | 02 11 2009 08:27:54 +0000
0
0

I agree , but every Industry has a share of good apple and bad apple ( Not apple Iphoe :) ), so this Network marketing Industry has too few bad apples, Why is so big deal.

Banks has got shut down, PF schemes has got mis management , pension scheme by govt had problem- DID WE STOP DEALING WITH BANKS, GOVT, - NO, then why so much negativity about Network Marketing,

  1. A wise man need to choose a right co based on few parameters-
  2. How old is the company(  Co shud be min 5 Yr old)
  3. Financial 's of co.
  4. does co have a valid license to operate
  5. does co have a weekly  system trainings in city
  6. does co invest in technology for its partners
  7. does company has a Verisign approved payment check
  8. does co has a web portal
  9. does co take care of calculations/operation/delivery of products.
  10. does co have wide range of products ,which are not only consumables
  11. does co nt force you to buy products and monthly targets
  12. does co allows credits to remain active life long
  13. does co pass on your business to your next generation in case of death
  14. does company pay the same incentives to all levels( Rarely happens with MLM but there are few co's, who pay same amount on each level)
  15. Lot to know- feel free to contact at lets.connect5@gmail.com

By Abhishek Gupta, Director , Skills Factory  | 01 28 2011 04:55:27 +0000
0
0
MLM will meet only limited success because of various inherent constraints..so many people who are ambitious (or over ambitious) to earn money(or quick money)enter into mlm business.as days pass when they do not get the expected level of success stop abruptly.people who bought the products mostly influenced,convinced or compelled by these novices are left in the lurch.there is no guarantee of the products sold,no after sales service,no follow up etc.business is continuity and never an one shot of operation.goodwill and credibility of the manufacturer go to the wind by such unscrupulous people.AMWAY & EUREKA FORBES HAE GAINED CONSIDERABLE SUCCESS
By s.baalu , Consultant, XYZ LTD  | 03 30 2010 13:59:07 +0000
0
0

MLM in Insurance is not  a success

 

IN MLM you sell a product to another person , try and make hime your agent and if he sells a product then you also get commission

In Insurance this was a disaster, a person was sold insurance policy , he wen ton to seel it to others and also makinga chain of agents and thsu deriving commision

 

Now the issue:-

1) all people who sold polciies did not clear the Agents exam as per IRDA

2) The aim was to sell the product, get the commission and also make the seller to become a agent so that they would get more commission

3) no one bothered about address all fulfillment of all documentation and as a result the policy did not reach insured

4) if the documentation was not correct the policy was not processed, and  all communication to insured for getting the requirements full filled came back undelivered due to wrong or incomplete address.

5) Policy was not converted and if converted then they did not reach insured

6) Now insured cameb back adn filled suits against insurance companies

7) cases were lost by both sides

8) Finally IRDA in 2009 - Aug instructed all companies to stop the promotion of products by MLM way

I am talking not about my company but of insurance companies as a whole


By Nikhil , Senior Manager, Insurance  | 03 26 2010 07:48:23 +0000
1
1

Hi Dalip I agree with you. What you said is true many start the company and when they get good profit they close and disappear. So what about the people in the chain. Even I have seen many companies doing this.

Thanks.... 


By Pragya Kothari, Construction-Heavy, DLF  | 02 22 2010 08:27:29 +0000
1
1

They only benefit the promoters and in most cases these companies make money and close the shop and disappear,as there is no learning curve in training the down line to trouble shoot problems or resolve any issues once the product is sold and one is left to fend for oneself as the person who got you to enroll or buy the product or your upline changes his or her mobile number so that he is not taking any responsibility to service to sales.


By Dalip Singh Singh, Head/VP/GM-Marketing, Interspace Realtors  | 12 28 2009 12:01:38 +0000
0
1

Sure . Product selling has to take equal priority as increase in the group size . Imagine all these people in binary or sunshine companies consuming and promoting good quality products at a lower price than ones available in the traditional market but still earning good regular commissions.

Unemployment will be taken care of....etc


By Daniel R Pranjal, Partner/Principal/VP - Direct selling + MLM , Strategy India  | 02 11 2009 11:09:56 +0000
0
0

MLM as a concept is not bad. However, in India, the concept is not being used in the right spirit (I mean the majority). If you read between the MLM schemes, money laundering is the underlying motive. You can't befool the people for long


By Kujnish Vashisht, Partner/Principal/VP, Expedient Consultants  | 02 02 2009 04:49:48 +0000
0
0

Mr Omkar, the video you posted has been removed. If you have a copy of this video, pl. mail it to me.


By Viktor Stephen, COO, I Entrepreneur  | 01 19 2009 06:26:54 +0000
0
0
When we look at score board of MLM's economy, It is characterized by massive failure rates and financial losses for millions of people. Its structure in which positions on an endless sales chain are purchased by selling or buying goods is mathematically unsustainable, and its system of allowing unlimited numbers of distributors in any market area is inherently unstable. You better quit this business and you take same risk in equity market you will get assured returns....
By Rishi Khanna, Product/Brand Manager, Mirc Electronics  | 11 04 2008 08:24:16 +0000
0
0
I feel that MLM business model is a hoax that is hidden beneath misleading slogans. Calling it a "great business opportunity" makes no more sense than calling the purchase of a lottery ticket a "business venture" and winning the lottery a "viable income opportunity for everyone." MLM industry claims of distributor income potential, its glorified descriptions of the "network'" business model.

By Christian Anews, Product/Brand Manager, Videocon Inds  | 11 04 2008 08:16:58 +0000
Leading recruitment firm
  • Create a confidential Career Profile and Resume/C.V. online
  • Get advice for planning their career and for marketing of experience and skills
  • Maximize awareness of and access to the best career opportunities
Viewers also viewed
Yes vs Mlm has no career in India
 
816 referals 13 arguments, 1835 views
Could global economic turmoil achieve, what the dream team of economic administrators could not...
 
82 referals 34 arguments, 1973 views
The debate to open up multi-brand retail to foreign direct investment will be taken to states to...
 
1076 referals 38 arguments, 343 views
more...  
 
More From Author
Yes it is, retail sees a huge demand in the urban crowd. And soon will have a better market in the rural too.  
Yes private label is one way to increase the margin. But it should not become a skimming strategy. Compared to fmcg, private label will work in food products because there is no standard price anywhere.........   
Rajkumar..... it would be great if you can give proper sides to the debate, so that people can take a side and debate....... :)
more...