Build your professional network on facebook via our app Go to app
 
<< Prev  9 of 14 in Topic  Next >>
 
Created by : Jayesh Jain, Software Developer, MS IT  | 11 04 2009 11:05:37 +0000
Industry : Radio, TV & FilmsFunctional Area : India(Markets)
Activity:  1049 views;  last activity : 05 18 2011 10:50:30 +0000

Bollywood director Anurag Kashyap feels there should be no film censorship at all. Even as he tries to push the boundaries, he says in India it is not easy to make films criticising real life politicians or to even use the term sex. "There should not be any censorship on making a film. We are still very conservative about the term sex," Kashyap, known for experimental films like Dev D, said on the sidelines of the 11th Mumbai Film Festival (MFF).

Should films be freed from censorship? Whats your thoughts on this?

 
 Refer 280
Share
 
 
  Rate : 
 
 
Yes Vs No
14
 
 
 
 
24
11
15
Support   Support
Top Argument
3
0

Guys have you seen people working for censorship board, everybody there would be above 60 years old and people who have no experience of understanding what world cinema is all about, they just have one perspective and that is Bollywood, and they want to be in that shell for eternity and don't want to venture out and compete at the world stage, why do you think any of our films don't get nominated to oscar's or do really good at the overseas market because the movies are typecasted to Indian's taste and not others and that mainly happens because the censor board doesn't allow films which is having bold theme and even if there are couple of kissing sequence and if the language is contradictive, they want it to be removed or they issue a Adult(A) certificate, and if there is a Adult certificate then it is sure that it wouldn't reach the masses in India who still think if the movie is having a Adult certificate then they can't watch the movie and this makes the filmakers to give us the same "naach gaana" time and again with no creativity happening, how many times we have seen similar story lines with different actors, I think Censor board should be liberal here and understand the creativity and the final product that is there, and not just because couple of scenes or couple of lines were found opposing to few Indian people sentiments, I don't want the whole Censorship to be removed but to be liberal and acknowledge the creativity that one can derive from a talented pool of people in the country, and which I am so sure there will be plenty, and a day we will see where an Indian film gets an Oscar on its own.


By Dayanand Deshpande, Senior Consultant, Ernst & Young  11 04 2009 13:25:17 +0000
 
Top Argument
4
0

I dont think that its a good idea to free the films from censorship. Because there are many films which coming up with things that are not suitable for homely viewing. Even after the strict censorship rules in India, many films are crossing the limits in showing the sex contents. So we muct continue the censoring of films.


By Jayesh Jain, Software Developer, MS IT  11 04 2009 11:07:08 +0000
0
0
filmz r Entertainment ...... not to be judged like ....... entertain urselves ....enjoy ..... is sheer business..... not to be judged
By Sebastian Akn, Freelancer, Radio, TV & Films  | 05 16 2011 07:20:57 +0000
0
1

A VERY GOOD QUESTION INDEED...

FOR BOLLYWOOD FILMS THIS IS INFACT A GOOD TOPIC...IF SENSORSHIP IS TO ACT THEN WHERE DOES THEIR SCISSORS VANISH WHEN THEY SEE A SIZZLING HOT ITEM NUMBER WHERE A HEROINE EXPOSES HALF OF HER BODY JUST TO WATCH THAT 3RD GRADED ITEM NUMBER SOME PEOPLE FLOCK THE MOVIE THEATRE...REALLY RIDICULOUS...

TALKING OF SENSORSHIP ALSO REMINDS OF SOME FILM LIKE AASTHA OF REKHAJI, UTSAB OF REKHAJI, WHERE CENSOR BOARD JUST WAS TOO LIBERAL...THE KIND OF SONGS, THE KIND OF SLEEZY DRESSES THAT THE ACTRESSES ARE MADE TO WEAR NOWADAYS ARE FIRST TO BE CENSORED BUT IF THESE ARE ALLOWED THEN WHAT ON EARTH FILMS ARE BEING PROTECTED BY CENSOR BOARDS.

RATING U/A .....DOSENT HAVE ANY MEANING NOWADAYS....IN HOLLYWOOD FILMS WE GENERALLY SEE THT THEY GIVE US" UNDER PARENTAL GUIDANCE" AND REALLY THE CENSOR BOARD ALSO WORK ACCORDINGLY BUT SINCE BOLLYWOOD CENSOR BOARD DOSENT EVEN UNDERSTAND THE RELEVANCE OF U/A THERE SHOULD NOT BE ANY CENSOR BOARD ACTUALLY/

IN BOLLYWOOD EVEN IN "U" RATED MOVIES WE CAN SEE SOME SCENES WHICH ARE EMBARRASSING AND NOT ALLOWABLE FOR KIDS...SO WHERE LIES THE SIGNIFICANCE OF SENSORSHIP??


By saswati chakraborty, Career Counsellor/Customer Support/Inhouse Sales activity handling  | 06 22 2010 14:16:59 +0000
0
0
So long as the film makers stick to the framework of moral and ethical values of this great Nation, venerated by unparallelled greats from the world countries for our very deep rooted cultural ethos, it is every Indian's responsibility to guard the prestine glory of our cultural diversity!
By S. Muralidharan, Executive Director, Knowledge Foundation & Campus Around the Corner  | 04 22 2010 08:13:56 +0000
0
0
yes anurag kashyap saves my vote in favor of his argument that films should be free from censorship because now we should act mature and sensible,nothing is hidden even from the kids in todays highly developed world, where at one side we talk to reach moon other hand we are so reserved and conservative on the issues of openness and frankness and display of violence and physical relationship onscreen that we talk to censor it, when we know that it is the time of revolution when we should get rid of all the dead and suppressing notions that prevented us from being no. 1 in the world.
By Dinesh , MBA/PGDM student, PROTON bschool, ahmd.Gujarat  | 04 22 2010 06:58:17 +0000
0
0

Let there be freedom to show what producer ans director want to show on screen , let there be regulation in cinem a halls whom to see, Censor ship has lost it value

There are many blue films in marlet what si censor board doing for that just letting that pass by, why does nto it act there and only stop and censor filsm of top producers and directors

 


By Nikhil , Senior Manager, Insurance  | 04 22 2010 05:59:42 +0000
1
0

Whoa Dudes and Babes, the inevitable question which bridge to cross and which to burn!

Himanshu thanks for the referral.

Censorship V/S old school and new school of thoughts, is very old discourse as old as the 18th Century aesthetic society question. When a well known satirist Oscar Wilde was imprisoned because his views parlayed against the then society. And he proclaimed later that “all art is useless.”

It is a tussle always between the maker and the supervisory board because of a myth : when one is wholly and solely involved in making a creative piece either film, novel or any art for that matter, his power of judgement underplays the power of creativity and in the process he can create a Masterpiece or a Frankenstein. Hence forth watchdogs are supposed to strike a balance in the creative process. The other reason is that Film-makers like Anurag Kashyap are intelligent modern film-makers who also estimate the common man’s common sense to be at par with theirs, and the irony is the censor board acts as a misnomer interpreting the common sense for the common man’s sake.

 The plight of current filmmakers is not only censor board but also the finance pockets, coz mostly all the Producers still believe in the formula based drama instead of concept based films.


By Shiuli Mukherji, Head Strategy Plan- , Region SEA  | 11 06 2009 06:15:18 +0000
1
0

I really agree to what Dayanand and others are saying here, and censor board really have no clue like on what they are putting a tab on, today people can get those cheap things like porn and other things on road side and one can also easily get these things on Internet, so why are we chopping the scenes to mainstream cinema, if anybody wants to watch it is their wish, why are we hampering the quality of the movie just because it had couple of obligatory scenes and violence, and this is the main reason why people don't go to movie theatres these days, and easily download the movie and watch the uncut version, this is why there is more piracy, because in movie halls you won't get to see the complete thing, with so many chopped up scenes the movie is not worth watching anymore, so i agree that there should be no censorship or anything like that, or else the censor board should be more liberal, or get themselves trained couple of months in other countries where creativity, content is given importance than social implications or the aftermath.


By Himanshu Pathak, Sr/Principal Coresspondent, Coresspondent  | 11 05 2009 08:26:02 +0000
2
1

preserving one's culture is one thing that can be considered as crucial but aren't we are being ignorant to the fact that it would be sort of hasty generalisation wen we say they ( the common people)would be indulging in same kind of lifestyle as that shown in movies ,it is same as there perception of indian dancing n singing around  trees .keep adult content apart ,the hollywood movies n tv shows are far better in terms of content .our tv industry in fact is rated "crap tv".if that is kind of values one want to be imparted to there childrens then there let there be dark beneath the lamp...


By kawaljit kaur, pgdbm student , Mount Carmel Institute of Management  | 11 05 2009 05:40:51 +0000
1
1

For what our films need a censorship?.........I have my intellect to decide and eyes to see or not to see and pockets to buy or not buy any stuff which is not suitable for me..............

Censorship requires to prevent what?..........Indecency, material not of good taste.......immoral items....( LOL)

See your society with your naked eyes......listen your news Channels, read your news papers......visit your schools /colleges.........every where....every body is munching its time in things ........which are so called required to be Censored. 

Adulteration, Rapes, politics, murders , criminalism...etc etc etc.... they are not the subjects which we read in books.......but we see and feel their impact in our society........

Censorship since its inception hasn't been able to make any change in the mind of people rather......thinking/mentality of people around has depreciated every moment.  

No ..I think.....people needs to be self managed (controlled) if they dont like to see, watch or be a part of anything. Otherwise, stopping anything will just suppress the people in doing........and result will come out as a bigger decrement in living values.........


By Amit Kumar, Company Secretary Cum Legal Manager, INX Media Private Limited  | 11 05 2009 05:37:55 +0000
1
0

I agree with Mr. Dayanand. Senior citizens are holding the seats of censor office who don't have any idea of what is international film industry. In the name of "Culture", they will never allow us to compete in international standards. This is the reason, hardly any of our movies get Oscar awards. These people still want that 60s touch in bollywood and make our film industry outdated. Cinema industry should be made free from them. Its their time to get retired...


By Yash Singh, Coresspondent, Star  | 11 05 2009 05:05:28 +0000
0
0

Some times some censorship is essential to some scene & some dialogues as most of the viewers are going to see the movie with their children.

I support your views, Jayesh.


By SHRIKANT MANOHAR DANKE, Project Manager, Phadnis Infrastructur Ltd  | 05 18 2011 10:50:29 +0000
0
0
No, never. With censorship only, we have such level of vulgarity around, its absence will definitely aggravate the situation beyond limits, in the name of so-called entertainment. Truly in sync with Ms Resmiji..
By Peeyush Chauhan, Associate/Sr. Associate -(Technical)  | 05 18 2011 10:01:07 +0000
0
0

Certainly not.

Today , the main argument for censorship is not just sex or violence. We can have movies , books or even mere statements , which are driven by evil ideas , such as ethnic cleansing , paedophilia , ... Any one can put out material that glorifies such evil ideas. Would you like that people , who are often not well educated or well informed , have access to such material ?

Why do we say that liquor / alcohol / drugs should not be peddled anywhere near educational institutions ? Is it that students do not know of these ? The idea is that if you make access to these difficult , it will easier for students to remain on the moral path and not stray. The same logic applies to censorship. If you make it more difficult for people to put out offensive material , viewers will be less inclined to go looking for such material.

 


By K. NARAYAN, None, None  | 05 16 2011 15:20:57 +0000
0
0

Anything presented to a mass market and which involves employee, payments, etc is subject to safeguards, standards, etc. So we should we make an exception for films.

 

 

Also film industry has been given an industry status so they have to be responsible and accept censorship since their products will be subject to checks and balances before it can go to market.

Also films have an influence on others, and are an instrument of expression and human expression on any topic is subject to laws.


By Shahnawaz Islam, PR & Media Relations Manager, National Institute of Smart Governance  | 05 16 2011 11:32:10 +0000
0
0
definitely there are certain rules and norms are there, it's not because of certain values or culture it is because our new generation and kids should leram the things in a descent and right manner not in wrong way.
By Namrata Chauhan, IT recruiter, Pinaki Consultant  | 05 16 2011 07:09:27 +0000
0
0
We are seeing cultural erosion in the name of film freedom! After the penetration of Television in bed rooms, our children and teenagers grabbed the remote control from the parents to watch anything and everything that is on display! At least, in yester years parents used exercise judgement to take their wards to cinema theatres. If you want to protect our cultural identity, censorship is essential. However, persons who enacted various roles as Heroines should not be made as Chairman or member because they won't mind any scene going through without cut in the name of art and culture!
By S. Muralidharan, Executive Director, Knowledge Foundation & Campus Around the Corner  | 05 16 2011 06:20:12 +0000
0
0
I believe in having something than nothing. Atleast presence of Censor board is giving us few movies to watch with family. But just imagine if we dont have any censor board then can we expect such movies in future? NO WAY!
By Rohit Thakur, Electrical Engineer-Industrial, Quality Engineering and Software Technologies  | 05 16 2011 04:55:51 +0000
0
0
I believe he is looking to make a Hollywood movie here...considering..actors like...Imran Hasmi and Mallika Sherawat as Brad Pit and Angelina.Majority of Toostep users seems liking his ideas as well. Strange!!!
By Rohit Thakur, Electrical Engineer-Industrial, Quality Engineering and Software Technologies  | 05 16 2011 04:50:50 +0000
1
0
Please dont do it.
By Rajesh Kumar Thakur, Regional Sales & Marketing Manager, E G Gas Limited  | 04 22 2010 09:53:26 +0000
1
0

Indian culture is very ancient and great. We like to change these great culture to a american culture and we think that would be better. American culture is individual centered but indian culture is group centered. that makes the two far different and we should be very proud about our culture and should preserve it at any cost. We should care our moral values and that resists some contents that should not explicit publicly.


By Reni sebastian, Assistant Engineer, State government of Keralam  | 12 02 2009 14:09:10 +0000
1
2

Whats wrong in preserving one's culture. In the name of modernisation, we can't be second America and in the name of boldness we can't make our industry vulgar and full with adultery. It will effect the life of common man especially children. There should be a strict regulatory board which supervises the category of a movie...


By Kavitha Shankar, Sr/Principal Coresspondent, ABC  | 11 05 2009 07:54:57 +0000
3
0

Absolutely not in favor. To vent out one’s so called “creativity”, do we need to sacrifice our values. Do we need to teach our children untimely about such creativity? Censor Board follows certain norms, which explicitly cover a pre-defined set of do’s and don’ts. In fact I was a CB Member for Malayalam Films and have censored a few films. I know to what extent a Member’s bias can influence the process. Hardly it happens, as judgment is made basis collective decision of the screening panel consisting of minimum 4 members. However, I feel it is imperative to reprimand those Movie Makers who violate the CB instruction. For example, there had been instances where the Directors interpolate scenes which were strictly instructed to be deleted from the reel. Censoring should be made more rigid!


By Resmi Maxim, GENERAL MANAGER - OPERATIONS, SI PROPERTY (KERALA) PVT.LTD.,  | 11 05 2009 04:41:05 +0000
2
0

When there is Censor Board, then also we are getting to lot of movies which shows lead actors using worst of languages. Most of the struggling film makers like Anurag Kashyap believes that showing hard reality of life is creativity. It is not. A child learns from their parents as well as micro and macro environment around them. Films being so popular in our country is one of the biggest macro environmental factor contributing shaping up life of any person in India. There are certain values a person want to pass on to their children to carry forward in society as well as next generation. And if there will be no censorship, frusteted film producers and directors will bring out porn and crime pictures in the name of creativity and audience demand.


By Mukul Bhartiya, Head-Sales & Marketing(Organic Food Business), Arvind Ltd.  | 11 05 2009 03:05:24 +0000
Post Your Resume Now !
  • Create a confidential Career Profile and Resume/C.V. online
  • Get advice for planning their career and for marketing of experience and skills
  • Maximize awareness of and access to the best career opportunities
Viewers also viewed
Azim Premji to start two free schools in every district. We do not value anything which is free,...
 
2320 referals 50 arguments, 946 views
These days as I switch on the tv or radio or look at a hoarding I do feel that power of ads I...
 
3004 referals 23 arguments, 482 views
Hi.....guys i have been seeing many debates and Idea contests in the Automobile sector regarding...
 
70 referals 9 arguments, 981 views
more...  
Recent Knowledge (5)
WE HAD A GOOD NUMBER OF INVENTORS WITH GREATER VISION ABOUT THE SOCIETY. INVENTORS HERE NEED NOT...
 
2 referals 2 arguments, 97 views
C vs B
 
0 referals 3 arguments, 51 views
I am associate of prajapati association and i am working for BJP from year 2005 to till date....
 
0 referals 3 arguments, 111 views
more...  
More From Author
Android is the latest OS but it isn’t as refined as the Blackberry OS. Blackberry is ‘business centric’ whereas Android is more ‘app centric’. So it depends what exactly do you want. For Business oriented people Blackberry will be the king.
Good article sir, but how are we going to change our political system.... ????
more...