More than anything, there is an aberration in human perception. Controversy sans scholarly content would not have stirred sales. Expulsion of Mr. Jaswant Singh from BJP on account of this book is just a misnomer. Controvery within the party against him was brewing since couple of months as he wrote to some leaders about fixing responsibility on election debacle. Controversy stirs sales is the dictum. It happened in the case of "Satanic Verses" by Salman Rushdie, a book on "da vinci code" etc. are the glaring examples. More than anything, the publishers are reaping more benefits, which will lead to more royalty paymet to Mr. Jaswant Singh.
By
S. Muralidharan, Executive Director, Knowledge Foundation & Campus Around the Corner
| 08 27 2009 16:14:13 +0000
Thanks Sudeep for inviting me to your community. The controversy is sometimes created intentionally and sometimes developed due to circumstantial reasons. This is what the modern civilization demands from the society. As we are busy day by day in our daily life, our attention only limited to controversial or sensational activities and news. As usual, this controversy will raise the sale of the book like a hot property, but in my opinion it is not intentional. Above all, the controversies have its own impact on the society and let us hope for a positive impact to the extend of forgetting our past relation with the neighboring nation and became one at least in our mind.
By
Santosh Kumar Mohanty, Civil Engineer-Municipal, Sambalpur University
| 08 27 2009 10:31:32 +0000
Controversy Sells.. People are actually curious to read and know as why is the write-up so controversial and provoking. Whilst the writing part of Jaswant Singh, he must have added it up to his book for the awareness either or may be a desperate intention of controversy.. Well nobody know about it what is the fact& with the S.S and othere parties raising a voice against the write-up has made it sell more & as one of our friend in the column has written too as well that Controversy is directly propotional to sale atleast for the time being or till the time situation is just started catching attraction and attention. For me, m curious too... No Indian can praise Jinnah, but if Jaswant Singh has then let us read and find out the reason and try to find the spark that caught the light and made a big fire.
By
Rajendra , Logistics Manager, Supreme Industries Ltd, Papua New Guinea
| 08 25 2009 22:22:48 +0000
Speaking in general, the content is important factor in sales statistics of books. But, in this particular case, controversy is solely responsible for lifting of sales of book. Really speaking, today, how many people will be there, interested to know about Jina?, in India and even in Pakistan. But, picking the leaders like Sardar Patel, Nehru ji and and linking controversial references about them with Mr. Jina, Jaswant Singh has been able to create such a hype, accross the continent, that his book will definitely hit jackpot. Till now, Jaswant Singh has been a political leader, with a limited mass base and survived in the shadows of Atal Bihari Vaajpeyi ji and Advani ji. But with one master stroke, he has joined the league of Pervez Mushrraf. Just remember, the scenes at the time of release on Mush's book.
By
Prakash Saitwal, Technical Support Manager, Aditya Birla Management Corporation P. Ltd.
| 08 25 2009 16:09:32 +0000
I absolutely agree with Mr. Deepak!! Initially it is the controversy, speculation that is going to sell for any product but of course later it is the Content that is going finally decide the fate of the product. More the controversy more the curiosity.. and better the content higher the sale.
By
Supriya Patade, Executive Assistant, Rare Hospitality & Services Pvt. Ltd.
| 08 25 2009 12:02:13 +0000
The expulsion of the senior leader has to some extent indused some speculative reading of the book
By
Hridibrata Roy, Manager
| 08 25 2009 08:29:04 +0000
Recent news suggest that Jaswant Singh is heading to pakistan to promote his book. Jaswant will visit Islamabad and Karachi to promote ‘Jinnah: India, Partition, Independence’, which will cost Pakistani Rs 2,000 each.
The new book has become a superhit and the Pakistani public will be eagerly waiting for the former BJP leader. I am sure there will be many takers.....
By
Himanshu Pathak, Sr/Principal Coresspondent, Coresspondent
| 08 25 2009 07:56:02 +0000
Manish thanx for supporting my idea and your genuine comment. I could have chosen either of them controversy or content. I have chosen controversy because it sells initally but if you are talking about long term then of course content sells. That 's why I have mentioned in my view- Controversy is directly proportional to sales initially at the time of launch. Content is directly proportional to controversial sell after the initial period of launch.
By
Deepak Agrawal, Consultant, Independent Consultant
| 08 25 2009 07:02:18 +0000
Whether it is good thing or bad thing, anything which is controversial in nature ,those stories sells like hot cake not only in india but also around the globe. Controversy always urge an individal mind to find out the facts ,intrepretation of the story in any form where the content is less important to the reader ,reader has an intrest to find out the truth . It also creates more intrest in the neighbouring countries if it is related to relegion or politics.
By
Hrudanand De, Area Sales Manager (Modern Trade )
| 08 22 2009 12:18:33 +0000
I think controversy increases more sales than anything, even if the content or the end product is good but then people today are very greedy and their PR's get paid to do these things and increase the brand value of it altogether by creating controversy, and media today is like if there is any controversy they show it all day and they hype it so much such that even where people don't have a TV will come to know ok there is this controversy that is going on. Its all about the money game here. even if there is no content the controversy will take care the rest of the things for them. People have become so addicted media such that they believe anything that Media is dishing out to them and they just blindly follow it.
Would like to know others view regarding this...
By
Sudeep Tarafdar, Senior Consultant, IBM
| 08 21 2009 14:29:35 +0000
|
"Please cite an example of CONTROVERSY without CONTENT being in place!" This question i specifically to all those people who are on the other side of the fence... Take the clasic example of toostep. There was a lot of controversy on certain debates. WAS IT WITHOUT CONTENT???
By
Makrand Bhave, Marketing & MICE, WIZCRAFT International
| 08 27 2009 18:00:45 +0000
i belive contants, i mean how many will be driven by controvarsy,... may be ok for startup but for the long term this is content only which will impress readers, and a satisfied reader is key to success of any literature not a controversy driven one..... toady most of famous books are sobecause of contents ie. gone with wind, a train to pakistan, suitale boy...etc... these are not having any controversies behind them....
By
Nagpal Singh, Sales and Business Development, Babel Group of companies
| 08 25 2009 14:20:26 +0000
Now with Arun Shouri joining the band wagon of Jaswant Singh the latter has been misquoted and misjudged and expelled the people will definitely look in to content as to which criteria our Journalist friend has pointed out?
By
Mallaya Pandravada, GM-Project , GSSInfraTech Pvt Ltd
| 08 25 2009 09:00:12 +0000
I think its CONTENT!! The content added FUEL to the FIRE... COntrovery is created after it is written or spoken or even broadcast!! The content when published did the damage that it did! It stirred into a controversy when the figure behind the puiblished content became known. I am of a firm opinion that its always content that leads to controversy. If his book is become a hot property and is selling like hot cakes, it is I am sure fuelled by the cointent now than when it hit the stands. I agree that the sales must have seen an uproar because the controversy became known first!! I will buy it not for the fat of the stir but what caused it in the first place!! Thanks Sudeep ofr the referral... It is indeed a HOT debate... please book your copyrights... :))
By
Makrand Bhave, Marketing & MICE, WIZCRAFT International
| 08 24 2009 08:23:53 +0000
|