Build your professional network on facebook via our app Go to app
 
 
 
Created by : Abhishek Gupta, Director , Skills Factory  | 04 27 2010 11:21:13 +0000
Activity:  363 views;  last activity : 10 10 2010 14:33:13 +0000
 
 Refer 924
Share
 
 
  Rate : 
 
 
YES Vs NO
25
 
 
 
 
19
16
12
Support   Support
Top Argument
2
0

Yeah ofcourse Girls are prtty smarter for HR profession....their Softness is the most important factor that men really lack...what leads to the benefits for the firm in ter,ms of expenses on employee...their mind adaptablity towards the case handling is appreciable...


By Sourabh Suman, Asst. Manager, Branding and Models Co-ordination, Nish Webtech Pvt. Ltd.  04 28 2010 19:20:57 +0000
 
Top Argument
3
0

No, Girls or Boys, if they lack that fundamental aptitude for handling people, they fail despite their Degrees and would become liabilities to the Employees as well Employers.


By M. Prabhakar Rao, Author of "Mayhem Of The Miserables!", http://www.smashwords.com/books/view/52075  04 28 2010 12:58:20 +0000
Arguments in: "Girls do better in HR"
0
0

THANK YOU JYOTI FOR YOUR INVITATION.GIRLS HAVE AN INBUILT SOFTNESS, IN ADDITION TO THEIR WILLINGNESS TO BE POLITE,CORDIAL,SOFT SPOKEN ETC.HR IS ONLY AN ABBREVIATION OF HUMAN RELATIONS.STARTING FROM OUR OWN HOME GIRLS IRRESPECTIVE OF THEIR AGE TEND TO GET ALONG WITH OTHERS,AVOIDING A CONFRONTATIONIST ATTITUDE AND GIVE DUE RESPECT TO OTHERS.THEY COULD NOT BE EASILY CONVINCED BUT,THOUGH THEY HAVE MORE CONVINCING CAPABILITIES.WITH ALL THESE AND MORE THEY SHOULD ALWAYS FARE BETTER NOT ONLY IN HR BUT ALSO IN VARIOUS WALKS OF LIFE.


By s.baalu , Consultant, XYZ LTD  | 05 01 2010 13:24:02 +0000
0
0
girls give best results where goals and parameters are fixed HR is suitable field for girls.
By PRITHVI RAJ DUBEY, Managing Director, RAJ ENGINEERING INDUSTRIES PVT LTD  | 04 29 2010 16:04:16 +0000
0
0
yeah :: finesse .. aesthetics reqd.. :: ::...hr not for real men ..::....i agree real men r dangerous , shabby & unkempt , uncouth..
By Ajay Ziz, Dy. Registrar,, University of Jammu  | 04 29 2010 09:22:38 +0000
0
0

Yes, of course, HR is a function which needs a lot of finesse, aesthetics, and overall housekeeping abilities, which obviously a lady is able to do justice to, very well.


By Jaya Ray, Manager, KyaZoonga.com  | 04 29 2010 08:58:18 +0000
0
0

i belive they edge out only on one thing n dats being empathatic. we must value others emotion and i belive male counterparts are more practical than being drowned by emotions......so way to go for:)........


By Chinansha M. Ahuja, Associate Director, Holistic Placements  | 04 29 2010 06:33:07 +0000
0
1

YES... THEIR EMOTIONAL NATURE IS A BIG BIG PLUS...

To me personally, HR is more about Human Relationship, rather than Resources. A Company GROWS FASTER WITH HAPPY EMPLOYEES... and to keep them Happy, one just needs to CARE ABOUT THEIR BASIC REQUIREMENTS.

It does not take much to achieve this. A WOMAN / GIRL in HR can do this JOB commendably, simply because inspite of being a Professional... at Heart She is still a Woman. Just like a Woman Runs Her Family & keeps them Bound with her Love & Care... same way She can take Care of the Company Employees, After all a Company where U work, is also like your Family too...

SOURCING OUT the Right Person for the JOB, is just the start of an HR Activity... BUT... to retain Him/ Her Happily is more crucial & important.

JYOTI... A very good Debate, which will compell Corporates to think on these lines.

Happy Debating Friends !   


By Naushad H.L., Creative Director, MAD COMMUNICATION  | 04 29 2010 05:57:01 +0000
0
0
in my opininon its right girls do and handle the cases fast and in good manner in HR
By virender kumar, REGIONAL BUSINESS MANAGER, CELON LABS LTD  | 04 28 2010 15:49:45 +0000
1
0

In my 40 years experience I have seen Girls are more commited to their jobs compared to Boys. Boys get easily distracted, and less focused and less goal oriented.


By Venkataraman D. Iyer, Freelancer  | 04 28 2010 13:49:45 +0000
1
0

i liked to see a male understanding the thing in exactly they same way as they are...really appericiate it.


By Minakshi Kapoor, Executive2, Secure Energy  | 04 28 2010 12:38:31 +0000
1
1

Yes girls do better as HR as HR has to understand human behaviours well and we should see what we expect from our HR.. we want them to understand our concern and girls emotional end helps them understand things better and as far as rountine work of is concerned it is a repititive and more of documentary kind of work both girl and men can do them easily.


By Minakshi Kapoor, Executive2, Secure Energy  | 04 28 2010 12:36:00 +0000
1
0

No matter what one say's Girls make a good HR
1) Since maximum aspirations are Guys, Guys like to attend calls from HR who are Girls, Hence Girl HR can attract Quantity to select from.

2) People are more likely to Listen to Girls and reach a settlement when HR is Girl

3) There is less chances of arguments with Girl HR in case of dispute.

and so on...

OFCOURSE there is exception when candidate is stubborn about his career goal and dream job.

GAME IS ALL ABOUT NATURAL ATTRACTION TOWARDS OPPOSITE SEX.

Had our society been a FEMALE dominant opposite argument might have been posted by a WOMEN.


By Navneet Hegde, Software Developer, Procit B.V  | 04 28 2010 12:31:34 +0000
1
1
Yes. Girls do do better in most areas as they seem to have a desire to "show-off" and entire the male bastion. Girls doing better in HR will be OK for white collar job areas like IT?. When it comes to the case of "blue collar" sections like in factories girls will lag behind as the language, the culture etc. goes against female sensibilities
By V. Srinivas, Freelancer, Information Technology  | 04 28 2010 12:04:12 +0000
1
1

Abhishek wht doubt, of course it is girls who perform better in HR. Because we are good in managing than mens. We can do multi tasks which mens find it difficult. The main reason why companies prefer womens is for their patience and clear decisions...... 

:)


By Jyoti Kapoor, HR Manager, Cybage Software  | 04 28 2010 11:33:06 +0000
1
1
i never agree with this.promotions depends upon our talent and presentation skills not on beauty.if all the managers are following beauty mantra then there is no scope of organization growth only presonal growth.
By mehargayatri marella, Software Engineer, AS Software Solutions  | 04 28 2010 05:09:32 +0000
0
0
I want to see opinion of people on this topic
By Abhishek Gupta, Director , Skills Factory  | 04 27 2010 11:21:13 +0000
0
0
you see with girls there is always a soft corner in our hearts and in some areas they are always seeking help.
By Bharat Ashokkumar Tiwari, Lab technician, Aditya Birla Group  | 04 30 2010 11:52:27 +0000
0
0
No your gender does'nt matter untill thing you do are sensible and in sync with organizatinal interests
By SidharthaKasiraju , Business Analyst, support executive, SG Technologies  | 04 29 2010 12:36:04 +0000
0
0

i think that in today era it has became a trend for Gals.

But i think that there should not be any comparison between both.


By Arun , Associate Technology L2, Sapient Corporation  | 04 29 2010 08:21:34 +0000
0
0

agree with you,


By Abhishek Gupta, Director , Skills Factory  | 04 29 2010 06:32:00 +0000
3
0

It depends upon the type of insdustry say we can divide our industries into 2 parts.

1> Manufacturing Sector ( mechanical/electrical/electronics/pharma) mostly labour oriented & dominated industry.

2>Service sector (IT/ITES/KPO/BPO/Broking firms/Research Firms/Banking/Insurance/Hospitality/Airlines etc)

HR people are having their true requirement into point 1 companies where there are hughe problem like labour problems, staff problems ,union level issues,strikes etc.

HR people just come for enjoyement in point no2 companies, in my 5 years of career into S/W insdutry i never found anybody working hard & late after 6PM.They only came with good make-up,short dresses & specially with lot much to eat, They always sit into canteen for more than 1 hour during lunch break , again for tea break again for snack break, total 3 hours wasted, 1 hour they stroll around all cubicle making some PJ about page 3 people,They don't have challenging job to do as all are too much educated & do not blame HR, appraisal time is also very smooth for them just saw the face of employee & then if they found him smart, good looking, wooing behind them then make apprisal , if they don't do then still no worries at all since professional never come up & hit you or curse HR people,no responsiblity, no tension just come to office eat tiifin, do all time blah blah blah & sharp 6.0 clock not 6.05 also to go home pretending they are handling all organisation

But in manufacturing sector union people shows them starts in a day, when they say a single word union people say 10 slang, Union people know how to handle these HR people very well, Here pressure is too much people directly slang to HR,even in strike perioed mob hit the HR people ouside company premises, they make life of HR peole like HELL comes to ground.

 


By Amit Saraf, Software Developer, Rave Technologies (India)  | 04 28 2010 15:01:28 +0000
1
0

Girls can better do in HR at grassroot level, but making policies regarding human resources are better done by males.


By mahendra kumar, Design Engineer, mecon  | 04 28 2010 14:50:08 +0000
1
0

As any other profession HR is highly competitive and demands professional attitude. You'll find most of the HR leaders of both gender (More male) in fortune 500 companies and top companies in India. Girls are doing well and good agreed but we should not generalise and develop perception that Girls are better HR mangers.


By rahulparasar , MBA/PGDM student, Jamia Millia Islamia, New Delhi  | 04 28 2010 13:20:52 +0000
0
0

Basically it is the system plays big roll in HR activities, so it doesn't matter it is girl or boy, woman or men.


By Manikandan Sankar, CEO/MD/Director, Eclat Tech Solutions  | 04 28 2010 13:19:58 +0000
1
0

HR is not only training, salary management and hiring people. It is dealing with humans, their Psychology, negotiations and IR. Therefore men are better option in all eventualities.


By AJAY SEHGAL, Corporate Advisory Manager, COTTAGE INDUSTRIES EXPOSITION LTD  | 04 28 2010 12:07:04 +0000
0
0

It all depends on the nature of the company job.


By mahendra kumar, Design Engineer, mecon  | 04 28 2010 12:03:18 +0000
0
0

It's not Girls or Boys, A Good Person usually does good in HR.


By Yogeshwar Vhatkar, Software Engineer - Product Engineer, Symphony Services  | 04 28 2010 12:02:27 +0000
Preferred Executive Search and Recruitment partners for Global IT and BPO organizations
  • Create a confidential Career Profile and Resume/C.V. online
  • Get advice for planning their career and for marketing of experience and skills
  • Maximize awareness of and access to the best career opportunities
Viewers also viewed
yes it is vs dont think so
 
1374 referals 30 arguments, 538 views
women only have an adjusting type to handle the administration vs Man can able take correct...
 
1639 referals 24 arguments, 315 views
Today I went through a post which named “To educate a girl is to educate an entire nation” ....
 
667 referals 8 votes, 693 views
more...  
Recent Knowledge (5)
WE HAD A GOOD NUMBER OF INVENTORS WITH GREATER VISION ABOUT THE SOCIETY. INVENTORS HERE NEED NOT...
 
2 referals 2 arguments, 97 views
These days as I switch on the tv or radio or look at a hoarding I do feel that power of ads I...
 
3004 referals 23 arguments, 482 views
C vs B
 
0 referals 3 arguments, 51 views
more...  
More From Author
TO three rightside column writers, Mainly Ardhendhu. Nobody can change ur So negative and overworking brain and its too kiddish to answer ur each Non Intelligent questions, Please stay away from toostep , I think u r doing just to get some comments on...
SIDE EFFECTS of working in the IT sector _____________________________________________________________ Once I was flashing my ID card instead of unlocking the house door with keys. __________________________________________________________  Just...
more...