Build your professional network on facebook via our app Go to app
 
 
 
Created by : Deepika Malik, Associate, HDFC Bank  | 10 29 2008 09:01:28 +0000
Industry : Equity Research/AnalyticsFunctional Area : India(Markets)
Activity:  143 views;  last activity : 07 06 2010 20:18:09 +0000
 
Share
 
 
  Rate : 
 
 
Yes Vs No
2
 
 
 
 
3
1
3
Support   Support
 
Top Argument
2
0

I will totally disagree to the point put forth by Ms Malik. There's no evidence that lack of flexibility has hit investment. Also, even the nominal pay for firing workers has been kept at a mere 15 days of wages. Some time ago, the Reserve Bank of India did a study and found that workers are not responsible for 60 per cent of the problems with any given company. Problems like mismanagement, embezzlement and government policy took the chunk of the blame for companies running losses. But when an industry becomes sick, it  is the worker who gets the axe.


By Sukumar Maity, Sr. Associate, IDBI Bank  10 29 2008 09:02:46 +0000
0
0

Clearly not. But to take the case of the Indian airline industry which is in the news, its fleet must be cut by a fifth but it can't do this unless it also has the right to fire workers. If you don't have labour flexibility, firms will just employ more capital and this will hurt the workers whose interests are being protected. The good thing about contract labour is that it gives jobs. We have 12.5 million people joining the labour force annually and only 2.8 million have formal training. The remaining 10 million can get trained only in a contract job and they can then go up the ladder. If you don't have flexibility in the law to allow companies to remove workmen, industry will depend more on machines as they can't take on any more permanent liability than their capacity.


By Deepika Malik, Associate, HDFC Bank  | 10 29 2008 09:01:28 +0000
0
0

Yes in concord with Sukumar's view, I would disagree with Ms Malik.  There are lot of ways to evade job cuts.  eg

1. Salary cuts for a specified period ( more importantly at all levels )

2. Remove or lessen the bonus components

3. Find methods to reduce cost and improve operations...

Job cut should be the very very last option if nothing of above or else doesnt work.

And I am very sure that an employee will happily agree to these solutions rather than getting laid off and will respect the company more.  This will not only boost employee's morale and inspire him to work more religiously but also his association period with the company may increase.  Because bad times never will last for forever and when they surpass companies will more determined and loyal employees than before.

Recent examples that comes to my mind is that of Goldman Sachs.  It did the same thing and to honour its employees patience and loyalty, it not only gave them the raise they deserved a year back bt were served with approx 100% bonuses.

So tt is always bilateral relationship because no company exists without its employees.


By Nitin Anand, SAP Professional, J P Morgan  | 12 15 2009 07:24:07 +0000
0
0

Regulations should help get redistributive justice for everyone. The second Labour Commission had recommended that every retrenched employee get 90 days' salary per year multiplied by the days of service. The law now provides just 15 days' salary. In China, if someone loses his job in sick government units, it is the government's responsibility to provide 50 per cent wages per year till it is able to find him an alternative job. It may apply this to private companies too. If you are a country with a surplus population, throwing you in the Arabian Sea is certainly not a solution. It is a governance issue. The government can't simply wash its hands off this. Profits should be for people and not over people. Surely companies can allow people to sit at home for six months with wages till they get another job? Mahatma Gandhi said that industry is a trust and the employer is a father who should look after workers as his children. Today it is convenient to forget all this ideal of trusteeship.


By Subhrangshu Das, Sr. Associate,bulls Research  | 10 29 2008 09:03:01 +0000
Leading software and staffing company
  • Create a confidential Career Profile and Resume/C.V. online
  • Get advice for planning their career and for marketing of experience and skills
  • Maximize awareness of and access to the best career opportunities
Viewers also viewed
India's much-needed infrastructure development. That fund will be available only to large...
 
416 referals 3 votes, 236 views
Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme has been luring away the work force....
 
1109 referals 27 arguments, 433 views
Goldman Sachs , the US investment banking giant, has issued a short-term alert over investing in...
 
616 referals 5 votes, 151 views
more...  
Recent Knowledge (86)
PM comes and declares few things and goes. He is not in regular touch and updating people about...
 
1900 referals 31 arguments, 231 views
Is it that we see them as threat and they see us. Is it possible that they feel that the same...
 
1766 referals 20 arguments, 209 views
Yes vs No
 
1332 referals 14 arguments, 124 views
more...  
More From Author
What could be the best trading strategy?
Recommendations and research - One should consider brokerage firms just because they have done research and it is the bread and butter for them, where they are trading everyday, Every investment brokerage firm uses financial professionals to research...
My idea is we should not leave the brand until the end of the process. It must be discussed upfront. A degree of tenacity may be required as the advisors will not be focusing on the brand - their objective is to get the flotation away. Therefore, it...
more...