Build your professional network on facebook via our app Go to app
 
 
 
Keywords : it mba corporate recruiter
Activity:  362 views;  last activity : 07 06 2010 20:18:09 +0000

For most of the leading companies to hire a Recruiter the compulsive education criteria is MBA or a Post Graduation Diploma in HR. Does this really helps them by providing the desired resources or they lose out on good candidates by blocking their opportunities???

 
Share
 
 
  Rate : 
 
 
Yes, MBA is required to have good managerial & hiring skills Vs No, MBA doesn't hold any significance in recruitments.
5
 
 
 
 
11
4
7
Support   Support
Top Argument
2
0

I wouldn't say that MBA is mandatory if one wants to be a HR manager in the corporate world but it do act as a value-addition in terms of various skills that you can incorporate through this course.MBA degree certainly provides that little bit extra with respect to managerial skills,communication skills & doing MBA in HR will specialises you in hiring eligible people according to the job requirements.Many people are doing this course because they are getting some value-addition from this and adds a lot to your personality in various aspects.


By Gargi Sinha, Senior Consultant, Hewitt Associates  05 11 2009 05:33:09 +0000
 
Top Argument
3
0

A Person must have vision to understand the company needs & indebth knowledge of profile to recruit a relevant candidate. A person working in a recruitment firm might have better knowledge & convincing skills than a corporate recruiter as he is exposed to multiple technologies & requirements from diversified fields.


By Suvidha Mahajan, Manager Recruitments & Operations, Phi RMS Pvt Ltd  04 21 2009 10:15:27 +0000
1
0

As it is a professional course, it is a value addition to your role. Helps to undersatnd the importance of HR in an organisation. Say, hiring is nothing but bringing an asset to your oraganization, What if a candidate is technically proficient but lost in attitude?


By Joe Cherian, an MNC  | 06 03 2009 10:13:37 +0000
0
0

yes i do agree with prakash here...as MBA is not the only criteria they are looking for..infact nowadays they are looking for various domain skills..and as per seeing the requirements these days by the companies...where they are asking for more than 2 types of skills apart from the main work that the candidate is into...so MBA helps in this criteria....


By Rohit Khanna, Project Leader/Managing Consultant, Accenture  | 05 12 2009 12:06:25 +0000
2
0

Intersting Question. There are 2 aspects to this question. And as I see it one need not follow the other.

A corporate will have certain culture codes and other criteria which ensures there is a certain uniformity in the team. From that perspective an MBA acts as a filter to a smoother hiring match.

An MBA alone is not going to make a better recruiter. Infact to be a recruiter the candidate would have to develop other job relevant set of skills + develop an interest in the job.

To rephrase 

The reason why Large Corporates choose a Qualification Criteria is to ensure uniformity. There other tools to assess whether a candidate is a safe bet for a Recruitment role.

Please feel free to punch holes in this view :) . Its an interesting debate. Thanks Suvidha.

 

 


By Prakash Francis, Director, Enterprise Hiring Solutions  | 05 11 2009 08:16:02 +0000
0
0

I think only a degree cant give you the ability to judge anybody,that is totally your own vision,I am not saying that MBA or any other degree doent worth,but a recruiter should understand each of every aspect of the person to whom he/she is interviewing.....


By Gaurav Malviya, Manager, bentley systems  | 03 21 2010 14:42:26 +0000
0
0

For all i think MBA is not mandatory to hold to be in the corporate world.Because i believe in learning through working.May u could be a one step ahead of knowing some extra knowledge but that you could come to know through your experience also.So it wont be true to say that having  MBA degree matters to recruiters.


By roumi chatterjee, asst commercial executive, century plyboard india ltd  | 01 05 2010 11:02:59 +0000
0
0

I don't think that One should have MBA degree to work as a Recruiter in Corporate,Not only in recruitments but also in other professional areas like Marketing,Finance etc MBA doesn't hold any Value.We cann't consider MBA as a contributory factor to create/cultivate managerial skills in anyone.One can find so many people in corporate world who are professionally doing very well without having any MBA Degree.Many of them are placed at high position like Managers,Sr. Managers,AVP,VP etc and they are very effective in Managing large teams.So it is not the Degree which helps anyone to rise in Professional world,it's the qualities/attributes/attitude that makes anyone to grow in professionalism.These people have good decisive power,leadership qualities,managerial skills,effective communication,negotiation & convincing skills etc which sometimes MBA degreeholders doesn't possess.There are so many Great bussinessmen who built great Business empire without having high qualifications like Dhiru Bhai Ambani etc.Even in our political world there are some great personalities who doesn't have any Management degree but makes great contribution in our politics.
As I have done my Master of Commerce with Specialisation in Business Administration and presently I am working as a Recruiter in a Consultancy,still I believe it's not the MBA degree that incorporates good Managerial & hiring skills in you,but it entirely depends upon an individual's personality, his/her goals and what that person wants to be? For eg. if a person wants to be a recruiter he/she has to cultivate this type of characteristics like good decision making,effective communication,negogiation skills,patience etc. Some persons have these attributes by birth & others have to acquire it.
Even some MBAs are lacking in getting good fit for their organisation,not having effective negogiation & convincing skills.Moreover now-a-days Corporates approaches Placement Consultancies for filling up their vacant positions and everyone knows the fact that most of the recruiters in consultancies are Graduates only.
So every organisation have to give a Chance to Non-MBAs to prove their worth and it may be possible that they will prove themselves as a better asset for the organisation than a MBA Degreeholder.

Regards
Shelly
Consultant
Black Tutle


By Shelly Guptarishi, Sr. Consultant(Recruitment), Black Turtle Placement Consultancy  | 06 29 2009 11:59:42 +0000
1
0

Its only about the company criteria that for becoming HR Manager or for promotion from Sr. HR to HR Manager & above you should have MBA degree it can be via DLP mode also.

MBA is just a post grad. degree, I have seen thousands of Fresh MBA HR professional joined as Sr. HR, HR Manager & requesting on citehr.com for Offer letter format, Joining letter, Pay slip & lots of query. What they have done in their MBA HR.

Good Managerial & Hiring skills are not slave of any Professional degree, its just a myth.


By a , a  | 06 07 2009 08:35:15 +0000
1
0

I support this.I ve also been an consultant and one gets lots of technology exposure in a consultancy than a corporate... You are confined to a limited technologies in a corporate...

MBA can act as a knowledge source which can be sought from online source now a days...

 In recruitment, you have to test the tone of the candidate and match up with the requirement which could be quite well learnt through hands on experience. its not necessary to have a MBA  degree to recruit a proper person.

 

 


By Hema , Asst Mgr HR , Aversan Inc.  | 06 04 2009 08:26:33 +0000
0
0

I would like to say that if recruitments is the only thing you would like to do in corporate I dont think so that MBA degree is mandatory as it is more of selling and convincing skills that are required. 

In order to be in all gamuts of HR in corporate MBA always is a plus and helps.

 


By Ashutosh Pandita, Sr Business Manager-IT Search, Quadrangle-Infoedge India  | 05 11 2009 08:14:34 +0000
Leading Recruitment, Outsourcing Firm
KAPTCO Talent Solutions Pvt Ltd., (KAPTCO) promoted by young, dynamic and dedicated professionals, offers a wide-range of HR services and has established itself as paramount recruitment brand in this gigantic arena of organized executive search firms in India. We consciously thrives to reach......
Viewers also viewed
yes vs no
 
831 referals 12 arguments, 172 views
only book knowledge vs good communication skills
 
24 referals 14 arguments, 776 views
Today everybody is running for an MBA. But can an MBA make a better manager? After engineering...
 
1105 referals 63 arguments, 2490 views
more...  
Recent Knowledge (4)
These days as I switch on the tv or radio or look at a hoarding I do feel that power of ads I...
 
3004 referals 23 arguments, 492 views
C vs B
 
0 referals 3 arguments, 51 views
I am associate of prajapati association and i am working for BJP from year 2005 to till date....
 
0 referals 3 arguments, 111 views
more...  
More From Author
Sometimes candidate shows too lousy or casual approach towards the position. Seems to have limited knowledge of the job profile & are not dressed up according to the job. This leads to an immediate effect of HR straight away rejecting the candidate on...
India must have strengthened its ties with Russia instead of focusing on making adjustments with US. India seem to have lost the only friend it had in due course of time due to its proximity to a nation (US) which was always supporting the country...
Yes Tina, India should learn from the other countries how to deal with terrorism not only from US but from Russia Israel which encounter these problems like we do. But i still have doubts about Osama being caught, killed then being buried in Sea...
more...