Build your professional network on facebook via our app Go to app
 
 
 
Created by : AMIT KATOCH, Freelancer  | 08 18 2009 17:56:08 +0000
Functional Area : USA(Markets)
Keywords : america muslims
Activity:  333 views;  last activity : 07 06 2010 20:18:09 +0000

shahrukh has brought forward an issue that needs to be appropriately understood and dealt with accordingly.If what he said is true,then govt. has to take action so that our people are not harassed in states.

 
 Refer 65
Share
 
 
  Rate : 
 
 
Yes Vs No
8
 
 
 
 
20
8
11
Support   Support
Top Argument
6
5

Yes it is true to an extent that people with muslim name are treated differently at JFK and in the USA itself. This problem only started after the 9/11 attack. Even me because my surname sound like muslim feel a little hassled whenever  I passed through JFK.

 


By Devi Kaladeen, Audit Manager, Health Sector Development Unit  08 19 2009 04:51:06 +0000
 
Top Argument
8
0

Dear Friends,

I do not think only Muslims are being targetted for checking in the USA. SRK was checked, only because there were some reports of some terrorists using the similar name-SRK's full name.

And second, SRK was coming only with one more person with his, whereas he used to come with full film unit( around 20 members), always. This time SRK was in time-pressed situation, and he left for the USA alone with only one person. That made the Officers doubt him  this time....    And therefore, the long check-up. They did not detain him.

There many people were in the queue, and I do not think Mr. SRK should be allowed first ahead of others. If many of you do not know the Officers also stopped many VVIPs, for the long check-ups only because they had reports that some Terrorists were using these VVIP's names in their passports. And the matter relates to the National Security, I don't think the Officers at the Airports could do much about it.

Because of the this kind of secuity check-ups only, the USA could avoid another New York Tower Attack, and they spare nobody. Even Salman Khan was checked the same way, but he did not make any scandal out of that.

It may be possible that the Muslims are suspected more because most of the terrorists in the world are Muslims. But it is not true that all Muslims are Terorists.

But, finally , the USA is their country , and the US Government has all the rights and ways to defend their people and Nation , in whatever ways and howsoever they can... It is their internal matter.

The USA is not India where the Officers let the VIPs or VVIPs go without proper security check-ups, only by mere looking at the VIP tags on their car. Pleae do not forget what  happened  during the Indian Parliament Attack, when security gaurds did not do proper checkings only seeing a VIP car. And the Terrorists entered the Parliament premises, almost reaching a  point of killing most of the ministers, including the PM, if he could not delay in the last moment.

No doubt that people with this kind of mentality-" Let it be " or " Sub Chalta Hai"-- overlooking the national security can put the lives of thousands of people in danger at any time, and still have enough courage to defend their mistakes. Amazing people with amazing brains....

Rgds.

 


By Jaspal Singh Sodhi, CEO/MD/Director, Amway Kuber Infrastructures  08 24 2009 14:00:45 +0000
0
0

The American are a paradox they racially profile Muslims coming to US and still they are bed fellows with Pakistan the hot bed of terrorism remember OBL was in Pakistan with ISI blessing and they still know were is


By R.SANJAY GREGORY WILLIAMS, HR-Admin MNager, CItrisys solutions  | 04 15 2010 12:42:48 +0000
3
1

Well! Well! I simply gave my opinion and share my experience and four appreciative members think that it is not a good comment. No problem. My views still remains my views. However, I will never go on an international forum and criticise any important people in my country. 


By Devi Kaladeen, Audit Manager, Health Sector Development Unit  | 08 24 2009 20:04:47 +0000
3
1

Sharukh Khan is an icon globally. He don't need a publicity stunt to become famous.


By Devi Kaladeen, Audit Manager, Health Sector Development Unit  | 08 24 2009 13:25:30 +0000
3
1

Arnold Schwarzenegger invites 'detained' Bollywood actor Shah Rukh Khan to dinner

It is not clear whether Khan will accept the California Governor's invitation Photo: REUTERS
Arnold Schwarzenegger: California agrees multi-million pound budget deal
Officials from the US Embassy in Delhi were asked by the Indian government to explain why the film-star was held for so long Photo: AP

The actor turned politician has offered to meet Shah Rukh Khan on September 20 in Washington in a bid to diffuse what has become a slight diplomatic row.

Khan, 43, who is considered to be one of the icons of Indian cinema, was held up for almost two hours after falling foul of US border officials in a New York airport at the weekend.

Officials from the US Embassy in Delhi were asked by the Indian government to explain why the film-star was held for so long.

The actor, who has featured on Time Magazine's '50 Most Influential People' list, was said to have found his experience at Newark Airport 'embarrassing'.

However, it is not clear whether the actor will accept the invitation.

Khan has recently signed a £125 million deal with Fox-Searchlight in the US to distribute his latest movie.

Ironically named 'My Name is Khan', the film charts racial tensions in the US following the 9/11 terror attacks.

Arriving back home to his Mumbai home, the star explained how the experience four days earlier had affected him.

"I am scared of authorities and rules, so I try to follow the rules of the country I travel to," he said.

"Whenever I am in America, I have to report at least two hours in advance while travelling within the country for security reasons - they ask me to take off my clothes and shoes, and I do that. "But I never experienced this kind of treatment."

Khan denied that the detention drama was a publicity stunt for his forthcoming movie: "I don't think that I need publicity."

"If you want to give a tit-for-tat policy to American actors, then call me to frisk Angelina Jolie and Megan Fox whenever they are visiting India," he added.


By Devi Kaladeen, Audit Manager, Health Sector Development Unit  | 08 24 2009 13:21:03 +0000
4
1
Published: August 15, 2009, 18:34

SRK harassed at US airport

XPRESS Report

Bollywood superstar Shah Rukh Khan's name landed him in trouble with US immigration authorities who detained him early Saturday, according to Zeenews.com.

The top-billing actor, popularly known as SRK, was reportedly detained at the Newark International Airport in New Jersey due to his surname "Khan", which triggered an alert based on a list drawn up by US officials since the 9/11 terror attacks.

It took an intervention from Congress MP Rajiv Shukla, who spoke to the authorities in the US and the Indian consulate, before Khan was released.

US immigration officials also denied Khan a phone call for about an hour.

Khan was reportedly quizzed numerous questions by US a immigration official and his hand baggage was checked. 

Khan was in the US as guest of honour at an Indian Independence Day event. 

SRK said in a statement to a news daily: “I told them I was a movie star and had recently visited the country for the shooting of my film. Nothing seemed to convince the immigration officer. There were other immigration officers who even vouched for me but this particular officer did not listen to anyone. I even told them I had an invitation from the South Asian community and was there to attend an event.”

Shukla told Zee News: “It is really sad and unfair. Just because he has a common surname does not mean that every Muslim can be taken as a suspect or considered to be a terrorist. The concerned authorities should adopt an attitude so that a well-known name like Shah Rukh Khan is not harassed like this. They should focus on getting the actual suspects."

Ironically, the harassment comes at a time when SRK is about to finish shooting Karan Johar’s ‘My Name Is Khan’, a film on the touchy issue showing how minorities are being targeted for no fault of theirs only because of suspicion and no solid proof.

The actor is set to fly back home to India on Tuesday.


By Devi Kaladeen, Audit Manager, Health Sector Development Unit  | 08 24 2009 13:17:06 +0000
4
0

Amit Kumarji, the intentions behind your voice may be true, I respect them. Muslims may be being harassed in the US. But the words phrased are a bit........ Because, to answer the above question, one need not become muslim (if he is not) and go to US and come back and reply, no?

I have not gone to US and muslims may have been harassed there. Why the question did not arise before Mr. Shahrukh was stuck up there? Does Shahrukh represent ONLY muslim community and nothing else? Are you sure that Mr. Shahrukh was harrassed during his detention there? Are you sure that there are no other reasons than that he is a muslim - for his detention?


By taranath joshi, DGM Operations, EOL,  | 08 23 2009 05:55:52 +0000
4
2

Did any of you guys ever went to the USA? By the way none of you are muslims...so how do you know?


By Amit Kumar Malhotra, Freelancer, Freelancer  | 08 23 2009 05:37:53 +0000
0
0

I don't know if Muslims are harassed in the US, But, I can testify that non-muslims are harrassed (it is a mild word comparing the treatment) in the Gulf States (so called muslim countries)


By Varghese P Thomas, Country Manager  | 03 26 2010 07:54:11 +0000
0
0

I don't know if Muslims are harassed in US or not. But, I can testify that non-muslims are harrassed (it is a very mild word in comparison to the treament) in the Gulf States (so called Muslim countries) I am an engineer working in Kuwait for 9 years now...


By Varghese P Thomas, Country Manager  | 03 26 2010 07:52:23 +0000
0
0

I do not agree that muslims are being harassed in US. Let us understand certain exceptional cases cannot be taken to make generalised statement. In wake of twin tower attack US had to take exterme measures to ensure that it does not happen & that required extensive profiling & interrogation of muslim inhabitants & travellers ( on assumption that terrorist org will recruit only muslim for their nefarious designs).


By santosh kumar, Marketing Manager, AUTOMOBILE  | 09 08 2009 08:57:01 +0000
3
0

It is better to save general public who die in BOMB blasts than to show warmth to celibrities.

When BJP govt was in power they BUGGED the walls of London Premier Tony blair hotel room.

When the security and necessity of country comes...People should become sceptical even to GOD.

This is why there has not been single attack in America where as city dewellers and common day to day middle class people of India kept on dyeing on streets in their own mother land in the hands of terrorists...Sometimes you need to be able to apply brain and need to understand a WAR is a WAR afterall and we can't stay BLIND.


By Sayan Chakraborty, Senior ERP Consultant, International Business machines  | 08 24 2009 13:55:46 +0000
6
0

A BIG NO,HIS IS THE INTERNAL PROBLEM OF USA ,AFTER 9/11 FOR THERE COUNTRY SECURITY THEY ARE DOING SO,THEY DID FOR GEORGE AND ASKED NARENDRA MODI NOT TO ENTER,.

WHY AREN'T WE DOING FOR OUR COUNTRY SIMILAR AFTER26/11.


By SB DIKSHIT, STATE QUALITY MONITOR, U.P.R.R.D.A  | 08 23 2009 06:41:50 +0000
2
0

Amit is right. Just because Shahrukh Khan was harrased, it shouldn't be concluded that all Muslims are harassed. Shahrukh Khan is a celebrity. That doesn't mean there should be separate rules for him that in a country like America which is always under the threat of terrorist attack. So what Shahrukh is celebrity, he is also India, so he should also undergo all the security rules. He is not a President of India.Just a film star.Thats it and news howled as if they tried to kill him. A few days back, even Emran Hashmi, after not able to get a flat in Mumbai blamed that he was ill treated because he is a Muslim. I can't understand why some Muslims of India relate every personal issue with religion ? Just to create publicity that whole religion is under threat ? They are not minorities and why should any Non-Muslim country take risk when all the terrorist activity is done in the name of Islam ?

I still don't agree to the fact that Islam is ill trated in USA or else Barack Obama, who is the son of a Muslim father, wouldn't have become the president of that country....


By Sarika Singh, Assistant Professor, BIT  | 08 19 2009 07:58:55 +0000
4
0

there is big no for the above topic

 i 'll go with d comment of MR AMIT


By varsha , Head/VP/GM-Quality, frac  | 08 19 2009 03:21:04 +0000
3
0

I dont know.

What you say Ms. Alkaji, may be true. There were news in the newspapers regarding underworld connections with cine-celebrities. If Mr. Khan is clean, there is no need to worry and people should keep cool. Only problem would be his personal schedules may have upset, for which he himself OR his personal asst (if he has any) should be responsible.

Comming to the main arguement, if there is any problem like pandemic or fight, the foreigner will be strangled natuarally - may be, nothing special for muslims, I hope. Do we not worry foreigners coming to India - if at all they brought swine flu? that should not be taken as harrassment.


By taranath joshi, DGM Operations, EOL,  | 08 19 2009 01:58:39 +0000
3
0

I would say the authorities at the NY airport were only doing their duty without discriminating between a common man and a celebrity. Duty always comes first without discriminating any caste, creed, religion, origin, etc.


By Alka Thakur, Technical Support Manager, Vendio Services and a freelance German Translator  | 08 19 2009 01:30:25 +0000
6
1

i feel its my big 'No' right at the moment.We cant come to the conclusion just because shahrukh khan has been harassed.We got to investigate the shahrukh episode.May be some faux pas has happened and otherwise things are in place . So It wont be right to brand america anti-muslims.There is lot of muslim population in states.And some of them are doing  very well .

 


By AMIT KATOCH, Freelancer  | 08 18 2009 18:00:58 +0000
Part of Randstad, the world’s second largest HR services company
Director – Commercials Jobs in Bangalore
Senior Process Associate Jobs in Chennai
Intercompany Associate Jobs in Chennai
Viewers also viewed
Danger to India's BPOs and Call Centres? vs No danger to Indian economy!
 
381 referals 10 arguments, 405 views
Yes vs No
 
0 referals 2 arguments, 196 views
                                             Hindu-Muslim Unity                                 ...
 
210 referals 7 comments, 269 views
more...  
Recent Knowledge (5)
WE HAD A GOOD NUMBER OF INVENTORS WITH GREATER VISION ABOUT THE SOCIETY. INVENTORS HERE NEED NOT...
 
2 referals 2 arguments, 107 views
These days as I switch on the tv or radio or look at a hoarding I do feel that power of ads I...
 
3004 referals 23 arguments, 502 views
Nirmal Baba is a fraud vs Nirmal Baba is a Saint
 
513 referals 6 arguments, 45 views
more...  
More From Author
todays world needs managers who are able to work at diffrernt verticals with the same ease.This needs a thorough information that is possible only through online route as class room is restricted by the four walls.Therefore the great advancement has...
i support swimming as its a complete exercise which means all the body ,internal as well as extenal,excercises while swimming.Also the most important component of the body is heart.Swimming increases the cardiac output of the heart so your body works...
dear suyashi i think handling it physiologically will not address the psycological blocks.This can be handled only through education .
more...