I agree,, MBA study gives us a additional knowledge for managerial role.
By
NITIN TIKARAM ZOPE, Sr. Design Engineer, ABG SHIPYARD
| 01 18 2012 18:01:39 +0000
I think MBA make a perfect professional person.
By
Saiyad Arifmahamad, MBA/PGDM student, Oxford School Of Management, Mehsana
| 01 18 2012 07:16:51 +0000
As per my concern, its a true. the reason behind this is that MBA candidate know his roll in organization, they are well aware about the environment, competitors, customers, etc. & other environment affecting the business. they are also well educated.
By
Saiyad Arifmahamad, MBA/PGDM student, Oxford School Of Management, Mehsana
| 10 05 2011 12:54:48 +0000
I also believe that it is better to hire a MBA Manager rather than going with a non-MBA manager. Simply because, there is nothing that a non-MBA manager can do & an MBA manager can't, But, after all the studies that he has gone through & by learning from the work experience, there is always a possibility that given appropriate opportunities he/she may do something that the non-MBA cannot do.
By
Kshitiz Kumar, B.Tech/B.E. student, Shri Sant Gadge Baba C.O.E.T
| 12 23 2010 23:37:03 +0000
Business managers require MBA .All managers do not require the MBA but should have the knowledge of business to understand their roll in the organistion wholesome growth.
By
Rajendran Mariagnanam Mariagnanam, Founder and managing partner, Braintrain consultancy services LLP
| 12 14 2010 12:24:35 +0000
Yes, MBA is a professional course related to managerial work top most company are heiring MBA students for managing their work engineering can start business but for managing it manager necessary with MBA.
By
M.B.MALANI , MBA/PGDM student, R.R.INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT BANGALORE
| 12 14 2010 09:01:20 +0000
MBA is an accessory for an employee to become a manager otherwise experience. Moreover, it provides a panorama of the business environment which makes life more comfort when join in an organization for the graduates.Also, it's not that those who have done MBA can be managers and those who didn't are not, it's the performance that matters. Present day scenario need MBA,We can't conclude that MBA isn't required by looking at the people who've not done MBA(Dhirubhai, bill gates,nilekani..) if it's true then why the young richest did it!!
By
krishna das puravarikkal, B.Tech/B.E. student, viswanatha institute of technology and management
| 12 14 2010 05:57:31 +0000
The top managers in the world are not mba however the companies hiring mba because they fulfill a minimum number of criteria to be a manager.
By
Nitin Mehra, Writer, Thinker, Technology Seekar
| 11 27 2010 12:31:06 +0000
its a yes and no from my side. MBA gives one added advantage. But the one who is not an MBA has experience about what one learns in MBA. The person might have taken 5 years to reach that postion where as an MBA would reach the same position in 2 years. MBA teaches us what to do, where as the person who isn't an MBA already knows how to do a concept learnt by an MBA.
By
KRITI A BHATNAGAR, HR Executive
| 11 24 2010 07:11:21 +0000
FOR BEING A MANAGER WHAT WE NEED IS THE CALIBER IN THE PERSON NOT A DEGREE....MANAGER IS ONE WHO COULD MANAGE THINGS ACCORDING TO THE SITUATION...........AND I THINK I COMES WITH THE EXPERIENCE NOT WITH THE STUDY..............SOME STUDENT ARE GOOD AT ACADEMICS BUT THY DON'T KNOW HOW TO TACKLE THE SITUATION.................AND ITS BETTER SAID THAT PRACTICE MAKES A MAN PERFECT
By
anamika ahlawat, HR Executive, MYFLEXIJOB.COM
| 11 24 2010 07:03:51 +0000
Sir if you are talking in terms of sales then definitely there in no need for an MBA guy but if you talk in terms of other aspects I think MBA is required depends on the job and company.
By
vibhav Kumar, Marketing Executive, Sri Balaji Enterprises
| 10 26 2010 09:53:30 +0000
yaa i agree ,
By
Nitesh Kumar, Transactions Processing Executive, Detucth Bank
| 10 19 2010 05:55:14 +0000
No amount of knowledge is enough for any person, the more you read, the more qualified you'll be.It's an absolute must have degree.
By
neha singh, Content Editor, Avestia Corp
| 10 06 2010 18:21:22 +0000
The main thing which is required for the managers is 'confidence' which comes from knowledge. Knowledge can be gained without MBA also. But MBA helps in gaining relevant knowledge. So it is helpful in present complex business environment,but not mandatory.
By
Deepak , Retail Store Manager, Reliance Industries
| 10 06 2010 18:04:07 +0000
definitely M.B.A. is required for decision making in day to day business
By
vishwas peddi, MBA/PGDM student, Institute Of Public Enterprise, Hyderabad
| 10 06 2010 17:34:43 +0000
yes ,I have a mixed argument,The world we live in is full of abnormalities ,for some people the have a power of decision making[Thats what MBA is all About]on their own but for some this power is acquired by experience as well as from learning , Now this dosent have to a class room one ,It can be acquired in the field while working.So Folks MBA is Required for an individual to become the best may be class room oriented or from their own experience
By
prashanth , MBA/PGDM student, New Delhi Institute of Managemment
| 10 05 2010 19:21:49 +0000
my vote goes for the MBA. i think to b a good manager u must have an mba but only if u r a amanager ian a corporate firm or any retail or marketing or advertisinf organisation. but if u want a manager in a technical organisation like BHEL OR ABB u must need to have a manager with technical background and vast experience.
By
vishwajit , Asst.Engineer, ERDA
| 10 05 2010 18:15:31 +0000
No,i dont agree.Managing is something which a person learns more from his real life experience rather than doing some MBA course...
By
Ranjit Nair, B.Tech/B.E. student, jodhpur institute of engineering and technology
| 09 21 2010 18:58:08 +0000
An MBA is absolutely necessary, as management is not easy to understand just by studying a professional field. The intricacies of business can be understood only by studying management.
By
neha singh, Content Editor, Avestia Corp
| 09 21 2010 17:35:01 +0000
We have the talent, we should overcome the rotton politics and curruption. A bold head will do the job.
By
Gopala Krishnan.H, CMD, DJA-Inc
| 09 18 2010 15:07:49 +0000
not every time , it is depends on the quality of person..
By
MOHD ASLAM, B.Tech/B.E. student, I.F.T.M (C.E.T) MORADABAD
| 09 18 2010 12:41:51 +0000
I agree with Kamakshi dubey, MBA is giving chance to increase the knowledge and quality
By
Mohammed zaheeruddin, Retail Store Manager at Coromandel International ltd
| 09 17 2010 14:14:25 +0000
I don't say that MBA is necessary or mandatory but having MBA is an add-on to your quality and knowledge..having MBA will help you to take any decision with some base and logic..will help you analyze on the prior basis consequences of any decision..I agree with rahul that if MBA doesn't required then why these IIM students are receiving better position as well as package
By
kamakshi dubey, MBA/PGDM student, institute of management studies, davv
| 09 16 2010 17:46:34 +0000
I will not say mandatory but it is necessary b'cause some important concepts are taught in collage which is a experience of many businessman in their life. that is why IIM student takes package of 1.64 carore/annum .without any prior experiance in business field
By
rahul p rinayat, Software Developer, Geometric Solution
| 09 13 2010 05:51:25 +0000
yes Managers need education how to manage. unfortunately we mix Managers and Leaders , leaders dont need any MBA.
By
Vivek Kumar Srivastava, Competence development Manager-Global Services , NSN
| 09 10 2010 09:50:45 +0000
For continuous growth its necessary but for only managers its not necessary. Only experience and result make them manager
By
Pratul Verma, Business Content Developer, AABS Pvt. Ltd.
| 09 09 2010 16:46:23 +0000
Yes I think MBA is better 4 being a good manager bcz it provide d proper way to growing in the managing life.................
By
Satish kumar karn, B.A student, NIIT
| 09 09 2010 15:13:23 +0000
MBA is a must to a manager since he the has responsibilities of managing things around the company and also bring in new things..
By
Ravishankar , M.Sc student, M.S. Ramaiah College Of Science, Bangalore
| 09 09 2010 13:54:29 +0000
MBA POLISHES AND TAKES OVER WEAKNESSES & SHORTCOMINGS OF YOUR ART AND SKILL. REST IS YOUR WORK AND LUCK
By
KUMAR SAURABH JHA, HR Manager
| 09 09 2010 13:52:46 +0000
MBA helps the person to gain knowledge in diverse fields from Behaviour to Accounts to Law to Mathematics. With such a diverse perspective and getting deep insight on practical situations through case studies, definitely a person with MBA can deal with any issue in a very effectiv manner.
By
Sanjay Kumar, Electrical Engineer - looking into Electrification, Air Conditioning, Fire Detection, Fire Fighting and other allied services, Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited
| 09 09 2010 10:28:38 +0000
In my openion Experience is the best education for any type of Managers but still MBA polishes the whole thing......
By
Gautam Dey, HR/Admin Manager, Netware Technologies Pvt. Ltd.
| 09 09 2010 09:29:17 +0000
|
MBA is really not required for managers, as I visualize MBA is only the management tricks to fix the salary. Just for example one of my friend is running an institute to train MBA graduates, he is just a Diploma holder with more than 20 years of experience in the industry. The candidates should get the training form industrialist rather than MBA institute. MBA institutes are Money making Business Agencies
By
NARAYANA V, Evolute systems Pvt ltd,
| 12 17 2012 16:20:30 +0000
MBA should not be the minimal criteria for being manager; but good MBA study obviously helps to groom anyone towards managerial role. Throughout the life everyone is being learned in various facet of learning but MBA is one of the most integrated ways of learning with practical approaches and practices which helps anyone to acquired skill to become a better manager.
By
Tanmay Sarkar, Project Manager- Global Sourcing, VWR International
| 01 26 2012 16:17:03 +0000
It requires perfect managerial brain and capacity to act as a Manager, MBA provides some theoretical knowledge as a feather on cap only
By
R N Bhattacharyya, Freelancer, Freelancer
| 01 24 2012 14:58:48 +0000
MBA does not make you a manager but can only teach you to be one. What makes you a manager or a better manager is LIFE. And this statement is from a grad. whos completed a regular MBA course as well as a distance one. Yes, MBA gives you the opportunity to make that extra money that your peers would certainly envy for and an edge over others to get recruited in a top notch orgn. BUT BELIEVE ME MBA IS NOT A ONE-STOP-SOLUTION FOR MANAGERS. ITS JUST A TICKET TO A COMFORTABLE LIFE AND NOT A LUXURIOUS LIFE THAT ONLY MANAGERS CAN DESERVE.
By
Saibal Ray, SQA, confidential
| 01 18 2012 16:33:55 +0000
in the world the most difficult task perform without mangers. like growing of plant or fly of bird. The world top business man rarely got mba when they had made millions of dollar. the world top scientist rarely got the education in very high institution. as i came to know the purpose of education is the birth of concept in mind but in these days education is producing another thing called ego. many people only think they are higher because they got some degree and other dont have that degree. Even I saw the peoples in situation where a new person presented a new concept in interview but he didn't select because he did not give the answer that the interviewer read thousand time in the book and he is not able to accept that there can be a new concept other then book too. what a hack?
By
Nitin Mehra, Writer, Thinker, Technology Seekar
| 05 01 2011 21:46:20 +0000
MBA IS A QUALIFICATION BUT MANY CEO HAVE NOT MBA DEGREE BUT THEY HAVE SKILL TO MANAGE A BUSINESS
By
mahendra kumar pareta, Branch Manager/Regional Manager, cjs medicare a retail chain
| 05 01 2011 15:27:56 +0000
there are many talented students who passed mba but don't get oppertunity to show their talent.
By
moupriya sengupta, MBA/PGDM fresher, ptu
| 04 30 2011 09:20:50 +0000
MBA is good for getting a JOB only? Managers can not be made in ... its an instinct .. all the MBA's are not the mangers ... but a simple graduated can become the CEO .. lot of example are there.
By
Priyank , Product Manager, Seo Process
| 04 20 2011 07:54:03 +0000
MBA is not required for Managers. It requires certain skills. Some academic courses help developing those skills but they are not mandatory.
By
Nilesh Pawar, Legal & Secretarial, Valencia Professional & Management Services LLP
| 02 25 2011 10:35:17 +0000
I am pursuing MBA & by reading i found that the ideas given in books have no more resemblanec with the practical issues. You have to think by own to solve any practical problem. So I disagree that MBA is required for managers. However it is essential in some of cases for promotion only to fullfill the psycological think of recruiters or boss. Regards, Anil Sharma Executive Technical sales Premier India (LUKAS) Delhi
By
Anil Kumar Sharma, Executive sales, Premier India Agencies
| 12 14 2010 13:19:22 +0000
"You need a degree in people"
By
Anoop Dhopte, Lead Developer, Avaya India
| 12 14 2010 13:14:11 +0000
How many MBA people are posted in TOP manager posts in large PSU/Private Sector industries!MBA degree just add some theoratical ideas.
By
R N Bhattacharyya, Freelancer, Freelancer
| 12 14 2010 08:08:15 +0000
Manager means who manages tacfully the situations. For this quality MBA is not necessary. MBA just add a degree and some extra knowlege to your career. this is an inner leadership quality. By MBA we can learnt how we improve our manager skills but no body can teach us how to manage differnt situation in real time. Such time no book theories will work only your mind and your soul wiill work and give you a command that how you will you manage that situations.
By
Tanima , First Medical Services Pvt. Ltd.
| 11 24 2010 06:42:48 +0000
In terms of Education,, MBA gives u an added advantage in the compettitive market, but managing the show is something which depends on the individual in coherence with the demanding situation & circumstance he/she is working upon / at..
By
Mohammed Sarfaraz Alam, Team Lead - Process Design & Quality Control, Powertech Automation Solutions
| 10 26 2010 08:48:08 +0000
You must first elaborate, 'Manager' of what type of organisation.In India, "MANAGER" posts are hold by any degree holder and it is >98% of total 'managers' in India.
By
R N Bhattacharyya, Freelancer, Freelancer
| 09 22 2010 07:00:03 +0000
No, not necessary. There are hundreds of examples of very successful non-MBA managers who took their companies to a newer height.
By
Suresh Prasad Gupta, Freelancer, Pharmaceuticals
| 09 16 2010 17:09:09 +0000
Not a must. But no harm. A way of managing that's all. But there are any nuber of examples without MBA / IAS people have excelled. My house contractor is just 7th std boy, In 30 years, from zero to hero. He has contrubuted to the society to a large extent,
By
Gopala Krishnan.H, CMD, DJA-Inc
| 09 16 2010 16:32:23 +0000
I totally agree with poonam.. There is no need of MBA degree for managing any company or firm or any organization.. The best example is Lalu prasad yadav, Mumbai dabba wale and there is so many people who never read this mba books and no one tell them how to manage things.. But the developed their skills and they are good managers.. Everyone has that quality but very few show this...
By
Nohar Singh Dhruv, Jr. Engg, Chhatisgarh State Electrical Board
| 09 16 2010 15:28:40 +0000
i do not support the argument that there is need for MBAs for managing the organization,as there we see various example around us the Guys Non-MBAs are performing well,eg-like dirubhai ambani,narayan murthi,nandan nilkeni htey were all NON-MBSs but still performing excellent....manager should will a good leader for that MBAs not required.
By
ARUN KUMAR SHAH, MBA/PGDM student, INSTITUTE OF MANAGEMENT STUDIES.
| 09 16 2010 14:55:12 +0000
In the practical life, the nature of thoughts one generate within are actually reflecting or manifesting outside in one's action, approach and behavioour and accordingly one manage activities in the outer world. Any one may be a better manager irrespective of qualification one possesses. It is not at all necessary that a MBA may be a better manager. I appreciate Poonam's creative thinking.
By
Nem Singh Gautam, Freelancer, Freelancer
| 09 10 2010 13:16:42 +0000
Not required, academically may be just to increase your knowledge. But people handling and business management came from experience only or its inherited and god given. Managers are born. You can find many example in Indian corporate who are not even graduate but running successfully million dollar company.
By
Priyank , Product Manager, Seo Process
| 09 09 2010 16:28:06 +0000
I REALY AGREE WITH YOU
By
mahendra kumar pareta, Branch Manager/Regional Manager, cjs medicare a retail chain
| 09 09 2010 15:29:45 +0000
Not really required. Academically it is good to have the degree. But there are many good managers without MBA. Hence MBA should not be manadatory in companies for the selection of good managers.
By
PV Divya Nair, research scholar, IIT Bombay
| 09 09 2010 14:22:23 +0000
Not really required. Academically it is good to have the degree, but without MBA also there will be good managers. Hence MBA should not be mandatory for selecting good managers.
By
PV Divya Nair, research scholar, IIT Bombay
| 09 09 2010 14:20:00 +0000
Not necessarily needed.
By
Kaushik Ghosh, CM, Information Technology, OFB, Ministry of Defence, Govt. of India
| 09 09 2010 12:51:52 +0000
NO MATTER EDUCATION IS IMPORTANT BUT EXPERIENCE IN RELEVANTE FIELD IS MOST IMPORTANT FACTOR,WHATEVER EMPLOYEE ARE MBA OR NOT............
By
RATNAKAR DWIVEDI, ACCOUNT CUM OFFICE ASSISTANT, SUSHIL CORPORATION
| 09 09 2010 12:35:00 +0000
MBA helps but cant take the argument that you must have it to be a better managers..Dhirubhai Ambani never did any Mba ..he still ran the show better than others..Mahatma Gandhi never did Mba but managed the entire nation..
By
Ravi Kumar Choudhary, Planning Manager, Encube ethicals Pvt. Ltd.
| 09 09 2010 12:04:04 +0000
I am with poonam MBA degree is not at all required.Dhiru Bhai Ambani,Bill Gates are a couple of examples of successful business leaders Regds Zaidi
By
saiyid safdar abbas zaidi, Consultant, self employed
| 09 09 2010 10:02:27 +0000
I support your views, Punam. MBA is not at all required for managers . Instead of MBA, PMP is better option for recognition.
By
SHRIKANT MANOHAR DANKE, Project Manager, Phadnis Infrastructur Ltd
| 09 09 2010 09:43:19 +0000
Depends-MBA is an added experience.Which will make one focussed.But it is the attitude and Aptitude that makes a good manager.
By
K.S Ashok kumar, Promoter / CEO, Aadithyaa Resorts lakeside-kollam,kerala.
| 09 09 2010 09:37:14 +0000
|
