foreign law firms can be permitted to work in our country with proper regulations to safe guard the interest of the nation in appropriate areas. There can be some restrictions. It would be benefecial for the legal practioners here to get more exposure in the current trend of globalisation. It would give new opening to new,young aspiring lawyers
By
Pugaleanthi , Lawyer/Attorney, S.P.Associates
| 10 13 2009 18:18:45 +0000
See guys, we are talking and living in panaorama of globalization, which requires thorough acquiantance of global judiciary system, 1. We are living in global panaroma, and if foreigh law firms are given chance to serve here in india, indian students will have access to international laws 2. In the state of globalization and MNC environment, this is necessory to have access to the internation law, which is possible easily when we have access to foreign law firms in india 3. this always is not possible for almost every law student to go abroad and study out there,
By
Nagpal Singh, Sales and Business Development, Babel Group of companies
| 08 16 2009 06:41:19 +0000
China has long allowded foreign law firms to take on non litigation cases in its teritory but has restricted their litigation cases. India is in the process of globalizing its economy. In the process, the legal market opening up to competition from the international legal market is rather inevitable. Instead of deliberating about the advantages and disadvantages of the legal markets being opened up to foreign firms, it is perhaps more sensible to accept that the entry of foreign firms in India is only a matter of time. However, this should not mean that their operations should nor be regulated, since otherwise they may just push out the Indian firms....
By
angel jain, Freelancer, Freelancer
| 08 14 2009 11:42:50 +0000
NANDKUMAR B.SAWANT.,M.COM.LL.B.(MUMBAI),ADVOCATE MOBILE. 09325226691,09271971251 e.mail.adv.nbsawant@yahoo.co.in e.mail.nandkumarbs@sify.com REGARDING THE ENTRY OF FOREIGN LAW FIRMS KINDLY NOTE THAT 1.INDIAN LEGAL SYSTEM IS ENTIRELY DIFFERENT FROM FOREIGN LEGAL SYSTEM .ACTS PASSED IN PARLIAMENT MUST BE STUDIED AND FOR PRACTICING AT INDIAN COURTS IT IS NOT THAT EASY.ONE SHOULD KNOW THE REGIONAL LANGUAGE AND HAS TO DEAL WITH LOCAL PEOPLE.HENCE EVEN IF FOREIGN LAW FIRMS ARE ENTERING THEN THEY HAVE TO TAKE HELP OF INDIAN LAWYERS .IT WILL GIVE BETTER OPPORTUNITY TO YOUNG PRACTICING LAWYERS.THE SENIOR LAWYERS ARE TOUGH ENOUGH TO FACE ANY COMPETITION. KINDLY NOTE THAT LEGAL PROFESSION IS ENTIRELY DIFFERENT THAN OTHER BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS WHERE THERE IS A THREAT FROM FOREIGN COMPANIES AND FIRMS. A MANUFACTURER HAS TO FACE COMPETITION FROM FOREIGN COMPANIES BUT IN CASE OF FOREIGN LAW FIRMS THEY HAVE TO WORK IN ASSOCIATION WITH LOCAL LAWYERS KINDLY NOTE. WITH BEST REGARDS NANDKUMAR B.SAWANT.M.COM.LL.B.(MUMBAI),ADVOCATE
By
NANDKUMAR B.SAWANT, LAWYER / ATTORNEY, LEGAL SERVICES FOR COURT CASES IN INDIA
| 05 31 2009 06:23:04 +0000
Our economy is in a globalisation mode, and to globablise means free entry and exit of foreign companies into our country with the specified restrictions and guidelines whereby there persist healthy competition with in the market with all small and big domestic companies. So why to restrict the foreign law firms into the country. As there are benefits of letting foreign firms enter our market with an Indian partner they are : 1. The employment opportunities emerge in the field where by upcoming freshers and trained lawyers get a platform to find a long lasting career with the better earning prospects. 2. With the edge of the cultural mix of employees with in the company the employees can share each others experience and can gain form it in their career. 3. With the international exposure the awareness about the international law with in the Indian lawyers improves where by in near future with the clause of " RECIPROCITY " when the Indian lawyer would be allowed to practice in foreign country he does'nt need time to update himself about the international law practices. 4. The performing lawyers may also get opportunity to work with the international counterparts where by they can get exposure.
By
Darshil , CEO/MD/Director, Darshil Cotton Company
| 05 20 2009 10:38:45 +0000
There are no issues foreign firms entering India with the common backgrounds. there is need of such firms.. These firms are welcomes as they would hire a lot of people with very good salaries.. also streamline the legal system in long term..
By
Japan Shah, H.O.D, Oxford School of Management
| 05 05 2009 11:46:45 +0000
I opine it will be good. It’s a good opportunity for freshers and good competition to the Indian Law Firms to prove/improve their profession. Also I opine simultaneously that Indian Law Firms also shall be allowed in Foreign Countries. Further I view that there will be more fair proceedings.
By
K.B. Upendar Sagar Upendar Sagar, Assistant (Legal Administration)
| 05 01 2009 10:53:20 +0000
NANDKUMAR B. SAWANT.,M.COM.LL.B.(MUMBAI),ADVOCATE MOBILE.09325226691, 09271971251 e.mail.adv.nbsawant@yahoo.co.in e.mail.nandkumarbs@sify.com REGARDING THE ENTRY OF FOREIGN LAW FIRMS KINDLY NOTE THAT 1.FOREIGN LAW FIRMS WILL REQUIRE ADDITIONAL SERVICES OF INDIAN LAWYERS.AND IT WILL CREATE MORE OPPORTUNITY TO YOUNG AND ALSO TO SENIOR LAWYERS.KINDLY NOTE THAT INDIAN LEGAL SYSTEM IS ENTIRELY DIFFERENT THAN FOREIGN LEGAL SYSTEM.UNLESS LOCAL INDIAN LAWYERS ARE ENGAGED BY FOREIGN LAW FIRMS THEY CAN NOT PROVIDE ANY LEGAL SERVICES.THE LAWYERS SHOULD STUDY THE INDIAN LAW AND ACTS PASSED.FOREIGNERS IT IS NOT POSSIBLE.HENCE NO NEED TO CARE ABOUT ENTRY OF FOREIGN LAW FIRMS. 2.INDIAN LAWYERS SHOULD UPDATE THE LEGAL KNOWLEDGE AND BE CONFIDENT.THIS IS A PROFESSION AND NOT A TRANSACTION FOR ANY SALE OF GOODS MANUFACTURED ABROAD IN THE INDIAN MARKET. WITH BEST REGARDS THANKING YOU YOURS SINCERELY NANDKUMAR B.SAWANT.,M.COM.LL.B.(MUMBAI),ADVOCATE
By
NANDKUMAR B.SAWANT, LAWYER / ATTORNEY, LEGAL SERVICES FOR COURT CASES IN INDIA
| 05 01 2009 04:15:46 +0000
NANDKUMAR B. SAWANT.,M.COM.LL.B.(MUMBAI),ADVOCATE MOBILE.09325226691, 09271971251 e.mail.adv.nbsawant@yahoo.co.in e.mail.nandkumarbs@sify.com REGARDING THE ENTRY OF FOREIGN LAW FIRMS KINDLY NOTE THAT 1.FOREIGN LAW FIRMS WILL REQUIRE ADDITIONAL SERVICES OF INDIAN LAWYERS.AND IT WILL CREATE MORE OPPORTUNITY TO YOUNG AND ALSO TO SENIOR LAWYERS.KINDLY NOTE THAT INDIAN LEGAL SYSTEM IS ENTIRELY DIFFERENT THAN FOREIGN LEGAL SYSTEM.UNLESS LOCAL INDIAN LAWYERS ARE ENGAGED BY FOREIGN LAW FIRMS THEY CAN NOT PROVIDE ANY LEGAL SERVICES.THE LAWYERS SHOULD STUDY THE INDIAN LAW AND ACTS PASSED.FOREIGNERS IT IS NOT POSSIBLE.HENCE NO NEED TO CARE ABOUT ENTRY OF FOREIGN LAW FIRMS. 2.INDIAN LAWYERS SHOULD UPDATE THE LEGAL KNOWLEDGE AND BE CONFIDENT.THIS IS A PROFESSION AND NOT A TRANSACTION FOR ANY SALE OF GOODS MANUFACTURED ABROAD IN THE INDIAN MARKET. WITH BEST REGARDS THANKING YOU YOURS SINCERELY NANDKUMAR B.SAWANT.,M.COM.LL.B.(MUMBAI),ADVOCATE
By
NANDKUMAR B.SAWANT, LAWYER / ATTORNEY, LEGAL SERVICES FOR COURT CASES IN INDIA
| 05 01 2009 04:15:24 +0000
If we can let all the MNCs enter in our country in the name of globalisation then whu not foreign law firms.And competition is always good as it keeps the competitors on their toes to outdo each other.
By
Anagha Thakur, Corporate Lawyer
| 04 30 2009 09:13:08 +0000
well in this present scenario...... why oppose them? I would rather say that let them establish here but the foreign lawyers will have to clear our exams and only then will they be allowed to practice here Or more so only allow the firms to be here and the lawyers shall be none but us. That will bring in good moolha for the lawyers who are as yet young and also a good scope and money and knowledge base for the senior counsels as they can also make more. I think change should be accepted and consider them for good.
By
Rohit Dangare, Private practitioner/Lawyer, Dangare & Co.,
| 03 11 2009 16:03:44 +0000
It is perhaps good,though we are not oblivous of the fact that in the long run it may cause a monopoly in the legal market.However,it shall be a healthy competition and an individual can weigh himself to international standards and ascertain as to where he stands and in particular it shall help the Indian mechanism/judiciary to understand as how much the law has developed since Independence as our parent Act is wholly based on international guidelines and theories
By
suraj dessai almeida, Legal Assistant/Apprentice, 2 years
| 03 03 2009 05:43:27 +0000
true but they should be curtailed else they will payu low fee and no security for the jobs also. we can take work just like LPOs and we should give them rights or spl prevailages when they were incorporated in the country
By
pavan9247634335 , Student, ICFAI
| 02 23 2009 03:55:38 +0000
We have opened so many things to the world and still opening up then why oppose entry of Foreign law firms.This will have healthy competion in India.It will generate more employment to new lawyers.It will ultimately help everybody connected to this profession
By
MANOJ VARSHNEY, Director, TULSI TRAVELS PVT LTD
| 02 13 2009 16:32:00 +0000
It's not a particular Foreign Law Firm, rather, it is a unilateral law to be passed by the Indian Parliament to allow foreign lawyers to practice in India, with certain condition, to restrict lawyers from particular country to practice in India. To my opinion if the Indian Govt. is desirous to allow foreign lawyer to practice or start their firm here in India, it should be done with each country separately, like a internation treaty. Before executing any deal India should ask the country with whom it's executing the treaty to afford equal rights to Indian lawyers/firm in their country, so that Indian lawyer/firms will have equal business opportunity in that country. Under such circumstances, I don't think it's a bad deal.
By
arun kumar, Examiner of Trade Marks, , trade marks registry
| 02 13 2009 04:49:10 +0000
We are in the era of free competition. Any accredition should be absolutely based upon merit of an Individual as well as organisation. We should keep in our mind that we have limited options and there are some (also called as monopolist) ruling the Industry.
Entry of foreign law practitioners will surely force competition in the Industry. Customers will have more options to put ahead their complaints. The level of domestic law practitioners will raise.
By
Pankaj Mishra, Business Development, Business Access India
| 02 13 2009 04:46:29 +0000
In my opinion we should not oppose entry of foreign law firms. In fact foreign law firms will bring professionalism and experience in India. If you join a law firm as an associate or senior associate tell me one law firm in India where you will be provided with the criteria for becoming a partner. Yoru growth iwill not be dependent on you performance only. Most of the law firms in India are family driven and you do not have an opportunity to become a Partner or Managing Partner one day. In case of big size foreign law firms everything is documented and if you achieve certain billing targets you can reach to next level i.e. from Associate to Senior Associate and then Partner and even Managing Partner. I have no doubt on capabilities of Indian Lawyers rather when they will be provided better opportunities and better infrastructure they will do extremely well. I don't see any problem if these experienced law firms set up their offices in India and give opportunities to Indian lawyers.
By
Vipender Mann, Lawyer/Partner, KNM & Partners, Law Offices
| 02 04 2009 07:43:38 +0000
Many of our young and buddging lawyers especially those who are keen on practising corporate laws get few chances to work in a Law Firm, the reason being reputed Law Firms are few. With the entry of internationally reputed law firms, our youngesters will certainly get an opportunities to work in an ambiance international standard and can improve/groom their skills to equip with the latest trend in the industry globally. Even if foreign law firms are allowed in India, the Government may not permit them to appear in the Courts as such their role is reduced to Legal Consultants and as such no threat is directly pointed at the Advocates practising at the traditional Courts. Certainly it will give a healthy competition to our young and skilled lawyers who will have an edge over their peers practising at traditional Courts.
I personally support entry of Foreign Law Firms but with certain restrictions which can give us a healthy and competitive atmosphere in the legal arena.
By
M.S.Lalkumar , Head/VP/GM-HR, Gulf Consolidated Contractors
| 01 20 2009 12:10:51 +0000
No i don't agree with Gupta on this, whenever there is change happening it is for the good and not for worse, just think about the service that will be there to provide, the standards will be raised, and all the arrears of cases which runs into thousands which were pending will be tackled effectively with the entry of Foreign law firms....so entry of foreign law firms is a very good thing that is happening now, and Bar council should allow them to come to India......
By
Anant Patel, Legal Consultant
| 12 03 2008 14:11:26 +0000
According to me The entry of Foreign law firms is good, there will be more employment oppurtunities than ever before for the law graduates and it will certainly raise the level of legal services that is offered in the country, which is badly needed....
By
Rajeev Khare, Corporate Lawyer
| 12 03 2008 14:06:59 +0000
|
VEry thorough Roop!! And finely put indeed!! It could also amount to being a part of our judiciary and then thorugh the legal channels interfere with our economic reforms, legal tie ups albeit on the LARGE SCALE levels etc... To puncture the wheel and create an imbalance by not llowing us to be the largest thriving economy in the third world!!! The bigger picture that you have painted is indeed gory and scary at the same time!! Dirty politics indeed!! But well they are all happy going to swiss banks anyway!! :))
By
Makrand Bhave, Marketing & MICE, WIZCRAFT International
| 08 16 2009 05:33:27 +0000
ALLOWING FOREIGN LAW FIRMS TO OPEN THEIR OFFICES IN INDIA SEEMS TO BE A STATE-SPONSORED AND THE UK HATCHED CONSPIRACY NOT ONLY TO DE-STABLISE THE BOOMING INDIAN ECONOMY, BUT ALSO TO COMPLETELY OVERTAKE AND EFFECTIVELY MARGINALISE THE LEGAL OUTSOUCING (LPO)BUSINESS IN INDIA. THE WAY INDIAN LAW MINISTER, MR. HANSRAJ BHARDWAJ, SPOKE,PUBLICALLY, IN FAVOUR OF ALLOWING THE BRITISH LAW FIRMS TO OPEN THEIR OFFICES IN INDIA,WAS UTTERLY SHOCKING AND LARGELY DISAPPOINTING AND DISCOURAGING THE HARD-WORKING LEGAL SECTOR PANDITS ! EVEN IF, THE BRITISH LAW FIRMS,AS PER INDIAN LAW MINISTER'S WISDOM, WOULD ONLY BE ALLOWED TO DO ALL OTHER WORKS ,INCLUDING LEGAL-DOCUMENTATION, EXCEPT LITIGATION PART,DON'T YOU THINK THE LPO BUSINESS IS LARGELY BASED ON DOCUMENTATION, RESEARCH,AND OTHER WORKS THAN LITIGATION !? THE MEDIA SHOULD ASK MR. BHARDWAJ WHAT SO MANY LAW FIRMS AND LPOs IN INDIA WOULD DO, AND HOW THIS ACTION OF INDIAN GOVERNMENT WOULD BENEFIT INDIAN ECONOMY IF THE BRITISH LAW FIRMS ARE OPENED THERE ? WHAT WILL HAPPEN TO THE EMERGING LEGAL SECTOR WHICH IS NOT ONLY GIVING EMPLOYMENTS TO THE EXPERIENCED LEGAL EXPERTS, BUT ALSO FULLY AND EFFECTIVELY UTILISING THE LARGE BANK OF NEW LAW GRADUATEDS, AND THEREBY STRENTHENING INDIAN ECONOMY ? AND STILL, IF THE GOVERNMENT IS HELL-BOUND TO TAKE THIS DECISION UNDER ANY COMPULSION IT SHOULD BE ON THE BASIS OF PRINCIPLE OF RECIPROCITY. MANY INDIAN LAWYERS AND SOLICITORS ( IN ENGLAND ) HAVE BEEN FIERCELY FIGHTING FOR A LONG TIME THAT INDIAN LAWYERS AND LAW FIRMS SHOULD BE ALLOWED TO OPEN THEIR OFFICES INDEPENDENTLY IN THE U.K., BUT THEY ARE SRICTLY NOT ALLOWED TO DO SO, AND AS A RESULT, THE LEGAL EXPERTS AND INDIAN LAW FIRMS ARE FORCED TO DO PARTNERSHIPS WITH BRITISH LAW FIRMS ONLY, TO GET BUSINESS FROM THE U.K. THE LPO BUSINESS MAINLY DEPENDS UPON THE COST-EFFECT THAT IS MUCH LESS IN INDIA AS COMPARED TO THE U.K. LEGAL MARKET. AND IF BRITISH LAW FIRMS WILL BE OPENING THEIR OFFICES IN INDIA, THEY WOULD NOT ONLY CAPTURE LEGAL OUTSOUCING BUSINESS FROM THE U.K. BUT ALSO FROM ALL OTHER COUNTRIES OF THE WORLD WHICH ARE, CURRENLY, GETTING THIS SECTOR OUTSOURCED TO INDIA . AND THEREBY, THEY WILL EARN HUGE AMOUNT OF FOREIGN CURRENCY WHICH THEY REALLY NEED FOR THEIR DECAYING ECONOMY, AT THE MOMENT ! BUT WHO AND WHAT INSPIRED INDIAN LAW MINISTER TO PUBLICALLY SPEAK IN THEIR FAVOUR WITHOUT ANY PROPER RESEARCH OR PUBLIC DEBATE ON SUCH AN IMPORTANT ISSUE, IS FOR MEDIA AND JUDICIARY TO LOOK INTO....OR IT IS SOMETHING TO DO WITH THE SWISS BANK ACCOUNTS !!?
By
ROOP JALUTHARIA, Head/VP/GM-Corporate Planning/Strategy, Recycling Business Power Processes Pvt. Ltd.
| 08 14 2009 12:20:21 +0000
India is independent democratic country.Judiciary, Executive, press, leglislative assembly are the part of democratic country.
foregieners have no right to vote in election. foreign advocate has no right to become judge.Foreign advocate has no right for advocacy.According to Indian advocate act only law graduate by recognised university of India has right for advocacy.According to Indian constitution foreign Law firm have no right for advocacy in India.
tomorrow foreign advocate will claim for become judge in indian court.Whether it is is legal?
tomorrow foreign citizen will claim for minister or military officer in India. Whether it is legal?
By
SANJAY SHANTILAL BRAHMBHATT, Other Legal/Law, Gujatat Govertment
| 03 11 2009 12:44:42 +0000
I do believe the Advocates Act has the principle of Reciprocity. So, if Indians are allowed to practice in the other country only then should the other country lawyers be allowed. Bar Council should ensure that.
By
Nikita Ved, Law Officer, Gas Authority of India Limited
| 02 23 2009 12:54:46 +0000
The entry of foreign lawyers is not exactly a new concept. Infact it always existed, and that is the reason, we have in our advocates act a clause known as "RECIPROCITY". If we Indians can go and practice in another country, only then can the advocates of the other country practice in India. So, allow the Indians to practice in other countries and there will be no problem. I really fail to undersatnd, as to why so much support for Foreign Lawyers? An American Lawyer say from Florida can not or is not allowed to practice in California, and likewise, if a lawyer from one state of the US of A can not practice in another state of the same country what right do they have to come to India. We atleast can go an appear in any of our states, whether Srinagar OR Kanyakumari, whether Guahati OR Mumbai. So, people supporting the foreign lawyers in India, its time for you to wake up!!!
By
Mrinal Madhav, Lawyer/Attorney, KnM Legal
| 02 23 2009 12:24:48 +0000
it will not open when there were no restrictions .... like no: of cases to be handled, and on shares etc.
By
pavan9247634335 , Student, ICFAI
| 02 23 2009 03:52:32 +0000
Entry of Foreign law firms in india is Bad Idea, because, orverall people mind will start to believe that our indian law firms are not capable handling big challanges.
This should not be the case and also preferences given to Indians in Foreign law firms will lesser.
So, I disagree with foreign law firms entering in my home soil.
By
Venkatesh Babu Thevendira Subramanian, Team Leader -(Technical), Aztecsoft Ltd.,
| 02 13 2009 16:34:22 +0000
If one goes and sees the kind of collaborations foreign firms willing to enter are doing for entry into the market, one will realise that for selecting and training our candidates towards dual qualifier status i.e. becoming a Lawyer in a different Jurisdiction are entirely inflating of legal costs.
I can outline a case of a UK Based firm offering such training after taking money from Indian Advocates for training them in two years overseas. And that too to open an LPO in India. The LPO temptation is too strong for them to treat us as equals and affford Indian Lawyers who are dual qualified hourly billing in their professions. So no followup by eased regulations of entry to other countries is likely. We have nothing much to offer in terms of alegal services market except LPO Sector which is running on cost arbitrage alone.
The only good thing is these lawyers will push the scene for expedited court processes and perhaps generate competition in Corporate work but given the cost differential of a foreign firm and their hands on ability to conduct anything more than advisory services will have to be seen.
Also an Indian Court will continue to remain a fertile ground for "Senior Advocates only" practice and they will be least affected. It is nobody's case that the ordinary, struggling litigator will be left without work as these firms will never do the dirty work and this work will pass on nonetheless to these people.
By
ASHISH , Lawyer/Attorney, Not working
| 02 12 2009 16:56:59 +0000
i assured this issue regard affect indian lawyers, but if the indian lawyers are not making hard work and grow their efficiency foreigners will be succeed. so we must develop our efficiency in legal field
By
vivekanandan , Bad Debts/Workouts Manager, finance company
| 01 22 2009 11:28:03 +0000
It will be shutters down for many Indian Lawyers. Before, attempting to bring in foreign lawyers and advocates in India, we have to first change the way society thinks. Mo matter how mnay of us may disagree but the common notion in Indians is that Foreigners are better. If a common man, comes and is faced with 2 lawyers, one who is a foreigner, and 2nd who is an Indian, he would definitely choose the foreigner. It is deeply rooted in the society that goods that are mad ein a foreign land are of far better quality than those made in India.The same logic would apply here too. So before we attempt to let foregners in India in the Legal fraternity it is essential that the mindset is changed first, lest the common man will suffer. Prevention is always better than cure.
By
Mrinal Madhav, Lawyer/Attorney, KnM Legal
| 01 22 2009 10:15:19 +0000
|