Killing Osama was wrong?

The Americans are celebrating. Can we rule out another 26/11? Yes / no, maybe, somewhat, %#$#$$#@***. The Ragan administration created OSAMA (Taliban armed with stinger) & supplied arms to Iraq. OBAMA administration annihilated Osama, story stretching some more than three decades.

Osama’s terror was his brain child, which had Pakistani support; terrorism is not war, so war rules do not apply.

American run global business and world politics, Iraq invades Kuwait US  the Clinton administration had the UN mandate to take action, Iraq is a nation and Saddam was the Leader he was captured from a hole arrested, put to trail and sentenced to death.

Is the film sholey a hit for Jai/Viru or basanti ? No it’s a hit because of GABBAR!! So Gabbar was the target.

In India we have Scam stars in Delhi Film Stars in Mumbai, Komunist Kartoons in Kolkata and some baba’s anna’s  etc.

Do we have global outlook? do we have global leader? did we have one? What’s the point in kicking the Americans? If we face another terrorist attack in multiple cities what can we do? can we do what the Americans did?

OBAMA fulfilled his election promise to his countrymen they are celebrating. In this debate I don’t see any American yet some people getting jacked!!

Who is a Police?   

A law enforcer.

Why do you think USA is a world police?

 Can any Police act unilaterally?

You tube is a free upload site, any garbage can be uploaded. Its only terrorist who act unilaterally something like cancer where cells randomly multiply, terrorist have killed more than 100 people in Pakistan after abotabad operation. What is the basis of such act?

Which country do you belong to Ijas?

 You are talking about courts?

Can you bring the master minds of 26/11 or Mumbai blast to court?

United States of America had the UN Mandate to take action in Iraq, They gave Saddam the President of Iraq enough time to evacuate Kuwait.

Osama was also asked to surrender in the torabora he used Afgan tribes as human shield.

Ijas if you think they are courts that can settle matters why don’t you resolve the Kashmir issue and the border dispute between India and CHINA.

I guess.... you can do this. :(

Osama was dangerous criminal having committed crimes against humanity and was hiding himself under the veil of Islam and further trying to involve a big Muslim community, where as Nazi's were fighting for a nation and had a reason to be tried as war criminals. Even if during entire KIA operation, any soldier had even a small apprehension or fear, he was right in eliminating Osama. Why criminals are eliminated in encounters in every nation. The best action was operation KIA.

Certainly 'NO' but yes terror was a disease spread much before Osama came to limelight. US have just weakened one of the roots of the terror tree. There are others waiting to occupy that coveted position and what US needs to now do is rely on India rather than PAK which is protecting the 'Other Roots' of the terror tree.

It would be now a huge mistake if US continues to rely on PAK to remove terrorism and pumps in more military goodies to their inventory. You may never see the end of terror attacks, then. One must understand that the famous adage from the movie Godfather "Keep your friends close, but your enemies closer" is not going to work here. It has not and will never. Rather PAK would end up being the Godfather.

Killing OSAMA was the right step, in fact the first step to root out terror, but we are miles away to eliminate terror. Probably now a more quieter approach is necessary than just using force militarily. And, what is that going to be? Downloading........

I tend to agree with you Joydeep on the subject.

At first I would like to thank Tina for this great and hot discussion. As far as the Osama is concern it’s not he who has got the right punishment for the mass murder of 11th September Incident, same should be done by India for the most wanted Daud and other criminals. We should take Osama’s killing as a lesson against the terrorism. I can’t presume the situation which is in favor of the the terrorists. In 11th September Incident, there were many Indian who lost their life. Every human being is against the crime whether it’s within the nation or outside the Nation. Osama’s murder can heal the pain of the Americans and as well as for the other nation’s people who lost their family and their belongings. Creating boundary against terror is very much important for the growth of the mental level to the sufferer of terrorism. I mean to say terrorist should stop playing with the innocent human mind. We should act like a brave and do tit for tat for criminal activities. I would like to appreciate Barack Obama for this great work towards the Osama, rather celebrating the victory; he should have take it as a challenge for any upcoming misshaping in near future.

Please go back to history. Adolf Eichmann a senior officer of Hitler’s brigade was convicted of ordering the killing of Jews and was executed and his body cremated by Israel. There was a film “Judgment at Nuremberg” in which there was a true account of trials and convictions of several of Hitler’s aides. These were cases where the Germans had surrendered and the people responsible taken into custody. Bin Laden refused to surrender. The US is a powerful state with people who remember all that is done to them in the 4 years of Presidency. They do not vote on emotions, Religion, Caste politics, greed for money, etc. O Bama could not make any significant improvements in the US Economy. With elections due in 2012 he needed to do something to prove his worth. By killing Osama Bin Laden he has shown that the US had the capability and intention of eliminating their deadliest enemy for protecting his people. The earlier presidents in the US have also indicated time and again that they would do everything to protect the life of each and every US citizen. The US president could not risk holding Bin Laden as captive and providing a regular trial in accordance with international law. They apprehended such an action may result in retaliatory moves from the Al Qaida which could capture US citizens as ransom for Laden’s release. O Bama preferred to accept criticism from the outside world for eliminating Laden without trial rather than put his citizens to risk. This act is to be appreciated and not criticized. The trial in India of Afzal Guru and Kasab has not been recognized by the outside world. The detention of Maulana Azhar Masood has cost the country both in terms of human lives, trauma of detention for a week for passengers of IC 814 in Kandahar, loss of an aircraft, money and humiliation for the Government and people of India. Afzal Guru and Kasab are small flies for the ring masters of the terror groups and they do not bother for their release otherwise by now they would have achieved their purpose. It is a normal human reaction for people worldwide to talk of human rights and principles of justice for criminals but what moves us who have suffered for decades in the hands of terrorists to dance to the tune of others.

@Sreeja: It is a 100% truth. The goodness of Indians is taken as the weakness by the terrorists because even they know that eventhough we are capable of responding back in a proper way but we are not allowed to do so. Until and unless, we will make up our mind to respond in a proper manner these crimes will not stop from the terrorist countries.   

Killing a person like Osama is not at all wrong. But all this happened because US has taken a blow from him on 9/11. The main thing is that it is they who sowed the poisonous seed of terrorism with the help of Osama and they themselves were not saved from the dangerous consequences. All this US did because it was they who got effected else they might have not even imagined of attacking him. If the same action was taken by India and other terrorism effected countries, then the US have instructed the other countries except Pakistan to restore peace. But do you think that the people who were protecting the terrorist like Kasab for 2 years are capable of taking serious action against terrorism? It is they who have to realize that they might have taken action at that time only by taking preventive actions when the Intelligence have made them aware of the possibility of attack or by not arresting him,but by shooting him then and there only. As it is rightly said "HUMANITY FOR HUMANS ONLY, NOT FOR INHUMANS".It is very important for our government to take stern action against terrorists,so that in future even their souls get terrified if they tried to imagine to do such a heinous crime.

Osama got what he deserved.he had crossed all boundaries of humanity.Infact he never acted humane.Shoot at sight for such people should be the agenda of the government.And he still managed to live quite long.Such parasites deeply suck the blood of nations and leave everyone in a state of terror and sorrowful plight.A mastermind has been killed and we should just pray that we dont have more Osama's in this world.

Tina,  You are thoroughly mistaken.  This is like saying I will not drink my medicine because it is sour.  If you dont eat the medicine, then how will your disease be cured?  It will spread and ultimately endanger your life.

This is also something similar.  Let us not like typical Indian politicians - always afraid to take decisions fearing the short term consequences - without thinking about the long term effects.

There will be escalated voilence for a short term now.  But if the Governments all over the world act toughly and put them down, terrorism will subside and peace will prevail.  Nobody in this world wants these unpleasant killings - be it a Hindu or a Christian or a Muslim or a Sikh.

Just imagine the expenditure to guard the lone terrorist caught alive in Mumbai terror! Osama was involved in gruesome murder of over thousand innocent civilians in the twin-tower attack in US, created panic throughout the world by his terrorist outfits across the world, forcing every country to spend more on external security threat, India was not an exception!

It definitely is not wrong to kill someone like Osama. And it has taken the US 10 years to get him, so calling it an action in the heat of the moment is totally wrong. Are innocent lives at risk? Yes, they have been so far and will continue to be so going into the future. The US has never been concerned for the common man, and will not be going forward as well, unless we get a radical thinking and path breaking individual as the US President.

They have got too deep into creating Osama's and then eliminating them, that it will take them a long time, which may not happen in our lifetime, to get out of this mess.

Now coming to the issue, has the US killed Osama, no one can confirm. Speculation has it that he has been captured alive, and with Pakistan support. However, given that Pak is a Islam nation, cannot afford to be shown as a traitor to someone who was espousing the cause of Islam, is one of the reasons given for distanscing Pak from the whole incident or Operation Geronimo. This is evidenced by the fact that there was a complete power blackout in Abbottabad during the operation.

Secondly, the conflicting and changing statements about what actually happened shows that Osama was captured alive, and the US wants the world to believe that he is dead for whatever reason.