Build your professional network on facebook via our app Go to app
 
 
Posted in Community :

Primetime News

 

Mahendra Singh Dhoni's decision to call Ian Bell back

Created by : Himanshu Pathak, Sr/Principal Coresspondent, Coresspondent  | 08 02 2011 11:48:10 +0000
Industry : Radio, TV & FilmsFunctional Area : Sports(Personal Interests)
Keywords : msd mahendra singh dhoni england vs india ian bell loard's test match
Activity:  288 views;  last activity : 08 11 2011 04:08:38 +0000

People are talking a lot about true spirit of cricket and saying that MSD has set an example. He has shown what is the game really about and why is it a gentlemen's game. Do you think it was a right decision , India has lost very badly after all.

  
 Refer 1849
Share
 
 
  Rate : 
 
 
Yes Vs No
10
 
 
 
 
6
6
4
Support   Support
Top Argument
3
0

What would have been your reaction on Dhoni's decision, had India won the match?

Definitely we would have been all praise for Dhoni on that event had our team won the match in spite of his decision, which people could not relish now. When India was destined to lose, why such type of lamenting on losing. Let our players decide how to play if they do not get themselves involved in unethical & corrupt practices of match fixing.

People can't be satisfied and start criticising the actions of the players even if they are 100% right & ethical. Dhoni is captain of the team and what his decision was that depended upon the circumstances and should have been honoured by us instead of criticising.

Do media and other people think that Dhoni should have come to India to first consult media and the people of India before communicating his decision during the game?

Do everybody, who start criticising Team India, know all about the nitty gritty of cricket?

In fact, we people have made a habit of just following blindly what the media tries to impose on us.
By PS Dhingra, CEO & Vigilance & Transformation Management Consultant, Dhingra Group of Management & Educational Consultants  08 07 2011 10:04:13 +0000
 
Top Argument
3
0

All are talking about true spirit of game but the decision was made. It was all there clear. We might not have won the match even then but why to take such chances.
By Himanshu Pathak, Sr/Principal Coresspondent, Coresspondent  08 02 2011 11:48:10 +0000
0
0
Whats wrong in it? That was the sportsman spirit and a fair game.
By Anand Sharma, Monitoring the research funded by DIT, Department of Information Technology  | 08 11 2011 04:08:38 +0000
0
0
Well! Forget the technicality of the matter for the game of cricket gains its prestige because it is a 'Gentleman's Game'. We are proud today to have played the test in the spirit of the game. Though I wish Dhoni & co, had reversed the appeal before the batsman left the field. Now the recalling of the batsman after he has walked beyond the boundary after being given out has set a dangerous precedent.
By Vinoy Scaria James, Consultant, Travel Hub  | 08 07 2011 08:34:49 +0000
0
0

Dear Himanshu,

Did not at any time your own decisions go wrong? Did not you take chance with wrong decision at any time during your life? Did you know beforehand that your decision would go wrong?

In fact media has ever played with the emotions of the people and they start making sensational stories out of nothing just for the sake of their own livelihood. Even on this very issue, the media has been harping the same tune for the last three days on the same stale story for want of any fresh news with them. BUT, WHAT FAR?

Even on winning the matches, every time media tried to criticise one or the other player on one or the other count. If media people are so perfect in their decisions, why they don't go to the field to play the match instead of fabricating such nasty stories?
By PS Dhingra, CEO & Vigilance & Transformation Management Consultant, Dhingra Group of Management & Educational Consultants  | 08 03 2011 05:54:24 +0000
0
0

I am not a fan of cricket and don't follow that game at all...... BUT based on what I read ,,...here is my view.

right now India is kind of super power in cricket because we are at the top of icc rankings, our board bcci is the richest, president of icc is an indian, we have the biggest cash cow called IPL etc etc. So, we are the kings (right now) of cricket. Such a leader(india) should set an example for other cricketing nations and not try to win all the time, at any cost. We should not snatch victory, instead we should accommodate the less fortunate ones by trying to be a gentleman. Hence I think Dhoni's decision is great.
By Munshi Ramchand, Retired  | 08 02 2011 13:30:04 +0000
0
0
Dhoni is right all the way...always !!
By Mayukh Gayen, PhD Student - Actuarial Science, University of Kent  | 08 02 2011 13:14:10 +0000
0
0
hello Himanshu,if cricket rules says that a batsman can be given out in such a situation and Bell was in that context there was no need to call him back.instead it only shows the gesture of Indian captain to pardon Bell for his silly mistake though not purposely done.
By jairaj shyam prasad, Production Manager, BOSCH Ltd  | 08 03 2011 14:49:02 +0000
0
0
I think Dhoni succumbed to the pressure of reports that Indian team is very aggressive, especially after Darryl Hair's press statements. Indians had mellowed down thereafter and the results are there in front of you. Dhoni should have struck to the appeal and should not have recalled Bell. If it failed to ring a bell that rules are to be followed, then that should have been done so all the way through. Otherwise how can you explain the appeal in the first place? So MSD is wrong and paid the price in losing the match.
By AMISH , Admin/Facilities Manager, VKVC  | 08 03 2011 06:14:53 +0000
0
0

I think the decision to call back may that be of sachin tendulkar. Dhoni knew very well that they will not be able to win hence at least there is some thing by which the captain will be remembered.

It is very unfortunate to see that our players lack commitment. They are professionals and a huge sum of money during last three IPL hence if they are on the team it is good if they are not they have lot many thing to attend to. 
By Rathin Deb, Freelance Retail Consultant  | 08 03 2011 05:04:50 +0000
Argue for "Yes"
Argue for "No"
 Found the debate "Mahendra Singh Dhoni's decision to call Ian Bell back "  interesting ?  Suggest to your connections and communities  
Leading recruitment consultants for Middle East Jobs
Mechanical Commissioning Engineer Jobs in UAE
Viewers also viewed
In the wake of their exit from the T20 world cup so badly, former players and BCCI officials are...
 
616 referals 23 arguments, 799 views
"Ae watan ae watan hamko teri kasam teri rahon me jaan tak luta jayenge" . This was the song...
 
98 referals 13 arguments, 856 views
Suppose this is the year 1925. We are still reeling under the British government. We have only...
 
24 referals 35 arguments, 2442 views
more...  
Recent Knowledge (4)
WE HAD A GOOD NUMBER OF INVENTORS WITH GREATER VISION ABOUT THE SOCIETY. INVENTORS HERE NEED NOT...
 
2 referals 2 arguments, 128 views
C vs B
 
0 referals 3 arguments, 72 views
I am associate of prajapati association and i am working for BJP from year 2005 to till date....
 
0 referals 3 arguments, 140 views
more...  
Sponsored Jobs
More From Author
Probably we should give government time to impose, apply and articulate it. Anna and team is warning the government now and again which is really not needed. Perhaps we should wait for sometime and if nothing works in this time we the common people...
This is hard decision and we can just give opinions. Leaving right away will not be a wise decision. Either you should see if you can get a better job and then change of you should urge for recognition in the current company for your contribution and...
While Team India is loosing terribly against England one more team India is won the Asian cup! Yes we have done it in Hockey and still I see people crying over cricket. What will you choose : a game which makes you feel good or a game which makes...
more...