Build your professional network on facebook via our app Go to app
 
 
 
Activity:  708 views;  last activity : 09 06 2010 04:00:46 +0000
 
 Refer 793
Share
 
 
  Rate : 
 
 
Yes Vs No
20
 
 
 
 
17
15
13
Support   Support
Top Argument
2
0

THOUGH IT IS APOLITICAL GIMMICK TO APPEASE RURAL VOTERS IT WILL HELP THEM GET AN ASSURED INCOME FOR AT LEAST 100 DAYS IN ONE YEAR IN ADDITION TO WHATEVER THEY ARE EARNING AT PRESENT.


By s.baalu , Consultant, XYZ LTD  06 30 2010 07:43:59 +0000
 
Top Argument
7
0

May be it will help but, how much is this going to cost India? And where is the money going to come from? As a start, an older, similar programme the National Food for Work Programme here is going to be converted into the employment guarantee scheme. All the money that was earlier supposed to be spent on the food programme will be switched over to the work programme.


All this sounds wonderful on paper but many people have expressed doubts over whether the NREGA will actually work. Maharashtra began a similar scheme some time ago, which ran into lots of problems. The biggest problem was corruption. Corrupt government officials and middlemen started faking work, taking advantage of illiterate workers by not paying them their due, or even just taking their names, inventing work and claiming their money. And since the poorest people could not read or write, they didn’t know that they were entitled to this money, or that their names were being used. Even if they did know, they could not do anything about it, their poverty made them powerless. The fear is that this situation could now be repeated all over India in the National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme.


By Ayan Choudhury, Sr/Principal Corespondent, Leading media House  06 22 2010 05:25:47 +0000
0
0

For the poorest of the poor Indian anything given is a blessing. So scheme like this will do some good for them. The object of the scheme and out look are good but as all other scheme the way it is implemented is important. It is here the purpose of such plans fail.


By Shashi Kumar U, Manager accounts & commercial, Mazda Concrete Products Pvt Ltd  | 09 06 2010 04:00:45 +0000
0
0

Yes, no doubt MNREGS of providing 100days employment to poor is good for uplifting the standard of life. Still there is lot of scope to improve its implementation. However Governments are seriously working to improve its execution and ensure more befits to poor. here, role of Not for Profit Organisation is to keep on pushing Governments fro better governance.


By Bhoopendra Kumar Singh, Head Extension, Mission Biofuels India Pvt Ltd  | 09 05 2010 11:27:13 +0000
1
0

It is a good step , creation of employment when workers r not having work to do.

Even at a time ther is employment /work this NREGA is being implemented. Resulting in shortage of workers for construction as well as agriculture.

Govt should examine places where it can be more useful and where workers suffer from lack of work.

 

 

 


By malladi madhukumar, AGM -MKTG, Andhra Cements Ltd  | 08 01 2010 11:08:17 +0000
0
0
Yes MNREGA is the greatest step taken by any govt in the employment generation, its a unique programme and once FSA will enacted then you will see the real fruits of that , yes there are discrepancies in implementation but we are now working on that and effective utilization and monitoring auditing
By Vivekanand , Senior Consultant (Economic & Rural Research) SAARC Nations, United Nations Development Programme  | 07 13 2010 07:50:50 +0000
0
0

The policy as such in good  from the look of it and if properly implemented it will certainly help the poor. Here the way it is implemented by each state government is important. As far as I understand that some states are able to achive a fair degree of sucess.


By Shashi Kumar U, Manager accounts & commercial, Mazda Concrete Products Pvt Ltd  | 06 24 2010 05:13:28 +0000
0
0

Whether, the system works efficiently or not , with  respect to labour under-utilized or over-utilized . But, one thing is clear that some money reaches the labours. Gradual awakening & prunning up a bit of the structure thro' which it is administered will give yield in the long run. At grass root level with available percentage of illiteracy & unawareness, cause this short-coming.Media can boost up this issues in a better way so that , labours start using it fruitfully.


By KALIYAMOORTHY , Oil & Gas Area Coordinator, Undisclosed  | 06 23 2010 12:53:05 +0000
0
0

yes it is success even if a single family has gained from the programme.yes the cost is high & money might be misused by some but it is wasted in many programmes run by government so better even if some money is utilized for the betterment of poor atleast it will feed them and keep them away from bad things.Above all it will give them satisfaction of earning  money with their own hard work.


By Wajid.Pathan , Enterprenuer (Designer /Developer/Supplier), Self Employed  | 06 23 2010 09:28:29 +0000
0
0

Will provide some succour to the farmers and villagers dependent on farming when braving the odds of these unstable weather conditions.


By Atul Joshi, Branch Manager/Regional Manager, Oswal Industries Limited  | 06 23 2010 04:37:00 +0000
0
0

i think its not a success at this point of time. but things will mature over the period of time. so it is a good initiative, which can help a lot if implemented properly.


By sanjay kumar mangal, IT , TATA Group Co.  | 06 23 2010 03:19:14 +0000
1
0

 

Thanks for the referral Mr Sachin

Any new idea needs time, the govt has introduced some new and good schemes they need time to come into shape. I agree that a lot of things get washed up due to the corruption , but I feel that efforts are being taken by the govt  to implement new ideas and we should encourage it,


By Dr Ali Ahmad, Medical Superintendent/Director, Surbhi Hospital  | 06 22 2010 17:49:42 +0000
0
0

No Sachin I dont agree with you on this. To start a project there will be loopwholes and those should be plugged.

I have personally seen in many parts of the country the people's faces with a hidden smile. Since they are now in a position to eat two square mills a day.

India is a corrupt country but it will take time to eradicate the same from our socity as a whole.


By Rathin Deb, Freelance Retail Consultant  | 06 22 2010 15:32:42 +0000
0
0
We have a very elaborate bureaucracy which is weighing heavily on government projects. NREGA, like other such social projects, is a well planned move. The bureaucravy and power lords of locality are to be blamed for its failure, not the programme.
By Indusekhar Das, Team Leader -(NonTechnical), ABP Pvt Ltd  | 06 22 2010 11:13:57 +0000
0
0
MNREGA is one of the sucessful priorities taken up by govt. of india for guaranteed employment for 100 days job in a year.The benificiary can achieve 100% through smart card or by use of biometric card.I think once the unique identity card number is given the implementation of mnrega will be more sucessful.
By kasturirangan.r , Consultant, videocon industries limited  | 06 22 2010 06:15:43 +0000
0
0

A unique system of Govt. of India of employment for the all majority of the village community. A huge sum of money is released from the centre to the districts for payment of the jobs. A unique way for the development of the village community say: help in irrigation, plantation and self reliance.


By Arunabha Kar, Sr.Officer. Liasion &Pr, Adhunik Group Of Industries  | 06 22 2010 05:11:52 +0000
1
0

Neither make any efforts to control population nor do anything about employment generation and to add insult dole out public money like their own pocket money and disburse with fancy names.

Story of India- Jai Ho......


By Ravindra Sharma, Managing Consultant, CHEF-India  | 07 13 2010 08:34:33 +0000
1
0

Instead of commenting from our air-conditioned rooms, let us go to a village and study the situation. I had been to a place in Krishna District of Andhra Pradesh, at least thrice in the last one year, which predominantly consists of tribals and scheduled caste communities. The parents look forward to their son/daughter attaining the age of 18, so that he can be sent as a agricultural labourer. Another earning member is added to the house ! All my efforts to bring three/four persons to Hyderabad by promising them roti, kapada aur makaan and quality education proved to be futile. Parents are unwilling to send them because the family loses 100 days income.

Over a period of time, India will become a country of labourers and illiterates while the rich and affluent will continue to rule India. Instead of spending crores of rupees on this scheme, we must make education free and compulsory upto 10th standard. Afterwards, it can become free or subsidized with the help of Corporates. If we start the policy in a 2-year period, India will become a Rama Rajya at least after 50 years.

I wish somebody will have a look at the other side of this coin. 


By Suryanarayan Murthy, Asst Vice President (Corporate Finance), A Hydro Power Project  | 07 13 2010 06:35:25 +0000
0
0

ayan it is true.  NREGA is one of the scheme where politicians can knockoff the funds behind this scheme with fake works.  If we watch closely the indian budgetary system, atleast 20% of the GDP is allotted for this types of schemes where their is lot of scope for stealing the funds with out accountability since it is difficult to audit the expenditure under these schemes.  Ayan what you say if media expose the indian budgetary system in subtle and  design a parallel idle budgetary system for a Financial year and draw a comparison vis-a-vis Govt. budget submitted by the pranab mukherjee  the loops are highlighted &  system will be exposed to some extent to the public. 


By manikanta raj, Assistant Manager Finance, project financing, leading Financing company  | 07 10 2010 10:53:08 +0000
0
0
mayawati,sheila dixit jaise logo ke rehte kuch nahi ho payeega wether any yojna be launched
By gyanendra mishra, Legal - Head, leading service industry  | 06 24 2010 08:31:42 +0000
0
0

well only if corruption is eliminated then only this scheme will be on right track. but corruption is a part of us. so this policy can be a failure. we need true son of INDIA to put the people behind bars with their face off mainly politicians.


By abhishek paul, Designer Trainee, pennar industries ltd., patancheru, medak dist., hyderabad  | 06 23 2010 03:57:30 +0000
0
0

Although it is not a success at the moment but the strict vigilance & implementation can sustantially improve the rural- urban divide...and especially the urban migration can be controlled...


By suhaschandra deshpande, Marketing Associate  | 06 22 2010 20:47:24 +0000
0
0

I agree with you Ayan. But according to me the Govt of India and Mr Manmohan Singh in perticular is at least looking for the benifit of the poor of this vast country wher one person earns Rs 20/- per day.

To start with there will be loopholes but one can always plug them. I will go upto saying the Sonia Gandhi, Pranab Mukherjee are also equally responsible for the upliftment of the poor in our country.


By Rathin Deb, Freelance Retail Consultant  | 06 22 2010 14:51:56 +0000
0
0
100 days job is not to bring up the standards of the hungry people, but to have minimum few days food instead of begging.
By R N Bhattacharyya, Freelancer, Freelancer  | 06 22 2010 10:30:02 +0000
0
0

It is not easy to say, because in India, there are many schemes launched by Govt. time to time. But all we know about the result. If the last performance is the criteria to answer the question then i have doubt to say yes.

Even i heard from many villages where Food are coming for poor people under Food schemes run by center/state Govt. But i am sorry to say that food comes in the places but only in the form of papers and bills.....No food program run in reality. WHO IS RESPONSIBLE FOR IT? I think We are responsible. And i am still not able to find out the solution. So i don't want to comment more on the topic.


By Vipin Bhasin, Private Equity/Hedge Fund/VC-Manager, Indian Investment Co.  | 06 22 2010 10:15:12 +0000
1
0

i completely agree with Ayan..given the kind of corruption scenario India has, its very difficult to get the money to the right and deserving hands..unless the whole hierarchy and the people working and involved in NREGA are judged and reviewed, we are going to lose more money than before which will severely affect the economy of the country without any result...100 days of work is fine but the people should be educated first so that they can rightly demand their dues, fight and the bring the matter to the top officials if they are not given what they deserve...so education is the saviour more than all..


By amrita nayak, jornalist and writer, freelancer  | 06 22 2010 09:35:17 +0000
1
2

No it is total misuse of public money.


By Sachin Kumar, Legal Adviser  | 06 22 2010 09:35:11 +0000
0
0

This and all other welfare schemes are used by central/state/local governments to siphon off the funds. In many villages across India, everyone registered and living have been bogusly accounted for having working under various schemes and the cash disbursed. The entire money is looted year after year.

Rather government should create lasting assets like schools, colleges, hospitals in every village. Government run hospitals need much to be improved in terms of quantity and quality.


By Prasad PN, Consultant, Trainer  | 06 22 2010 06:01:12 +0000
Leading HR Consulting Company
  • Create a confidential Career Profile and Resume/C.V. online
  • Get advice for planning their career and for marketing of experience and skills
  • Maximize awareness of and access to the best career opportunities
Recent Knowledge (88)
Facebook has become a drug. Everyone wants to be on Facebook. Even if not everyone still...
 
1632 referals 14 arguments, 225 views
if Baba's business was successful wht's his fault? vs This country can only have rich...
 
1701 referals 27 arguments, 269 views
more...