.NET vs JAVA. Which one is hot and reliable?

bcoz of platform independence and high security

For Enterprise applications better to choose J2ee, Bcz java spports interoperability.

For small projects u choose .NET and UI part is more .net is best.

I really am not able to get it. Can you explain your point a bit more? What do we find faster and realiable?

I would support for Java because of its versatality and interoperability across different OS platforms. Not just this, the Java model has developed and adopted for a wide variety of products. .NET binds us to port the application only in one OS.

I am completely agree with Mr. Swapnil cos now Java is merged with oracle but its basic functionality will not be changed. Still Java will support multiple platforms and now its very easy to connect java to oracle cos may be they will develop some functionality to access directly oracle database...

java is robust

Java is anytime better, because it provides you flexibility to work on multiple platforms. It is also more expanded horizontally, as compared to .NET . Java has a much open community than .NET which has forums mostly dictated by M$ paid "experts"

Also, Java is not dependent on any single company. See work of Apache Foundation for example. I am sure it will outdo even Sun in contributions. You don't see something similar in .NET which is mostly, M$ gives - others take

As a bottom line, however, I would say that the superiority of a particular technology is anytime dependent on the application we have in mind. End of the day, I would end up using technology which "serves my purpose" better.

<p>I dont agree on any particular platform! Perhaps the best logic would be that, both have their individual positive features as well, as negative features. </p>

<p>.Net still excels on a typical RAD scenario, where we need shorter dev cycles, like in most XP mothodologies. And, as such, it heads the scenario, still carrying on the legacy of the Best IDE, ever.</p>

<p>Similarly, J2EE, has its own set of advantages and disadvantages, the most prominent one being cross-platform support and interoperability; as till date I haven't seen a .Net Compiler optimized for MIPS, or SH4 platforms.</p>

<p>Also, earlier we had promises from the Redmond Giant that we'll see a .Net compiler for Linux, in 2003. It hasn't happened yet.</p>

<p>The best answer would have been that depending on the requirements and the platform in Question, .Net and J2EE overwhelms each other. Otherwise, I see it as nothing more than a Karma-Nirvana problem, a clash of ideologies, between the "Redmond Giant" and "Open Source" worshippers.</p>

<p>Sorry Dear all, I couldn't post my article, on a neutral column, so being a Embedded SYstems Designer, I had to intuitively post this in the Java/J2EE column. :(</p>
<p> </p>

All we know Java used for SERIOUS and strong web applications and projects

I prefer Java with linux operation with lifetime job instead of .Net with windows platform with many crash

it's easy to use for me and portable

also with large libraries for working easier and easier such as RichFaces, IceFaces and so on..

and it's better to know that java is most pupolar language in the world! check this out tiobe.com

HI,

I am very much supported what you mentioned except something like ".Net for windows only" Or "Security Issue". I beleive today what .Net 3.5/3.0 is giving us is more flexiblity than before. I can't comment on Java becuase I never get a chance to work in it. Security is depends on number of factors rather than language only. for example how your project architecture etc. Or W3C W* consortium levels deployed in you project.

For today and future companies are looking for Agile methodlogy and sure shot coming days we love SOA. And Those Language provide these features will be reamin in market. and .Net is one of language who support this.

Mr. Kiran i just want to confirm whether you are saying that security of JAVA needs to be improved for safety in the future.i'll wait for your reply.

I woked on J2EE as well as .NET.

We use technology as per the Project Complexity and the Timeframe

We can use .NET technology if we need to deliver in short span of time.

For the companyy .NET will be costliar because they may have to buy the required components and J2EE is free to use.

j2ee is more flexible then the .net and one can easily work on the java

Maninder I don't agree with you because Java is in good form because of its reliable Internet features like struts,springs and hibernate. Java obviously is portable and can be run on any operating system which you don't find in .net. Java may be vast but it is most powerful web designing language in the software industry. Apart from all these java source code is accessible free of cost and this help us to learn the nuances of programming. .Net is preferable only for Microsoft related solutions and applications.

kinjal, i couldn't understand the point that you are trying to convey, could you please elaborate.

well kapil, i don't agree with what you said...... wrt to your lengthy deployment procedure and settings that are required to run java applications isn't of much importance as that is one-time activity AND wrt to user-friendlyness, java gives you flexibility to such an extent that it is left to the devloper and the application requirement to leverage them.

As far as devlopers point of view is concerned, i wouldn't buy that either as it depends on individual.

well i beleive that the point Sayan have made about JAVA being used in upcoming products like fusion itself says about the portability , releaibility and acceptance of java

Though all are reliable

Dont want to offend anyone, ultimately workers are bigger than technologies!! But, J2EE has got big scope of area. I am neither a java guy, nor am I a .NET professional.

J2EE is now being used in ERP like Oracle apps and upcoming technologies Oracle fusion, Oracle middleware. This is because of it's acceptance.

People need to understand few points:

1) When the ease of use increases--scope decreases

2)When you come up with new versions frequently--it means giving less options to professionals and giving less chance to explore the power of the technology.

3)When you frequently release new versions, it means forcing clients to upgrade and adding worries.

4) Lastly, why Unix is called more reliable in industry?

because it is core and has got big scope and so no need for frequent changes.

Why Microsoft operating systems are used mostly in clients PC? Ease of access. and why Unix is used with server? Because of it's stability and reliability.

Tag line: Provide robustness, and the chance to professionals to inovate and ideate--end product will be more reliable.

Java is any time better than .Net....

Free source, and very very reliable....

I have experience with both Java and .Net. I feel Java is much more advance and better than .Net. Project build on Java is more maintanance free. Whereas I find .Net project require much more maintance. The coding style in Java is more userfriendly. Java coding conventions are great. All java technologies like JSp,Servlet, EJB, J2ME are build over Core Java(or J2SE). Once you master Java you could know power of Java. But I feel project in .Net is easy to create for new bees. It is well known Microsoft always try to steal technology from others. Most of the feature in .Net already Java had(or may be .Net steal them from java). 

In my opinion Java Technologies are superior. It has extensive flexibility. Many larger projects are  developed and will be developed inJ2EE.As far as my knowledge is concerned, many shopping sites which is having enough challenges, banking applications, health care , supply chain and ERP systems are developed in Java and are continuing in this development.

And one of the primary reasons is that these are open source. Many open source tools can be integrated and can be built on. When Java versions are changed then there will not be nay problem  to update the software to the newer release. Whether it can be web-based applications or desktop applications

Please keep posted  regarding this

In Java everything is in our control. as such it is an opensource framework, there are so many utilities buit on top of it. you just plug and play. it's most scalable. easy to implement and challenging. as a developer, i feel proud of java.

.Net people does't know what's going on in the background.

Thank you for your support Rajiv and another important advantage of java is it can mix with TCP/IP , HTTP and FTP protocols as well called as Network Savy. This is one of the advantage java has over DOT Net.And i will prove it with the help of an example in our daily issues.

All the projects now which are part of the framework will use J2ee as their technology source

Java is also now user friends as you have learnt that setting the classpath is older technique we have got much powerful tools than DotNet as you have not known.

Remember friends: Knowledge is not same all the time keep on changing update yourself. Dont consider i am your enemy just friends. 

But People dont know that DotNet doesnot support Big Projects like developing multiple virtual pad using RFB Protocol. This we have done using java and some used DOTNet they have stopped upto developing a single virtual pad using RFB Protocol.The extention in developing multiple virtualo pad is only possible with Java.

       For Example slow and steady wins the race in that way java have made all the basic foundation very clear and running now. Definetly Jdk1.7 will overcome the DotNet just wait. People dont know the terms while coding but java people know it.

Example2: In order if you have used any tool and there you find a bug in the compiler then you cant do anything beacuse you dont know the coding part. But we can monitor the activity and test where the problem is. Then correct it. Another thing is DotNet has larger code and some people will find difficult to find and trace an error.

                                                                                                     Thanks to your feedback in this way we keep on going  Java vs DotNet.....WAR 

But People dont know that DotNet doesnot support Big Projects like developing multiple virtual pad using RFB Protocol. This we have done using java and some used DOTNet they have stopped upto developing a single virtual pad using RFB Protocol.The extention in developing multiple virtualo pad is only possible with Java.

       For Example slow and steady wins the race in that way java have made all the basic foundation very clear and running now. Definetly Jdk1.7 will overcome the DotNet just wait. People dont know the terms while coding but java people know it.

Example2: In order if you have used any tool and there you find a bug in the compiler then you cant do anything beacuse you dont know the coding part. But we can monitor the activity and test where the problem is. Then correct it. Another thing is DotNet has larger code and some people will find difficult to find and trace an error.

                                                                                                     Thanks to your feedback in this way we keep on going  Java vs DotNet.....WAR 

But People dont know that DotNet doesnot support Big Projects like developing multiple virtual pad using RFB Protocol. This we have done using java and some used DOTNet they have stopped upto developing a single virtual pad using RFB Protocol.The extention in developing multiple virtualo pad is only possible with Java.

       For Example slow and steady wins the race in that way java have made all the basic foundation very clear and running now. Definetly Jdk1.7 will overcome the DotNet just wait. People dont know the terms while coding but java people know it.

Example2: In order if you have used any tool and there you find a bug in the compiler then you cant do anything beacuse you dont know the coding part. But we can monitor the activity and test where the problem is. Then correct it. Another thing is DotNet has larger code and some people will find difficult to find and trace an error.

                                                                                                     Thanks to your feedback in this way we keep on going  Java vs DotNet.....WAR 

Now a days .Net is getting updated but it cannot solve the mystery behind java. In .Net every thing

along with source code is not secured then how can you make protection to .Net. Come on we will show our skills by some meaningful and show that our technology is most powerful and secure. This will never end up. Ok start from now onwards..................Get Ready Go............