New Generation Managers Only Holds Management Dregees

As they step out of MBA Colleges, they have only degrees.A Management degree would be an added advantage for any Manager, I don't deny that.But experience always counts.This is a learning world.Though he/she has a degree, there are many things that would be learnt daily.Market trend and scenario runs very hastily.So, for the novice people, it would certainly take some time to embark their cadres.

well, it is difficult to judge by the way question is asked.i can say today's education level is more advanced and people are really looking good.but, we can't simply accept any man who has got all advanced education as a good manager / successful manager unless he has experiance in handling the position and to level expected.here comes the ethics of the business and how it is handled.today we are seeing young people taking some unwanted decisions in the name of change/innovation with the help of qualification and recognitions of the institutes they have came from.

This might not be true of all management graduates, but a majority would fall into this bracket. As research suggests, only 23% of management graduates from B and C grade management schools are "employable". Most of these management graduates have poor communication, even less analytical skills and definitely are found wanting in managerial skills. Given their first exposure to the corporate world, most flounder and continue to stay at levels where growth gets stunted and soon lose drive and enter a "comfort-zone". 

I guess, it is also the education system and the management schools who are to blame to a large extent since these institutes do not focus on the all-round development of the students. I have come across many instances where project reports are copied from those of seniors and there is zero understanding of what is mentioned in the report.

New generation Managers can be affective only on the work place. Unfortunately the world is changing so fast that the relevance of the degree has be come a question mark every now and then. That is the reason why experience takes over the degrees.Unfortunalely in India, we could bring the eductaion system of western world but could not provide the platform to test. This is the reason why most MNCs fail miserably in India and Asia in first 3-4 years . The degrees give the tools to analyse the data to come to a conclusion but the adequacy and accuracy of data itself is questionable. There is a difference between knowledge, skill and wisdom, we get confused in these definitions and consider all of them to be same.If the management degrees are only tools for development, Japan and Germany could not have come to frontal territories in every field. Management is to mange unknown or to manage known. If it is to manage the known then may be degrees and experinece would have helped to some extent. Slowly the world is moving towards " Managiing the "unknown"--------- Quite a big challenge.

Had the degrees and experience been so effective, we would never had a complete grounding of so called booming economy. shattering of empires within no time. Shows  complete failure of knowledge pandits, experts and the overall system

There is something wrong somewhere with what we perceive as true and actual

I certainly wouldn't say that all of them passing out of management colleges only hold degrees and don't have the requisite knowledge and skills to back them up.But yes like any other group there are few guys who only do this course for the sake of it and don't have any value-addition in their personalities but on the other side there are people who really benefits from this course and are capable enough to handle the work given to them....we should not generalize the entire thing based on few elements.What do you guys say?

Before MBA was something like niche....where only selected people were doing such courses...nowadays everywhere one can see institutes offering MBA and PGDBM courses in business management.....so they are not effective at all they are just only degree holders.....

I fully agree, they are good at study material but practical implemantation of what we study requires experience and full understanding of the system. In todays world of technology and communication any one can access any study material and references anytime but implemanation needs experience.

Yes, I do agree with you.