Build your professional network on facebook via our app Go to app
 
 
 
Created by : NIKHIL GUPTA, B.B.A student, GYAN COLLEGE OF MGMT  | 02 24 2011 15:46:57 +0000
Activity:  38125 views;  last activity : 10 05 2014 08:56:44 +0000
 
 Refer 1456
Share
 
 
  Rate : 
 
 
FAVOR Vs AGAINST
28
 
 
 
 
51
38
66
Support   Support
Top Argument
3
3
Yes they need reservation. However only reservation will not help. Lot of infrastructures need to be provided & care should be taken not to benifit creamy class
By Biranchi Narayan Acharya, AGM, Simplex Infrastructures Ltd  02 25 2011 09:15:53 +0000
 
Top Argument
3
1

We all should know one thing.

Babasaheb Ambedkar brought reservation into picture. The biggest conversion from one caste to another happened at that time. The condition of SC ST and OBC was miserable. They were not treated well and needed a platform to grow. What he did was to be implemented for only those 5 to 10 years span. But after him other politicians took an advantage of his reforms. They wanted votes and thus they kept the reservation on even after betterment of society. It was never meant to be the way it is today. We misinterpreted the condition and are doing wrong by not understanding the real message.


By Namrata Pathak, Accounts Manager, American Express  02 25 2011 08:50:37 +0000
0
0

i agree


By Sanjibb Sorenn, B.B.A student, allahbad agricultural universities of science and management  | 08 30 2014 09:40:17 +0000
0
0
at this stage i support the reservation of cs/st.
By Sanjibb Sorenn, B.B.A student, allahbad agricultural universities of science and management  | 08 30 2014 09:38:44 +0000
1
0

sc,st quota shld b increased.... every person of a upper caste wants to put there caste name as surname,cos they want to get recognised by there false sense of pride....even till today 2014 there  are STUDENTS & people who fallow untouchability in so called "METROPOLITEN CITY OR SILICON CITY"...N IF upper caste person is in top position of Hierarchy OF ANY INSTITUTION govt body or a private body..he may fire the subordinate(if he/she is low caste) him for any reason or no reason...IS THERE ANY PERSON upper caste READY TO MARRY A SPOUSE FROM SLUMS(Even if she/ he beautiful or handsome).......BUT IF THAT SLUM PERSON HAS VERY GOOD ECONOMY(MONEY) upper caste will marry without any hesitation.......THE UPPER CASTE PEOPLE ARE JUST SEARCHING PATH OF THEIR convenience OR MAKING IT....people always busy in authenticating caste of others...and immensly not trying to ERADICATE CASTE SYSTEM....BUT ALWAYS SPEAK ABOUT RESERVATION


By JAYASHANKAR.J ,  | 04 15 2014 14:09:36 +0000
0
0
ECONOMICALLY DEPRIVED SECTIONS MAY BE GIVEN RESERVATIONS IRRESPECTIVE OF CAST CREED , RELIGION....
By dinesh kumar sharma, ZONAL SALES MANAGER - NORTH, WOCKHARDT LTD  | 04 21 2013 08:50:45 +0000
0
0
SC, ST quota should be increase BECOZ their is alot of discrimination regarding all aspects of life.its true it still happening in India
By Srikanth Gundala, ja, ap dept  | 04 07 2013 11:14:55 +0000
0
0

SC, ST quota should be increase because in india every person is not equal. SC, ST peoples have not lot of money, lot of people in SC ST poor and very poor but other high level cast people have lot of money mostly so, should increase quota for SC, ST NOTHING WRONG.


By SUNIL KUMAR, Desktop Support Engineer, DMRC  | 03 19 2013 07:55:17 +0000
0
0

this is happening all because of the Hindu mentality ... agar hame bhi vahi chance vahi position milti toh reservation ki jarurat nahi padti.pehele hume dabake rakha humse shiksha ka adhikar china our fir humari bdhoti pe rok lagayi our jab hume mananiya bharatratna dr babasaheb ambedkar ji ne sir uthake chalne ka mouka diya toh ab tumhari g@##$%d jal rahi hai ......!!!!! ye sab tumhari galatioyn ka natijaa hai ..... that's why we wanted equality.


By Chandu Bede, Freelancer, mobile repairing  | 02 28 2013 06:31:28 +0000
0
0
Must give chance for all caste
By Abhikukkamalla Rajanna, 10th student, jmj  | 02 08 2013 10:49:06 +0000
0
0
sc st obc
By Abhikukkamalla Rajanna, 10th student, jmj  | 02 08 2013 10:44:54 +0000
0
0
In this 21st century the upper caste In this 21st century the upper caste Hindu people may not practicing untouchability publically but their vicious minds still practices the untoucablity. Read any Newspaper you will see crimes happened against Dalits all over in India every day. These crimes happen publically but there are also a lot of cases where the partiality, discriminations and even crimes against Dalits occurred in an Institution or a Government Body. The Upper caste Hindus discriminates and hinders the path of Dalit students and employees in various ways even though they are scholars. In Government Bodies they change the policies of promotions when there is a term of promotion for a Dalit at higher posts. For the last 5000 years Dalits were not allowed to do any kind of job out of their casts, not allowed to educate , not even allowed to save money in any form and levy a lot of monstrous restrictions so that the Dalits will always serve ‘Sawarna’ hence the Dalits remained poorer than any other else in society and even today most of them are still poorer. If you ask the BPL(Below poverty Line) people which caste they belong and 99% answer will be a Dalit Caste! Reservation is not meant for ‘Garibi Hataw Andolan’ but it serves as the opportunity in education and employment and bringing the backward class in the main streamline of the Nation and more important it secures the Dalit seats in Institutions and Government Bodies from Upper Casts Hindus otherwise they would not even gave a single seat to a Dalit even if he were a scholar and acquired more marks than upper casts. There is also a Women Reservation Bill in Parliament, does it mean that all the Women are Poor??? Why it is needed such kind of bill? Because women know that their representation will be suppressed as usual hence this bill is for Women’s Guaranteed representation in Parliament and a way of women emancipation. Thus the Reservation for women is social based but the Reservation for DalitHindu people may not practicing untouchability publically but their vicious minds still practices the untoucablity. Read any Newspaper you will see crimes happened against Dalits all over in India every day. These crimes happen publically but there are also a lot of cases where the partiality, discriminations and even crimes against Dalits occurred in an Institution or a Government Body. The Upper caste Hindus discriminates and hinders the path of Dalit students and employees in various ways even though they are scholars. In Government Bodies they change the policies of promotions when there is a term of promotion for a Dalit at higher posts. For the last 5000 years Dalits were not allowed to do any kind of job out of their casts, not allowed to educate , not even allowed to save money in any form and levy a lot of monstrous restrictions so that the Dalits will always serve ‘Sawarna’ hence the Dalits remained poorer than any other else in society and even today most of them are still poorer. If you ask the BPL(Below poverty Line) people which caste they belong and 99% answer will be a Dalit Caste! Reservation is not meant for ‘Garibi Hataw Andolan’ but it serves as the opportunity in education and employment and bringing the backward class in the main streamline of the Nation and more important it secures the Dalit seats in Institutions and Government Bodies from Upper Casts Hindus otherwise they would not even gave a single seat to a Dalit even if he were a scholar and acquired more marks than upper casts. There is also a Women Reservation Bill in Parliament, does it mean that all the Women are Poor??? Why it is needed such kind of bill? Because women know that their representation will be suppressed as usual hence this bill is for Women’s Guaranteed representation in Parliament and a way of women emancipation. Thus the Reservation for women is social based but the Reservation for Dalits are both social and economical based. As long as there is Caste based society in India, there must be Reservation for the Dalits as a Security.
By tacchhoo , Program Manager, aksoftec  | 11 09 2012 09:44:21 +0000
0
0

Mr. Shailesh,

I do agree with you strongly that, Competency is to be given priority & consideration. But, the fact is that, INDIA HAS NOT GIVEN EQUAL OPPORTUNITY TO GROW THEIR SKILLS EQUALLY TO ALL. Either through geographical location, infrastructures such as college, university,Library, transportation etc. Considering this, a Govt as a machinery, is to develop its people on equal foot .There are various ways. Reservation is one such option available. Competency can be, further, developed through various training program at the work-place as required.


By KALIYAMOORTHY , PHSEM, CTCI Corporation  | 10 07 2012 06:10:01 +0000
0
0

"mr moorthy ist you are trying to say that if caste would be abolish then people from diffrent community start dharna".

Mr. Vicky,

Forget about people. Firstly, will the elected representative from reserved constituency who are enjoying the pay & perks & likely to be involved in any legal amendment, accept this?.


By KALIYAMOORTHY , PHSEM, CTCI Corporation  | 10 05 2012 08:28:27 +0000
0
0

"mr moorthy you want to say upper caste people are allowed to kill or oppressed sc,st"

Mr. Vicky,

Caste is a social disease. Once it crippled either it kills the society or mars it to the undesirable degree. It is very difficult to eradicate it unless, there is a strong People's Will. Govt alone can not do anything in it. Now, tell me which community like to give away the caste affiliation. Is it any ST/SC/FC/OBC interested to give away the association? Your wish may be genuine & real intention. But, can you achieve it in your life-time? If so please do it at-least from your end. To day , if govt says, there is no caste in India, you see what will happen to the system & the mass.There will be amptin number of Dharna's from all caste. So, it passes a message to the ruler that, it needs to address the issue with it only. Hence, the viable option available to them is to go for reservation policy to some extent without destabilizing the equilibrium of the social structures. If you say, upper caste are killing the other caste, then it is the " Law & Order problem" of the community.That is to be tackled by the community leaders locally. So, address the issue which really harping the reservation policy.


By KALIYAMOORTHY , PHSEM, CTCI Corporation  | 10 04 2012 05:57:03 +0000
0
0

 "mr moorthy u want to say that oppression should be ignored and caste must remain same. people should leave their caste ist if every 1 is looking for the betterment of india"

Mr. Vicky,

Our thought process are moving in two different directions. Viz, you are talking about the Social pathology existing in society but, I am talking about Economic upliftments to achieve inclusive growth for various strata of the society. 

Recently, India conducted a census based on caste basis on various states. So that, the section of people lying in the criteria for upliftment are identified & social program are launched sizably & in due course of time, an inclusive growth is achieved. 

Reservation is one such policy that makeup & help the political thinkers, to be adopted to achieve the goal. There is no harm in it, as long as the real needy is identified & social support is given. At the end, society's basic needs are catered for & the next goal to be achieved is set-in for development.

 


By KALIYAMOORTHY , PHSEM, CTCI Corporation  | 10 03 2012 14:46:58 +0000
0
0

Mr. Ricky,

Your anguish is quiet understood by many. Everyone say, " there is an oppression of a class by religion/race/region/language.". But how to cull out it. The process of reservation is a tool picked up by the rulers to bridge the gap.


By KALIYAMOORTHY , PHSEM, CTCI Corporation  | 10 03 2012 06:17:46 +0000
0
1

Mr. Nikhil Lele, you need a reservation by economic conditions . But, how do you ascertain the economic backwardness. A man earning Rs.5000/ day, also , claims economic backwardness along with a guy who earns a paltry amount of Rs.50/day. Your revenue guy is ready to issue a salary / income certificate to both the people to claim the economic backwardness. The malady lies here.


By KALIYAMOORTHY , PHSEM, CTCI Corporation  | 08 28 2012 05:59:57 +0000
0
0
see this whole scenario is very quite complicated, let me tell you in brief. here:-- all the upper cast people are on the upper positions and they are responsible for the selection of either the students or the employees. they all have the same thinking as you all have. how come they will provide a position for a lower cast personnel. it is the hate that resides within the heart and cant be erased and coz of that only this reservation system came in picture. see the reason is very clear as water " you broke down us for 5000 years now its our turn, we wont let leave in cut short you people will also suffer as our ancestors felt. woh kya likha hai manu script mein ""Dhol..gawar...sudra...pashu...nari sakal tadan ke adhikari"" toh beta aise nahin bachoge tumko bhi jhelna padega
By akash , Freelancer, Management & Strategy Consulting  | 08 27 2012 20:19:26 +0000
0
0

Medical or engineering Pass karata hai tabhi doctor or engineer banata.

Engeineering or medical pass karne ke liye 12 th ke 40%, ya reservation kam me nahi ata do u Know that?


By indian , Manager, India  | 07 08 2012 08:33:22 +0000
0
0
This is for General people : jab india ko 150 years tak gulam banaya to sab kese paresan ho gaye. ajadi ke liye chat patane lage. aur SC/ST ko to hazaro salo se gulam banaya tha general category valo ne. Unnko achut kehte the. Aur to aur unke liye ajadi jesi koi bat hi nahi hai.... ye to angrej aye to baba sahab ko chance mila lower caste ko upgrade karne ka othewise general people- vo to chahte hi nahi hai ke koi harijan unke level me aye, voto sifr unka gulam hi rehna chahiye. aaj bhi des ke jyadatar i repeat jayadatar hisso me yehi dekhne ko milega. Lower caste people are for just their waste lifting/cleaning. Adivasi ko dekhke ye log khus hote hai. photos khichte hai.. kaise nange log hai. aaj bhi jo upgrade hua hai vo reservation ki vajaha sehi varana unkoto school me bhi bethane nahi de aese hai ye general category vale. governement to diya to kitna 7% for SC and 15% for ST. jab ki SC/ST ko school me hi jyada padhne ko nahi milta to vo college to kaise pahuchenge. Tabhi to jo padhake kaise bhi pahuj jate hai. unki range percentage 90% se 40 % vale 7%& 15% mehi include ho jate hai. aur general valo ko sirf 40% vale hi dikhatew hai... So for up lifting of SC/ST. Revervation is compusory in country like INDIA. where the General category narrow minded people are living.
By indian , Manager, India  | 07 08 2012 08:30:33 +0000
0
0
TO REMOVE RESERVATION TAKE A OUTH TO TREAT EVERY HUMANS AS HUMANS,IT IS SHAME TO KNOW AFTER 64 YRS OF FREEDOM ,WE STILL THE SAME,AFTER BEING EDUCATED , AFTER KNOWING HOW THE CASTE SYSTEM CAME INTO EXISTENCE,AFTER KNOWING THE BLOOD WHICH RUNS DOESN’T HAVE ANY BARRIERS,THE WATER THAT ,WE DRINK DOESN’T HAVE ANY BARRIERS,THE FOOD WE TAKE DOESN’T HAVE ANY BARRIRERS,THE AIR WE BREATH DOESN’T HAVE ANY BARRIERS.IT IS SAME FOR EVERYBODY.WHAT IS HUMANITY?WHAT IS OUR ROLE IN THIS SOCIETY,STATE,COUNTRY AND WORLD? DON'T CLOSE UR EYES FOR THE PEOPLE WHO ARE SUFFERING INFRONT OF YOU.JUST FOR A SECOND THINK YOURSELF IN THEIR PLACE AND BRING YOUR THOUGHTS, THAT YOU ARE IN INDIA, WHICH HAS CELEBRATED 64 YRS OF FREEDOM ,THEN REALIZE WHAT IS THE STATUS OF THOSE PEOPLE,CAN YOU PEOPLE IMAGINE YOURSELVES THE, ONE WHO IS TALKING.......CLEANING ROADS EARLY IN THE MORNING, BATHROOMS, TOILETS FOR OTHER’S USE.DIGGING GRAVES, PREPARING FOR BURIAL, WASHING YOUR CLOTHES IRONING IT FOR OTHERS,IF THE DRAINAGE SYSTEM GETS BLOCKED ,CAN THEY GET IN AND CLEAN FOR PEOPLE. THEIR ARE SOMANY CASTE OF PEOPLE WHO ARE WORKING FOR THE SOCIETY AND CONTINUING WITH THEIR WORK WHAT THEIR ANCESTOR'S USED TO DO. NOW LET US SAY THAT THEIR WILL BE, NO CASTE OR RELIGION BARRIERS. WE WILL WORK ANY WORK GIVEN TO US FOR OUR BASIC NEEDS FOOD,WATER AND SHELTER……..WE ARE ALL EQUAL IN ALL RESPECTS………..NO BODY IS HAPPY TO BE CALLED THAT THEY COME UNDER RESEVATION.DO U KNOW A RESERVED CATEGORY PERSON IF HE/SHE SCORES, THE REACTION WILL BE OH! YOU COME UNDER CATEGORY MAY BE DUE TO IT ,U MIGHT HAVE GOT THE SEAT, WHERE IS THE APPRECIATION FOR THEIR ACHIEVEMENT. MAKE A SURVEY, MAKE THE REAL INVESTIGATION, WHAT IS HAPPENING IN EVERY CORNER OF INDIA.ITS NOT JUST UR CITY, TOWN ITS OUR COUNTRY............AND THE SURVEY SHOULD BE A LIVE TELECAST AND ALL THE CLASSES AND ALL CASTE AND RELIGION ,SO THAT NOBODY HIDES ANYTHING.ITS LEFT TO PEOPLE WHO HAS TO DECIDE.WHEN THEY DECIDE THERE WILL BE NO BARRIERS FOR ANY CASTE TO WORK FOR PARTICULAR WORK.THE PEOPLE WILL DECIDE ACCORDING TO THEIR NEED WHAT THEY CAN WORK TO EARN BREAD,SHELTER FOR THEIR EXISTENCE IN THIS WORLD.
By parimala.c.wagh , Tech Architect, freelance  | 09 30 2011 08:18:49 +0000
0
0

Reservation is to be taken as a phenomenon " as to uplift" or reserve for those who need it. India is a developing nation and is towards the path of development , we will reach there when all the citizens will match the standards of a developed nation. And according to the statistics their are many citizens of India who need help and support to uplift themselves. And here reservation plays an important role. Those who are against this system they should think it in a abroad way and leave their narrow thinking. Yes government implementation in this way is wrong they are not checking that after implementing some system, are we getting some results, candidates should get monetary help. Because we can not afford to compromise on the services where we give reservation eg medicine, intelligence, technical services. So govt should think on this again.


By arpita sharma, lecturer of finance, AMITY University Jaipur Rajasthan  | 06 02 2011 10:59:04 +0000
0
1
This is to bad because of 60% science students became An MBBS and 95%open category students may not becam an MBBS that is because of Resevation. I sugest to our Indian Goverment that If they really want to help him than pay money for study but not reservation. Our goverment policy are shameless.
By Brijesh A Patel, Accounts Executive/Accountant, MMTC  | 03 02 2011 06:33:06 +0000
0
0

totally agree with u


By raj singh sindal, Software Test Engineer, Rishabh Software Pvt. Ltd  | 03 01 2011 04:00:11 +0000
1
1
Reservation System for few years i.e. 15years of after independence of India. But political parties are extending that because of their vote-bank. Political issues are main thing for that. Those who well educated person from upper-cast(with or without financial support) he/she has to get job in open list. but those dont know about any thing and came from lower cast(with or without support) they are getting jobs. is this correct and justify?. If some thing will happen wrong lower-cast persons are complaining of upper-cast person with SC,ST atrocity cases with non-bailable warrants. Most of them are lining based on the cast and making mistakes and if they catch by official then we are from lower-cast and we will report or put cases against upper-cast persons. if u people have guts then come out we will fight together against corruption . then Free Education for all students and show your performance in the education and get the jobs.
By Mouleswara Rao Alasakani, Sr. Executive, SPECK SYSTEMS LIMITED  | 02 28 2011 11:09:00 +0000
0
0
its correct tallent dosent know cast.
By umesh adwankar, Service Engineer  | 02 28 2011 03:48:53 +0000
0
0
what u say is right,talent dosent know cast
By umesh adwankar, Service Engineer  | 02 28 2011 03:47:33 +0000
0
0
I agree..
By Rahul Kulkarni, Technical Support Engineer, vCstomer India Pvt. Ltd.  | 02 27 2011 18:01:34 +0000
0
0

I agree denying reservations for a 'rich' SC candidate. But I can't think of a reason why an uneducated 'forward' caste guy to be economically poor. It's not the societical condition that would make him poor. Either this guy is not trying, or making a mess of his life himself or he is untalented. Providing reservations to such people is dangerous.

The difference is in the mindset and it's the enlightened mindset. To understand this, one has to live the life of these people. For ex., a shoemaker would think of putting his son to work at the early age to support his family than thinking to push him to school.


By Sridhar Bhaskarla Bhaskarla, CEO, MetaSparc  | 02 27 2011 14:20:42 +0000
0
0

The very reason why India is still in 'developing' state is because of the fact that the reservations are not 'properly' implemented. We have majority of the population that come with the 'heritage' and 'culture' of living backward due to the centuries of oppression. As 'forward' gang, we will never be able to understand what it means to live with that mindset and we tend to think with the steriotypic concept of 'talent' etc., etc.,. Just go out out of your comfort area and see how they live. Upliftment is needed to get them out of those habits and the corresponding mindset. Unless the creamy layer is separated, there is no way the reservations will benefit the read need and we will continue to sulk against them. The 'caste' is needed only to repair the damage the done to the country. And please do not club them with economically backward, but forward castes. There is a vast difference in the mindsets of these two. There is no reason for a forward caste person to become economically backward unless he/she is untalented or messed up his/her own life.

The voting here itself indicates that the 'representation' from the majority of the population is missing which stresses the need for reservations, but in right manner.


By Sridhar Bhaskarla Bhaskarla, CEO, MetaSparc  | 02 27 2011 14:11:34 +0000
0
0

Hey,

I feel guys are discussing about untouchable's. Hope that is not the content of discussion.

There is one hand , we have , a population who does not have a college / school within reach , even that does exists so, no infrastructures (such as communication, transportation, financial etc.) available. By virtue of his birth in this country , divided by geographical barriers , one overcomes all these hurdles & attains a specific a quality. On the other hand there is a population who has all facility within his feet. Say, good college, infrastructure (library, coaching class, good transportation, learning environment etc).

Now, a Govt,that really intends to strike a balance in the mass has to explore the possibility to bridge the gap. It finds, reservation is a tool to get it done.

Equal opportunity to all in Education, Employment. Govt, justify its inability to provide equal facility to all (irrespective of remote living) by reservation.


By KALIYAMOORTHY , PHSEM, CTCI Corporation  | 02 27 2011 08:48:31 +0000
1
1

Mr. Raj, I am living in real world where neither the dalits are allowed to enter in to temple nor allowed to walk even in the street roads where upper caste is living. Please go to rural & remote areas where 80% Indians live or otherwise can be said soul of India prevails you can understand that. By the way do you know there are some tribal & dalits who got merit refused to avil reservation? Mr. B. Majhi an IRS officer did not avail quota.


By Biranchi Narayan Acharya, AGM, Simplex Infrastructures Ltd  | 02 26 2011 12:05:49 +0000
0
0

Giving free education, free hostel compared to other main stream people is also a reservation.


By Biranchi Narayan Acharya, AGM, Simplex Infrastructures Ltd  | 02 26 2011 12:01:19 +0000
1
1
I can understand objection of many to favor caste based reservation. Majority think that reservation should be based on class not on caste. That is good but are we ready for a casteless society? Those who think that caste based reservations divide the country, why not they demand to abolish caste based discriminations? Why don't they suport to dalit's entry to temples. A poor upper caste can enter to temple where as a rich dalit cannot enter the temple as per social rules. That is where inequality prevails. There are so many discriminations still prevail in this society. Those who are against caste based reservation must find to end this caste based inequality. Then only my friends your claim can be justified. I always wish there should be class based reservation instead of caste based reservation. But looking present social practice I am unable to justify my wish.
By Biranchi Narayan Acharya, AGM, Simplex Infrastructures Ltd  | 02 26 2011 04:51:02 +0000
0
0
I leave it to the discretion of the Government of India.
By Amarendra Gogoi, Law, Law  | 02 25 2011 18:33:47 +0000
0
0

Mr. can u please tell me how u said that Dr. Ambedaker's whish fullfilled ???


By Nohar Singh Dhruv, Jr. Engg, Chhatisgarh State Electrical Board  | 02 25 2011 12:49:06 +0000
0
0

In a multi-culturally diversified India, where there is no equality exist , even in natural resources and it's distribution & where the infrastructure is poor to establish an equal footage to all by the Govt by rules and regulation And where the downtrodden remains exploited by various means by the HAVES' , it is mandatory for the government to pave a way to bring everyone on equal terms socially, economically and politically in whatsoever manner they can. For which, every citizen vote a government-  be it minority or majority run by coalition.


By KALIYAMOORTHY , PHSEM, CTCI Corporation  | 02 25 2011 12:29:07 +0000
0
0
Give your supporting argumentI DON't THINK RESERVATION IS NECESSARY
By NIKHIL GUPTA, B.B.A student, GYAN COLLEGE OF MGMT  | 02 24 2011 15:46:57 +0000
0
0
I worked so hard in 12 class and wanted to get admission in Sri ram college of commerce (SRCC).But i don't get and were the cutoff of sc and st were 85%. What's this it should change the students who don't study full year get admission to he'll with this reservation please someone take action so in future these cheap, freaked, moran people can't get admission
By Nishant Dagar, Studying, Student  | 10 05 2014 08:56:44 +0000
0
0
rich class people reserves their seats with their full fledged money,and lower class people with their sc/st caste certificate how about the middle class people.In any streams let it be education basis,job o anything the vacancies are reserved by the top and lower level people...after 12th educations there must be no caste certificate to be considered during addmission o recruitment.
By Naina Joshi, BBM student, Sesharipuram First Grade College  | 09 04 2014 07:22:32 +0000
0
0

Which has been done for a very limited period, why it should continue even on 21st century? According to me there shoud not be any reservation in Government job at all.


By Rathin Deb, Advisor and retail consultant, currently as Branch Manager, Tower Infotech Ltd  | 01 08 2014 07:19:14 +0000
0
0
at this stage and generation every person is given equal power,but using the benefits for the right purpose,...as per the statics the GM is being degrading and the benefits of SC/ST certificates are in full advantage , a Scheduled Caste youth, for example, whose father is a very wealthy timber merchant, will still be eligible for free university tuition and perhaps a hotly contested place in a medical college, while a Brahman girl from a poor family, who has much higher examination marks than he, may be denied admission...its not fair
By Naina Joshi, BBM student, Sesharipuram First Grade College  | 01 07 2014 06:33:15 +0000
0
0

Dear Abhik probably you are mentioning about the financially weak people, who should only be considered for reservation and not on caste basis.

I hope in that case the deserving candidates will grow in our country over a period of time. There are thousands of examples can be quoted in this regard.


By Rathin Deb, Advisor and retail consultant, currently as Branch Manager, Tower Infotech Ltd  | 04 25 2013 06:57:27 +0000
1
0
To bring the backward classes (who are financially backward) into the mainstream,financial help needs to be provided.But certainly not reservation in 'jobs',because eligibility,I.Q and capability has nothing to do with the rich and the poor.
By Abhik Dasgupta, Consulting Civil Engineer  | 04 23 2013 07:31:29 +0000
0
0
If we talk about reservation in that case those people will reservation in assembly seat as well. Will that be accepted to politicians? If yes then there is no problem with continuing with reservation.
By Rathin Deb, Advisor and retail consultant, currently as Branch Manager, Tower Infotech Ltd  | 04 22 2013 06:29:27 +0000
0
0

I am of the opinion that quota system should be completely abolished. It may still be there for the physically challenged persons.


By Rathin Deb, Advisor and retail consultant, currently as Branch Manager, Tower Infotech Ltd  | 03 13 2013 07:11:06 +0000
0
0

Quota system is only useful if it reaches the Economically/Physically 'NEEDY' and not smartass individuals who are well to do in all respects, but have an advantage of being born into a specific community.

Plus there should be no compromise in 'Quality/Merit' in fields like Medicine and Engineering... Govt should provide FREE EDUCATION AND FOOD to them if it is must, but this System is TOTALLY UNACCEPTABLE!

I have many friends who

-Spend their scholarship money for partying and drinking or buying expensive clothes and mobiles

- They want to go for outing with friends, so they apply for exam centers and Govt pays for their travelling expenses;

Its like you pay money to somebody as an urgent help and later see them drinking and partying... Thats pathetic! Look at you guys.

A colleague of mine (belonging to SC) is an alcoholic and boasts he can bully anyone owing to the "Atrocities act ". Moreover he believes in corruption of 'kind' not 'cash'; (thats the new trend these days.) wtf is this? You should be humble, grateful & true to your country dude.

And if a person has been awarded a wonderful job with a decent pay-package via this system; Good!!Awesome!!

-Why should they get or hope for "Another/ Unlimited chances"?

Why do they need quota in promotion as well?

Why should their Sons & Daughters & other family members need it in every aspect??

Its high time people you should do things on your own and let the benefits reach the really needy.

In the name of creating equality the govt is encouraging animosity.. Sooner or later this is going to cause big troubles for many.


By Hoshang Keswani, Bank of India  | 03 12 2013 22:58:50 +0000
1
0
Wipro chairman Mr. Azim prem ji's comment on reservation: Good one..read on.... I think we should have job reservations in all the fields. I completely support the PM and all the politicians for promoting this. Let's start the reservation with our cricket team. We should have 10 percent reservation for Muslims. 30 percent for OBC, SC /ST like that. Cricket rules should be modified accordingly. The boundary circle should be reduced for an SC/ST player. The four hit by an OBC player should be considered as a six and a six hit by a OBC player should be counted as 8 runs. An OBC player scoring 60 runs should be declared as a century. We should influence ICC and make rules so that the pace bowlers like Shoaib Akhtar should not bowl fast balls to our OBC player. Bowlers should bowl maximum speed of 80 kilometer per hour to an OBC player. Any delivery above this speed should be made illegal. Also we should have reservation in Olympics. In the 100 meters race, an OBC player should be given a gold medal if he runs 80 meters. There can be reservation in Government jobs also. Let's recruit SC/ST and OBC pilots for aircrafts which are carrying the ministers and politicians (that can really help the country.. ) Ensure that only SC/ST and OBC doctors do the operations for the ministers and other politicians. (Another way of saving the country..) Let's be creative and think of ways and means to guide INDIA forward... Let's show the world that INDIA is a GREAT country. Let's be proud of being an INDIAN.. May the good breed of politicans like ARJUN SINGH long live...
By gaurav joshi Shah, Freelancer, Textile  | 12 19 2012 05:19:57 +0000
0
0

Can u solve an algebra equation by chewing Bubblegum? Thats much effective is reservation...


By gaurav joshi Shah, Freelancer, Textile  | 12 19 2012 04:28:58 +0000
0
0

i really agree with your words


By JAYAN NAIR, Below 10th student, NARMADA VIDHALAYA  | 12 18 2012 16:44:15 +0000
0
0
Our Total politicians looking for only vote, vote, vote?
By Bhupendra Singh, Head Logistics , MANKIND PHARMA LTD  | 12 18 2012 16:20:04 +0000
0
0
Also i want to ask a question to everyone is it right to take away anything like a college seat from a deserving student and to give it to a non deserving student on reservation basis? Will you tk ur child to a doctor who knows nothing but is a doctor by the grace of reservation? or you will go to a knowledgeable doctor? Likewise in every field
By gaurav joshi Shah, Freelancer, Textile  | 12 18 2012 12:18:17 +0000
0
0
Its nothing more then a government conspiracy to rule the masses. As per the government by the National Sample Survey Organization (NSSO) put the OBC population in the country at 40.94%, the SC population at 19.59%, ST population at 8.63% and the rest at 30.80%.So the 69.20% population whose getting benefited by the reservation system will never say no to the reservation system. And if the government dares to think to drop the reservation system in effect they will directly lose their 69.20% votes. And the government doesn't work for the people of this country but for them self. Moreover According to the survey, 91.4% of STs, 79.8% of SCs and 78.0% of OBCs were in rural areas. Conversely, 8.6% of STs, 20.2% of SCs and 22% of OBCs were in urban areas, while 37.7% of 'others' lived in India's towns and cities. So if the government actually wants to work for the real people in need the first thing required is to remove the middleman between govt. and farmers. Make it mandatory for any doctor studying in the medical college to work for at least 5 years in rural areas and this is no charity from the doctors they will get their salary its imp to do the service for the doctors because the give peanuts as their fee to become doctors but they are actually studying on us Indians hard earned money which we give as tax. If reservation is needed then the right implication is more important otherwise it’s just like stealing from one mouth to feed another. If somebody doesn't allow any human to enter a temple then the temple staff needs to be changed immediately by govt. interference and the person should be treated equal but if for that the govt will give u a certificate of being the victim and give you a years grocery supply then how the govt is uplifting the victim they are just playing their cards and now the victim also enjoys playing the victim for getting additional benefits. If i am incorrect kindly please advice me name of any 5 persons who falls in reservation but they have actually given up reservation benefits because they are now IAS or a minister or a millionaire or just well read or well off Dear Mr. Biranchi Narayan Acharya, Sir you are a Chief manager and a well read and well of person. Sir if you fall under the reservation benefits kindly advice now since you are well off have you given up the reservation benefits for yourself and your family? With all due respect sir kindly reply. That’s harsh but the bitter truth about our country. Remember Religion and casts never bonds but divide the people it never works for the people but to rule the people.
By gaurav joshi Shah, Freelancer, Textile  | 12 18 2012 11:42:16 +0000
0
0
NO RESERVATION MUST BE THERE FOR ANY CAST .IT MUST BE BASED ON ECONOMIC CONDITIONOF INDIVIDUALS AND THEY MUST BE FINANCIALLY AIDED/HELPED TO GET EDUCATED AND AFTER EDUCATION MERRIT MUST BE THE ONLY CRIETAREA FOR JOBS AND PROOTIONS. I FULLY REJECT THE IDEA OF RESERVATIONS ON CAST BASIS BECAUSE WE CAN SEE PEOPLE WHO ARE IN ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES AND MILLIONERS ARE GRABBING THE BENIFIT OF RESERVATIONS AND THE REAL PEOPLE IN NEED FAL TO GRAB THE OPPORTINITY.PEOPLE WHO BROUGHT RESERVATION WERE FAIR BUT NOW PEOPLE HAVE LOST MORAL VALUES AND EVERYONE WANT TO PROGRESS THROUGH SHORTEST ROUTE,I.E.BY HOOK OR CROOK . THIS HAS FAILED THE SLOE PURPOSE OF RESERVATION.
By rakeshbhatnagar , GM Projects., wig brothers india pvt.ltd.  | 12 07 2012 10:36:31 +0000
0
0

from last sixty year people says believe in equality . how can we became equal when from childhood in school only children are taught about cast, reservation, minority. from child they are taught that STs are different from them . then can we washout cast-ism from indai . the path is stop believing political leaders,they play its as a game, but effect does it plays on our children, does any one noticed.how much a student feels bad who worked so hard to pass any compition and fails and sees his friend, not worked hard, but enjoying the prize.


By Agarwal chirag, B.Tech/B.E. student, charusat  | 12 06 2012 07:38:12 +0000
2
0
we all agree that in past history peoples were divided based on the job/ work done by them , i mean people who cleaned the dirt, or servants were belonging to shudra group. they were treated very badly. but this is modern 21st century. we dont com across such things. my point of veiw is that if at all reservation of upliftment is given .it has to be for below povery line who score good marks but dont have money to pay for admissions into higher class. instead of that govt is just giving quota to anyone who shows that certificate. what right a student who has scored less marks gets a seat in IIM-A, then a person who scores more then him is deprived of the seat. then what is the meaning of merit . if he is sc/st , and son of mp/mla and gets 40% marks , why the hell he should be given aseat in good college. a general category student who score 590% , his life is ruined , becoz he cannot even apply for job. if 60% is for GM AND 55% for sc/st , where should a GM (55%) SHOULD GO. SHOULD HE die..?
By SHIVAYOGI G HIREMATH, EXECUTIVE TRAINEE, RITES LTD  | 10 23 2012 08:50:33 +0000
2
0
I am completely against reservation on any basis. Reservation is a kind of protectionism which is given to the weak so that they can survive in the competition. The consequence of this is, it hampers the competition. If some sort of protection is given to the incompetent people that will be unfair to the competent persons and this will also discourage them and will encourage the incompetent persons to remain incompetent. That is why any kind of reservation, may it be on the basis of cast or other, should not be given so that it will be justifiable to all. Furthermore, now a days the law has banned all the practices which were discriminating against people from lower cast. Discrimination for the lower cast has become thing of the past. I see reservation as a new way of discriminating against upper cast people by refraining those competent upper cast people in jobs, education or any other sector.
By shailesh , B.B.A student, kumaun university, ssj campus almora  | 10 06 2012 06:01:42 +0000
1
0

I feel reservation is required but not on the basis of caste. It should be done on the basis of monthly earning of per family and this should be done for say 10 years.

This will help economic upliftment of the real needy. The end result the people who need the reservation most will be benefited.


By Rathin Deb, Advisor and retail consultant, currently as Branch Manager, Tower Infotech Ltd  | 10 03 2012 06:33:23 +0000
0
0
In globlization, reservation is artificial obstcal in development
By Ghadge , Freelancer, Asset Management  | 10 03 2012 05:53:37 +0000
0
0
Reservation should be only for those who are residing in rural area / village where population is less than 10,000.It should be based on the performance of benefishery.
By Ghadge , Freelancer, Asset Management  | 08 28 2012 09:53:21 +0000
0
0

Nikhil I am in total agreement with you.


By Rathin Deb, Advisor and retail consultant, currently as Branch Manager, Tower Infotech Ltd  | 08 28 2012 09:10:36 +0000
0
0

Mr Kaliyamoorthy I do not agree with you. If we are being able to base the reservation on economic basis it will be actually benefit those for whom the scheme is meant.

Say two decades back no body thought Voter ID will be a possibility but today it is a reality. If Government wish they can always find out a way but for their own benefit they will desist from doing so. Sad but true.  


By Rathin Deb, Advisor and retail consultant, currently as Branch Manager, Tower Infotech Ltd  | 08 28 2012 08:48:05 +0000
1
0
I agree on the Reservation System, however, it CANNOT be on the basis of Caste. It can be based on economic classes of people, so that people from the under priviledged economic classes get equal opportunites.
By Nikhil Lele, Business Unit Head - RPO, Hexagon Executive Search Pvt. Ltd.  | 08 28 2012 04:27:14 +0000
0
0
as per our indian constitution all the humans are equal. secondly, every person must show his own performance and skills and dedicate to the nation without these kind of reservation. he/she come forward with his/her skill.
By kannan , Head/VP/GM-Accounts, own office  | 07 09 2012 04:55:57 +0000
0
2

By giving reservation for SC/ST/OBC we are giving them the thing they don't deserve for (like a begger) and enabling them to make this a habit when a SC/ST/OBC candidate got a civil services job or any reputed job

why the reservation policy also applicable for his SON or DAUGHTER also??

he is earning more than enough to educate his/her child BUT this is in their habit that they become the heirarchial begger and give their not the proper education but a CASTE CERIFICATE to avail the benefits(but actually the shortcut to college in spite of he is not deserving) or to teach them that he need not to do HARDORK RAM KUMAR 12 student at RPVV DELHI


By RAM KUMAR, Pursuing Graduation student, NIT DELHI  | 06 24 2012 12:07:53 +0000
0
1
I'll show this by an example. If a SC/ST student does medicine, manages to struggle through college for choosing a course he/she isn't suited to and secures just 40% marks and passes. How many patients knowing this would go to that doctor? Wouldn't it be bad for that student himself? He will have probably worked and worked but not getting patients? How is that beneficial?
By Dhananjay Salgaocar, B.Tech/B.E. student, GEC  | 06 16 2012 16:58:43 +0000
1
0
RESERVATION MUST BE REMOVED AND IF PEOPLE ARE ARE FINANCIALLY POOR PROVIDE FREE EDUCATION AND LODGING BOARDING FACILITIES TO SUCH PEOPLE WITHOUT LOOKING INTO CAST THATS WHAT IS REQUIRED TODAY. NOW THIS A TOOL FOR POLITICS AND POLITICIANS ARE UTALISING THIS TOOL TO GET POWER .
By rakeshbhatnagar , GM Projects., wig brothers india pvt.ltd.  | 03 08 2011 16:18:32 +0000
0
0

You forgot to add another category that is rampant in our society.. The rich class that simply 'buy' seats in other states and become the doctors or engineers. So, here money buys talent too.

Folks - If we are interested in inclusive growth of India, we have to think about majority of the population and that's not the forward castes. If majority of the population remains underdeveloped, then there is no way country is going to grow.It is going to take us further down.

We are already seeing the effects of this underdevelopment.. Aren't we?


By Sridhar Bhaskarla Bhaskarla, CEO, MetaSparc  | 03 04 2011 14:38:18 +0000
0
0

Talent doesn't know caste?. Great argument.

But there is something fishy. One could see (just watch around) that majority of the forward caste people are well educated and settled and the majority of these unfortunate classes are still backward and are under poverty..

Yes. Talent doesn't know caste. But it is to be brought out and mind-set is one major road-blocks in it alongwith poverty. This stresses the need for reservations, but to be implemented in proper way, not political way.


By Sridhar Bhaskarla Bhaskarla, CEO, MetaSparc  | 03 04 2011 14:34:30 +0000
0
2
As casts are abolished, reservation is needless now.
By Ghadge , Freelancer, Asset Management  | 03 02 2011 21:13:33 +0000
0
0

I agree to him...


By suhaschandra deshpande, Marketing Associate  | 03 02 2011 08:25:36 +0000
1
0
good one too hang on... reservation system is a good idea in past,present and future. But the changes should be brought on platforms. Now it is caste based. It should be changed to economy of the family or knowledge of the individual.
By Ravanam naga durgesh, Junior engineer, Ericsson  | 02 28 2011 12:58:28 +0000
0
0
Deserving candidate only. No Quota No Reservations.
By Anand Sharma, Monitoring the research funded by DIT, Department of Information Technology  | 02 28 2011 10:46:23 +0000
0
0
100% Against, no need any reserve category, all people are common. If you have talent skill then can take admission,job etc. It does not require any reserve category. Only one General category.....We all are come in general category
By Virag Shah, Confidential  | 02 28 2011 05:55:51 +0000
0
0
60 years of reservation and the story still goes on. This is because, the reservation does not trickle down to those that actually need it but is skimmed off at the top itself. The son of a Chief Secretary in the IAS may prefer the SC route as it will give him a better options. The son of a CMD of a PSU will similarly look at this route in other competetive exams to increase prospects. This is where the problem arises. Like a Ration-Card the Govt can perhaps also issue an SC-ST Card that will allow the holder to use the SC-ST trump card let us say for a total of 2 or 3 times only IN THE FAMILY. If the father has used it, then the son will not be eligible. In this way, the concessions will start seeping down to those that actually need it.
By V. Srinivas, Freelancer, Information Technology  | 02 28 2011 03:57:17 +0000
0
0

i am living in most rural area of Rajasthan. one of the backward area of rajasthan. and i havent seen any dalit stopped entering into temple...

and come out from ur parallel world Mr... neither 80% of india is not living in backward area now days...nor dalits in 80% of area are in poor condition or wrongly treated.

 

 


By raj singh sindal, Software Test Engineer, Rishabh Software Pvt. Ltd  | 02 27 2011 07:36:05 +0000
0
0
Any reservation should be based on some real need for it and not on cast basis.
By Anand Hisaria, Branch Manager/Regional Manager, Ceasefire Industries Limited  | 02 27 2011 06:39:36 +0000
0
0
If there is reservation than what is need of qualification and higher % of marks in education,employment.This is merely vote bank practice.Original backward class members are not care for any reservation.Practically all sc,st and obc are not get any mass benefit of that reservation.And all backward classes are not depend upon reservation.
By LAXMAN KESHWALA, Freelancer, Telecom/ISP  | 02 26 2011 20:39:18 +0000
0
0
Favour only those who have potiential. Let him be from any caste
By Sarabjeet Singh Johar, BMS student, Mumbai University  | 02 26 2011 18:39:41 +0000
0
1

and Mr... stopping reservation means we are giving them chance to stand equal with general.

today's young generation think that we all are equal.. so why to divide us in name of cast.

its just politician and supporters like you know ,  just blame other, are main cause of this thing.

 

and just because few rural areas where few so called political favored powerful people are doing wrong thing , you are supporting reservation in all India...HUH?

isn't this is Inappropriate ...? injustice for student ?

 

tell me .. which student did stop entering any dalit in temple?

thinking like you is stopping indian growth. just because few people are facing wrong treatment because of few wrong parties .. you beg for reservation .. to destroy already destroyed indian structure and growth.

 


By raj singh sindal, Software Test Engineer, Rishabh Software Pvt. Ltd  | 02 26 2011 07:46:19 +0000
0
1

r u living in parallel world.. MR.

other than few most backward areas  i never heard or seen any thing like that..

now days every one has right to enter in temple.

 


By raj singh sindal, Software Test Engineer, Rishabh Software Pvt. Ltd  | 02 26 2011 07:38:49 +0000
0
0
BECAUSE RESERVATION IS WHY NEEDED TO ALL .BECAUSE ALL STUDENT DOING SAME COURSE & SAME TIME SPEND IN SAME COURSE . WHY ST SC .............
By avinash kumar, Production ENGG., NUBERG ENGG.LTD  | 02 26 2011 05:00:51 +0000
0
1
No I do not agree with reservation for SC,ST etc. If you have guts then take job with your hardworking and knowledge,skills. Now with the help of reservation you also stop some good candidate to come into picture and also "INCREASE CORRUPTION". Not all the candidate are same but still it increase the corruption.
By ROHIT ARORA, Sr. Budget Controller, Haier Appliance India Pvt ltd  | 02 26 2011 04:59:30 +0000
0
0
The reservation is meant for particular period only. More than that period is not necessary. But, it has become a political issue.
By Arunagiri Velu, Chief Executive  | 02 26 2011 02:46:04 +0000
0
1
Reservation itself is like creating a second class citizen in the country. It is deplorable, not only as human beings, but also as the citizens of this country. Give them free educations, free hostel and make them compete with the best in the field. Instead of that by giving reservation, one is jeopardies the administration by sub standard quality personal. And reservation brings to me the story i heard in my childhood of the wolf and the sheep. If not you your grand father might have had water upstream and so I am going to eat. This generation of upper cast or general category has not done anything to deserve the second class treatment.
By Ramakrishnan P R, CEO/MD/Director, Business  | 02 26 2011 01:32:37 +0000
0
0
This is a criminal act by doing reservation for SC,ST & OBC. The only way to support them is to support at their basic need during their growth of up bringing in child hood education to college by providing finencial and economic support. After a comprehensive support up to the maximum level of or minimum level of qualification than for getting job there should be equal treatment to all. Again based on the merit their educational stream should be decided not like the general candidate after getting 80% + in Medical or IIT is not getting selected if a ST,SC & OBC candidate is getting selected after scoring 40% due to reservation policy than the fate of this counrty is going face !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! So i am strongly in favour of 100% support for SC,ST&OBC from their pre birth to make him a complete man / woman by supporting at all spehere of upbringing and education up to the level of competeion whrere the real test starts,
By SUSANTA PATNAIK, SALES, Eureka Forbes Ltd  | 02 25 2011 14:04:42 +0000
0
0
No reservation to any caste. Economically backwards be given all assistance to acquire sufficient knowledge to compete with others in study.
By Dr. Prahallad Panda, Surgeon, Cochin Port Trust Hospital  | 02 25 2011 13:47:04 +0000
0
0
The concept of reservation for SC/ST was incorporated in our constitution only as a short term measure, say just for 10 years. Our politicians have made it a permanent fixture. Also they added reservation for OBC, which is anybody with political backing and muscle power.More and more groups are clamoring for inclusion in the reserved list.This type of reservation is against equality and meritocracy. Instead of reservation or quota, we should go in for affirmative action, where the really needy are helped.
By Prof TKG Namboodhiri, Director, Metallurgical Consultancy  | 02 25 2011 13:25:03 +0000
Leading IT Recruitment firm
  • Create a confidential Career Profile and Resume/C.V. online
  • Get advice for planning their career and for marketing of experience and skills
  • Maximize awareness of and access to the best career opportunities
Viewers also viewed
Should be based on financial status of individual vs Should be based on Cast
 
46 referals 14 arguments, 364 views
* The Care, Breeding Management, Exprimental Techniques And Welfare Of Laboratory               ...
124 referals 4 comments, 549 views
Yes vs No
 
66 referals 22 arguments, 8745 views
more...