Reservation Quota in Private Sector ?

Dear Mr.Santosh Sinha,

I understand your feelings for the up liftment of the downtrodden, But in India, Unfortunately the beneficiaries are identified and then suitable policy is framed, which is suppose to be other way around. I argue on the same stand point. which i discussed before.

Let us only talk about bringing social justice by providing adequate facilities and support, under any criteria, Primarily Economic condition. because That is the main hurdle in every developmental plan. Once that is provided by identifying the needy in the society,  then choosing the right career and Lifestyle should be Equal with every citizen of the country.

Can any one argue with me that All those who belong to the so called upper class are socially sound and healthy and all those who are under privileged or backward class in terms of caste,creed and colour are socially poor and do require reservation to get a Job in India.

Make education free for all up to school Level, atleast up to 10th std, and in some cases up to 12th based on need, remove the discrimination from the minds of Children and see a prosperous India visualised by the great Leaders like APJ Abdul kalam.

Jai Hind

Prabhakar

Hi,

I oppose the idea of reservation based on Caste,creed, colour. The reservation, as bijumon put it was one of the measures to elevate the downtrodden to bring it on par in the Society which was well twisted by the Politician for their benefits. So many states in India are working on caste based vote banks, There were great leaders and freedom fighters who were fighting for the up liftment of the under privileged in those days. while now this has been used as a trump card to gain political mileage which is absolutely not necessary. Even to the extent using  caste to their advantage to win elections.

Yes. Definitely socially backward class should be identified based on the their economical condition, necessary and suitable support in terms of Education, food, shelter can be provided to bring them in the soceity, later gaining entry in to the jobs should be purely based on merit.

Is there any one in the country say that all those who are backward class in terms of caste are poor and upper class are Rich. Are Lalu yadav and Mayavati are poor, their children do need reservation. can any one agree with this.

So There is no need for any reservation in the Private sector at all.

Prabhakar 

HAS TOO STEP GOT ANY VOICE EVEN IF SCORE IS 00:100?,

WE ARE JUST TAKING OUT OUR ANGER.

don't , dilute corporate genes.

let them behave the way they want :: iam with rahul / shishir bajaj

I agree with Mr. Mohan Murari that Neither private nor government sector should have reservation policy on cast ground. Government should help weaker section for their study and food. 

it may be true that reservation is to help underprivilaged and weaker section of the society, but to what extent and how long? even though Govt. do have fine systems in every thing but not executing properly is because of this reservation evil.people without any much knowledge will not allow any development as they will always under constant fear of being downgrading.there should not be any reservations in any private sectors as it hampers quality indulged in services of that sector.when human beings are not created/borned without any reservations Govt should think in some other ways to make them competetive by providing adequate financial help and see that one will put in thier real effort to get / achieve the goals.

atleast private sector should be spared

The idea behind reservation is to help underprivileged and weaker section of the society. Very sad to see that this purpose has been defeated due to poor exectution and some other reasons. The deserving people are not getting the due benefit instead other powerful people(creamy layer!) are taking advantage. The same will happen anywhere govt. will apply reservation whether its education or private sector.

ATLEAST PRIVATE SECTOR BE SPARED FROM RESERVATION ,OTHERWISE DEVELOPEMENT OF OUR COUNTRY WILL REMAIN A DREAME,GOVT CAN GIVE FACILITY TO THESE TYPES OF CANDIDATES IN ADMISSION TO STUDIES,IN PROVIDING BEST FACILITY EVEN MONITORY ALSO,FOR WRITTEN COMPETETION ALL BEST COACHING ETC. BE PROVIDED,BUT NO RESERVATION BE PROVIDED FOR JOBS,THIS ALSO DECREASE THE COMPETITIVE CAPACITY ,THUS THEY BECOME DEPENDENT,AND A DEPENT WORKER CANT EVEN THINK OF COUNTIES DEVELOPEMENT.

Reservation quota had made it too difficult for a fresher to get a govt. job at present.

If reservations would start covering private sector, then it would b quite more tough competition in private sector too. There would b more than enough opportunities for categories under reservation, but what about generals.......??? It would simply raise the cut-off for general category everywhere.

Companies Bottom Line is make Profit. They can't work similarly the Govt. system work in India.Private companis have very clear EXIT POLICY for non-performer,whereas,in Govt. org. it doesn't happen so.