'Sach Ka Samna' TV show challenged in High Court: Should this be Banned?

yes u r right Mandeep. This program is not to be banned.

It should not be banned ,atleast people learn from this that if they do something wrong and later they are forced to face like such ka samna,how will it be then,further  in general it can be seen how courageous a person is and also he can judge his courage to face the such  sach.

If Sach ka samna is to be banned, then let's also ban all those other programs and game shows where they show prying women, extra marital affairs, nudity, obscene scenes etc etc... if they can ban all the other nonsense that viewers are subjected to on TV, then for sure Sach ka saamna has to be banned. I find all the soaps on TV a very bad projection about Indian culture. What do you say for that?

no it should not banned,rather show should invite allpolitical leaders,cleberarty to shows.if polygraph test is treated as proof in court host should invite all such leaders to the show let them face sach ka saman with public.it is very easy to say lie,but difficult to confess the truth in public.i know show does not provide any entertainment or it does not have saas bhau logicif you want to ban the show,ban another kiran bedi ki kacheri,wht lanugauge they using in the serials,wht do we gat from that show

SHOULD NOT BE BANNED AT ALL....

LEADERS OF INDIA R ALWAYS HYPOCRITS, THEY CAN DO THE THINGS UNDER COVER, BUT CANT SAY, CANT HEAR...CANT SEE..... THAT'S Y THEY WANT 2 BAN THE PROGRAM, BUT LEADERS THEMSELVES SAY THAT IT'S A DEMOCRATIC COUNTRY...

HEIGHT OF HYPOCRISY

Well if Indian Television comes up with something new in the industry people tend to complain a lot! I guess people just stay ready to complain anytime any moment. Why don't they think of others who love the particular program. I feel people whose stories are somewhat similar to what is shown in the program gets disturb by it and they are the ones who complain about such kind of things. Therefore, it should not have been banned.

 Treat this serial as an entertainment...............

Today if we ask from ourself that is it posiible to say truth everytime..........you will find that...........no.......no one can really say truth even from himself. So this is really interesting to see people doing very difficult thing by commiting truth.

Just treat it as an entertainment..................

As par as it is related to the gain by watching it..................we are gaining half an hour pure entertainment.

The show has not forced any one to come the show, ppl eventually come as they are greedy for money, hence ppl are to be blamed who go to the show and not the show itself.

If we are talking bout what we are learning from this program than we should check all the programs that we watch on TV and after deep analysis we would find that 90% program are just for fun no learning part in it. The reason i am in support of this program is that this show gives us something to think bout, we can relate to this show, we can take a look inside the deepest and darkest corners of our heart and try not to do things in future that if reveled would hurt the people who love us.

I will never dare to be on that hot seat but i would try change somethings in future, somethings that might hurt my loved ones if reveled, and moreover this show is not telecasted on primetime so if you don't like to watch it just change the channel no need to ban it.

It shoudn't  be stop,atleast public is able to see the courageous persons who can face the truth openly on TV. 

Entertainment in its form has evolved over the ages from gladiaters,operah's to reality shows.Etical,Nonetical let it be decided by the ages and the people.

Till then jst njoy.

There is no need to ban or stop the show. After all it is showing, or should we say, exposing the truth of our society. We have grown up with the saying that 'sahitya samaj ka darpan hai'. The stories of Manto during the period of our partition days was also a bitter truth. It is true that directly we only see a person's private life 'thread bare' in the show, but if we dare to see in the hind sight it gives message to all of us.

HI,

There are no reasons to ban this show. If we are talking about the questions asked in the show then they are just asking about their lives.

Moreover, people want to tell about their lives in front of camera. Channel or the makers of Sach Ka Samna are not pressurizing anybody to participate.

If the participants are comfortable about sharing their secrets then why are others making hype off this?

It’s an individual choice to reveal the secrets about their life and if somebody's finding it hard to digest then please don't watch the programme.

This programme is much better then many other realities show where celebrity participants are doing anything to earn money and publicity. Here at least participant are truthful and accepting the truth in front of whole world.

And it needs guts. SO, there’s no point of stopping the telecast of the programme.

Regards,

Rohini.

it should not be banned according to me because they themseleves participate in the show knowing that their personnel life will be exposed in front of the world.

When people sell out there self to earn then what the hell is this kinda story tale "Sach ka samana", if you will understand one's necessity then its just a earning medium for them...

People who sell out themself even when they feel gulity then its the dead end....despite this what ever is the way to earn is comparitivly better.

Exploitation will only have a end now when it will be published among the crowd and one will really think of making a dot somewhere, everyday it happens in lots of ways somehow its all hidden...

such ka samana karane ki himmat sab me nahi hoti hai ,isliye kuchh log isase gayab hain.

Why do we refer case studies ?

Cant we think of sach ka samana giving deep results into personal life style deeds, results of doing such deeds which one should not do..

Yes we are gaining lots, you must have heard that you only get better when you face failure, so this is the truth which will enrich you for doing the things right , so that one does not get the result which they have got...

Tell me one thing why people often refer case studies...?...hopefully you will get the answer for gaining something out of it...

No body has free time, why anybody would come to show for free and promoting "sach ka samana", its all very much commercial, everybody is earning out of it...thts it, if you take out incentives then it would become a church where people do go and have there confessions. The world is all about give n take...nothing is free....

what a prostitute pays in turn of getting paid....its something very big than of just "personal life" . infact people should take the positive signs from the worst examples of personal life and improve their life style, so it does not comes there way....think positive ...you will surely get everything in the right track...

Dear Alka,

Viewers might not be getting anything but a the end of the show there are lots of people getting paid, infact people are getting some resources to earn, just think of people who does not get any resources and opt for being in prostitution.

There is nothing so called VULGAR in the program  as nothing obscene is showned as many other reality shows do. And the basic concept is very clear and should be appriciated, 'coz the idea is just to bring the truth in front. As far as the scene created in the parliament is concerned, we all know our politicians, whenever the question of Truth or Confession arises, they behave like this only. Infact, these ppl should be called by the HOST.

THe programme hs been rated success with a TRP of 4.5 & had also resulted in Star Plus regaining No 1 slot from Colours in first week of July. what i dont understand is  if there are so many concerns ( & if it has to be banned) regarding the format how come it able to get such high viewership. And if it gets such good TRP then what's wrong is showing what people want to see. Star Plus is an entertainment channel & its being truthful to its policy.

You really want to stop the programme or stop people from saying the truth.

Telling truth is not an offense ,atleast for the sake of winning people are speaking the truth

If a person telling truth dont have problem

If a person listnening truth  dont have problem

then who is HIGH COURT to put a ban on it . India is free country, citizens have right to speak,hear and express their point of view.

When kambli been asked that question"he ever asked any woment for abortion?" he only said Yes din took any lady name

when he dont have any problem, his wife dont have any problem then why... then why others are scratching this topic.

First of all look in your heart how many lies we are hiding and start respecting someone who have guts enough to stand up speak the "TRUTH"

and about the money stuff . If there wont be any money in the show then neither the supporter nor opposer would had saw the show for once even. You have to pay "celebrity" price for being his/him celebrity.

Atlast this is again one more generation VOID in understanding 21 century

when people choose to face the truth, they should be allowed. the people being questioned know the consequences. inspite of that they agreed to do so. there is nothing unethical to make so hell out of it & stop the show.

I agree with Santosh that It would be a right platform for our politicians and why not  bureaucrats too ? 

Everyone should have a choice, those who want to see, can watch, those who don't, just simply use your remote and watch something else, whats so fuss about that.

it is a adult game, played by adult at their own will n wish

The polygraph tests for the show is done beforehand wherein 50 questions are asked & 21 questions are chosen from them for the show. so the participant knows all the possible questions & he also is given ample opportunity to opt out at any point during the show.  Also note that the participant had taken part because he willfully wanted to face the truth & convey the same.    I think it will be right platform to put all the politicians to test hence the apprehension.

Using a term like "fool", for them who do not think as you, is not proper.

You are very much right Sir.

What I feel is that speaking truth in open is very tough, and only few bold can hold it.

The way of writing also has got a influence, that you might not understand the insights, but it is to make a change where normal scipts will fail and wont be able to shake up the person who has almost stopped themselves to accept new things.

Life is always not being so simple and straigjt, sometimes u need some twist or else ur surrounding will not be able to enjoi you in the whole lifetime.

The catching of words also has started from you, when u picked up my earlier conversation and failed to understand the synergy between Ques. and Ans.

Join some further studies with youngsters then you will enjoi more ! hopefully you will get the required updates in you.

Knowing some words is not enough, try to learn where to fit it.

Raturiiii,

The next generation will not understand you and will also not understand anything to respect your ideas, the thing is they are very very very professional, which im pointing out to you only, that ur not a professional one.

The reason behind is, you might be able for domestic markets, but internationally you dont stand anywhere with ur so called professionalism which does not even understands media and go on comparing it with culture.

DRUGS ? Very intresting...Do you know even that ur daily routine intakes also contains one or another chemicals (part of sum drug) from the morning you wake up ending up in ur bed, just try to leave any of ur practices, the answer is NO, you wont be able to , even if you try you will face such situations which will force you to take it as soon as possible.

Tell you something you people are baseless, and even are several issues which we all tried to highlight, you people are still on one line of culture and will end up with that only, biggest thing is that you people will never be able to cope up with the change.

When childrens at ur home is exposed to T.V with cabled channels is also a part of moderated situation out of culture, better have DD1 n DD2 only or even more better go for a RADIO only (fantastic Yes), NO T.V, no star movies, no cartoons, no MTV, FTV, NO V TV...lots of regional channels too showing nudity my frnd...better cut off the cable lines if ur not able to control ur family and childrens....iiii.

COOL GUYS...CHILL PILL...I WOULD SUGGEST THAT PUT UP A LINE BEFORE SHOW....EVEN IT WILL COST ALOT BUT FOR ALL MAD PPL OUT THERE...

CHILDRENS, MEN LIKE WOMENS & WOMEN LIKE MAN ARE REQUESTED NOT TO WATCH THIS SHOW OR IT MAY HURT THEM N MAKE THEM REACT OPPOSITE BEHAVIOR WISE (BASICALLY WHICH IS REUIRED).

JAY HO......riiiiiiiiiii

Firstly,the channel is not calling anyone,people in the greed of money are coming in this event.They know the game and rules very well, still they want to sit on the 'Hot Seat'.......Secondly, if you are so much ashamed of this programme, then remote is in your hand- change the channel.

As far as the leaders are concerned, there are a million of other issues which are of more importance than this. They should have concentrated on those.....most of these hypocrites are ready to watch if a woman sheds her clothes and dances. Censor board gives all the permission to such scenes, includes violence also....Shouldn't that be banned?......Whereas, this show is all about courage of facing and telling the truth, it should not be banned. Those who have problem should avoid themselves and their children to view this programme.

The answer within question was for all the fools who cannot think the media limits and broad concepts...it was given because the concept does not falls at any other point where it cannot make any end, i was here to make a final solution to an end but not to fight and play within words....its something cheapest you did it within a debate..you should first go and learn about etiquettes and culture of debate too.

If you really dare, come up and show ur involvment in removing prostitution..CAN YOU ?

Bloody hell, when persons being in sales will not be able to sell the product then they are not in perfect place , if i will be your boss then today itself i will give you a termination letter.

1st strategy after the product has been produced is supposed to be sold but nothing to discourage...thts hardcore sales... or keep and make a dead stock of it...

My dear friend, tel me few things, can you organize a show, can you think of its investment, can you really come up with legal points of registration to put the show on air, i know the answer will be NO from you so let me tel you, ur just wasting everybody's time and nothing else,

First of all i request everybody, pls put a vote of BAN on this gentleman, he is talking all non-sense.

If you cannot beat the competition then better JOIN it and continue being there.... unless u wil always see urself out of market with ur products...coz of ur attitude...

CHANGE IS GOOD (YE BAN WO BAN ....PEOPLE LIKE YOU ONLY DO SUICIDES...R U AWARE OF IT ? )

No it should not be. This program has made me to realise that although I thought that I am truthful to myself but I was wrong.

But certainly the topics on which the exploration of truth is attempted must be more varied and broad. From the episodes which I saw and also what the excerpts which they show in program's promotions, it seems that sex and related matter are their favourite subject.

i dont think it should be benned bacause of any political party / person.it is about volunteerly taking part of individuals in such programms, no one is forced to take part in it.

i wonder the person taking part in such programm has no issues but everyone else has.

and about the political / social leaders i would like to remind them that there are so many issues to think about in india instead of this.recently one girl has been molested in public in patna  girls are getting raped ,on such issues why this social leaders are not taking any serious actions.

i really want to advise them to do some meaning full work.

it is good to see the participation and our concern on issues like these...i only have to add to what m/s kiran and mandeep has very well said..when inflation reached 12.75 pc there was no uproar in parliament…when our intelligence warns government of possible terrorist attacks like 26^th Nov on Mumbai there is no uproar in parliament..when students are beaten like animals because they come to other states for appearing in competitive exams there is no uproar in parliament…when there is problem of social security and unemployment there is no uproar in parliament…

But when a TV programme like “Sach ka Samna” appears on a channel there happens to be uproar in parliament……

I believe it is high time the government should take up important issues rather than fighting on reality show and the opposition should also raise this issue on behalf of public.