Build your professional network on facebook via our app Go to app
 
 1 of 21 in Topic  Next >>
 
Created by : Nikhil Jain, Senior Consultant, Hewitt Associates  | 05 25 2009 08:33:47 +0000
Industry : Human Resources (HR) ConsultingFunctional Area : Business Policy(Strategy & Execution)
Activity:  606 views;  last activity : 07 06 2010 20:18:09 +0000

These days there is a growing trend of Companies opting for Job Portals for their Internal Hiring in order to reduce costs instead of approaching Placement Consultants. Placement consultants also use Job Portals like naukri.com and monsterindia.com.

Job portals by way of their Huge Database Access and Job Posting Options Offer a seemingly very attractive way to hiring.

Is it the best and cheapest method?

There are so many costs involved in using Job portals for recruitment which makes it much costlier than head hunting. Are job portals cost effective?

 
Share
 
 
  Rate : 
 
 
Yes Vs No
15
 
 
 
 
4
8
2
Support   Support
Top Argument
3
0

I feel that the company should go for job portals because it is beneficial in the long run. It helps organizations by identifying approapriate candidates and at the same time frees up managers’ time so that they can focus on their core business. There are many more advantages like higher level of expertise in identifying candidates, dedicated team to provide fast response time and guaranteed quality of service.


By Nikhil Jain, Senior Consultant, Hewitt Associates  05 25 2009 08:43:17 +0000
 
Top Argument
1
0

As there has been constant changes made in recruitment process to make things more visibly cost effective by different portals BUT there are still a no. of issues which havnt been addressed BE IT on the Clients side or Recruiters for hire.

HOWEVER, there is a new concept [Insane HR] for RECRUITMENTS which has been designed by people who have had experience in both the worlds(CORPORATE & PLACEMENT AGENCIES). The concept has proved to add immense VALUE for Corporate HR as well as Placement Agencies keeping the objective SIMPLE, COST EFFECTIVE & EXCEPTIONALLY LOW TURN AROUND TIME.

to learn more visit our website www.insanehr.com

or call us at 0120 3122331 for a DEMO


By Soheb irfan, Business Manager, Insane HR  11 18 2009 09:51:26 +0000
1
0

I strongly agree with Web 2.0 recruitment.Most of the companies, especially all IT companies, have started recruiting through social media networks and blogs. Earlier we had blogged about social media sites being a threat to job portals. This is a very good trend coming up as recruiters get a chance to make a background check of the person they are recruiting. Websites like Orkut, Facebook and other social media websites are the new haunting places for HR Teams these days to scout for talent that can deliver very good results.
Social media sites are places where professionals are looking forward to build relationships with other professionals. There are many communities on both facebook and orkut which professionals join in order to increase their knowledge of their respective fields. Many professionals exchange a lot of crucial notes on these communities which helps them build a reputation of their own. This certainly leads to recruiting from these social networking sites.
There are even specialized professional networks like
LinkedIn , ERE and Ryze which cater to the needs of professionals only. These professionals mainly register these sites in order to already keep in touch with past as well as present colleagues. Thus, this is clearly an opportunity for HR agencies and HR teams to collect relevant data, reputation and other crucial data relating to the prospect in question through contacting the colleagues connected to the prospect on the site.
Nowadays, even senior professionals are catching up fast on the blogging scene and writing content that develops a rapport with a lot of visitors. These senior professionals write on blogs to develop a reputation for themselves and establish themselves as experts in their respective areas of work. This way they are attracting companies to recruit them by initiating them to read the quality of content that is put up on their blog.


By Parul , Client Servicing/Key Account Manager, Lancesoft India Pvt Ltd.  | 02 01 2010 16:48:18 +0000
0
0

i completely agree to u n i think if one is a recruiter ,he can very well understand this.

in hiring process challenges are w.r.t. time. n web 2.0 cannot take this challenge in its early stage bcoz one cannot ignore privacy terms on such portals.

just to add this something new by combining job portals n network site , may b more precise .


By dilip gour, OWNER, GOUR TECHNOLOGIES  | 01 28 2010 11:39:13 +0000
2
0
Todd Raphael in his post 3 Good Things About Hiring via Social Media highlights the advantages of social media recruitment:
  • The company’s more prepared, and can conduct better interviews and be better at selection. If every interviewer, from recruiter to manager to senior management (if they’re involved), has read the candidate’s blog, viewed his/her videos, or perused their Tweets, they’re better prepared going in.

  • The candidate’s more prepared. If the candidate has read about a company on Glassdoor.com, connected with current employees on LinkedIn, looked at what company employees are saying on Facebook, kept up with a company blog, and so on, they know more than they would by looking at company marketing-speak. They can decide themselves that they do or don’t fit.

  • Onboarding. No more nervously asking random people, “tell me where the bathroom is again?” Life’s easier on the new employee because they know a lot of people on Day 1 — or at least recognize them from their Twitter photos.



By Viktor Stephen, COO, I Entrepreneur  | 07 02 2009 11:54:25 +0000
3
0

Nikhil using Web 2.0 facilities for recruitment is not a new concept in west but for this neglecting Job Portals & Staffing consultants can harm recruitment procedure. Even the recruitment firms are also using this platform but response time is too low there are lots of pros & cons of web 2.0 communities.

you cant be solely dependent on this. jobs portals can give you rich database via which you can search them and contact them immediately but you cant do this in web 2.0 communities bcos 90% users hide their contact info for strangers.

Neglecting Staffing consultants over web2.0 and job portals can more harm the recruitment procedure bcos they dont have only readymade rich database, job portal access but also apart from that they have very good social contacts in market for diferent fields via which they recruit their 40% staffing and expertise in head hunting which you cant get from web2.0 and job portals also.


By a , a  | 07 02 2009 11:49:39 +0000
2
0

I feel that Direct Hiring through internal referals, Job Portals, Recruitment Agency services and Manpower outsourcing services will all co-exist in the market place.

Companies will use one or any combination of these depending on the Kind of Positions required, Urgency, availability of their own resources for hiring process etc. All these services satisfy a different need.

Job poratals give you access to large database. You still have to pick up the right candidate like picking up needle from hay stack simply because the search technologies used by them are no way near to Human Brain reading a CV. That is why Recruitment Consultants are in business who knows what fits where & where to find them.

Manpower Outsourcing satisfies a different need of companies. For a very specific One Time Job employees are outsourced from an outsourcing agency for few months to one year. Or simply to avoid legal problems they want to keep their head count low. Some do it for cost reduction, some do it for focussing on their core business activity. Some companies can not access highly specialized manpower because it may be unavailable or available at a very high cost & companies don't want to hire them on permanent basis, so they out source.

So don't worry. They will co-exist.

As the advent of TV did not wipe out Cinemas or CAS / DTH could not finish Cable TV or Mobile Phones could not kill landlines. Similarly none of the services will go away. Only Market share will change.

References :

By Purshottam Jagiasi, Head/VP/GM-Marketing, Aarvi Encon Pvt. Ltd.  | 07 01 2009 10:42:32 +0000
1
0

I am in favour of what Nikhil has suggested. The quality of HR recruitments has deteriorated over the last few years and this does have a great impact on the quality of the employees and their performance. It will be better to use the web portals available to screen and select good candidates.


By Ramakrishnan Chandrasekharan, Asst Vice President, RBS Business Services  | 05 26 2009 18:33:17 +0000
3
0

companies should out source recruitment to portals.

admin officials of the portals , while sitting on the other side of the screens have a bird eye view of the participants of the discussion boards as they are unbiased.

they will make a  psychographic profile of the prospective job seeker and eventually place him in a best fit situation suited both to the company and the job seeker


By Ajay Ziz, Dy. Registrar,, University of Jammu  | 05 26 2009 10:52:28 +0000
1
0

I would keep web 2.0 as an option for hiring people at lower levels of management.

For senior, more responsible positiions I would trust the good old method. I have always beliebedin the fact that what you may analyse of a person in person is far more better in quality and judgement than on web. For starters on the web you have no idea of the true identity of any person. You maybe a good bathroom singer but in front of an audience is your tune carrying the right notes??? I may enhance my voice on a voice chat on the net but maynot carry a barritone in person... well such a bummer isnt it?? I may exude super confidence while typing furiously on a keyboard as I am my own boss that time, but under watchful, bespectacled and stuffed shirts sitting in a room with no music or familiarity where would that confidence go???/

Well I still believe in person interview rather than web 2.0!! Thanks gentlemen! :))


By Makrand Bhave, Marketing & MICE, WIZCRAFT International  | 07 02 2009 12:31:45 +0000
Leading Recruitment Firm
Leading Recruitment Firm
Viewers also viewed
I want to know that if I am a company which can take help of any one job portal due to financial...
 
3 referals 32 votes, 10159 views
Job sites provide the most easiest way to go job hunting. These sites make the task more simpler...
 
1117 referals 10 votes, 565 views
In today's organizational recruitment, most of the organizations go for external recruitments...
 
1032 referals 52 arguments, 1126 views
more...  
Recent Knowledge (68)
PM comes and declares few things and goes. He is not in regular touch and updating people about...
 
1900 referals 31 arguments, 231 views
Parents lay too much emphasis on the children securing high marks in the examinations at cost of...
 
27 referals 6 arguments, 67 views
When thought process is ticking as the time goes,  every inhabitants start looking at thing that...
 
51 referals 11 arguments, 132 views
more...  
More From Author
Kerela IT firms are hunting hackers .. recruiting them in their companies...This is  unique way of finding the talent because formal degree does not matter here and what you get is the best people. But what about safety factor.. Is your comany...
Reservations are always in govt orgs.. and the drop outs do not open them.. do they? Managers having poor marks has nothing to do here becasue either they have establlished the platform or they have enough experience and to add to this let me tell you...
Business schools were meant to be guides and they don't create a perfect person, they give raw mind a direction.
more...