Should Autonomy be given for Jammu and Kashmir?

i am no moslem . brother .so out of my grasp..this rocket science .

The only solution of the Kashmir problem to get the area illegally occupied by Pakistan re-occupied and be merged as a State within Indian territory. When Kashmiris shall become in more strength then taking the benefit of democracy they may permanently rule Kashmir and this problem shall be solved for ever. Kashmir was part of Bharat, is of Bharat and shall remain as an integral part and no force of the world can change this settled issue.

i value ur bubblingly thoughts ..immensely ...capturing & deceptively "" engaging "

but brother here the ""roman coin has king lui xxx on both sides ""

MY dear Brother Ajay (jay is win, ajay is beyond win) StALIN (a communist rushian name) ZIZji, you have not got what i was pointing to; when somebody extends a coin towards you and you turn your head to look only at the heads knowing that the tails too exist BUT declare that ONLY heads exist because you see only HEADs; IT is such ATTITUDE AND LINE OF thinking THINKING that was being pointed to (NOT the actual deaths taking place). THAT THINKING that I AM NOT FREE, I am BOUND by,,,india,,, is very same to a man thinking of suicide, getting drunk, smoking cigarette.... THE FREE THOUGHT PROCESS is what is being pointed to. I am busy at work now so cannot type long detailed messages  but cryptic short bursts of THOUGHTS. pramodkaimal@gmail.com / yahoo.co.in could be used for.....CHAT? i am surrendered (in ARABIC ISLAM) to in the ABSOLUTE (in Arabic ALLAH, in Sanskrit BRAHMAN) PRANAM (salutation... MaSalama) bye Namaste (Greeting ISALAM Valiakum in Arabic, Good day in English)

Again dear brother Brother Ajay Stalin Ziz, Dy. Registrar,, University of Jammu, what has Media report to do with suicidal tendency in Human.Of the two choices available to a Human animal (Suicidal and Laughter) asking for separate selfish for oneself (state or autonomy) is suicidal and joining together and enjoy given life is cheerful. You make your free will choice just as a cigarette smoker drunkard makes a choice same way as a good fruit eater makes one. Cigarette smoking in Injurious to health Universally to both the smoker and around; lets joint together and take live happily together. do read my previous observations too please

Brother Ajay Stalin Ziz, Dy. Registrar,, University of Jammu suicide is psychiatric any where and no sane HUMAN will support it; though among animals human alone can think and feel suicidal; laughter is also unique to Humans. Chose to be chearful my brother not suicidal. Peace be to you

Are not Human (Genes) related to land of Birth, especially the individual characteristics.Bharatiya Subcontinent has its specific characteristic that is distinct. Because some human can think suicide doesn't mean all agree to it and allow. They asking for separate identity need to be treated psychiatric-ally

.

Jammu & Kashmir is the land of Vedas and Kalhan. Merely change of religion by maximum sons of land is not change to forefathers and so sons of land of J & K cannot be permitted to demand separate land than of their forefathers so the recommendation of justice is entirely against history and geography.

ONE WHO CLINGS ON TO A THORNY TREE AND CLAIM THAT THE TREE IS HOLDING THE PERSON (man or woman) is pretending; You can awaken a sleeping human but not a human hypocrit pretending to sleep. If you imposter children of mother Bharath pretend not to be free as we are in free Bharath GO TO MAD HOUSE ARABIA TO FEEL FREE. YOU ARE right it is not muslim or hindu KASHMIRI BUT.. look deepter ANd NOTE THE arabic cultured so called 'MUSLIMS' who are BAYING FOR MOTHER BHARATH'S POUND OF FLESH AND BLOOD

Promise? to scoundrells thieves thugs killers; as Jinhaits were BUTCHERING HINDUS. scoundrels threatenning that if BOOTY IS NOT HANDED OVER, THEY(ARABIC THUGRY CULTURED IMPOTER CHILDREN0 WILL GO ON KILLING MOTHER BHARATHS TRUE CHILDREN. GO GO TO YOUR ARABIC ROOTS MR WASIM MUSTAQ AND PRAY 5 TIMES, AS TRUE CHILDREN MEDITATE AT EVERY BREATH MOMENT IN TRUE BHARATH

Remember the Parable of judge ordering a child to be halved between two quarelling women as what this MUSLIM arabic cultured judge has decreed as what an arabic culture had Christ crucified. a child or "mother cannot be halved to a true child", so MOTHER BHARATH CANNOT BE CUT, the imposter child can go to its Arabic roots by all means and Arabia is just well spaced area for all rootless Arabic cultured whether KASHMIRI OR PALASTINIAN TO BE WELL ACCOMODATED but may be as second or third class citizens.peace be to them

Bhutan has never been a part of India and Kashmir cannot be equatted with it. Kashmir is an integral part of Bharat and shall remain till this erth remains.

It is very dangerous recommendation of Justice Sagir Ahmad Committee to provide "maximum autonomy" to J & K. Kashmir is an integral part of Bharat without which the existance of Bharat cannot be thought of. Article 370 should be abolished at once so that J & K may also become as one of normal states of Bharat.

Pakistan tried to impose a military solution on J&K yet again in 1965, by instigating a war against India. The people of J&K resisted this new invasion.  Pakistan's failure to impose this military solution and the efforts of the people of J&K to thwart the aims and designs of the Pakistani invaders are well documented. 

In a diverse country like India, disaffection and discontent are not uncommon.  Indian democracy has the necessary resilience to accommodate genuine grievances within the framework of our sovereignty, unity and integrity. Government of India has expressed its willingness to accommodate the legitimate political demands of the people of the state of J&K.  However, Pakistan sponsored terrorists have terrorised the population and hindered political dialogue by intimidating or silencing voices of moderation that wish to engage in dialogue. The human rights of the people of J&K have been systematically violated by such terror tactics and the kidnappings and killings of innocent people by terrorists. 

The abve information is collected information.

The reason for sharing the same with all is simple. If India leaves kashmir, Kashmir will be doomed and will be taken over by pakistan. Its because of the fear of their invasion that kashmir come to India.

Kashmir is part of INDIA and will remain so, forever.

Regards

Kiran

Dear all

After rumours that the Maharaja was for the union with India, Muslim revolutionaries from western Kashmir and Pakistani tribesmen made rapid advances into the Baramulla sector. Maharaja Hari Singh of Kashmir asked the government of India to intervene, However, India and Pakistan had signed an agreement of non-intervention (maintenance of the status quo in Jammu and Kashmir.) Although tribal fighters from Pakistan had entered Jammu and Kashmir, there was no iron-clad legal evidence to unequivocally prove that Pakistan was officially involved. It would have been illegal for India to unilaterally intervene in an open, official capacity unless Jammu and Kashmir officially joined the Union of India, at which point it would be possible to send in its forces and occupy the remaining parts.

The Maharaja desperately needed military assistance when the Pathan tribals reached the outskirts of Srinagar. Before their arrival into Srinagar, India argued that Maharaja Hari Singh must complete negotiations for acceding Jammu and Kashmir to India in exchange for receiving military aid. The agreement which ceded Jammu and Kashmir to India was signed by the Maharaja and Lord Mountbatten of Burma.

The Accession of the state of Jammu and Kashmir to India, signed by the Maharaja (erstwhile ruler of the State) on 26^th October, 1947, was completely valid in terms of the Government of India Act (1935), Indian Independence Act (1947) and international law and was total and irrevocable.  The Accession was also supported by the largest political party in the state, the National Conference.  In the Indian Independence Act, there was no provision for any conditional accession.  The Instrument of Accession executed by the Maharaja was the same as the ones executed by over 500 princely states in India.  There has been no complication in any of the other cases.  There would have been none in this case either, except for Pakistan's action in sending in tribal invaders first (in October 1947) and its own regular troops later (May 1948).

India made a reference to the United Nations on 1^st January 1948 under Article 35 of the Charter, which permits any member state to bring any situation, whose continuance is likely to endanger international peace and security, to the attention of the Security Council.  The intention behind this reference was to prevent a war between the two newly independent countries, which would have become increasingly likely if the tribal invaders assisted first indirectly and then actively by the Pakistan army had persisted with their actions against India in Kashmir.  The Government of India requested the Security Council "to put an end immediately to the giving of such assistance which was an act of aggression against India”.  

Autonomy should be felt within, HUMAN ARE BORN FREE. If crooked half baked muslims imagine that they have caught a tree the tree and the TREE is not leaving them, and because the imaginary tree is thorny their holding the tree tighter makes the TREE hold them tighter and more painful; unless the Senseless people claiming themselves to be following ISLAM (Absolute Surrender) so are Muslims; drop their IMAGINATION of being CAPTIVE nothing on this EARTH Can satisfy them. You can awaken a man who is asleep but not a man who is pretending to be asleep.Just be INDIFFERENT evolution will wake them.

There is no point giving autonomy to J&K. All efforts should be made and all steps should be taken to merge the state completely into main stream.

How can we give them autonomy? Already that state is creating so much problems in spite of being ruled by the central government. Giving them autonomy would mean creation of more problems. They will pay taxes to their state government and that only will run the state. Moreover the "Pundit"  problems will increase since the religious fanatics will get more power to torture them. Kashmir government is not eligible enough to deal with terrorism, will we give them autonomy in that too? If not, then why should we take tax for that and what kind of state it will be which won't be in contact with the capital? In that case, it won't be less than any separate country just taking military support from India and not even paying tax for that...