Mr.Parveen Varma, What I say is that , the Currency transfer need to take into account of factors I mentioned here & accordingly, if a policy required at National, be mooted.
Secret, Prompt payment, Interest to your account, Holiday from the tax from the country , I believe, are driving them to go for it.
By
KALIYAMOORTHY , Oil & Gas Area Coordinator, Undisclosed
| 03 18 2011 09:17:44 +0000
Ya..Swapna, we don't know that what an exact problem is ? I think, whatever it is, it will be solved if every transaction have a verification from RBI first and if needed then others too. After all, Transparency of money transfer is required.
By
Santosh Kr. Gupta, Business Development- International Market,
| 03 18 2011 08:29:23 +0000
Mr. Parveen varma, It is not the tax relief. The secrecy they maintain. Over more than 400 years or so, they maintain this integrity. Moreover, payment without fail & hazel. Will it be possible here? BJP will leak out Congress guys & Congress will come out with BJP?. If you announce a similar facility, all those who are possessing an account there , will without letting you know , transfer the account & maintain it. Encourage people what they do, with similar facility if you want benefit out of it. This capital can be used for home projects. Secret, Prompt payment, Interest to your account, Holiday from the tax from the country , I believe, are driving them to go for it.
By
KALIYAMOORTHY , Oil & Gas Area Coordinator, Undisclosed
| 03 18 2011 08:25:47 +0000
That is exactly the point I am also trying to make Mr. Kaliyamoorthy. The money must not leave this country. Make “Special Banking Zones” SBZs in line with SEZ. Let people invest their money there and no questions will be asked.
1. No account holder names 2. No addresses 3. No nominee names And so on... Only an user ID and Password for the account holders These banks can offer some nominal interest or slightly higher rate of return for the money invested here instead of “No Interest” or “Very Low interest” being offered by Swiss Type Banks. This way, people who have invested in Swiss and other banks around the world would route their funds to banks in these SBZs. At least the country would have funds available to implement more development projects. This system can be implemented only as a tax heaven and not for crime money (mafia or bribe money).
By
G A Narayan, VP - Marketing, KE Housing P. Ltd.
| 03 18 2011 07:03:40 +0000
Mr. Parveen Varma, Ordinary citizen knows there is plenty of illegal transaction exists on earth (India is no exception). Kuruvi / Hawalaa / Hundi are the numerous names available for transfer. The guy doing it, gets commission for it. Its' his survival. But, the question is why do you give scope for such illegal transfer?. Why do not you save it in your own country, if you provide them ,secrecy/tax haven?. Black money will get out of India it will be banked here. And the investment goes to India's prosperity. Unclaimed money(after death) also remains here. In Swiz, the unclaimed money is so much they can develop new ventures with it.
By
KALIYAMOORTHY , Oil & Gas Area Coordinator, Undisclosed
| 03 18 2011 06:41:44 +0000
So many guys are throwing the Black money in TRUPATHI Hundi, is there anyone asking anything to it? Swiz bank offers complete protection to its account holder through Law. We feel that its a TAX haven for many. But, if the Govt finds criminal offense on any of the account holder, they will co-operate & produce details as we need. Why do not we have a similar private Bank, governed by Act as TAX HAVEN ?. It can be, in any one of the Union territory say Pondicherry, Goa etc. So, it is basically a policy mater at Govt level. Individuals/ organizations, having potential to amaze wealth, earns money & protect it in safer place. For that, there numerous places in the World. Why do not you offer a similar facility as a Business venture, in India. Are you ready to go for it. Otherwise, what we are shouting is a political gimmick.
By
KALIYAMOORTHY , Oil & Gas Area Coordinator, Undisclosed
| 03 18 2011 05:26:17 +0000
Swapna I think any transaction outside the country should be limited to say Rs. 1.0 lac. Any amount which is parked in any bank particularly in swiss bank the bank must inform Indian Government. some protocol to this effect should be drafted and put to practice.
By
Rathin Deb, Freelance Retail Consultant
| 03 16 2011 04:48:42 +0000
Let Indian Government allow swiss bank type banking to happen in India in specially designated "Special Banking Zones" similar to SEZs. We can have 1 such SBZ for each zone of the country. Instead of no interest or very low interest rate that is prevalent abroad, we can offer marginally higher interest rates. However, the same principle of "no questions asked" baking must be followed. This way, the the outflow of money would be curtailed and the money would remain in India for re-investment in various projects.
By
G A Narayan, VP - Marketing, KE Housing P. Ltd.
| 03 15 2011 12:42:27 +0000
As we all hear about scams, black money and swiss bank money of
Politicians and others too on daily basis. I think that money belongs to
society should be
stay with society but for that transfer policies need some major changes to be introduced like:
Transparency of money transfer..
Support of International banks towards every transaction have a verification from RBI. and more
if all that will happen, I assure you that face of
India even the world will be changed.
By
Santosh Kr. Gupta, Business Development- International Market,
| 03 14 2011 11:25:44 +0000
|
Dear Mr Kaliyamoorthy, It seems you are missing the subject point here. I once again say that there is no need to change the currency transfer process however we need to do the changes in Tax Structuring.
By
Praveen varma, Sr Manager, Reliance Industries
| 03 18 2011 08:32:04 +0000
Dear Mr Kaliyamoorthy, Thanks for your post. In fact in your post you have came close to the point i.e. Tax structuring. So there a need to change the Tax structuring not the currency transfer process. Some attempt are being made through direct tax code, but as I have seen the last draft there are lot of changes from the original thought process. I really dont know wheather it will help or not????
By
Praveen varma, Sr Manager, Reliance Industries
| 03 18 2011 06:53:02 +0000
I dont think that there is need to change in current policy. The current policies are very good and can control the transaction. We must understand that the International banks have all the black money and this money is not being transferred through regular network. Like if I want to transfer 100 cr to Swiss bank then I will contact to Hawala dealer in India and will handover money here. The money converted into international currency will be delivered in Switzerland within no time. So WHERE WE HAVE USED THE REGULAR BANK NETWORK. Secondly, if I want to buy equipment worth 50 Cr for my plant. I will ask the supplier to raise the price to 70 Cr and accordingly I will place the purchase order on him. In such case, I will make a payment of Rs 70 Cr to supplier company then the supplier company will deposit 20 Cr in my Swiss account. That way I will transfer the money in my swiss account also will enjoy depreciation benifit by showing higher cost of the equipment. HERE WE USED THE SYSTEMATIC WAY TO TRANSFER THE MONEY AND SAVED TAX TOO. FINALLY SWAPNA, I REALLY LIKED YOUR COOL COMMENT.
By
Praveen varma, Sr Manager, Reliance Industries
| 03 18 2011 06:24:22 +0000
|