Should Modi be dethroned from CM's position in Gujrat?

Thats what you doing Mr. Kashif.Your comments are 100% communal. Let the things get proved. In the mean while people should start think about patrons of, who attacked on Sansad, and who attacked on Mumbai.

no

If Mr Modi does not resign of his own, to create high example in to-day's politics, there is no law that he may be removed until a guilt is proved. It is the voters of Gujrat to decide when next election comes.

No, Modi Bhai should not leave the Post. This is just a planned activities by those who has nothing to do with Progress and Imotions of Indians.

I am apprecate with Mr. Phanindra

if modi have to be removed from CM chair, then every congress leader has no right to stay in power! courtesy what happened to sikhs 25yrs back. Modi came for interrogation ask the congress leaders to do the same? they cant even in their dreams. its a shame that a sardar is congress's PM candidate.

Why single out Modi, there is genocide in Kashmir, many Kashmiri Hindus were murdered and their houses burnt, hindu women raped and killed, was the govt then moved out of power.

Let there be aholistic view and not a view of Modi alone 

There is currently no evidence that Mr Modi was involved. Hence, there is no need for him to resign. Did anyone from congress resign after the anti Sikh riots ?? The media eats out of the hands of congress and has a dislike for Mr Modi, hence one would see more coverage when he is accused. A fraction of that does not happen when the Anti Sikh riots eyewitnesses accuse Jagdish Tytler and Sajjan Kumar.

Mr. Jay Makwana

Thanks for your strong statement for supporting to Modi , Really Narendra Modi Have done lots of things to developed Gujarat & leading Gujarat in International position

No.

We should follow the norms of law and justice. Until evidence is found that proves Modi had a hand in the riots following the Godhra incident , till then he should be presumed innocent.

Added to this is the fact that he has been a good chief minister for the state.

Normally , people in power are supposed to step down till the investigation into a case is over , because otherwise , they may prevent the investigating team from carrying on their investigation fairly. Here , that is not the case. Hence Modi need not step down.

Narendra Modi is a gr8 leader who is working for Gujarat and it's people without any personal interest,

His ideas are Innovative...which other state in India has thought of building RIVER FRONT project ? - Sabarmati Riverfront project in Ahmedabad has been started with prime objective of environmental improvement and provision of housing for the poor who living in life threatening conditions along river bed. More details on below link -

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sabarmati_Riverfront_Development_Project

The work in progress is amazing and in 2 years the city will have a different look...

Best development is 3 lane roads in all over Gujarat ...Infrastructure is one thing that has improved by miles...

3 cheers to MODI!

Godhara is just another such incident inflaming communal tensions and the state government has to be questioned, involvement or not. When we are still to touch Sajjan Kumar, HKL Bhagat, Mulayam, Laloo, Mayawati and likes so far with their involvement almost proven in their acts at certain stage of their political career, why are we targetting Narendra Modi? Not that I'm a BJP / Modi supporter but I'm almos sure that's the way things happen here. It shall take decades for SIT to complete the report, and by the time that happens another committee shall be formed and so on.

To sum aforesaid. If GUJRATIS are willing to put faith in him and to have him as state CM, what possibly can SC / SIT / other parties do? Dethrone him - NO WAY!!!

I do not wish to comment on whether Narendra Modi was responsible or not for the riots.

What I wish to say is that if he is in power, that is by the choice of the people of Gujarat.

Who are we to decide on what wrongs others have committed ?

We need to look within ourselves and see.

Whether it is Mayavati or Lalu,  Jayalalitha or  Modi : they have got whatever they have, by their karma (destiny).

Why should we be envious ?

Most of the persons who rise to power in this world do so by seemingly immoral means. Nobody who is  pure can ever gain power in the world.

That is the way this world is designed. We should see the brighter side of the people and things.

Modi is definitely a greater leader than many leaders who are central ministers. 

Instead of becoming sentimental : let us accept Modi just as we tolerated Indira Gandhi despite her support for Sikh fundamentalism (which finally claimed her life).

We also accepted and adore a  Nehru who pushed India's defense to the rock bottom.

We have roads in the national capital that are named such tyrant Kings as Aurangazeb.

So let us tolerate Modi at least for his developmental work.

I dont mind you rating me thumbs down but my argument is not at all favouring anyone its a very diplomatic argument tha we should not grow hatred among each other. I would request Mr . Himanshu Pathak to kindly close or ban this argument as soon as possible. Guys lets focus on the progress and not what u left in past. Its the sign of poor vision we are having for our future. And this medium of toostep is for awareness and spreading of healthy and intellectual knowledge and not the one for spreading hatred.

all muslims on toostep, First apne zako apne kya kiya hai , Riots hua wo pahale muslimone chalau kiya to uska jawab hinduo ko dena hi padega ,1990 bpmbblast was done by local people and Abu azami also invoved they are now free b'coz of congress leader and for vote bank ,  then that so many should resigne for bomb blast at that time you have not think about inocent people who are killed by muslims

u just say this..bcz in 2002  hindu killed muslims..and u dont able to digest this....

its modi bcz of whom gujarat is growing supebly....

modi ne gujarat ko jannat bana diya.............. 2002 jaruri tha..ab vaha shanti hai....

Let the legal system follow its path, and till proven guilty, maintain a status quo.

Some of Muslims &  congress blaming to Narendra Modi

I think this debate is rather getting communal then being a fair debate. If you can see the 2 people who wants him to get dethroned in this debate are saying due to communal hatred and others defeneding them on the other side is because they favour that community so in all I think this debate should be stopped right now so that we dont spread communal hatred on this intellectual platform of toostep.

Absolutely no Because Narendra Modi was one of the best chief minister in India ,he leads Gujarat to new Horizon ,His dream was no one educated Gujarati go out of GUJARAT for job or earning,, NOW in future most of business or some big industrilist buid there comapies in Gujarat , Mukesh Ambani going to shift all his bisiness to Gujarat , like Tata other automobile companies also shifting there industry to Gujarat, Maharashtra state needs chief minister like Modi , B'COZ ministers of Maharashtra govt. are money makers ,they are not thinking about peoples , the Sharad Pawar is the example of  taht minister 

Ok ,Narender Modi did not burn the innocent pilgrims at Godhra.

So blaming a true nationalist like Narender Modi for the Godhra incident is none of anybody`s business.     He is also an able administrator and prudent in giving the right Medicine where required(unlike some of the Nicer Gentlemen who cannot even defend the country by punishing those who attack the Indian Parliament for fear of losing Votes).                                                                                                                                     That he is magnet for development and industry is acknowledged by even those who despise him(like u Mr Pathak...nice topic u selected!).Last but not the least he is untouched by corruption,double standards,    or the kind of person who will tolerate any kind of Nonsense.India needs a person like him to be the Prime Minister.Jai Bharat.

Narendra Modi has only one bad habit- His communal feelings. Other than this, he is a good chief minister in every manner. He did all possible things to develop Gujrat. Gujrat's development is a clear cut proof of this. So, I don't think only for one reason he should be dethroned from CM's position.