Water cooled Chillers Vs Air cooled Chillers

Posted in Community :

Project Management ++

	Water cooled Chillers Vs Air cooled Chillers Created by : Bandi Kanna, Sr. Vice President- Facilities & Administration, Essar AEGIS \| 1 year ago Industry : ConstructionFunctional Area : Infrastructure(Technology) Keywords : Air Water Chillers Cooled Activity: 10 referals 955 views; last activity : 1 day ago In the present day Real Estate desizn , what could be factors to go for either a water cooled chilling system or Air cooled chilling system	Refer

Rate :

Water cooled chillers

Air cooled Chillers

Support

Top Argument

I still feel that for bigger requirement , water cooled are best options but for small area is still Air Cooled options are best.....
By Shakti Singh Chauhan, Head-Real Estate & Facilities Mgmt( South Asia )Orange ( France Telecom Group) 1 year ago

Support | Oppose

Top Argument

Everyone prefers to be cool in cool environment. Water cooled chillers are better because of the cooling which they provide at a lesser cost & power consumption also as compared to ACs . But do remember that they are few cities which contain beaches in surrounding and thos places an water coller chiller is never sufficient. Even in gulf places like dubai, muscat the heat is so much that even in bathrooms and kitchens you find ACs because one cannot stay there without that. Lots of new technoligies being adopted and nowadys ACs are coming at ECONOMICAL way both by money and energy consumption. As per your comfort and requirements please adopt anyone but even think of green building concepts also.

By C Nijagunaradhya, M.E/M.Tech/MS student, Osmania University College Of Engineering, Hyderabad 7 months ago

Support | Oppose

Arguments in: "Water cooled Chillers Vs Air cooled Chillers"


Sort by : Most Recent Top Rated
0 0 For bigger capacity of HVAC load , i feel Water Cooled chillers are always benificial from energy saving point of view . Initial investment will be higher but ROI will be @ 7-8 years of operation of plant. For the plants upto 300 TR of total load , air cooled chillers are prefered. By KAMLESH HARHARE, MEP CONSULTANT, ARCHGROUP CONSULTANT \| 5 months ago Edit \| Delete Support \| Oppose 0 0 For higher temperature water cooled is more effective then air cooled. By attar singh, Dy.G M, Adani Power Maharastra Ltd.(adani group) \| 1 year ago Edit \| Delete Support \| Oppose 0 0 For larger proccss unit Water cooled chillers are essential like centralised air condition system of a mall or office building.But in smaller units ,air coolled chillers can be used. So it totally depends on the reqirements. By Abhishek Mojumder, PGPM(Project Management) student., National Institute Of Construction Management and Research \| 1 year ago Edit \| Delete Support \| Oppose 1 0 I, agree with Mr Ashok and Mr,Bundi,but still my view is that of the worst case the water chillers have the edge. By srinivasalu. chintamani, Dy.General Manager(projects),Sunil Mantri Realty Ltd., \| 1 year ago Edit \| Delete Support \| Oppose 2 0 Factors favouring water cooled chillers: For heavy to medium loads. Greater efficiency. Though air cooled chillers are available with matching efficiency but they need huge space and large amount of heat is generated. By Ashok Datta, Director Projects, ProInteractive Services (India) Pvt Ltd \| 1 year ago Edit \| Delete Support \| Oppose 1 0 Efficiency is a strong favour on the side of water chillers as large units bleed a lot to heat losses anyway... By ajay pandey, Head/VP/GM-Corporate Planning/Strategy, Simco Foundation \| 1 year ago Edit \| Delete Support \| Oppose 1 0 present day to day requirement is concerned for centralised air condition system irrespective of the cost factors and disadvantages posed by water chillers ,I fully go with that system only. By srinivasalu. chintamani, Dy.General Manager(projects),Sunil Mantri Realty Ltd., \| 1 year ago Edit \| Delete Support \| Oppose 1 0 With what ever disadvantages Water cooled chiller systems have, I am for it as it delivers the required temperature at the user end. Now I would throw the discussion to the respectable forum to air their arguements. By Bandi Kanna, Sr. Vice President- Facilities & Administration, Essar AEGIS \| 1 year ago Edit \| Delete Support \| Oppose	0 0 as ambient temprature is increasing every day,and %R.H is also increasing its better to go with aircooled chiller, By shakir akhtar hussain, Mechanical Engineer-HVAC, Arch Group int \| 5 months ago Edit \| Delete Support \| Oppose 0 0 I agree with Bandi and Ashok. By Mallikarjuna Gupta Bhogavalli, Sr. Product Manager, Oracle India Pvt Ltd \| 1 year ago Edit \| Delete Support \| Oppose 2 0 Chiller plants upto 800 KWr in capacity and operating for less than 2000 hrs per year, it is advisable to go in for Air cooled Chiller systems. The desirable transition point form Air cooled to water cooled starts at aout 400 KWr for plants operation for more than 8000hrs per year or approximately 900 KWr and below 2000hrs of operation. The ecomonic cross over point has an imprecise range which warrants project specific LCC ( life cycle costing) analyis representing particular site conditions. By Bandi Kanna, Sr. Vice President- Facilities & Administration, Essar AEGIS \| 1 year ago Edit \| Delete Support \| Oppose 2 0 Following factors favour Air cooled chillers Suitable for smaller loads. When the conditions to be achieved are not very severe. In cold climates where water will freeze. Saves electricity since cooling tower and condenser are avoided. By Ashok Datta, Director Projects, ProInteractive Services (India) Pvt Ltd \| 1 year ago Edit \| Delete Support \| Oppose
Argue for "Water cooled chillers"	Argue for "Air cooled Chillers"
Prev1NextShowing 1 - 8 of 9

Found the debate "Water cooled Chillers Vs Air cooled Chillers" interesting ? Suggest to your connections and communities

Oracle DBA , Mphasis, Pune

SQL Server DBA, Mphasis, Pune

Viewers also viewed

	Will the global economic downturn cool commodity prices down ?
	What do you think ?
	0 referals 5 arguments, 129 views

	The cool new route to mobilise employees
	My Union is the name of a new application launched on Facebook by the Trades Union Congress...
	0 referals 2 comments, 88 views

	Astec re Ply systems - Cool roofing
	Astec Re-Ply Systems easily meet and surpass the standards and requirements of a Cool Roof...
	1 referals 0 comments, 73 views

how to measure the efficiency of cooling tower?

GLOBAL COOLING 10 BnT-Yr

What are the problems with India's water supply system?

more...

Recent Knowledge (144)

	Will Mumbai Lose its Status asa Financial Capital Of India
	With events in last many years has shown that Mumbai has done little to maintain its status a...
	346 referals 8 arguments, 78 views

	Should we give more importance to higher education than sound experience of cadidate in technical field ?
	Presently tremendous infrastructures developments going on every where in all types industry and...
	9 referals 4 arguments, 22 views

	Should there be more deduction in housing loans?
	In the economic slowdown process, one of the worst hit sectors has been the construction/realty...
	233 referals 6 arguments, 46 views

Legalising illigal Constructions - Should we do it or not?

Is India having medical infrastructure capacity shortage or it's expertise brain-drain

Will renovation always increase the resale value of a house?

more...

Full name*:
Email address*:
New password*:
	Sign Up or Log In
By clicking 'Sign Up' above you are agreeing to the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy of TooStep

Project Management ++

comparison of air colled chiller and water cooled chiller

air cooled / water cooled chiller comparison

Shakti Singh Chauhan, Head, Real Estate & Facilities Management India & South Asia, Equant Solutions

disadvantages of water cooled chillers

Comparison air-cooled and water cooled screw chiller plant

disadvantages of air cooled chillers

air vs water cool chiller

water cooled chiller versus air cooled chiller

"Ajay Pandey" realtor bangalore india

what is a disadvantage of air/water chillers