WHICH ONE INDUSTRY IS BEST EITHER PRIVATE SECTOR OR GOVT. SECTOR REGARDING WORKING CONDITON ??

Government job is a shelter in rainy as shiny days.  Efficiency should be promoted.  When the whole world crumbling under recession, VI Pay Commission redressed Central Govt Employees financial standing.  After what country has done for you, it is our turn to see that what we can do to our country. 

However, good management is all that an employee wants to make himself feel good.  If that is not provided, Government sector is the best.  If not, it is not so a bad place to stay.

On the other hand, management is not good in private sector, it is a bad place to stay that too when no other place is found to take shelter.

hi reena thanks for participating in this topic. i m not totally agree with ur statement although i can understand that in the present senario mostly youths of india going to private sector but if this will happened continusoly than what will happen our country growth by which india can make developed country.

so as per my view youth should go also in govt. sector by which effort of our youth our vision of making developed country will be possible till 2020.

otherwise there will be create problem to us because without growth of gov sector growth of our inia can not be possible...........

thanks

job as a son in law in father in law ( union of india) 's company ...

aaraam haraam nahin hai ( pandit nehru enjoyed and relaxed in his life and taught others to work )

so yeh aaraam ka mamala hai .. jenaab ..

i prefer for a govt job because we have many benefits compare to private sector i am not saying private sector is not suitable for youth but from view of benefit and comfortable side it is govt for which we prefer .........as private ppl exploits/make a individual to work a lot and try to get more from ones

Both the sectors are having their own benefits , i do prefer govt. job if you ask me.. in terms of  Job security...

Govt. sector is more secured.

can't say any thing both are good in their own way

govt job is more safe in all respect

private job is also safe in few points

govt job is safe till the end of the life but not the private job

according to my view and thinking i go with the private job only  

yeh araam ka mamla hai

Hi Manveer ,

I would like to give my opinion , after the following clarifications :

1.  You have given several attributes , which makes it difficult to come to a decision. The government sector may be good if you consider one attribute , while the private sector may be good if you consider another attribute. You will have to decide which attribute has a greater weightage.

2.  You have heard of the Navratnas ; the first thing about individual growth is that it is difficult if the company that you are working in is a sick company or a company which does not have enough funds to implement ideas or expansion plans. If a concern has access to enough funds , it can dream big , and employees can also participate in these dreams. Nowadays , there are quite a few government sector companies which are not only doing well financially , but have also embraced various quality initiatives. Thus the earlier impression that government sector industries were slow moving behemoths is no longer true.

3.  Secondly , it is a fact that the government can afford to spend money on a much grander scale than private sector companies , with a few exceptions like the Tatas , Birlas , Ambanis ... To that extent , joining a government company will give you access to more sophisticated know-how , equipment and so on.

4.  Thirdly , it is a fact that the government sector still has a tradition of employees remaining for a longer period. Even today , you will find employees who have worked in steel plants for more than 30 years. Very few private companies will have senior management which has been with the company for so long. Again there will be exceptions. This is experience which is invaluable. Freshers would do well to make full use of this available experience.

5.  Lastly , it is a fact that the private sector no longer looks down upon government employed personnel. Thus , you can always make a transition from government sector to the private sector ; making a transition the other way is more difficult , since the government sector rarely takes in employees at the middle levels ; it is either a fresher or a very senior level ( Director or such like ) requirement.

My opinion would be that a government sector industry to start with will be a good learning experience. There is still a lot one can learn from the 'Babus' !.

Nothing better than Govt. Job

TO take into full stride of life, with few moments to think, and few moments to be useful towards one's committments

Nothing other than Govt. Job

TO be precise, nothing better than Govt. Job. Changes you can't make but for sure your presence can be felt. The expected change has to take a long course as it is not a matter of affecting 1+1 but a great lot.

I believe to enjoy the life, time and your career, govt jobs are the best.

The cut throat competition appears good but for the whole lot of life and years it doesn't suits.

Hi,

I would like to place my opinion on the Govt sector why is it not that challenging the private sector on this matter,

1. The job security is assured, hardly I have heard that any body fired for Non- performance, mis-conduct, corruption, etc., (max Suspension for Few months even in serious offences)

2. comfort at work : Limited / No accountability : compare a Private Institution with Public institution or Bank Pvt vs Public.

3. No challenge/Defined Growth plan : Any level of contribution doesn't make big impact, Then why run the race.

4. Mindset : This needs to be changed, the gauge has to be set, Performance to be monitored effectively, then things may change.

As of Now, Govt Sector job : Good, Nothing like it.

Prabhakar

I don't believe that private sectors are best for youth...If we see the competition in public sector then we come to know that there are lots of youth applying for Govt. Jobs...Job security might be the one reason...I don't know the actual reason but as far as my friends are concerned most of them want to go in Govt. sector excluding me...because I think we get more friendly and free environment in private sector...But some of my friends think opposite of it...It might be true... they might like the lazy life...they don't want to do regular work...I am not saying that in Govt. sector employees don't do any work...But this is the mentality of outside world... especially in my friends mind... it should be changed...

I will not say all Indians think like that but most of the Indians think like that...If you see the employee point of view then Gov. Sector is best...

yes i ll go for govt sector coz in govt sector u getting job securirty and more benenifite then pvt sector

SPECIALLY FOR YOUTHS WHICH ONE IS SUITABLE REGARDING WORKING ATMOSPHERE, JOB SECURITY, CAREER GROWTH ETC.

EITHER

GOVERNMENT SECTOR

OR

PRIVATE SECTOR