Build your professional network on facebook via our app Go to app
 
<< Prev  2 of 10 in Topic  Next >>
Associated with other topics :
 
Activity:  961 views;  last activity : 07 18 2010 09:37:48 +0000

Who has more controlling Power over Environmental concerns...???

 
 Refer 1428
Share
 
 
  Rate : 
 
 
Government Vs Individual persons
14
 
 
 
 
41
18
26
Support   Support
Top Argument
2
0

To say only Govt. is responsible or to say only individuals are responsible for pollution control is very wrong.

Everyone right from the common citizen to the Bureaucracy, to the politicians, the industry, trade, the celebrity community and every stake holder of the society are collectively responsible, for this.

And the most shocking part of it all is that most stake holders are not at all aware of the basics of the pollution, emissions, global warming, climate change, fast depleting fossil-fuels and a need for alternative energy sources, et al.  Today's school going kids are better aware of these issues than the adults.


By M. Prabhakar Rao, Author of "Mayhem Of The Miserables!", http://www.smashwords.com/books/view/52075  04 11 2010 13:46:09 +0000
 
Top Argument
5
3

Sampanna amazing debate, but I feel it is the individuals responsibility to reduce pollution and go green. Whatever strategy or rules the government develop it is in our hands to follow it or not. So everyone should realize the importance of going green and should start practicing it.

:)

 


By Mridula Maity, Product Development Manager, Rugel  03 20 2010 07:27:01 +0000
0
0

Dear, More than Government Its Individuals who got to blame for pollution, from implementation of rules to polluters every one is an individual and if every one performs his role then only we can control this menace. Till then even toughest of law and any act of government will be useless


By Anupam Pandey, Asst. Manager/Manager (Technical), Indian Air Force  | 07 18 2010 09:48:43 +0000
0
0

Dear all, No one individual is responsible for pollution control... This can be achieved  by all together. In india people need to educate them self regarding their responsibilities. We should not through ball to each other court i.e. govt v/s citizen. Here govt machineries and people should take their responsibility. Normaly in India most of people do not care about responsibility, they only willing to know about their rights. Govt machineries can utilise media to educate people about responsibilty for pollution control or other actvities. We sould not think about profit from all activities done by us, we must have responsible to our nation. We are getting everything from nation only. Govt machineries and people have to work hand in hand, otherwise it is not possible to control polution.


By Dhan Raj, Section Engineer Electrical commissioning, CCIC  | 04 30 2010 17:23:00 +0000
0
0
i think both of them have equal responsibility in going green but on the pollution front its more a duty on us i think
By Reshmi , Senior Recruiter, Replicon  | 04 30 2010 11:35:37 +0000
0
0

Agree Intent is important yet repeating myself and request you to look for answers:

An individual howsoever well wishing has the least role in effectively tackling this problem.

Let us analyse Why?

1. A company makes a vehicle that does not meet the published specs? 

2. The vehicle goes for servicing to an authorised workshop that is not equipped to check and caliberate to prevent pollution?

3. PUC check centers equipment fails calliberation and efficacy?

4. The Petrol or diesel is adulterated? Spares are duplicate?

The Government through Regulator, Auto Manufacturer, Authorised  Workshop all have much bigger roles in correcting the problem compared to the car owner who at best can ensure timely servicing and is not qualified to correct any of above listed is given to bear the entire responsibility which is basic cause of problem to persist.


By Ravindra Sharma, Managing Consultant, CHEF-India  | 04 19 2010 08:34:47 +0000
0
0
think as u r the first citizen of ur city and think over it. in our country democrocy is there.the rule made by us and break by us. goverment is the system folled by us or we selecte people for it. just start from ourself and i think we get the results.
By jayendra ravindra kumbhar, Assistant Professor, rayat education institute  | 04 17 2010 14:02:28 +0000
0
0

Both Government and citzens  should take reponsibility.


By malladi madhukumar, AGM -MKTG, Andhra Cements Ltd  | 04 15 2010 13:58:51 +0000
0
0

Agree with you Prabhakar Rao,

And for this reason I say the bigger the chunk from pie the bigger the responsibility. If the government fails to provide public transport it has no right to charge congestion fee you will agree.  


By Ravindra Sharma, Managing Consultant, CHEF-India  | 04 12 2010 06:50:56 +0000
1
0
I guess,for the removal of any thing its the responsibility of both the public and the govt as the rules should be stictly followed and the initiation of not cutting trees should be availed by the commom man and for that the electronic media plays a important role.
By Jaspal , BD Manager, Birla Sun Life Financial Services  | 04 12 2010 03:36:14 +0000
0
0

Mridula,

I thought you would change your opinion after reading my detailed analysis.

Would be interesting to hear your thoughts point- wise.


By Ravindra Sharma, Managing Consultant, CHEF-India  | 04 09 2010 08:43:27 +0000
0
0

Dear Sanjay & Javed,

Please read the reason's cited by me earlier in debate and decide how can an individual help except playing his part actively which alone is akin to wishful thinking and not a reality. The bigger the stake the bigger the responsibility is absolute truth when it comes to any adherence to bring any success.


By Ravindra Sharma, Managing Consultant, CHEF-India  | 03 22 2010 17:05:45 +0000
1
0

Government will make some rules which is properly regulated by citizens


By SANJAY ROUT, Project Engineer,OTTET  | 03 22 2010 13:06:29 +0000
0
0

The individual certainly has a big role to play,

But the government has a BIGGER one!... by passing a simple policy and seeing to it that it is applied to meet a sustainable development HELPS A LOT MORE than an entire city individuals going green !

The power being generated from Bagass (sugarcane) has no poilcy as of now... NO subsidee...there are many more problems like these...the watertable depletion by the Coco cola in villages of kerala and Tamil nadu...

Government's role is huge!!.. def the citizens can be made aware, but by changing some basic rules in the country and enforcing them, there can be a lot of change...


By Varun , Ideator  | 03 21 2010 18:18:29 +0000
0
0

Of course, individual plays a part in preventing pollution but major contribution is done by Governmental agencies. Particularly, by introducing stringent measures to arrest pollutant release by Industries. Major source of pollution is by industries. In all forms - in atmosphere, in water & in soil- industries spread pollutants. Govt agencies need to be a strict watch dog when issuing, regulating, distributing permission to function various industries.

I can quote for example, Apple pad put in so many regulatory conditions to seller when it wants to sell anywhere in the world. Unless the conditions are met it will not give the authority to sell.

Similar vein, be it individual or corporate, govt agencies need to scrutinize the liecence while issuing & also operating.


By KALIYAMOORTHY , Oil & Gas Area Coordinator, Undisclosed  | 03 21 2010 18:16:27 +0000
0
0

An individual howsoever well wishing has the least role in effectively tackling this problem.

Let us analyse Why?

1. A company makes a that does not meet the specs? 

2. The vehicle goes for servicing to an authorised workshop that does not have equipment to check and caliberate to prevent pollution?

3. PUC check centers equipment calliberation and efficacy?

4. The Petrol or diesel is adulterated? Spares are duplicate?

The Government through Regulator, Auto Manufacturer, Authorised  Workshop all have much bigger roles in correcting the problem compared to the car owner who at best can ensure timely servicing and is not qualified to correct any of above listed is given to bear the entire responsibility which is basic cause of problem to persist.


By Ravindra Sharma, Managing Consultant, CHEF-India  | 03 20 2010 19:00:05 +0000
1
0

The responsibility lies on both government and the individual persons. The government has to do at the higher level and the individuals has to do at the individual level to control the pollution. If any body stands on a road and ask a car/bike owner regarding the pollution, he says he is not only cause for the pollution. He is right from his perspective, but if all the individuals put together it is a bigger and bigger problem. Towards the government side, they say the pollution control is the individuals responsibility, but how about the pollution caused by the industries. Therefore, it is the responsibility of the both the parties. 


By Kumara Swamy, Project Associate, IIIT-H  | 03 20 2010 07:53:24 +0000
1
0

I feel Govt has to come up with Some Strategies for controlling Pollution and see to it that these get Implemented at Ground levels by Individuals...

It is Obvious that Govt can get it done thru Municpal Corporations and even If Decided Individuals can not help to Disposal of Enviorment polluting materials such as Plastics, Papers which are not Degredable at there own level....

So... I feel If taken steps Properly Govt can reduce pollution instead of Individuals and Industries through Worth Strategies......


By Sampanna Shastry, Deputy Manager- Marketing & Sales, Arani Power Systems Ltd  | 03 20 2010 06:47:04 +0000
0
0

Its collective responsibility.  Every individual should think in broader perspective in terms of environment protection.  Almost in general people are selfish.  They always think that their work is done, they dont think much about the future generation.  we can say this is partially due to avaialbility of resources for ex. Instead of Plastic covers, if the shoppers give paper bags eg.(Ooty) it prevents pollution. Easiest way to avoid is attack the source point.  Similarly occupying the Road by shopkeepers will narrow the road and result in traffic which in turn result in excess fuel consumption, Stress to the person travelling and it result in chain reaction at office or Home. So Govt. should take steps in making the available resources to reach the common people. Good example : if traffic police or CCTV  is available at signal point every passer respect the signal otherwise as per the wish of the driver.

Dharmendra Vietnam


By Dharmendra , Accounts Manager, NIVL, Vietnam  | 07 18 2010 05:27:51 +0000
0
0

Yes Mridula you are right. In India i think people are not follows rules which government sets.There are many examples which tells goverment sets the rule and people breaks it so finally results remains same(Pollution).

So its our first whole and sole responsibity to follow rules and government should take strict action on those guys who breaks the rule.


By Manish Badarkhe, sr. software engineer, L&T infotech ltd  | 04 30 2010 13:26:31 +0000
1
0

Yes. GO GREEN is good. But, it primarily depends on the economy dispersion of the state. Who owns what and who is responsible for what ?

 Adding on April 20th..

Please note : China is a communist country and every decision is taken by the Government which owns it. So, it is the government which is responsible. 


By Sampath Kumar Kannan, Sr. Developer, Aequor Technologies  | 04 20 2010 01:25:13 +0000
0
0

Dear Deepak and Virender,

Should every one be a train driver or pilot or doctor or x y z. the answer is NO.

Similarly when it comes to responsibility each has to carry their respective size of share or slice of responsibility pie. The share in Pie is determined by each one's level of stake, power to intervention and so on so the best of INDIVIDUAL SENSE OF RESPONSIBILITY may not be able to match the might of Government if stacked against. 

So while each one has a role the share of role if clearly defined and better designed can be the only way to expect any results.  Else we shall be left forever talking only....


By Ravindra Sharma, Managing Consultant, CHEF-India  | 04 19 2010 08:32:30 +0000
0
0
if every indian think for non poluting india the thing can possible in days not month or years are requiredand solely it will go indirect presuure on govt to awake or active in this regards,example if we see all apartments and good localit it is only educted people whm has jointly worl for against polution and that citied or areas have very less polution
By virender kumar, REGIONAL BUSINESS MANAGER, CELON LABS LTD  | 04 18 2010 08:48:08 +0000
0
1

Government can only become a facilitator and a regulator but ultimately it is the duty of individuals and specifically i mean fundamental duty to reduce pollution by taking various short term measures and every day life style changes by individuals.We can only expect Government to make stricter laws and norms and enforce it in real sense.


By DEEPAK SHARMA, Assistant Marketing Manager, ABC Montessori  | 04 17 2010 12:15:52 +0000
0
0
if every person decides to behave in a socially correct way by avoiding pollution , we will reach our goal of green planet.
By dinesh kumar sharma, ZONAL SALES MANAGER - NORTH, WOCKHARDT LTD  | 04 15 2010 17:50:42 +0000
0
0
Once in Nepal a friend of mine, seeing my trouble finding a trash can to throw a piece of garbage said to me: "Just throw it away, we are in Nepal." In other words, unless individuals are aware of the problem, a government will have no encouragement to ever do anything about it.
By Davor Virkes, Advisor, Croatian Telecom inc.  | 04 09 2010 10:53:20 +0000
0
0

Yes I think People are more responsible for this. We are innovating technology & lots of things for our easy life but we don't think what will be effect in future.


By Devendra Kumar Gupta, MBA/PGDM student, Centum Learning Centre  | 04 08 2010 13:19:18 +0000
0
0

Sampanna a good debate, I too support Mridula. It is we the individuals are responsible to reduce the pollution. The government should make policies and procedures. Whereas the NGOs and individuals should implement voluntarily such things and also bring a change in the persons whom we know. Today being a world earth day, through the world people have decided to dark from 8.30 to 9.30 pm on a voluntary basis. Such causes should be given more propaganda which saves the earth. I further suggest that we the working class should bring a change in our organizations in switching off equipments like lights, computers, monitors, printers, ACs whenever not required which not only saves the power consumption of the organisation and also saves the earth


By ATMA RAM CHAVALI, MANAGER IT, SBH  | 03 27 2010 16:23:23 +0000
0
1

Obviously the indvidual himself to begin with and forever always whatsoever...conciousness, eticate, thoughtfullness & of course awarness begins at home & hopefully transpired into the outer world thereafter...


By Wayne-Russell Macedo, Procurement & Logistics, Dana Group, Lagos  | 03 27 2010 14:07:56 +0000
0
0

Definitely, it’s our responsibilities to reduce the pollution.

Moreover the government can implement the rule in the morning and we will break it at night or they plan greenery in night till morning we definitely………


By Mohammed Abdul Bari, Network Support Engineer@ETISALAT, Dubai  | 03 23 2010 05:50:50 +0000
0
0

Government will make the rules and people follows but is the government going to take very strict action against them. whatever will be the plan or strategy it wont succeed until and unless we individual takes one step ahead to reduce pollution and save the planet. Yes to go green a support a required but if the feeling doesn't come towards the environment nothing can be done. So we all individual should take the initiative rather then saying "Pehle aap" other the way Mr. Mirza missed the train we ll b on the same place and ultimately nothing will be done for the same. 


By Javed Akhtar, Sr. Executive - Logistics, Keventer Agro Limited  | 03 22 2010 14:14:22 +0000
0
1

An individual's efforts will be having a bigger impact since it is at the individual level that the final use of the earth's resources ends. Nonetheless the govt. has its role to play like those suggested by many of the comments here, and in ways like introducing env-friendly policies like subsidizing power generation thru solar energy, from sugar molasses etc. 

But the contribution of the individual will be the greatest if he/she decides to do so.

The point put forward by Sampana is right in indicating that most people wont be contributing towards avoiding pollution coz of their "I don't care" attitude or simply lack of awareness and thus have to be forced by the government, but as far as the topic goes the bigger responsibility does lie with the individual.


By Sanjay Suvarna, Senior Software Developer, a MNC  | 03 22 2010 09:17:40 +0000
0
0

every person always think about him/her self they can't fear about anybody they do only that ,what thaey want to do. Some times they break the laws of the governmaent. That's why this pollution problem is not solved by the govt. This is only solved by the public.


By rina sharma, lecturer, Dr. R.K. college neemuch  | 03 22 2010 08:37:49 +0000
0
0

I think its the self realization of the learned and cultured Individuals , and possibly

again their duty to educate people who are unaware of this, however the government

policies also matter as " some humans get cultured and sensitive for such matter

under a stick only"


By vasem want, Head/VP/GM-R&D, 3i Infotech  | 03 22 2010 06:07:30 +0000
1
0

While the government DOES have responsibilities, the individual can contribute more because of the sheer numbers in this country.

As a classic example, let us consider what will happen if we all, at least to begin with, recycle plastic bags when we go grocery shopping. The demand for them will drastically drop. These bags of various sizes are clogging everything from residential drains, stormwater drains, sewage and even rivers and cannals. They are also affecting the land fill siutes considerably. They can be seen all over the place.

So given the number of us who go shopping, if we switch to recyclable materials - go green - that itself will be a phenomenal contribution. 

Yes the individual can do more. it is not the power of one but actually the power of many and has the ability to solve the problem of pollution.


By RAMESH KANDADAI, Principal Consultant, ARM Consultants  | 03 22 2010 05:16:37 +0000
0
0

Government are for making rules but it is our responsibility to follow those rules. This is our planet and we have to take steps to save this from pollution. If every individual will do something regarding this the pollution level itself decreases and hence we save a lot of money of government which is used for the development of some other necessary things.

This is the time of stop blaming government and doing something at our level also after all this is our life our environment and it is every one duty to save this.


By Barun Kumar, Software Test Engineer, KPIT Cummins Infosystem  | 03 22 2010 04:44:44 +0000
0
0

The government is only a policy maker. It is we who has to follow and bring change. So it has to start within ourselves to follow the rules and ensure some other to follow.


By ATMA RAM CHAVALI, MANAGER IT, SBH  | 03 21 2010 17:34:00 +0000
0
0

offcourse its individual persons responsibility to avoid pollution...government can only bring some laws or new green equipments but if individuals are not motivated enough to avoid pollution how can government will be successfull..and the matter of fact is that government is not a machine government is also run by individual only ..in both ways individuals should motivated towards reducing pollution and going green....


By sanjeeb tamuli, Business Development-NER, Indian Energy Exchange Limited  | 03 21 2010 15:55:18 +0000
1
0

I think every pollution created by society & persons are responsible for problems.avoiding pollution resposbility is also created by them so persons are responsbile for it. 


By Anoop Trivedi, Director on Board, Rudraksh IT Solutions & Trading Pvt.Ltd.  | 03 20 2010 12:40:37 +0000
1
0

Yes, I believe its the individuals responsibility.if everyone takes the initiative about the go green concept then we can make a huge difference to the society and to the environment.


By Ajay Hulji, Planning Engineer, Pinkcityexpressway.pvt.ltd.  | 03 20 2010 09:21:22 +0000
1
0

Obviously its each individuals responsibility. Indian common man have washed his hands everytime some disaster arises, on government. Sure government does its own but the same govt is not gonna individually come & put your ignition off on signals or while u r having a chat with ur car engine on. Small steps can lead to higher gains but these so called sophisticated power brains fail to understand simple steps to ecological living. The rickshaw unions, BEST union should train their drivers towards fuel saving, non-wastage etc. Here we are debating about pollution and lakhs of trees are cut every other day. Why one should travel in a car for small distance shopping etc. Its infuriating. Instead of cycling in a AC packed gym why not sweat out on a bicycle. Japan has been following this trend and its reaping benefits. A society is made of individuals and if each individual cares for the cause ultimately society follows.  


By Smita M, Copywriter  | 03 20 2010 08:54:24 +0000
1
0

As Mridula said, its the responsibility of every citizen to control pollution and go green.. our political scenario is like that we individuals should make the government to focus on this.


By Muthukumaran Amirthalingam, Managing Partner, Goldengrass Consulting Services | Entrep Business Consulting  | 03 20 2010 07:55:30 +0000
1
0

It is the resposibility of citizens to draw the attention of government to reduce or avoid pollution level in country. Goverment is a resultant of citizen nor the vice-versa, so the main responsibilty lies in the hand of individuals.

 

If citizens take the initialte to go green they government will be forced to walk with the citizen.


By Mithu Deb, Analyst, Northern Trust  | 03 20 2010 07:42:09 +0000
The Art of Placements
The Art of Placements
Viewers also viewed
Air pollution in Indian cities is growing by leaps and bounds. Shillong is the lest polluted...
 
0 referals 47 arguments, 1251 views
Poisoned pet food. Seafood laced with potentially dangerous antibiotics. Toothpaste tainted with...
 
860 referals 63 arguments, 554 views
Is nuclear energy essential or not? vs nuclear energy is unavoidable
 
690 referals 18 arguments, 293 views
more...  
Recent Knowledge (88)
YES vs No
 
79 referals 24 arguments, 251 views
yes all the signs indicating double recession vs no we are under recovery and will see stable...
 
1390 referals 12 arguments, 177 views
'Following a disciplined path limits your freedom or in other words exercising more freedom will...
 
2191 referals 19 arguments, 133 views
more...  
More From Author
I think, Mr. Abraham needs to be given a Serious thought for the reasons  1.he has seen Failures in his career and must b in phase to resolve the Problems ( there may b external factors which must have taken banks in Bankruptacy) 2. I presume He must...
I really dont Understand How Digital marketing can help to Increase the Market share and Promote Customers to Invest money out of there Pockets..???? I feel attracting customers with Promotional Schemes which really help them to take the decision...
I agree to your Point sir, Basic Requirements of a Human being can be provided which will creat the value for company in HEART of the Population. Obviously, It can be created with help from NGOs, Govt Organization and other Institutions. Everybody...
more...