I'm not 100% supporting for company policy and also manager. First main thing is atmosphere of the work and adoptability of the person. if a person can adopt to any managers he won't think of that even if the manager is bad.. but even if he change his company he can easily to adopt to other company manager.. Coming to atmosphere, if you fit for the atmosphere irrespective of manager or policy you won't be interested to move out of that.. So the main reasons may be 1. Lack of salary 2. Distance of work place.
By
Aries Brune Tyson, Software Developer, iGate Global
| 04 09 2011 15:57:35 +0000
Mr.Ranjeith kumar I am really sorry but I am not agree with you at all. The days gone when Blaming others was a way to get rid of the responsibilities, now learn to take responsibility and leave blaming others. Boss can be a reason but not always. there can be other reasons as well like: 1. Work environment. 2. Organizational Culture. 3. competition 4. Money. 5. and many more things are responsible not only boss. coz my boss was such a person that i never would like to leave a company.
By
Vivekanand Rai, HR Trainee, HDIL
| 04 05 2011 05:38:50 +0000
There are few reason: 1. People Change company Due to Poor work environment or Internal politics. 2. Bad HR Practice i.e.(Compensation or benefits. 3. Managers inefficient assessment blocks employees career growth. Hence employee explores better career opportunity out of organization.
By
Pravat Rana, Graphic/Web Designer, Sapient Corporation
| 04 04 2011 16:36:28 +0000
Companies treat their existing employees as labors.They are not giving hikes to their existing employees but they hire an outsider on double pay packages...no appreciation is there to the employees saying that he knows every thing that's why they did the same and if the new commer does so it is a complement.
By
swamit , Asst. Sales Manager, Dimensionie.com
| 01 16 2011 05:17:32 +0000
I guess this has to be an ideate rather than a debate because these are not the only two reasons for a job change. Moreover a job change is mostly not because of any single reason. There are many factors involved. So it is not always about the boss or about the policies sometimes some personal or legitimate reasons coupled with certain other factors cumulatively decide the move.
By
Nitin Anand, SAP Professional, J P Morgan
| 12 10 2010 10:05:11 +0000
As i have experinced they dont change job just because of their company or managers. If they quit because of these reasons they they should not join another one because anywhere they will be there and you will have to face them. I think people change jobs just to have different kind of experiences which will help them in future.
By
Neerav Galathia, Sales Engineer, Aerzen Machines (India) Pvt. Ltd.
| 12 10 2010 09:37:32 +0000
"Frustration over the company policies and wages which will not be affordable for a persons hard work will lead him to look for a switch over.I dont think managers would be a constraint for people with stuff and knowledge"
By
Arunkumar , DBA - Oracle / Linux, Verizon Communications
| 11 22 2010 10:46:39 +0000
People change jobs in India because the systems and policies are too slow and merit has no chance. Honest workers need to survive in a battle hungry set up.
By
neha singh, Content Editor, Avestia Corp
| 09 27 2010 12:33:01 +0000
People change their jobs for the environemt around, Every person undergoes different stages of the life and the needs are different at every stage, successful companies take care of these needs of people from time to time If person wishes for growth and better prospects then he needs to keep a Vision and evaluate the progress against the vision that is set from time to time ONLY THING CONSTANT IN LIFE IS CHANGE !!!
By
ABHIJIT KULKARNI, Project Manager, BNP Paribas
| 07 31 2010 10:12:56 +0000
as people always work for Satisfaction, Security,Growth.but changing job depends on all these factor.if minor things affects all these then one should change the job.
By
shashikumar dubey, BCA student, pcti
| 07 17 2010 09:18:44 +0000
Hi Kaveri, I am afraid that I can't see the logic. All organizations are vertical (some now claim to be lateral ). Someone supervises someone and that's the way it goes till the MD/CEO whose immediate boss is the board. If that is true, all companies will have the same employee turnover % in average. But that's not true-is it!'
By
Arindom Borah, Sales Manager, Confidential
| 07 02 2010 10:56:09 +0000
manager all generally known about what should be done but company policy will affected in managers skill
By
raja , mentor, einflexion pte ltd
| 06 28 2010 11:15:37 +0000
The best way to deal is "dont change ur attitude"be the way ur ...managers r never responsible....stop spending ur time and day in those cozy cabin...be on ur toes...its u r responsible for eveything...as ur the 1 who sets the system...so never be a blame shifter..its ur baby..u need to take care of it...Simle...BE PRACTICAL
By
Parag Trivedi, National Creative Director/VP-Creative, KHP;INDIA
| 06 25 2010 00:26:23 +0000
The managers mess up and do not give the employee to stay back - 'He will leave'... There are a lot of triggers for which an employee may choose to part ways with the organisation; his MANAGER is a the TOP REASON for the same.
By
Ralston Coelho, HR Director, IMRB International
| 06 12 2010 14:24:43 +0000
I think people changes job due to company policies. Manager may be one of the reason behind it , but friends manager is also an employee of the company & they are doing only their job. & their first responsibility is to implement the policy of that company by all means whether it is against the employees or for the employees. Managers are also human being like us . Please don't treat them like someone coming from Mars. Also some people have tendency of changing the jobs on regular basis for just a sake of hike in package & job satisfaction is secondary to them. & in last "Badal to Prakruti Ka Niyam Hai Wasta!"
By
SHRIKANT MANOHAR DANKE, Consultant, Project Management Consultancy Firm
| 06 12 2010 14:13:30 +0000
More often people change jobs because of bad colleagues who are manipulative, selfish and controlling.such people who are selfish sticks to one job or puts in 'n' number of years because they fail to try outside( test their real skills in a competitive environment). they just become a sitting duck in the same organization, hence few good real people are forced to quit.
By
Apeksha , IT/Technical Editor,
| 06 11 2010 08:20:27 +0000
what if your manager is very nice and good but if there is no company poliy which may support your aspirations, what can ur manager apart from lending a shoulder to cry??---- YOUR Manager can help u in feeling comfortable in your day to day job or support you few times, where his own butt is not coming in question. your manager dont run your house your manager can try to get you 5% raise extra than co might have decided. ----So company policy/environment has to play a big role, MANAGERS ARE JUST MEESANGER OF THE MANAGEMENT
By
Abhishek Gupta, Director , Skills Factory
| 06 11 2010 05:39:19 +0000
people can manage people (boss/manager) to some extend, but their need, financial expectation, wishes always adds in a comparison basis so wages. Then dissatisfaction linked with policy plays a vital roll.
By
Aravindan , Asst. Manager HR, NGO
| 06 07 2010 11:40:13 +0000
I changed jobs for the sake of better pay packages & inadequate company policies then. Another reason felt by me during the change is nothing had remained to learn new in that field of business.
By
suhaschandra deshpande, Marketing Associate
| 06 07 2010 10:40:40 +0000
May be a very small percentage of people change thier job due to thier Managers, as Managers just impliment the company policy. Mainly , job changes are for better organisation with higher salary/wages.
By
R N Bhattacharyya, Freelancer, Freelancer
| 06 07 2010 07:51:33 +0000
If you are leaving a job and going to another job at a salary higher than the present salary then you are changing nio becoz of your boss but becoz uit is a suffocating environment, yuor boss can pass teh pressure to you but you are not abel to pass it to another person Let us all accept 1 fct no boss will screw his / her career for a reportee , they will pass on the fire and keep 90% credit. So if a person says he is leaving becoz of boss means that man cannot manage any perosn in life Look at the trend people shift jobs approx every 3-4 yrs ie they work ina company for 3-4 yrs and then move out, why so becoz they get a bigger pay check else where, but the reason they give is boss is bad No boss will be good it is salary becoz of which we move and not boss There are movemnets even when boss if good and there are numerous instances where I have seen this If any person get more than 20% hike in present salary there is movement, present market is offering 50% to 65% hike, so why will there be no movemnet Who does nto love money, job satisfaction and job enrichment does not fill your basic and family needs
By
Nikhil , Senior Manager, Insurance
| 05 12 2010 08:34:29 +0000
I think the primary responsibility lies with the Company's Policy. If the company is run in a professional manner with systems in place and the management strictly adheres with the systems & procedures then the employees will love to work in such companies and will be pround. Insufficient professionalism and lack of systems and procedures forces the employees & staff leave their jobs.
By
SUNIL KUMAR RAMACHANDRA, Supply Chain Officer
| 05 10 2010 07:34:07 +0000
I believe company policies & compensation that an employee draws are the two main factors.Even Managers are bound to follow those policies & becomes a target for employees to take all their frustration on his head.Most of the companies hire the candidates but dont offer the work according to their qualification & capabilities.Everybody is working on the same platform whether a guy is Btech/bcom/bsc whatever.So, please!!!! I say it loud.. PLEASE DONT DO THAT....It arises only frustration and jealously among employees.Offer jobs according to their Qualification. Companies are stiill treating their inhouse employees as labours just on the name of recession.They are not giving hikes to their employees but they hire an outsider on double pay packages.Why?? There are hell lot of factors which are directly/indirectly dependent on the company policies.These days the attrition rate is very high as the industry is out of recession and everybody wants to get out of the companies with the policies as Junk.
By
Devesh Srivastava, Senior Analyst, HCL Technologies
| 03 15 2010 13:41:38 +0000
companies policy and wages are the main region behind changing the job , the companies policy and wage are the main criteria who can satisfy the individual and as individual is satisfied and motivated he can not change the job
By
anjani nandan, DR .K.N.MODI .INSTITUTE.OF ENGG AND TECHNOLOGY
| 03 14 2010 16:27:45 +0000
|
company policies are generally not against the employee but most of the times the manager is against the employee so superiors/managers are the reason why most leave their jobs.
By
Narendra Tiwary, student placement coordinator, SSIM
| 10 27 2010 08:56:43 +0000
People leave jobs because of their team managers, team politics, female colleagues who are manipulative, back-stabbing, etc. Bad apprisial rating.. quite often the apprisal report always says opposite of your true nature ( your core beliefs). Thus attrition rate is high, and this is a on-going process as long as we are working.
By
Apeksha , IT/Technical Editor,
| 07 29 2010 07:43:02 +0000
The greatest impact on any employee has of its boss.If the boss is kind and understanding i dnt think company policies matter a lot.And about wages it is also dependent on managers.
By
Heena , CA student, ICAI
| 07 17 2010 07:25:49 +0000
Most of the time employees leave their jobs due to their immediate boss. it has been researched and this has been found out to be the single most reason for people to leave their jobs. It is not because of salary/ wages, conditions or any other similar reason.
By
Prashant Welling, Partner/Principal/VP, Innotech Enterprises
| 07 17 2010 06:05:51 +0000
People are forced to change jobs becomes of office politics- especially of the immediate team leads or managers. the general perception is that employess who have put N number of services know it all- they are the best and that the subordinates who join the team, even if expereieced are under-rated.
By
Apeksha , IT/Technical Editor,
| 06 25 2010 08:31:02 +0000
People don't change jobs; they change bosses. This is particularly so in the corporate sector where a target-driven boss finds a soft target in a subordinate- if the subordinate is new, even better- and lays the entire blame for non-performance at his door. After all, the boss has greater position power to manipulate higher management.
By
Mukesh Srivastava, Freelancer, Radio, TV & Films
| 06 19 2010 08:18:23 +0000
While entering into a Company we had known about company, polices and wages, but not known about managers or superiors or bosses, pretty much we misunderstanding and other facing problem between manger makes us to move for other jobs, if make interaction and get job satisfactions makes not like to move,,,, Thank You
By
PRAVEENKUMAR.V , Student , Sri Krishna Arts and Science College
| 06 11 2010 10:21:40 +0000
Mr Darpan I dont know what made you write this and what you have gone through but I must say....... GOOD QUESTION!!! According to me people leave jobs definitely due to their managers... They are the prime reasons for job change. No one wants to leave a comfortable job and start all over again so easily... According to me it is their managers who make them leave the jobs....
By
Aditi Sharma, MBA/PGDM student, Sri Sharada Institute of Indian Management - Research
| 06 07 2010 13:18:48 +0000
I think such unilateral assignmnet of reason is not right. The reasons usually are more than one. But treatment from the immediate superior is one of the principal reasons.Lack of clarity about career is another important reason for such change.
By
Jaganmoy Basu Roy Chowdhury, Consultant, A reputed Media House
| 05 12 2010 07:04:35 +0000
change and challenge are the need of today is what employees want. sme times the managers their supervisors are not encouraging. and dis motivates them and then they are not able to perform
By
aditi gupta, MBA/PGDM student, pimr,ips
| 05 10 2010 10:01:00 +0000
Yes in most of the cases people leave jobs because of their managers.Secondly you can consider the options like job satisfaction.Rest of the reasons depend on the situation of market, growth both career/employer. You can add more as you go toostep.
By
Kiran Jonnalagadda, Associate/Sr. Associate -(Technical), IBM
| 05 10 2010 09:14:22 +0000
A quote says "A Manager job is to do things right". An employee looks at his manager for his growth, satisfaction and appreciation. Manager is the person who evaluates the performance of employee working in his team based on different parameter. Each employee next step get decided by the manager. If the next step planned is not matching to the employee expectation (could include salary, profile, responsibility, other balancing factor..), an issue starts. It creates a dis-satisfied employee. If it handled properly the dis-satisfaction would be resolved without further issues but if manager does not put effort to understand or does not able to resolve,this in turn raises an employee iteration. Impact of the immediate senior (manager) to any employee is most compared to any other factor. Other factors aggrevates dis-satisfaction.
By
Santosh Kumar, Product Technical Lead
| 05 10 2010 07:27:24 +0000
It al depends on the situuation a person is into. Neverthelesss it is found that most people quit their jobs due to improper guidance/motivation/not identifying them as one amongst the team & their immediate superiors/managers are the one's to be blamed for. One's immediate boss/manager is supposed to be the torchbearer of one's rise or fall in his career. Obviously one can't rule out the role of the person, his attitude towards his superior/mentor & his own job profile. This is a very complex situuation if you ask me, and the blame can't be put on anyone without having taken a note of the circumstances that one went through.
By
yugal k dhuliya, Branch Manager/Regional Manager, Mirc Electronics
| 05 10 2010 04:58:36 +0000
Agree that people leave managers not the company. One of the HR survey finding has given same conclusion. to add the reason , it is observed that managers are biased for race, language,region, caste etc. It happens because of lack of supervision by their bosses on them. In such organisation, gradually attrition rate goes up. People argue that family managed organisations are more prone to such practices but this can happen any professionally managed organisations too if professional do not act in professional manner.
By
Ulhas Ranade, Analyst, ExxonMobil Chemical
| 03 14 2010 11:56:53 +0000
neither due to company policies/wages or managers but because , they cannot adjust / adapt ... so have no option but to search .. research a new job ..
By
Ajay Ziz, Dy. Registrar,, University of Jammu
| 12 17 2009 06:22:22 +0000
I do agree that people often change job due to their managers.Actually unless you get the job satisfaction,you cant be in the job for long.And job satisfaction comes from various things like job profile,work environment,relation with the hierarchies and subordinates.So our work appraisement very much depends on our manager.He/she is the one who can motivate our work,who can show new path in professional field,who can give recognition to our work.So either way managers role is significant for being in the same job for long time or looking out for another one.
By
roumi chatterjee, asst commercial executive, century plyboard india ltd
| 12 17 2009 05:57:07 +0000
Managers....seems to be main cause being the very first person with whom we remain in touch during working hours.. most frequsnt combination.... a good policy wid bad managers or a bad policy wid bad managers have same terminal effect......
By
bimal sikdar, Joint Director, central services
| 10 15 2009 17:13:50 +0000
There could many reasons in general, but I agreely with you in totality with Ranjith that the points which have been emphasized are straight and open. Quite knowledge sharing and thought provoking !
By
T Jagan Mohan, Partner/Principal/VP, TRIOELITES
| 08 10 2009 13:17:22 +0000
When we discuss about the reason for an employee leaving an organization, we need to think about certain aspects from the emp's point of view. The reason why he/she works? Why he/she looks out for change? Whether for more salary or for a better job profile or for mal-adaptation with the peers. If the employee is much keen about the money, then obviously no one could stop his/her switch. Wherein, the reason for job change is for better profile or mal-adaptation with peers or whatsoever, then there comes the vital role of a manager. In such cases, when a manager doesn't play the role which he is supposed to play, then obviously it will drive the employee to move out of the company. Regards, John Rambo R
By
John Rambo R, Senior Analyst, Alp Consulting Ltd
| 06 03 2009 09:21:06 +0000
Yes.....Managers may be the cause for this.......coz it is the kind of environment he creates in the department...which too has a major impact on the employees working in that particular department.....
By
Praveen Bhise, Nutrition Officer, Nestle India Ltd.
| 05 28 2009 05:50:57 +0000
I think there are usually 3 reasons when people change their job.
(1) work satisfaction (2) salary (3) releationship with managers
I think whenever any two of the three above mentioned reasons are true [generally one becomes primary and the other secondary] people do want to change.....
so it depends on person and orginization collectivly !!!
By
Vinay Mudgil, Sr. Application Developer, Computer Sciences Corporation
| 05 21 2009 06:33:16 +0000
I appreciate your saying with high dignity. Managers are ones those who know both the sides of the coin though they do not take effective Steps most of the times. If they react honestly keeping Company and GOD in Hearts, The Results may come extraordinary and Superficial. Therefore, the MASTER KEY OF " HONESTY " must be Practiced in all Circumstances by Top Ones.
By
Diwan.Mohammed Talha.N, HR , ATLAS INDIA - CANADIAN CONSULTANCY SERVICES
| 05 19 2009 18:28:37 +0000
Hi Samir,
Yes, it is indeed a precarious situation when there is a friction between the superior and the subordinate as it is not in the intertest of the firm nor in the personal interest of the subordinate. Latter stands to loose too much when left the situation to continue.
By
Rakesh Ojha, Head/VP/GM-Sales, E2 Solutions
| 04 07 2009 12:34:00 +0000
Mr.Rakesh i would agree with you that sometimes what happens is employees leave their jobs because of their friction with their managers. If an employee doesn't feel comfortable in interacting with his manager then it is neither good for them and neither will it benefit the organisation. So for the benefit of all there should be healthy relationship between the superiors and their subordinates so that the productivity levels will automatically increase .
What do you say?
By
Samir Das, Tech Architect, Infosys
| 04 07 2009 11:30:49 +0000
i fully agree with you Yash, but unfortunately subordinates doesn't have a right to choose their bosses.but, still if someone has the carefree attitude towards his boss ( not towards his work!) will definetly make the boss himself to go out!!
By
jairaj shyam prasad, Production Manager, BOSCH Ltd
| 04 02 2009 12:39:44 +0000
|