Build your professional network on facebook via our app Go to app
 
<< Prev  2 of 2 in Topic 
 
Created by : CHINTAN , Security/ Equity Research Analyst, chintaninc  | 02 20 2010 08:54:46 +0000
Activity:  457 views;  last activity : 07 06 2010 20:18:09 +0000

With events in last many years has shown that Mumbai has done little to maintain its status a Financial capital of India. Be it Infrastructure, affordability, peace. Since Investment  attracts FII they need world Class Infrastructure like road, Water, Education, Recreation and Mumbai lacks in most of this. Which city could take over May be Ahmedabad. With recent incident It proves that one man can still stop the whole city which is really against to reamin Finanial Capital

 
 Refer 346
Share
 
 
  Rate : 
 
 
Mumbai Lose its Status as a Financial Capital Of India Vs Mumbai Maintains its Status as a Financial Capital Of India
12
 
 
 
 
4
5
3
Support   Support
Top Argument
3
1
Mumbai controls the financial nerves of India. It is a colourful cosmopolitan city whose colours represent the colours of India’s diversity not that of the Marathis alone. But the recent happenings in Mumbai is affecting the city very badly and its status as the financial capital of the country. Mumbai's concerns also includes its infrastructure, civic problems and the quality of governance.  If this goes on like this, Mumbai will lose its status as the financial capital of IndiaMumbai controls the financial nerves of India. It is a colourful cosmopolitan city whose colours represent the colours of India’s diversity not that of the Marathis alone. But the recent happenings in Mumbai is affecting the city very badly and its status as the financial capital of the country. Mumbai's concerns also includes its infrastructure, civic problems and the quality of governance. If this goes on like this, Mumbai will lose its status as the financial capital of India.

Mumbai controls the financial nerves of India. It is a colourful cosmopolitan city whose colours represent the colours of India’s diversity not that of the Marathis alone. But the recent happenings in Mumbai is affecting the city very badly and its status as the financial capital of the country. Mumbai's concerns also includes its infrastructure, civic problems and the quality of governance. If this goes on like this, Mumbai will lose its status as the financial capital of India.


By Kavitha Shankar, Sr/Principal Coresspondent, ABC  02 22 2010 08:20:50 +0000
 
Top Argument
1
2

Probably think a little differently on this issue Kavitha. Irregardless of terrorism activity, certain political vendetta, fanatisism and so on woudnt expect Mumbai to lose its sheen yeah...People measure up or look upto Mumbai on a different note still; people from all corners of India zeroing in with due respect to a livelihood, influx of money and trade, MNC's still setting up base & office & and of course carrying on business,etc...


By Wayne-Russell Macedo, Procurement & Logistics, Dana Group, Lagos  02 22 2010 09:57:15 +0000
1
0

As the hatred of non-maratis is fueled in Mumbai more and more, those who invest and run businesses there will become more and more uncomfortable. This will result from increased difficulty in getting routine things done; increased levels of uncertainty in what was taken for granted till now. Investors always get nervous when uncertainty increases. See what happened in west bengal with the nano project.

Over the years to come things will gradually move out of mumbai and dispersing around the country. By that time all the people who started this wholly unnecessary campaign would have passed on. So who benefits.....The common man alone suffers. 

Sad but true....such short sighted policies that divide people seldom improve anything. They only destabilize.

Mumbai will reduce in acceptability....bit by bit....but reduce it will.


By RAMESH KANDADAI, Principal Consultant, ARM Consultants  | 02 23 2010 03:47:28 +0000
2
0

Dear Wayne..

gone thru your Post.... you have rightly pointed out some current issues....

As being in Logistics Inds you may feel rite of my point...

1. India has major manufacturing of Chemicals, Textiles and Pharma based in Gujrat which contributes to the Major of our Exports to American and Europian countries where we have distinct advantages of low cost offering over the other exporting countries... and Mudra and Kandla ports are under developments and UMPP ( Ultra Mega Power Projects) are also joining hands for the developments of State of Gujrat... Its not only Infrastructure development work but also Industries development work going on in Gujrat...

2. Major Businessmens of Indian virgin are gujraties and scenario is that they Stay in Mumbai and had offices in Mumbai... but there manufacturing base is in Gujrat only...... The opening of these ports will reduce their dependancy on Mumbai ports and cost implications therefore.. The traffice from major North and western Part will be diverted to these ports.. Instead on Mumbai...

3. Since Independance Mumbai has strategic advantage of having Port and International connectivity of Airlines... I feel Ahmedabad Airport is also opening up for International Airlines... Indian Airlines already had International flights starting from Ahmedabad... So both Advantages are loosing...

4. State Govt of Gujrat call VIBRANT GUJRAT meetings everyyear where they ask Every and Individual Inds about the Expansions, Additional investment in Inds for the upcoming years etc.... so they are more keen for Total development of the State... Industries are the Major contributor towards the growth of State and flow of Money as Investment in the State... In short they keep track of every minute things to be done for growth of Individual as well State...

5. I even feel per capita Income of person based in Gujrat is higher than in Maharashtra...

6. Maharashtra on the contrary has many problems like.. High cost towards Manpower, Labor Unions, High cost of Land, Water, huge Taxes, less subsidies etc.... The Mahrashtra State Govt Hardly takes any Innovative step to attract Manufacturing Industries...

7. The world Economies ( Japan, Germany, UK, US etc) are evolved only from Manufacturing Inds and less on Services Inds which Maharashtra has major presence... wether Hotel, Software, Banking  etc....

These are couple of points besides Terror, I feel needs to be addressed carefully as to Mumbai to be the Financial capital of India....  Please comment


By Sampanna Shastry, Deputy Manager- Marketing & Sales, Arani Power Systems Ltd  | 02 22 2010 11:40:29 +0000
2
0

S.. I fully Agree to you and strongly feel the Financial Capital will be very soon shifted to neighbouring state... there are couple of reasons for the things...

1. The first & foremost being the Problems in day to day life for every human being and failure to get resolved faster than the speed of raising the problem.....

2. Terrorism in the states.. making common man UNSAFE AND UNSECURED to Live and grow ... wether thru Internal agencies or External Terrorism...... It is going to bring the same result... This is the most potential threat for Mumbai as an Investment point of view in Infrastructure, Assets etc...

3. The faster growth rate in the neighbouring State...

4. Mumbai since beginning was enjoying advantages of PORT availability, Internation route thru Air ports etc... The development of Kandla Port, Adani port are potentially threat for Mumbai also and attractive Subsidies put up by Govt of Gujrat helps to develope area and business faster than even in States of Maharashtra...

5. Gujrat being the major contributor to theIndividual Business growth by Origin and they used access the Nationa and world from Mumbai. I feel bringing up some gud business strategies can help shifting major Businessmens to neighbouring states...

6. The raising cost of living, Manpower, Electricity, Taxes, Water and other Raw Materials has been witnessed since long years.. so all major Inds from Mumbai and around were shifted to Pune, Kolhapur & other near by area... But now the Problems are raining and needs very careful attention to Maintain Status eanred since Independance of the nation.....

They are other problems also which may force every business owner to think on Mumbai as park for investment...


By Sampanna Shastry, Deputy Manager- Marketing & Sales, Arani Power Systems Ltd  | 02 22 2010 09:29:18 +0000
2
0

With events in last many years has shown that Mumbai has done little to maintain its status a Financial capital of India. Be it Infrastructure, affordability, peace. Since Investment  attracts FII they need world Class Infrastructure like road, Water, Education, Recreation and Mumbai lacks in most of this. Which city could take over May be Ahmedabad. With recent incident It proves that one man can still stop the whole city which is really against to remain Financial Capital. With rise of fanatics its not Why its about When


By CHINTAN , Security/ Equity Research Analyst, chintaninc  | 02 20 2010 08:54:46 +0000
0
1

Of course, Mumbai should continue to be financial capital of India in lines of New York in US, London in UK, Frankfurt in Germany and many more.  Because of its cultural diversity and cosmo lifestyle, meseems, Mumbai is the only place for financial hub.


By S D Manjunath, Sr Manager (Corr Bkg & Int'l Trade), Axis Bank Ltd  | 02 27 2010 02:47:03 +0000
0
1

NEVER.

There are many great people to monitor the same and save ir from losing the pride.


By KUMAR SAURABH JHA, Manager-HR & Admin  | 02 22 2010 08:42:56 +0000
Leading ITES/BPO Consultants
Leading ITES/BPO Consultants
Viewers also viewed
Back Packs, hands bag vs laptop bags
 
1 referals 2 arguments, 33 views
As recent developments of Maharashtra shows still we are divided And divided we fall. All states...
 
3 referals 5 arguments, 273 views
Recession had a great impact on the job scenario in many market and people were laid off like...
 
1081 referals 61 arguments, 797 views
more...  
Recent Knowledge (4)
These days as I switch on the tv or radio or look at a hoarding I do feel that power of ads I...
 
3004 referals 23 arguments, 482 views
C vs B
 
0 referals 3 arguments, 51 views
I am associate of prajapati association and i am working for BJP from year 2005 to till date....
 
0 referals 3 arguments, 111 views
more...  
More From Author
Boycotting is not an answer Awareness is. As in western world people because of awareness converting to become VEGAN, not using any milk product because of bad effects of good(not contaminated) milk I think we also one day become aware of it and leave...
World is falling BE SAFE. With major economies of the world like USA and Europe in unsolvable problems Developing Ecomonies also showing signs of slowing down Hard Days are ahead of us So Play Safe at least for few years its going to b hard Submit
Though most people don't go but they always in back of their mind of leaving everything and to live in Himalayas.
more...