Build your professional network on facebook via our app Go to app
 
 
Posted in Community :

Accountablility by Government bodies

 
Activity:  21 views;  last activity : 05 20 2011 07:56:41 +0000

 
 Refer 185
Share
 
 
  Rate : 
 
 
 
 
  2 1
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1 2
1 Possible reasons for Asymmetry in Indian Economy
2 Asymmetries in our Economy is a fact and how does it happen unlike other economies that choose better internal structure.

Possible reasons for Asymmetry in Indian Economy

idea posted by Srinivas suravajhala Asst. Manager.
The imbalances in the growth story of an economy is asymmetry. Both Mr. Mathew Cherian and Muralidharan have presented their ideas in a scholarly way. They forced me to go through different portals to provide my view, because I dont have much knowledge in both the areas of Economics and maths. What I could derive from the content I just read, the overreactions to the economic reactions is one of the major contributing factor to Asymmetry in an Economy. There are too many theories on the causes for this. I conclude as a layman that the adhoc counter measures and poor policy making are the two important contributing factors for the asymmetry in our economy. I will be thankful if Mr. Cherian and Muralidharan correct me.
2
0
  
by Srinivas suravajhala, Asst. Manager.  | 05 19 2011 11:12:33 +0000

Thank you Mr. Muralidharan. The finance ministers at states must have some basic knowledge of economics and have knowledge of economic scenario. They lacks minimum planning capabilities. The statistical data as you said have their own confinements. The growth in figures is marvelous but when it comes to reality it is totally different. Dont they know the facts. We need to adapt true reflectors. Choosing correct indicators is required.

0
  

Yes Mr. Srinivas. We are evolving, taking corrective measures as they happen. In today's scenariou, you need a overhaul of the entire planning process. New age thinkers should put up a brave face to alter the situation. Mr. Cherian is very right. If you have 280 items in the basket, most of them are not relevant for computation purpose, to arrive at our CPI, and 30% of our population contribute to 100% GDP, only in India this is possible. Our economists are playing a volume game. We still stick to Gadgil formula for arriving at number of constituencies. Allocation of resources should be proportionate to the development in each State. If a state is falling behind for various compulsions, they should provide for a grace period to bring them at par with the other State. If they fail to prove, then they should try an alternate method. Funding of States, in majority of the cases, have become subjective. You will demand more attention, if the ruling government in the Centre and State are the same or their allies, otherwise, all your requirement would be negated. There are many flaws. You have several Statitical Organisations in the country, each producing different statistics, and the World Bank Report, sometimes, present a different viewpoint. Human Development Index of the UN is different from our Centre's data. A thorough over-hauling is required, in my view!

Add your argument:

Asymmetries in our Economy is a fact and how does it happen unlike other economies that choose better internal structure.

idea posted by Mathew Cherian Research Associate/Analyst, Western Michigan University

Asymmetries  in our Economy.

There is a theorem by the one  of  the only few women Professors of fame in Mathematics, Professor Emma Bonners Noether, which states ‘in any continued symmetry there is an underlying invariant structure’. This is translated into plain commonsensical language as any symmetry seen in nature has an underlying ‘structure’. Conservation of energy is an example, where one cannot create or destroy energy but can only change one form of it to another.

In a similar vein we can say that any continued asymmetry has a time varying structure underneath it meaning there is unstable-processes creating those asymmetries. Like the Indian environment we see malnutrition, illiteracy, prejudices, poverty, cumbersome and dysfunctional economic infrastructure, delayed and troubled transport system, lack of welfare, unhygienic healthcare, lack of infrastructure in education, high infant mortality rate, low life expectancy, dysfunctional products and services etc; etc;.

Applying the above theorem to our environment we can conclude that we follow unstable policies in our Economic structure which is causing all the asymmetries.

1
0
  
by Srinivas suravajhala, Asst. Manager.  | 05 20 2011 07:56:41 +0000

Thank you Mr. Cherian for sharing your knowledge in depth about economics. Laissez Fair (a free reign model) in which Govts. have minimum interference. But, here in India the situation is different. The Govt. dont want to lose its control on anything. Policies of the Govt. should confine to the role of regulator.

0
  
by Srinivas suravajhala, Asst. Manager.  | 05 20 2011 07:51:35 +0000

Thank you Mr. Cherian for sharing your knowledge in depth about economics. Laissez Fair (a free reign model) in which Govts. have minimum interference. But, here in India the situation is different. The Govt. dont want to lose its control on anything. Policies of the Govt. should confine to the role of regulator.

0
  

Thanks, Mr.Muralidharan and Mr. Srinivas. I think many knowledgble elements in our economy doesn't like the present 'developmental model' initiated post independence and would like to follow a new different model. For example what we follow is a 'socialistic developmental model' where as there is also a choice like 'free market laizer-fairez developmental model' which were followed in countries like US where it produced better results as can be perceived from the enormous amount of wealth and prosperity these developed nation are endowed with this alternate developmental model. American parliament takes only a few minutes to deliberate and execute a 600bn dollar fund request where as for a country like India a 350bn dollar request to create 'state of the art' highways for economic and commerce development cannot be delibrated or funded from our wealth. Mr. Murlidharan thanks for mentioning Chaos theory, there is a new science coming up from it called 'Econo Physics' where 1)organized chaos and 2)emerging behavior are studied in it to make economic policies. There is another new field called 'Complixity theory' where they use similar models like pointcare sections to study the distance to rupture and chaos and even they can make audits on any economic system and conclude how much ccmplisity exists in an economy and how much to be reduced to bring the system back to non-defiling states.

Add your argument:

Add your Idea
Idea* : 
Add your argument:
edit in rich text ...
Could not find any idea interesting in: "Asymmetry in the Indian Economy !!" ? Click here to add a new idea...

Found the idea contest "Asymmetry in the Indian Economy !!"  interesting ?  Click here to refer to your connections and communities
Leading recruitment Firm, Permanent Staffing, Temporary Staffing, Executive Search & Selection, and RPO
Aim Plus Staffing Solutions is the brain child of a set of professionals from the HR and technology communities. Established in 2005, Aim Plus Staffing Solutions is the leading provider of Talent Acquisition and Recruitment Process Outsourcing solutions to the Technology, Knowledge Services,......
Viewers also viewed
Support the price rise. vs Do no support the price rise.
 
269 referals 15 arguments, 4793 views
Bollywood is becoming famous world-wide. At the same time, our Businessmen are climbing the list...
 
49 referals 9 arguments, 362 views
Yes vs No
 
555 referals 11 arguments, 249 views
more...  
Recent Knowledge (4)
When we are watching news channels or any other channel or reading news papers you bump upon...
 
2022 referals 11 votes, 200 views
we all know the perils of talking on cell phones while driving. besides being hazourdous to...
 
290 referals 2 votes, 36 views
more...  
More From Author
It depends on what sort of work. Healthcare professionals cannot forefeit night duties. Toruism and outsoruced work gets done sometimes during night shifts. If we had state of the art campuses female students need to use the library during late hours,...
Are we all bored to try out different changes without knowing why one has to do it or if need be what is the reason for it?What is the need for so many divisions, since each state is divided into districts which are like mini states. The country has...
Yes, thanks, there need be 'rational choices' available for a budding youngster from cradle to coffin. This is the only way economic theory prescribes normal life for citizen. This might breakdown the family oriented choices in India then it will be...
more...