Build your professional network on facebook via our app Go to app
 
 
Posted in Community :

HR Professionals |

PHP

 
Started by : Sujatha srivastava, Associate/Senior Associate, AT Kearney   04 07 2010 13:24:51 +0000
Industry : Human Resources (HR) ConsultingFunctional Area : Performance(Corporate Finance)
Activity:  235 views;  last activity : 07 06 2010 20:18:09 +0000

Employees in the Government sector are far less confident about finding a job compared to their peers in other sectors. They are, however, less fearful about a job loss as compared to their peers in other sectors. So users, according to you, what may be the reason of this?

 
 Refer 585
Share
 
 
  Rate : 
 
 
 
 
  5 2 2 2 1
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1 2 3 4 5
1 Lack of confidence
2 No Drive to Achieve in Life
3 why should I ? attitude
4 Comfort Levels
5 Non-existence of proper performance metrics
6 Power and money making opportunity through currupt practices deters Govt servant to look for other opportunities
7 Kings in their so - called palaces
8 lazyness
9 Switch-over from Non profitable to Profitable requirement
10 Lack of SKILL and WILL issue
11 lazy ness
12 lazy nature in work
13 Do not want take risk

Lack of confidence

idea posted by Sujatha srivastava Associate/Senior Associate, AT Kearney

It is an inertia to leave the secure. I think govt jobs have some of the best talents because they generally select well and more importantly, train them well. Lack of confidence is not just PSU oriented. It is age related. So to say someone above 50 may be more careful than say someone below 30. But of course unlike the private sector where a single guy handles multiple things and thus gets more exposure in the govt sector the same job maybe divided amongst four/five people. This may lead to a certain lack of information but again everything is relative. For an example a nuclear or rocket scientist may find quick takers as compared to a railway clerk. Same to comment about certain specific operations such as projects/materials/supply chain/info systems etc which are more specialised and skilled manpower might be low. The tough chance is for guys in marketing who lack the confidence to shift due to lack of specifics.

5
0
  

The "perform or perish" work culture of the private sector will never be acceptable to most PSU employees, who revel in the glory of "No Accountability" that their much-sought-after job brings along with it. Complacence breeds incompetence, and results in lack of confidence and inertia. So while they do envy the pay packages of the private sector, they are seldom ready to give it all up, and instead switch over to a work atmosphere which, irrespective of all its rewards, is ruled by Goals, Deadlines, Efficiency, Productivity, and, in most cases, longer working hours and lesser job stability. 

1
  

i agree. it is the system itself that saps one's drive to think about a change. I know of many freshers who join govt sector with so much josh only to be dragged back by the attitude and temperament of their senior colleagues. as sreenivasan mentioned, all these factors eventually rub into their minds and he gets well settled in that system. It is quite difficult to change one's work culture later on after a stint at govt sectors. when they see/hear of the challenges their peers in the pvt sectors face, they lack confidence and the courage to see themselves in that role. Job security, easy promotion are some factors which also influence their 'home sweet and safe home' mentality.

1
  
by Sreenivasan , engineering, indian railways  | 04 07 2010 16:44:51 +0000

A generalization is very difficult.Lack of confidence, lack of drive ,laziness etc are existing in government system. ( i just remember the 4 blinds trying to describe the elephant). Dr APJ Abdul Kalam, Vikram Sarabhai, Dr Kurien , TN Sheshan all were the products of government system.Does any of the adjectives suit them? Similarly we a have a great junk of inefficient people in the government system.; inefficient, complacent etc. An average government official is likely to lack confidence because the private sector working is totally different from the public sector.both are challenging in its own way. But those who left the government service and joined pvt sector are fairing well. i know about a dozen of them who excelled and superceded the traditional private sector stalwarts after switching to private sector

 

Add your argument:

No Drive to Achieve in Life

idea posted by V. Sushanth Abhishek Senior Manager - IT, Seva Bharat

I think the issue is more importantly the lack of drive the govt employees to achieve anything in life. All they want is their very comfortable job (no work pressure, no goals, therefore no learning), a salary at the end of each month. Because they know this will suffice for them and their family. As Sujatha said, 'The inertia to leave the secure'. But i personally do not know anybody in the govt. service who has an ambition or goal in life.

2
0
  
by Ajay Ziz, Dy. Registrar,, University of Jammu  | 04 20 2010 06:19:25 +0000

if a govt. servant ( repeat servant ) draws a pension ( in lieu of salary ) on the last day of every month..as aking with or without work..

result :: why should i ???

.. as bhave sahib says :: sandook mein bandook ..man mein bhook .

.hum sab govt. wale dhoort prani hain ..yatharth nishkarsh yehi hai ..

 

Add your argument:

why should I ? attitude

idea posted by R. Rajagopalan Sr.vice president, CUMI

while I agree withthe question, the fact is things are changing a bit. The major reason what I could see is, due to years of experience, make them comfortable, profit or no profit, they get their salary. many do side business and" other" income. it is like frying the frog story....once you get used to ceratin comforts, itis difficult to change........ whu should I? no need.  5 days, no work or less work. no timings ( flexi).... visit  one old Govt office...........

But youngsters, are different

2
0
  

Yes, this is the the reason, Why should when there is a secured job with pension and all. No one in a Govt job will think about to even send an application for a new job since they know that they have a job which they wont lose because of management and other politics

0
  
by Ajay Ziz, Dy. Registrar,, University of Jammu  | 04 08 2010 09:41:34 +0000

aaj kare so kaal kar .. kal kare so parso ..

aisi file latkavain gein . bhagwaan bhi hove confused Narso..

Add your argument:

Comfort Levels

idea posted by Ravindra Sharma Managing Consultant, CHEF-India

Most people provided that level of comfort levels and lack of process ownership is bound to fall prey. To say the are inefficient or lazy do not know the job is not at all the truth especially if said for majority.

People working for Government have better knowledge of rules and procedures as compared to private sectors and it is solely lack of process ownership that makes them get into 'avoid as far as one can" attitude. 

2
0
  
by Ravindra Sharma, Managing Consultant, CHEF-India  | 04 20 2010 06:03:44 +0000

Thanks for participating Mr Arikrishnan,

Yes and there are excellent performers as well but lack of consistency brings the effect to zilch or negative as there are many more out to negate the good.

Problem is lack of process ownership and accountability, once these two are put in place missed opportunities or wrong decisions shall be questionable. Objectivity, Logic and Why you do what you do is completely lost out to procedures and oneupmanship to appease and obtain benefits. 

1
  

Thanks for the referral Mr. Ravindra Sharma Ji.

Yes you are right. It would be worth mentioning here that the government jobs are first well secured than the private organizations. The feeling of security in their minds make them not to contribute effective/quality performance in their jobs. This is because they can not be questioned or grilled by their superiors who are also normally, of course not all, having the same attitude. This kind of nature make govt. employees to become inefficient. Hence without concentrating much on their jobs, of course a take it easy attitude, they are coming to office in the morning & going home in the evening. Therefore, it becomes a comfort zone for them.

It may please be noted that in govt job in case any one take initiative to do a job, he will be questioned as WHAT INTEREST YOU HAVE GOT ON THAT PARTICULAR CASE?

Suppose, if he is not taking any initiative & awaiting his superior nod, he will be treated as lazy and will be questioned as is it not your duty to do the job and why are waiting and what for ?  here what for sounds...

Because of this, the employees loosing interest to do their jobs. As a result, there is inadequate opportunity for them to sharp their brain, lacking motivation, and becoming not efficient , They are doing what they are asked to do by their immediate boss. Nobody is going to sack them and their jobs are secured till retirement. Therefore the working atmosphere give them a COMFORT ZONE & TAKE IT EASY ATTITUDE.

Is it possible in private companies?       

Add your argument:

Non-existence of proper performance metrics

idea posted by kiranksrs National Head, IRIS SERVICES

I think Govt are less confident about finding new jobs because of non-existence of proper performance metrics in the government offices. In most of the govt offices, you will be promoted irrespective of your performance after certain period. For example, in DRDO, for every three years, you will get promoted to next level irrespective of the employee performance. Coming to Private organizations, your future career path depends on your present performance, so in order to move survive or move ahead, you need to perform. And also, you will be challenged by the new employees constantly which leads you to upgrade your skill sets frequently.

1
1
  

I agree with mr.srinivasans statement that a very systamatic working atmosphear in the govt agencies , when switched to pvt sector they work efficiently.we can also see this in many banking officials switching to pvt and proved too good .

Add your argument:

Power and money making opportunity through currupt practices deters Govt servant to look for other opportunities

idea posted by K LAXMINARAYANA RAO Freelancer

Gone are the days when Government jobs gave respect in society for a person. To day it is the power and the opportunity to make money through currupt practice that attracts Government jobs. Some people also become slaves of politicians - politicaal bosses, gets opportunity to buy degrees, amase  wealth, and start liking such life. After all where is the need to switch from Government job to Private. Private is complementary to Governemnt. They are the other side of the coin. They give money to get their jobs done. They are the instruments for the Government people.

1
No supporting Arguments for this idea
Add your argument:

Kings in their so - called palaces

idea posted by Jaya Ray Manager, KyaZoonga.com

They are the kings in their self - proclaimed palaces, where they call the shots and the whole world is at their feet, asking their favour to get a simple file passed or a plan to be approved. By doing so - they feel they have obliged the entire human race and hence should be rewarded.

Now this is a phase which will be there till they are in their comfortable chairs which even they are aware of. The moment they are out of that chair, they are no body. so - make hay while the sun shines - thats the motto every govt employee believes and follows religiously. who knows - if tomorrow, possibly their sector gets privatised- they dont have a job anymore, as such kind of jobs exist ONLY and ONLY in the govt department in India, on this planet, and no where else!!

1
0
  

Hmm... I believe that too. Might as well keep take my BANDOOK out of my SANDOOK... ;)

0
  
by Ravindra Sharma, Managing Consultant, CHEF-India  | 04 19 2010 09:12:42 +0000

Makrand, let's be cautious in our celebrate .......because this Mandook has the Bandook (All the Power), May I  add. 

0
  

Support thisd idea completely. I especially like what Ziz sahab has said and Ravindra's, "KOOP - MANDOOK" ... :)

Add your argument:

lazyness

idea posted by Tarun Kumar Verma MBA/PGDM student, IIScs

they know , they have a job which is permanently nobody claim to him.so they do a other things like business,for more earning.

0
No supporting Arguments for this idea
Add your argument:

Switch-over from Non profitable to Profitable requirement

idea posted by KALIYAMOORTHY Oil & Gas Area Coordinator, Undisclosed

Many of govt agencies are non-profitable. So, when an employee look for jobs in profitable business concern. It looks bit indifferent. Though they may have repository of knowledge & skills, they find difficult to use in proper applications. Need be there, a capsule of orientation training before they enter.

0
No supporting Arguments for this idea
Add your argument:

Lack of SKILL and WILL issue

idea posted by Rana Deep Bhattacharyya Executive Officer, HSBC Holdings

For obvious reasons I would say that the Govt employees lack on many and varieties of major concerning factors required for the up-bringing of the company and potray an image of the Organisation to the common public. Quite obvious that the Govt service exams (written) are quite tuff to crack but what matters the most are the its after effect. It is very rare seen or heard that few Govt sectors are providing manful hours towards the replinishment and honing the SKILL set of their employees hence effecting the employees WILL towards applying towards other sectors and the result is in front of us everyday and in every walk of life, wherein we complain about the Govt employees not working up to the mark.

Hence, I believe that ' SKILL ' and ' WILL ' issue's are the factors why the govt emp are less confident in finding new jobs which I beleive walk hand-in-hand towards the make or break of the company's pride.

0
No supporting Arguments for this idea
Add your argument:

lazy ness

idea posted by Sundraj Thapa Business Manager, Rochester Investment consulting pvt ltd

cos they dont have confidence in them to find a new job other than govt job . so they dont put any kind of effort in which they can gain a success, but for that they feel so difficulty or lack of confidence and communication .

0
No supporting Arguments for this idea
Add your argument:

lazy nature in work

idea posted by anuradha as faculty teach in this institute, parallel infotech pvt ltd

mostly goverment sector person  not work their work properly they  know very well that after loss this job iam not manage in private sector . bcz now i have totally lazy in my work besides comaprison to govt to private. i will do very work hard int that job

0
No supporting Arguments for this idea
Add your argument:

Do not want take risk

idea posted by Srinivasa Varrey Sr Architect, Peak Technologies

The whole idea is itself questionable. Before coming to a conclusion, you need to compare  apple to apple. You need to compare the same age group, then you need to ask reasons for changing job. 

0
No supporting Arguments for this idea
Add your argument:

Add your Idea
Idea* : 
Add your argument:
edit in rich text ...
Could not find any idea interesting in: "Govt staff less confident about finding new jobs " ? Click here to add a new idea...

Found the idea contest "Govt staff less confident about finding new jobs "  interesting ?  Click here to refer to your connections and communities
Leading recruitment Firm, Permanent Staffing, Temporary Staffing, Executive Search & Selection, and RPO
  • Create a confidential Career Profile and Resume/C.V. online
  • Get advice for planning their career and for marketing of experience and skills
  • Maximize awareness of and access to the best career opportunities
Viewers also viewed
According to a survey conducted by Team Lease, a staffing company, about 89 percent of...
 
1126 referals 66 arguments, 935 views
In a recent study, it said that attractive women faced discrimination when they applied for jobs...
 
646 referals 71 arguments, 2173 views
I have seen some queries coming in very regularly about job offers. Whena person gets job in two...
 
1952 referals 23 votes, 1294 views
more...  
Recent Knowledge (4)
When we are watching news channels or any other channel or reading news papers you bump upon...
 
2022 referals 14 votes, 346 views
we all know the perils of talking on cell phones while driving. besides being hazourdous to...
 
290 referals 2 votes, 46 views
more...  
More From Author
The National Sample Survey Organization(NSSO) discovered in its survey that almost half the country's farmers would abandon farming if they could find another occupation. If the FARMER does not grow food what will we eat ??? It is not like...
Today I read these three diferrent news story related to environment. 1. Desert geopark in China : What is a geopark ? Geopark is a place where rare geological landforms are preserved in an undisturbed state and where low impact recreation,...
The local currency dropped by Rs 1.24 against the dollar to close at 49.58 and is now expected to further weaken to below Rs 50 against the dollar. One dollor right now is equal to 49.58 Rs and time is not far when it will be more than Rs 50!...
more...