Build your professional network on facebook via our app Go to app
 
 
Posted in Community :

HR Professionals

 
Industry : Human Resources (HR) ConsultingFunctional Area : Organizational Development(People Management)
Activity:  28 views;  last activity : 06 29 2011 18:32:11 +0000

Let me take you through a case study.

This is about 4 employees Radha (26 yrs/Engaged to Avinash/working/ Ambitious) John (bachelor, 20 yrs old ) Avinash( 30 yrs old/ Engaged to Radha, Dominating character) Aslam (45 yr old/ married and settled in life/ superior in the org)

Avinash doesnt want Radha to be working at his level. John is a buddy to Radha but still is jealous of her acheivements. Aslam feels women should not be working, kind of a ancient bugger.

The management makes a decision to move the supervisor out of the org and make one of the 4 as the new supervisor. Radha is chosen as the new supervisor.

The rest of the guys are not happy with her promotion.

Scenario - The business make a profit of 10 crores every year. And the last year it was 12 crores. Suddenly management says to her that she should make 10 crores in the next 2 quaters (6months). Radha doesnt have any choice since if she doesnt make it Avinash will be promoted in her place. And avinash is so upset with Radha that he will ditch her if she fails then. Also he is not happy to work under her as he is engaged to her.
Aslam is a senoir guy and feels very bad to report to radha, john is ok to report to Radha but has evil intentions in his mind about Radha.

What would you suggest Radha should she reach out to you for help ??

 
Share
 
 
  Rate : 
 
 
 
 
  2 0 0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1 2 3
1 productive environment.- Transperency with clear thoughts & Ideas
2 Be clear to them...
3 Be clear to them....
Ideas in: "HR Case Study"

productive environment.- Transperency with clear thoughts & Ideas

idea posted by Amit Ranjan Regional HR - North India, Maclellan Integrated Services India Pvt Ltd

As far as Radha is concerned, I would say that both business and personal life are two different Extremes and one should not mix up the business with the personal life. If Avinash is so much worried about the happenings, It clearly shows that he doesnt have any work - Life balance. He need to be made understood about the situation clearly and Radha is promoted only for the reason that she is performing. Avinash should be happy instead of being worried to share that radha is a performer.

As far as john is concerned, Organizational politics would surely evolve in any organizational setup. It is the responsibility of each individual in the organization, to direct the organizational politics to a productive way.

Aslam, as mentioned, is a superior guy who would really would have worries in reporting to a person who is younger then him. This is where the issue of experience/ performance based appraisal system takes place. Aslam and every other person in the organization should be clearly explained about the metrics through which radha is promoted. There should be a transparent appraisal system. This would make aslam to actually realize the gap between his and radha's performance. He should also be motivated in a manner that he would also perform in order to get his promotion.

If Radha could carry out all these suggestions, I hope the situtation would turn out into a productive environment.


Looking forward for the others to comment and make corrections in the solution....

2
0
  
by Anubhuti Sharaf, MBA student, University of Pune  | 06 27 2011 10:26:57 +0000

Definately, depends on Radha, to manage the situation. As far as Avinash is concerned,sometimes it happens but have no relation with the professional life. The only reason of worry for Avinash is that Radha is working in the same company. So this can be managed between them how they can avoid or resolve the imbalance. John can be said as a representative of all those people who are making Radha's job, a challenge. So, productive way of doing work is only solution to such problem. And Alsam's case is well explained above.

Add your argument:

Be clear to them...

idea posted by Gargi Sinha Senior Consultant, Hewitt Associates

Indeed the condition of Radha is very pathetic. But Iam more unhappy with the attitude of Avinash. Its a regular trend men don't like women to be more successful than them. Radha should not mix work and personal life and should say the same thing to Avinash. If he cannot cope up with this situation, there is no need to pull this relation further as it shows Avinash will dominate her for the entire life and would never give her freedom.

As far as Jhon and Aslam (old fashioned) are concerned, if they have problem with Radha's success, they should perform better than her. If they can't, then silently should obey Radha and blame themselves not her. Radha shouldn't be disturbed with all this as in an organisation, always there are people who will try to be against your success. Even best friends. So, rather than worrying, she should say all these things to these three and if something happens to their friendly relations because of this, still there is nothing to worry since its better not to have this kind of friends who can't see a friend's success...

0
No supporting Arguments for this idea
Add your argument:

Be clear to them....

idea posted by pragati parihar MBA/PGDM student, banasthali university,jaipur
It should be clear to the employees in the organisation, hence more productive.
0
No supporting Arguments for this idea
Add your argument:

Add your Idea
Idea* : 
Add your argument:
edit in rich text ...
Could not find any idea interesting in: "HR Case Study" ? Click here to add a new idea...

Found the idea contest "HR Case Study"  interesting ?  Click here to refer to your connections and communities
A executive search and recruitment firm
SVA, OOPs, ASIC Verification Lead, A Leading (ICT) Indian MNC, Ahmedabad
Verilog, Vera, Sr. Engineer /Engineer,
C, C++, ASIC Engineer (Should know Japanese language), A Leading (ICT)
Viewers also viewed
Why are employees in some companies happy to stick with the company while others look for a...
 
1178 referals 11 votes, 1600 views
If we imagine of a best world where people are very happy with there jobs, co-workers, salaries...
 
512 referals 54 arguments, 2364 views
It is a general situation everywhere. Employee attrition is on rise with companies losing their...
 
1066 referals 39 arguments, 940 views
more...  
Recent Knowledge (15)
Everyone needs to show that he/she is different and can do things which others cannot. But as...
 
1103 referals 13 votes, 112 views
Please give out every possible logical and rational idea which is practical in present context.
 
81 referals 5 votes, 130 views
The question is simple. What makes you smile? Let us stop fighting on various topics and discuss...
 
1697 referals 27 votes, 361 views
more...  
More From Author
HAVE. No FEAR. If you were afraid of nothing, what goals would you set? What could you accomplish? What would you do if nothing scared you or made you nervous? Fear stops success. For example, a woman who wants to get married, but she is afraid...
The one to be Blamed..... A Boy was born to a couple after eleven years of marriage. They were a loving couple and the boy was the gem of their eyes. When the boy was around two years old, one morning the husband saw a medicine bottle open. He...
After years of experience in job and feedbacks from friends in other industry led to following list of things that we should have known and should know when we start our career. Just add your thoughts on the same to make the list comprehensive...
more...