Build your professional network on facebook via our app Go to app
 
<< Prev  28 of 32 in Topic  Next >>
Topic : politics of india
  Rate : 
 
Industry : Public Sector/GovernmentFunctional Area : Politics(Personal Interests)
Activity:  24 views;  last activity : 08 28 2010 14:23:17 +0000

In work machinery in Indian politics, the decision of how to take forward the nation lies on the hands of POLITICIANS. Its their ideas (in consultation with experts most of the time) that can take our nation ahead.

But ignorance or lack of standard qualification to manage a particular portfolio by a minister might jeopardize any project however beneficial it would be.

Therefore as rightly said by Mr. Narayana murthy (infosys cahirman) in today's daily (11/8/10), that there should be some basic training for those aspiring politicians to better appreciate the project responsibility handed out to them.

We are no longer just a mere nation, but a global democratic giant and whose each step towards progress is watched with keen eyes world over.

So, I am asking for all participants to pour their ideas as to what should be a minimum or necessary qualification for the various portfolios that our government ministers handles.

Please provide your idea and mention the targeted portfolio like: Home, Finance, Petroleum, Aviation, Railways, Roadways, Shipping, Telecom, Defence, External affairs, Education, Health etc.

 
 Refer 452
Share
 
 
  Rate : 
 
 
 
 
  3 0 0 0 0
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1 2 3 4 5
1 Political Ex change (like BSE and NSE)
2 Health: Minimum MBBS along with managementarial qualification
3 Education: Phd with some experience as principal or director of an institution..
4 Political
5 Minimum Post graduation for respective fields + experience
6 Honesty and committment is required
7 MANAGEMENT GRADUATES /POST GRADUATES WITH EXPERIENCE IN PRIVATE SECTOR
8 Ph.D laloo style...

Political Ex change (like BSE and NSE)

idea posted by Prashant Bhurke Manager, Sales and Operations, Sony Computer entertainment - Playstation
  • Will Be controlled by A Body like (sebi)
  • All People can buy in the shares of the person they want, to lead India.
  • The candidature will Be based on the Spread (width) of the Share Purchase and Not by No of shares Held BY the Rich.
  • A single Commitee (Chaired BY Members in planning commision, Imminenet Lawyers, Defence, Economist and trade experts)
  • For any Politicians to offer his candidature has to comply with certain norms and conditions.
  • As the value of his shares fall, he will have to SHOW - CAUSE or else his candidature will be Terminated.
  • Guidelines, to gauge the performance can be then like variable PAY ( performance linked)
3
0
  

@ Dr. Siva Adarsh,

Stock market is not for me, i was amazed to see such an influential trade happening during my PG days, this idea rose from that.

Mind you this is just and Idea, its form or intricacies can be moderated, changed, developed etc. etc.

My understading Behind this System is very clear,

  • i want Educated People to take control of Indian Politics ( which YOu and me will agree is heading No where)
  • doing this can curb Corruption to a greater extent.

1
  

Phew Prashant!

You must be a share market freak 8-). Sounds really interesting. But then for this to happen, first of all we need to educate each and every citizen of our nation. Only an educated person will be able to judge a candidates performance as to how beneficial it is to him and as well to the nation and buy his shares.

In politics, this will help in identifying ones popularity among the masses. But what about selecting the right candidate for a particular job? will that be first assigned by the committee and then asked from the public as, would they be interested in giving such a post to that individual.

If all political parties assigns who will hold what portfolio before the election begins, then public can decide better even by the present voting system. Similar things happens in colleges where each candidate is contesting for a particular post and if he gets majority he will be in the cabinet irrespective of the party to which he represents. This is what I have seen during my PG studies in Kerala.

Add your argument:

Health: Minimum MBBS along with managementarial qualification

idea posted by Dr. Siva Adarsh Consultant, Metabolic Disease & Research, Narayana Hrudayalaya

Health is one field where our nation stands low. this is partly because the person handling the post is neither aware of the sensitivities and understanding of the requirements of the nation in health scenario.

Just like the requirements of Kitchen is best identified by the person manning it. Similarly the health sector development can only be appreciated by a person who has been in that particular field.

But merely being in that field doesn't make the person competent to manage the issue on a national scale, this requires the person to have some additional training or qualification to suffice that lacunae.

therefore i believe, as far as health portfolio is concerned, the person holding that post should have at least a basic MBBS qualification with experience together with some Administrative training or similar course qualification.

0
No supporting Arguments for this idea
Add your argument:

Education: Phd with some experience as principal or director of an institution..

idea posted by Deepak Kubal Media Coresspondent, Media House

Education ministers should hold a Phd degree with a sufficient experience in relevant field. Like a principal or director of an educational institute. Where he understand the wants of student and parents. Which will help him to bring some good laws..... which will improve the education system....   

0
0
  

At least we now have a person in HRD ministry who seems to know and understand the pain and burden that the present generation school children bear.

Its another fact that many of us dont want to accept any change in this section. A debatable issue in itself :-)

Add your argument:

Political

idea posted by Princy Singla Fresher, Tech Mahindra

ignorance or lack of standard qualification to manage a particular portfolio by a minister might jeopardize any project however beneficial it would be.

 there should be some basic training for those aspiring politicians to better appreciate the project responsibility handed out to them and illetrate people should not be allowed to enter in political field

0
No supporting Arguments for this idea
Add your argument:

Minimum Post graduation for respective fields + experience

idea posted by Sivakumar Krishnamurthy Head/VP/GM-R&D, Torium Consulting (P) Ltd

If it requires a PG for any fresher to even get a job these days, why should these people be spared? Honestly, there has to be some scale for these people who lead the nation and are the sole representatives for the country

Also I am in with the idea that these people should not be given a chance to be in any post for more than 2 terms giving way for younger people to come in and SHOULD quit the position at mutually agreed superannuation age

After all, if experienced MBA's can run an organization WHY CAN THEY NOT RUN A COUNTRY?

 

0
No supporting Arguments for this idea
Add your argument:

Honesty and committment is required

idea posted by Srinivas suravajhala Asst. Manager.

Honesty, commitment and leadership qualities are the minimum required qualifications.  He need to have a vision, ability to understand the subject is holding as a minister of such ministry.He need not be proficient to hold a ministry.  Bureaucracy system is there to help them.

0
No supporting Arguments for this idea
Add your argument:

MANAGEMENT GRADUATES /POST GRADUATES WITH EXPERIENCE IN PRIVATE SECTOR

idea posted by s.baalu Consultant, XYZ LTD

WE SHOULD IDENTIFY CAPABLE,EXPERIENCED PEOPLE IN PVT SECTOR AS IN THE CASE OF MR. NILEKENI FOR UID IF WE ARE SINCERELY INTERESTED IN BUILDING OUR NATION.

0
0
  

Like Mr. Nandan N, there are countless number of people who are actually carrying out the ground work.

Mr.Nandan is not holding any portfolio. It is under some ministry ( I am not aware of). its just that his name got highlighted because of media who brought the actual person behind this project. In  fact the ministerial person got sidelined at least in this regard.

Similar efforts have been put forward in all other fields, but only the ministry takes the spotlight.

Even our former president Dr. APJ Kalam, also was a scientific advisor to PM and was never known (to general public of his contribution) untill he became president.

Add your argument:

Ph.D laloo style...

idea posted by Ajay Ziz Dy. Registrar,, University of Jammu
doctrate in the school of life !!
0
0
  

8-) He is veteran in that field. But I doubt others can emulate him.

Add your argument:

Add your Idea
Idea* : 
Add your argument:
edit in rich text ...
Could not find any idea interesting in: "Political Qualifications" ? Click here to add a new idea...

Found the idea contest "Political Qualifications"  interesting ?  Click here to refer to your connections and communities
Redefining Recruitment
  • Create a confidential Career Profile and Resume/C.V. online
  • Get advice for planning their career and for marketing of experience and skills
  • Maximize awareness of and access to the best career opportunities
Viewers also viewed
You might have tons of degrees but in the end do they matter. How much is a BE + MBA is paid?...
 
2182 referals 50 arguments, 669 views
Politics is not only there to decide who forms the government, but also the politics has rubbed...
 
1709 referals 21 votes, 3282 views
Yes college politics should be band. vs Yes college politics should not be band.
 
299 referals 12 arguments, 912 views
more...  
Recent Knowledge (4)
we all know the perils of talking on cell phones while driving. besides being hazourdous to...
 
290 referals 2 votes, 36 views
 
202 referals 3 votes, 125 views
more...  
More From Author
A vague question. I believe you r not referring to Dr. Jayalalitha, Dr.Rajkumar or even proposed Dr. Tendulkar(who humbly refused) :-D We actually need more of good/efficient doctors, but even then the problem doesnt solve, as no good doctors will be...
In today's world anything can mint money if properly put up. Working with your dreams will provide you utmost satisfaction and if you can channelize it to mint money as well...Sone pe Suhaga!
One's daily expenses are the things that would in all probability continue even in future. So calculate how much it totals per month. Double the amount for every ten years that you choose as the time to get a corpus (ideally @ retirement age) whose...
more...