Build your professional network on facebook via our app Go to app
 
 1 of 19 in Topic  Next >>
Topic : Internal Security in India
  Rate : 
Associated with other topics :
  Rate : 
 
Started by : Dayanand Deshpande, Senior Consultant, Ernst & Young   10 16 2009 12:22:25 +0000
Industry : Radio, TV & FilmsFunctional Area : Politics(Personal Interests)
Activity:  256 views;  last activity : 07 06 2010 20:18:09 +0000

It has been seen that, in the recent times, there have been many cases which have imposed a threat to the internal security of India. We could see lot of terrorist activities, corruption, maoist activities and many more which is dis balancing our internal peace. So, in this regard, I want to ask you, according to you people what are the different factors which effect India's internal security factors. What are the factors which occurs as a threat to our internal security?
Please post you valuable comments....

 
 Refer 987
Share
 
 
  Rate : 
 
 
 
 
  5 3 2 2 2
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
1 2 3 4 5
1 WE... The People !
2 MORE PARA/MILITARY INVOLVEMENT IN DECISION MAKING
3 Ineffective tackling of Maoist's
4 Attitude of We Indians
5 Political Environment & Govt.......
6 Bread and Butter
7 There are several factor effecting India's internal security
8 d factors r...........
9 3 P
10 running from responsibilities
11 Inefficient Economy
12 High Crime rates on cyber Space
13 Ethnic Militancy
14 Corrupt People manning critical systems like all parts of judicial delivary including police
15 yes we indian............... who born with lack of nation love................

WE... The People !

idea posted by Naushad H.L. Creative Director, MAD COMMUNICATION

My take on this is very simplistic but realistic...

Its WE... The People, who are responsible for our Country's Internal Security. If we decide to be Hindustani by heart n soul, No one, I repeat No one has the gumption to come & create terror & unrest in our motherland.

Let us be INDIANS first... then belong to different religions. Let us unite & decide that any person, whoever He or She may be... If they are against the Country, they should be dealt with in the severest manner. Religion & Social standing can go take a ride. Lets all for a change ' Look beyond our noses ' ,,, stop debating and start acting.

Believe me all of this will slow down & come to a stop. Lets stop being Gujarat, Assam, Arunachal, Kashmir, Tamilnadu, Karnataka, Bengal... Lets start being INDIA.

JAI HIND !   

5
1
  
by Manoj T P, Area Sales Manger, INALSA (Tuareg Marketing Pvt ltd)  | 10 22 2009 13:59:33 +0000

Yes we the people who are now becoming more & more self centered and manipulated by Politicians with no National vision. A person who cleans his house but dumps the garbage in the public area or neighbor's  property. A person finds faults with the government for any thing and every thing and thinks it as some body's job etc etc ( We in Kerala Probably will go for Harthals too ) 

 It is a true fact that India is politically united by the British and the tactics of their political system is re branded & utilized. It is a game of nos and minority appeasement / reservation campaigns in the name of cast creed etc at local level to cross the Vote numbers and then demand his share over the big country's resources. Also you have education system suiting to different states but not for united India.

& There is an escapist route to the Brainy by becoming an NRI and so on & so forth

Until we the people decides to have a strong central government, policies & education to promote Nationalism, the problems will recur. 

 

 

 

 

0
  
by Nitin Kuchhal, Business Development, ...................  | 10 20 2009 08:42:59 +0000

Nothing shouts out loud than this... "WE ... THE PEOPLE".

Indeed it is US who make ourselves vulnerable to such shallowness within.

Country is BY the People, For the People & OF the People.

1
  
by S. Muralidharan, Executive Director, Knowledge Foundation & Campus Around the Corner  | 10 19 2009 15:25:36 +0000

We, the people, are responsible for this malady.  How? you may ask!  In the democratic India, we are only left with one right - that is - Voting Right!  We do not even know how to exercise our Voting Right! We have premier Management Institutions (IIMs) and B-Schools.  Let them use their expertise to train our people as to how to exercise their franchise. 

We are in total anarchy! We have allowed and turned a handful of otherwise, low caliber people, into giants in the eyes of public.  Inequity, Injustice, Corruption in all corners, weakened judiciary, every one wants to wield power and misuse them.  In reality, four hundred and odd people rule 115 cr. population at ease! Sardar Patel toiled to unite the Princely States.  The Rajas and Maharajas descending from various dynasties had faith in their Prajas and Almighty!  Taking their kingdom, making them too small under the garb of democracy, we have created and are creating dynasty of politicians!  Who is at fault?

The so called four pillars of democracy (Executive, Legislature, Judiciary and the Media) are shaky.  We have one Sridharan to mend the pillars, if found cracky, in the Metro Network, however, we have failed to produce as many Sridharans as possible to attend these cracked pillars. 

Let there be unity and the like-minded people join hands to disseminate and educate the people of this country to bring about a just leadership for building a very Strong Nation, called, India!  If we don't do it, we would be answerable to our next generation! 

JAI HIND! 

Add your argument:

MORE PARA/MILITARY INVOLVEMENT IN DECISION MAKING

idea posted by Mel Davidson Partner, GlobaDesignTech

 

     Obviously the political mileage factor meter has influenced National Security, which thing is counterproductive in the long run; in fact, it borders on treason and constitutional infringement. The time has come for India to face the responsibility of having democratic freedom: allow the paradox of giving security forces more say in matters that deal with the violent elements of internal opposition to the established and elected status quo! One cannot negotiate the blood of children and innocent bystander citizens on political terms alone: there must be something to counterpoise the election carrots. The late president Roosevelt once said the success of a democratic leadership team is to "... talk softly and carry a BIG stick!"

     The reference to a 'Veerappan Factor' when mentioning Maoist or Naxalite insurgencies is to say the least an indication of serious national treason on the part of the various political individuals who might be indirectly shielding these rebellious elements that violate not only law and order, but also the very constitutional fabric of the nation itself! So, all this to say that: soft pedaling security issues and cuddling national traitors is probably more to the point, when focusing on what the ills of India's current social ills are about.

     Addressing the development issues that have given rebels and traitors a base to work their evil intentions from is not to be ignored; however, to my experience this is insufficient to deal with the actual grassroots ground-reality local security agencies must face daily; politicians who fail to do their jobs must be held responsible and the diverse mafia entities that accompany them must be dealt with according to national security parameters, no less!

3
0
  
by Ajay Ziz, Dy. Registrar,, University of Jammu  | 10 21 2009 10:30:31 +0000

mel now you are more specific :: we will be in touch :: god willing

1
  
by Mel Davidson, Partner, GlobaDesignTech  | 10 21 2009 10:25:40 +0000

Ajay!

     First of all, I'm neither English nor American, but have lived in India for 30 years and have an Indian Family. Second, dear friend, theoretically to hypothesize about the bitter struggle of rural downtrodden to cope with the avarice of the upper classes and the unscrupulous hatred of the violent terrorist is a mute subject. One must get out of the classroom and into the dirty ditches of the struggle to feel the blood, sweat, and tears of the victims, before any meaningful statements can be made. Sweeping statements and casual comments to tantalize the intellect is a scant value in this type of discussion.

     The various metaphoric inserts from your pen are to me not amusing or constructive; I am looking for something more meaningful and comprehensive to tackle this deep-seated problem that knows no borders or nationality in a general sense. Obviously, we are discussing India's internal security problems, and as such must take note of the peculiar Indian situation, agreed; nevertheless, my friend, I seriously doubt the advantage of bias you seem to nurture in assessing the statements presented here in this forum. Mel

 

0
  
by Ajay Ziz, Dy. Registrar,, University of Jammu  | 10 21 2009 07:49:47 +0000

mel system nurtures an issue/terrorist org( track 3 diplomacy ) feeds it  and cripples it whenever it desires ..

same hold true for netas .netas are planted by the system on the basis of population corerelation ..

mel if u r an indian then only you will visualise this ..logic..

india .. it's ground realities are different than the US/UK

Add your argument:

Ineffective tackling of Maoist's

idea posted by Dayanand Deshpande Senior Consultant, Ernst & Young

In my view, Maoist (Naxalite) movements have gripped a significantly large portion of India and presently pose one of the most serious threats to our internal security. Though the “ideology” and the “methodology” may be imported, the basic causes are indigenous. There is a wide-spread perception that “land reforms” and efforts at redressal of genuine grievances have only been superficial and that the “exploiters” continue to “exploit” the poor and the landless agriculturists.

A majority of India’s small farmers have been facing severe economic problems due to various factors, including globalization, credit crunch, non-inclusive economic progress etc. It would not be difficult for the Maoists to project themselves as the sole protectors of the poor farmer’s interests and the militant way as the only viable redressal procedure available to them. Some recently announced relief measures, including the “revolutionary” farm loan waiver scheme, are very welcome steps, but they should be the beginning and not the end of the many measures necessary to retrieve the poor farmers from the potential embrace of the Maoists. The perception of imbalanced subsidies, which is also a major source of alienation, needs to be overcome by introducing a more rational system.

2
1
  
by Kadal Amutham, Head R&D , Fifth Generation Technologies (P) Ltd  | 10 19 2009 07:27:24 +0000

Is there any link between verbal attack by Chinese Government on India w.r.t Arunachal Pradesh and the internal attack by Maoist?

Add your argument:

Attitude of We Indians

idea posted by Prakash Saitwal Technical Support Manager, Aditya Birla Management Corporation P. Ltd.

Our own attitude towards building a nation will make India a united, strong country and superpower. And our lack of positive attitude, will power will have just opposite effect.

For strong and internally secure India, we should display attitude of-

- raising above barriers of language, regionalism and strive on principles of "ONE INDIA".

- be pro-active in helping police/Government to tackle terrorism.

-show zero tolerance towards corruption.

-show politicians, who exploit regional sentiments to gain short term political mileage, their place.

 

 

2
1
  
by K.Uthirapathy , Bad Debts/Workouts Manager, Government of Puducherry  | 10 20 2009 16:25:45 +0000

I have been dealing the subject of security in a diffrent manner and aspect.Having closely studied the fundamentalist elements in our country I found that some vested interests create fundamentalism in the name of caste,religion,language only to satisfy their own personal interests.But unfortunately when the group grows things become uncotrollable even by the creator himself.And it takes its own toll.When fundamenmtalism has proliferated ,instead of finding the root cause and eradicate at the grass root level our law enforcing authorities attempt to destroy the groups but they pay a heavy cost in terms of money and lives.It can be definitely and assertively stated that any number of para military forces clubbed together could not do any miracles.Because they are managed by our bereaucrats.Till this management system exists,we cannot expect any concrete results.You would find that less number of forces with less failures and more number of forces with more failures.Unless the police commissions reprt is implemented there shall be no results in reality.

Add your argument:

Political Environment & Govt.......

idea posted by SUSHANT AWASTHI Business Operations

These are the main factors and Major Threats who are effecting India's Internal Security,.......

Why I am putting this idea u all know and want you to put your views in light to exactly know the weakeness in India Govt.......

It's all the corruption.....is responsible and corruption is still high because govt is allowing locals even every deptt to do.......

 

2
1
  
by Uday Uttam Kadam, Chef De Partis, Sammy's woodfired pizza  | 10 21 2009 06:51:21 +0000

yes. these polititions are mother of all bad thing .

0
  
by Ajay Ziz, Dy. Registrar,, University of Jammu  | 10 20 2009 09:17:21 +0000

awasthi i support you but just imagine the junta of UP & BIHAR ( major contributors of Parliament)

taking the lead & working on your idea .

p.s. awasthi's are from UP , am i right ??

Add your argument:

Bread and Butter

idea posted by gurminder dhir Associate Vice President ( Marketing), ISMT Ltd.

If everybody living in India at the very minimum will be able to have two square meals for him and his family by being gainfully employed in any legal activity then 99.9999.... % problem would be over.

Then after that gradually the question of Clothing, Housing , Sanitation , Envirinioment ,Education,Health etc. etc. will have to be tackled by Indian Political setup.

Rest 0.0000......% problems can be easily taken care by our security appratus.

1
0
  
by K.Uthirapathy , Bad Debts/Workouts Manager, Government of Puducherry  | 10 20 2009 16:32:01 +0000

Unfortunately in our country people do not want employment but want only bread and butter and in turn they state that the same is only social justice.

Add your argument:

There are several factor effecting India's internal security

idea posted by birander singh dhankher Private practitioner/Lawyer, birander sngh & co.

1. Corruption giving rise to unequal distribution among the public. 2. lack of moral character in the society particularly among our Leaders. 3. Lack of political will in the indian leadership.4. Lack of patriotism and disregard for the country.5. Form of Democracy which is being used by the indian leaders in their favour for their own benefits.6. Non-promotion to the Honest,Intelligent,brave and dutiful officers and promotion to inefficient,dishonest and weak officers in the govt. deptt.

1
No supporting Arguments for this idea
Add your argument:

d factors r...........

idea posted by Suraj P. Shukla M.A student, University Of Mumbai

The factors which affecting India's internal security is we are. we who not gvng attention towards d our nation, our responsbilities 7 gvng blaim to our security. the main factors r our POLITICIAN, who just divide nation on the name of cast, creed & race. They r playing an important role in destroying security.
IN hindi there is 1 quote "AGAR DISHA SAHI RAHEGI TO, DASAA BHI SAHI HOGAI"

 

SO WE HAV TO GVE MORE ATTENTION TO OUR PEOPLE........

1
0
  
by Kumbakonam S Venkataraman, Associate Editor, Dynamic Youth online magazine  | 10 27 2009 19:38:48 +0000

Yes. We may go on listing out the reasons like Naxalites, Maoism, Regionalism, Caste conflicts, labor indiscipline and so on. But behind each one of these you would see a dirty politician's face.

About thousand years ago, it was the selfishness of our rajas that opened the door for foreign aggressors. The result was that about 1000 years of foreign rule, directly or indirectly, was imposed on India. Even now the disturbing legacies of such foreign influences bother us a lot.

Most of the today's politicians, who want to carve out an empire of himself and his family within India, divides the people in the name of religion, caste, region, language and so on. They do not allow the spirit of one nation to give roots in any part of India. This is the most dangerous factor affecting our Internal Security.

They would start arguing that India is a vast country, having a number of languages and cultural variations. So what? While respecting them all, we may emerge as a united strong nation. But our politicians do not want this. Some of them would want to impose Hindi; and some others would make it an issue and try to keep the people divided. Similarly every conceivable thing like religion, caste etc., is used by them to keep the people divided.

We should teach the people that they are Indians first and then only other classifications should be thought of. Improving our political standards and developing patriotism among our people should receive topmost priority.

Add your argument:

idea posted by TARANJIT SINGH Client Servicing/Key Account Manager, CENTRAL PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT

for a healthy and good industry 3M are involved i.e. Men,Machine and Material,and for healthy and strong country 3R are involved i.e. Politicians,Police and Press, when these 3 R are working for thrmself only the health of a country shall automatically effected

0
No supporting Arguments for this idea
Add your argument:

running from responsibilities

idea posted by Megha Johari-MJ faculty, ACI (MASS COMM & MEDIA INSTITUTE)

We have thousands of brilliant plans & projects regarding the security for our country but the demerit lies in their improper implementation...if we all will start understanding our responsibilities for us & our nation 80% problems will automatically resolved...What we have to do is just concentrate on our work & our duties ...if every Indian will start thinking in this way definitely India soon will have a different scenario...a peaceful and developing INDIA...Few intruders are just baseless against the united standing indians,need is just to make our conscious awake and BE A REAL INDIAN & A REAL HUMAN....

JAI HIND

0
No supporting Arguments for this idea
Add your argument:

Inefficient Economy

idea posted by Mathew Cherian Research Associate/Analyst, Western Michigan University

Inefficient economy, poverty, mulnutrtion, lack of welfare, lack of Social Security, wrong political will, inefficient political agendas, lack of vision, no common goals for the citizen, class based transactions, inefficient democratic forces etc; etc; create threat to internal security for India.

0
No supporting Arguments for this idea
Add your argument:

High Crime rates on cyber Space

idea posted by Radhakrishna Marar Business Analyst, Oracle

I believe India is becoming notorious as a major originator of spam and “phishing” on the internet. Cyber-based economic offences like illegal money transfers to anti-social entities, laundering of black money, share market manipulation, bank frauds etc. are on the increase, though specific and reliable data is not available.

0
0
  
by K.Uthirapathy , Bad Debts/Workouts Manager, Government of Puducherry  | 10 20 2009 16:28:35 +0000

The present trend is that if you just make your mail ID public you would soon find how much disastrous consequences it causes at no time.

Add your argument:

Ethnic Militancy

idea posted by Himanshu Pathak Sr/Principal Coresspondent, Coresspondent

There has been some success over the years in handling ethno-centric militancy in the northeast. Successive governments in India have been following the dual path of negotiation on grievances and firm handling of violence. The near and long term prospects of this approach would very much depend on the fine tuning of the balance between the two paths and the drying up of external support or safe havens. The future would also depend on the relative strengths (real and perceived) of the government and the militant groups. If the latter are able to consolidate their positions and secure an advantage over the state - as had been happening in Sri Lanka - they may be tempted to escalate their demands to the point of a breakdown and reversion to violence. On the other hand, if the state negotiates from a position of demonstrated strength, these groups could weaken with the passage of time and may be inclined to accept the maximum benefits and honourable solutions offered; and rejoin the mainstream.

A potentially dangerous development is the “opportunistic” and “unprincipled” (but limited) international support to the declaration of independence by Kosovo. Ethnic separatists like ULFA, NSCN and those in Manipur could try speciously to apply the Kosovo precedent to their areas. The Government of India should therefore take note of this potential land-mine and be very careful in framing its reaction and response to the developments in Kosovo.

0
0
  
by Ajay Ziz, Dy. Registrar,, University of Jammu  | 10 19 2009 05:57:11 +0000

helen & troy :

booby traps

Add your argument:

Corrupt People manning critical systems like all parts of judicial delivary including police

idea posted by Murali Murugesan _,

The criminialisation of society begins with Criminals in Police Force and other sections of justice delivery systems.

 

The Police who are to curb criminal activities are manned partly by criminals then who can assure internal security

 

0
No supporting Arguments for this idea
Add your argument:

yes we indian............... who born with lack of nation love................

idea posted by Uday Uttam Kadam Chef De Partis, Sammy's woodfired pizza
First & foremost Indian people, second politicians, curreption, religion, so many.............
0
No supporting Arguments for this idea
Add your argument:

Add your Idea
Idea* : 
Add your argument:
edit in rich text ...
Could not find any idea interesting in: "What are the factors effecting india's internal security ?" ? Click here to add a new idea...

Found the idea contest "What are the factors effecting india's internal security ?"  interesting ?  Click here to refer to your connections and communities
Leading Recruitment Firm.
WE – an organized recruitment resolution services based at Bangalore, pioneer into manifold domain expertise, fanatical to optimize and import innovative recruitment solutions to all organizations, through uninterrupted custom-made services. Our success spans beyond our destiny. From a......
Viewers also viewed
In retail industry segment like Apparel and garment segment, Jewellery segment, mall, hand...
 
217 referals 19 arguments, 952 views
Even after 62 years of india's independence , the plight of commonman has worsened. Corrupt...
 
138 referals 94 arguments, 14918 views
It is said that India has a wealth of amazing places that is to be seen and appreciated and...
 
501 referals 29 votes, 12181 views
more...  
 
More From Author
How convenient it is to blame the government.. There are flaws in government and then there were always flaws there.. now we can see them clearly because many people are coming up and giving voice to the wrong practices..
It is a wonderful concept but we need a right plan to follow it. Just an idea wont help.
Bad news really bad news . 1) We should produce our own arms . 2) More arms means more fight. 3) Only arms would not ensure security.
more...