| Topic : Best Practices by HR |
|
|
Project Management ++ |
HR Professionals |
Customer Service & Relationship Management |
26 more ...|
|
Activity:
1012 views;
last activity : 03 04 2011 19:12:25 +0000
|
|
|
|
1
Stability Factor...............
2
Lousy attitude
3
Many a Reasons
4
Fitment is the main reason of Rejection....
5
Many a Reasons
6
REJECTION OF CANDIDATE
7
Common reasons for a candidate's rejection in an interview
8
Compatibility with boss
9
Lack of research.
10
Lack of experience
11
First Impression is the Last Impression
12
Attitude, poor communication sklls and stability
13
Attitude
14
Less Competent
15
Many Reasons
16
Lacking Integrity
17
Interviewer's Personalized views
18
clarity
19
Not asking questions
20
Lack of confidence
21
Frequent job changes
22
attend all question without knowing answer
23
First Impression
24
Senior Candidate
25
Simple is that you cannot judge person at one interview
26
an idea
27
Many resaons
28
Lousy attitude
29
Fitment & Cultural Issue
30
poor communication skills
31
Anantharaman Seshan-Head HR
32
Looking in the EYE while answering!
33
talkative
|
||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|
Following are some points which can lead to the rejection of candidate in any interview:- Stability Factor........if the person is not seems to be stable. Like keeps on changing his/her jobs in short time. Poor Communication.........it’s not only about talking in English or in any specific language it about conveying the proper message in proper manner. Job Knowledge..............some time people comes for interview for any particular post but if you ask any question regarding that field they don’t give a proper or satisfied answer which means they don’t know even about their own field and some times they just try too bluff instead of accepting it that they don’t know much about it.. This creates a negative impression. Un updated Resume.......If a candidate is coming without updated resume it really creates a very negative impression. Sometimes they write on the printed resume in order to update it. These are the points which can lead a candidate to the rejection in any interview. Many other points are also there but these are the most important. Regards, Rohini  |
13
|
I agree with Rohini on the fact that communication skill is major criteria for rejection of the candidate at initial stage as if a person is not able to express himself interms of the job expectation & responsibilties then probably he's not fit for any job which requires effective communication.
Moreover too casual or too formal approach is also another reason for non consideration followed by the unexpected & unjustified salary expectations.
it is attitude which decides ur altitude and not ur aptitude,so, if a candidate has the required  attitude w r t the overall job requirements/, then he will with out fail be well --prepared, informed,dressed, punctual and the body language will be confident as well.if a candidate can convince /sell ,her/himself w r t the job hoppings,lack of industry knowlegde,position , then nobody can stop her/him. take myself for e.g: in my 5 yrs' work ex, its my 4th industry and 4th organisation, and have ascended the Role as well, but coz i cud convince the interwier, hence, i have been thru.
|
|
Well i agree with Gargi on her Point but then everybody won't think like that, just because he is not having experience in the field doesn't make him that he is not eligible, if we do like that we might potentially loose a good candidate who could have been in the organization. For me to reject a candidate during the interview is like; |
6
|
ya i agree with nikhil jain.. as a fresher they don't know the exact job pofile for what they appear for. They just look for some skill sets thats it.. Some will not have good communication skill but they have very good knowledge in subjects but don't know how to express..
Cultural issue, Fitment, skill sets requirement all belong to the Organization climate which I think are internal issues of that Company or atmosphere but more than many, experience of an HR Manager to look into the candidates with a humanly touch and more so devoid of Nepotism and Despotism counts in INDIA.
|
|
In my openion...No one is good or bad resource in the industry... the thing which bother you to reject is fitment in the organization. |
4
|
I do agree with what Mahesh has proposed. It is absolutely the balance between the candidate and the organization based on certain factors like communication, technical expertise and so on.. which differs from one organization to the other.
|
|
I absolutely agree with Gargi and Nikhil Jain. If candidate is a fresh one and nobody wants to take a fresh candidte who will take them and how they will get an experience. Believe me I was the fifth ranker in the mumbai University (India) in Chemical Engineering in 2003, But it was very difficult to get job for me. Such situations ask candidate to do any job. He may joins Call Center or try to do any stupid jobs which he actually doesn't wants to do. Again when he actually get a call from his related industry, due to lack of knowledge he/she may get reject. Some candidates has good experience but due to less cofidence they may get reject. Poor Communication Skills. Less experience in the required field. Even from resume also u cant predict the quality of a candidate. On paper he/she may be well knowledgable well experienced but in actual practice he/she may not be so. Â |
3
|
I do not agree with You, First impression will be the best impression you will get on any person. That's the reason why one should be good at appearance, attitude, communication, body language and skills or knowledge. If you speak with a person for the first time directly its his appearance which gives some impression on him first and the way he expresses his views(Communication) will be the second, third will be his attitude which will expressed by his words and thoughts and also by his body language and last but not least are his skills or knowledge about the things.
|
|
Just chk this out, I strongly feel any single mismatch of the below mentioned points would disassociate the interaction. 1. Mismatch of employer and employee stand 2. Mismatch of the qualification or eligibity criteria 3. Mismatch of the role clarity 4. Mismatch of the culture 5. Mismatch of the eye to eye contact 6. Mismatch of the dress sense 7.Mismatch of the speech, voice, pitch, tone etc., 8. Mismatch of the intentions and actions 9.Mismatch of the expectations 10.Mismatch of the past and present profiles and overall a mismatch of the frequency fluctuations between an interviewer and an interviewee. |
2
|
Adding to what Mr.Mohan said,I would like to add on some more reasons which led to rejection of a candidate like poor communication skills,lack of knowledge of his domain etc.If the candidate can improve on the mentioned things then there is no reason why he won't be selected for the job.
|
|
It is such an important factor and yet i have never, never seen an HR professional mention this as one of the reasons for rejection. Every one acknowledges the fact that people do not leave jobs, they leave their bosses. This is one of the main reasons for attrition and also one of the best methods of retention. Yet whe we recruit, we look at his cultural fit, his attitude, his experence, his integrity blah, blah but never his compatibility with his BOSS!!! Lets face it, he could have all the factors "top class" but if he is not going to be compatible with his boss, he is not going to be there for too long. You might have an immediate closure but hang on dont stop recruiting because you are going to need a replacement very soon. Cheers Navneet  |
2
|
Yes Navneet, compatibility is what is required, i guess this is where most of the people leave jobs, and most of the reason being due to their managers and their bosses, so compatibility with the top c's of the organization is very important...
|
|
1. Poor attitude. |
2
|
|
|
The classic case of chicken-and-the-egg problem. How does a candidate get a job if they don't have experience? How do they get experience if they don't have a job? Both of these give a candidate valuable experience and show programming isn't a chore, it's his calling. Initiative, dedication, and problem-solving skills, not to mention an obsession with technology, This is what makes a candidate stand out. |
2
|
What is the use of having a person without experience, when it is needed. The experience on a particular skill means much important than other factors. If a candidate is not having the expected experience, will you consider him for a job that needs specific skill?
|
|
We all know the famous saying, " First Impression is the last impression." The candinate having shabby dressing, whould at times outright be rejected because that shows the seriousness of the candinate. Also at times the resume is very shabby with awkward fonts, the candinate does get rejected there. The candinate not comming on time for the interview also gives a bad impression. |
1
|
|
|
A bad attitude would showcase bad body language, strong negative communication skills and also instability in jobs. |
1
|
|
|
Many candidates face rejection during interviews primarily due to the lack of attitude and job knowledge |
1
|
Yes it is attitude, attitude and attitude which really matters. Other thinngs are important but then one or the another weak point will always be there. But if the attitude can be correctly judged then nothing like that. Because a person with right attitude will certainly catch up with his short comings.
|
|
Most Common and Strong Reason to Reject a candidate is, that if they are found to be less comptent |
1
|
|
|
If the candidate is upto the mark in qualification, personal skills and experience, he will learn other things and get adapted quickly. But a person tries to wilfully give misleading information about the reason for leaving his past job etc., or in other cross questioning, his integrity is to be doubted.  It is better to avoid if a person is found to be lacking integrity. |
1
|
|
|
Many a times the interviewer has an obsession to compare the cadidate's performance with his own at the age and time of interviewee and rejects the person who fails his anticipations.The human affliliatiations of the interviwer often plays important roles in choice of the candidate for the post : such as the institutions favoured by him, the place from which the candidate hails etc..These are the more personalized criteria when the interviwer rejects candidates not conforming them from the few probables he zeroes after preliminary screening. |
1
|
Yes i agree with your comment and this often is the case where HR compares his performance and his knowledge at the time of the interview and most often is the case like where The HR is trying to not to select the candidate....
|
|
i try finding out the clarity of thoughts....which finally leads to most things shared here & above....many times its important to help the candidate in getting clarity, during interview or the discussion. however, my single most reason has been the clarity of thoughts for rejection, as if this is there, rest can fall in place..... |
1
|
|
|
Another reason from lack of experience is they don't ask Questions Sometimes candidates dont have any questions to ask us when we give them the freedom. They just go blank. This shows that they are not interested in the company and the position. Thus we reject that candidate....No interest means no job... |
1
|
|
|
The attitude, mannarism and delivery indicate confidence level and if cofidence level is low ... that person does not deserve to be recruited. |
1
|
|
|
Changing the job in less than one year does not give any potential employer the faith that the candidate will stay for more than a year. Studies have shown that a person rarely exceeds the duration in service of their first job. |
1
|
|
|
it is one type of behavior which is danger while working in group. which may misslead other. those are always not agree that, they don't know the clear picture but putting asumption ideas to others. And also they always want to create such type of image that, he knows all subject. |
1
|
|
|
Not many people identify this as the reason for rejection. But I have seen so many people get a job only because they made a good impact in the first one minute of the interview. If the first impression is not good, I think 80-90% of the times the candidate will be kept in pending, until they see more if not rejected. |
1
|
|
|
Reasons for rejecting a candidadte is different for each level and the role/position. Every one has covered all the points. I am just putting down my thougths around the Senior resource.. All the candidate are good, it is only the expectation is not aligning. Because one candidate rejected in one company, still gets a job in other company. Senior One (Mgt, Domain, Product, Process): Career direction - Focus, Strategy, Roadmap Research - Company, Competitors, Landscape, Market, Technolgoies Attiude - Strong, Weak, Poor, Aggresive,Conservative Humility - SWOT analysis Why You?- Differentior Strategy - Story Board, Tactical, ... |
1
|
|
|
I think it all depends on candidate's attitude & interest towards the work and also comin to interview late which gives an clear answer to reject the candidate and when u asked the candidate to come down for one more round of interview see his expression on his face and he replies is it required to come once again or y cant u arrange today itself , coz iam coming from distant place and lastly he will say iam getting this much CTC i want more than that so on these basis u can reject the candidate |
0
|
|
|
i believe if the interviwer feels the few mst important reasons can be:
|
0
|
|
|
* Lack of product knowledge * Poor Attitude * Poor communication skills * Over expectation with regards to CTC |
0
|
|
|
Hi All ,, we are going to hire people not a paper ,so attitude is very important.making them to stay with us is the clear cut job of HR professionals.finally we HR's mean to say not only Human resource its Human remains.So during the time of F2F interview we have to make them clear about job and expectation and prior to this screen them before calling for face to face round.
|
0
|
|
|
One of common reason for me to reject is "FITMENT & Cultural issue" or lack the right set of skills required to perform this job well. |
0
|
|
|
1) POOR COMMUNICATION SKILLS:-.......a person can easily pass on in interview via his/her communication skills ...a host always see that person is really able to staying aur not...means person is able to explain his/her views in a proper manner or not ..........and communication skills tell it   many reasons are more but these are common.... what you say guys |
0
|
Yes Komal you are right here and Indeed with now organizations requiring candidates to have skills on various domains, it becomes more so important to have great communication skills...and other factors that you've mentioned...
|
|
I choose a person w.r.t Talent [skill, demonstrated experience, latent abilities & behavioral profile], Intent and Confidence [Balance between SO & WT in a SWOT]. So I normally reject when they fail in most of above factors.If one asks for one single factor, mine will be inability to apply commonsensical approach.
|
0
|
|
|
Anybody who doesnt LOOK in the eye while answering is not a candidate at all! Confidence comes from staring back and answering.. Its an attitude that says "nothing you ask me is going to unfaze me".. "I know all the answers..." so I am your GUY! |
0
|
|
|
the talks more like telling lot of stories for their past to impress. if you go indepth conversation, then you will find the emptyness in the talks. |
0
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
I think the serious job hoppers rather stick to their own company or tend to shift to companies which has 1/2 month notice rather than going for a brand which has 3 months notice!!! This really affects the company and not the job hoppers! |
Thank you so much and wishing you the same through out your life!!! |
Good one! |
