Build your professional network on facebook via our app Go to app
 
<< Prev  3 of 8 in Topic  Next >>
Topic : The Good, bad and ugly of the society
  Rate : 
Posted in Community :

Durga Rao & Knowledge

 
Functional Area : Homes
Activity:  15 comments  425 views  last activity : 09 21 2011 10:05:16 +0000
 Refer 63
Share
 
 
 

Irom Sharmila Chanu and Anna Hazare have one thing in common - the ability to fast indefinitely for what they perceive is right. But the similarities end there.              

Irom Sharmila of Manipur has been on a political fast for 11 years but her silent resilience moves you when you realise the sheer magnitude of what she is single handedly trying to achieve. Manipur's "iron lady" sharmila has a tube running down her nose as the government alternately force feeds her and incercerates her for attempting to take her own life through her hunger strike.              

Veteran activist Anna Hazare launched a similar fast unto death April 5 2011 demanding a bill that gives an independant ombudsman police like powers to prosecute ministers ,bureaucrats and judges had tapped into widespread public anger  .Thousands of indian exploded into a social network driven mass movement.                                                                                 

why has Hazare's movement been a success?

It has much to do with the fact that corruption as a broad subject is easily understood by indian middle-class than an obscure martial law that is perceived to have no bearing on the lives on the majority of people.With more households connect to internet in 2011 than ever before indians are embracing social networking to exchange ,disseminate and process information --a powerful tool that came after Sharmila's time.Also endorsed by celebrities, film-stars,sports- personalities and socialites to relationship experts and politicians.                                                                                                                          

The national media has been largely silent about Sharmila's crusade against AFSPA( armed forces special powers act) in one of india's resource rich but remotest corners whose people often complain of apathy and neglect from the central government.                                                                                                          

why has the centre ignored Sharmila?

The government's quick acquiesence to Hazare's demands while ignoring Sharmila's bears testimony to the geo-political importance (or lack of it) of the North-East in a country where cast divides can shift the balance of power.        

AFSPA has been imposed in Manipur and most of the north-east since 1980 . It allows the army to use force,shoot or arrest anyone without warrant on the mere suspicion that someone has commited or was about to commit a cognisable offence.The act also prohibits any legal or judicial proceeding against army personnel without the previous sanction of the central government.                                                                                                                      

Under intense pressure the government in 2004 constituted  a five member commitee under the chairmanship of justice B.P.Jeevan Reddy,a former Supreme court judge to replace it with a more humane act.                                    

Although the government hasn't taken any concrete action on the findings of the Reddy commitee that suggested, among other things , the repeal of the act ,it helped bring a burning issue to the forefront.

     For further reading go to                              http://ibnlive.in.com/news/spot-the-difference-hazare-vs-irom-sharmila/149755-3.html                        

         Spot the difference: Hazare vs Irom Sharmila

 Top Comment : jhallajit    | 08 25 2011 09:28:59 +0000
What is democracy? Is there any different policy for the North-east India? then why they imposed such Act to north-east area? if not then we should get the same right..! Sister Irom Sharmila, struggling for our own Human right as a citizen of India, since 11 years. And Indian people doesn't knows who she is and why is doing protest, but oversea organization know him. we support ANNA HAZARE, Anti-corruption. However, firstly need our own right of citizen from central Government. They didnot recognize us as Indian citizen. the problem is this. thanks for ur page..!
 
15 comments on "ANNA HAZARE vs IROM SHARMILA."
  Commented by  parimala.c.wagh, Tech Architect, Rites.Ltd/GC/BMRCL    | 09 21 2011 10:05:16 +0000
The difference is corruption is burning issue, which is efftecting whole India in day to day life is the reason why ANNAJI got massive Support.

IROM SHARMILA plead for the Indian government was the repeal of the AFSPA, which allowed soldiers to indefinitely detain any citizen on suspicion of being a rebel The act has been blamed by opposition and human rights groups for permitting torture, forced disappearances, and extrajudicial executions in north eastern States.As it is not a burning issue when it considered in mass.BUT ONE SHOULD BE AWARE OF THE FACT THE LADY IS FIGHTING FOR HUMAN RIGHTS WHICH IS MORE IMPORTANT THAN CORRUPTION.WHEN HUMANS ARE TREATED LIKE INSECTS AND KILLED FOR NO MISTAKE WHAT WILL HAPPEN IF THE SAME IS APPLICABLE FOR US.AS A HUMANS WITH HUMANITY SUPPORT THIS GREAT LADY AND I WOULD LIKE TO SALUTE HER FOR HER GREATER RESPECT TOWARDS HUMANITY.IN TODAYS WORLD PEOPLE WILL FIGHT FOR SOMEONE MAY BE FOR DAYS,MONTHS AND A YEAR NOT FOR 11YRS......................IF WE R HUMANS,IF WE RESPECT HUMANITY WE WILL SURELY SUPPORT THE GREAT LADY.
  Commented by  Shameena W., Admin Manager, Wizcraft Inc.    | 08 27 2011 14:15:20 +0000
I would like to start a blog on Sharmilla. Will my friends on toostep help me. 
  Commented by  Shameena W., Admin Manager, Wizcraft Inc.    | 08 27 2011 14:14:23 +0000
Sharmilla is a true Gandhian. And our society is not even as responsive to her as the imperialist Great Britain was to the Maatma. Truly I salute her. 
  Commented by  Munshi Ramchand, Retired, Self Employed    | 08 27 2011 10:03:54 +0000
Rating : -1 
The issue with Manipur and the north-east is that they do not have a good leader. Irom Sharmila is using a gandhian method called "fasting/satyagraha". Anna is using the same method because there are lot of other organizations backing Anna who are able to bring people to the streets. Irom Sharmila is not able to do that. Instead, what the people in the north-east should do is to create a tough and rough leader who can spit venom and violence to achieve the goal. If the whole India were to blame this leader for venom and violence then point your finger at Bal Thackray, Narendra Modi, Vinay Katiyar and Pramod Mutalik. You should pose the question, "Why are these(Thackray,Modi,Mutalik and Katiyar) people allowed to use violence to achieve what they want?". Today, without violence you cannot achieve anything in India.
  Commented by  Vinoy Scaria James, Travel Consultant, Guiders Mission    | 08 27 2011 06:19:49 +0000
Rating : +1 
I agree with all of you. Justice is not being done to Ms. Sharmila.
  Commented by  Shanti Roshan, Accounts Manager, Aditya Birla Group    | 08 27 2011 06:00:35 +0000
Rating : +1 
What has Ms Sharmilla got to give the media if it backs her. A minuscule amount of TRPs in the N-E. Annaji will not get this media coverage if goes fast in Sikkim or Manipal. So why should he? 

But why is not the citizens of the country not waking up to her demands. Are we hypocrites. We got excess time for A - team, which has agenda except hold the government to ransom. Are we as a  nation that stupid?
  Commented by  AMISH, Admin/Facilities Manager, VKVC    | 08 27 2011 05:51:43 +0000
It is hard to believe a person can survive 11 years without food. 
  Commented by  S. Muralidharan, Head, Project Planning/Strategy, Knowledge Foundation    | 08 25 2011 18:46:48 +0000
The only difference between Anna Hazare and Irom Sharmila is Anna is able to galvanize public support through various means and supporters across the globe for a cause.  Most importantly, he could get a media glare to reach the mass at a rapid pace, whereas Irom's battle is so silent and confined to Manipur.  Government looks for how many tow with you for a cause to arrive at a solution.  In the absence of people voice, unfortunately she failed to garner, the government took her as a weak contender and did not bother to address the issue in war-footing.  The Congress Government in Assam under the leadership of Tarun Gogoi, if pressurised, can take up Manipur's cause easily, as he enjoys good rapport with the senior leadership in Congress.  Its the political will that is stopping the entire issue.  Thanks Jayanta for sharing this very pertinent issue when the whole country is boiling in agitation mood.  As per some media inputs, Anna Hazare had be apprised about the plight and he would step up the pressure with Irom to get a speedy outcome!  
  Commented by  Munshi Ramchand, Retired, Self Employed    | 08 25 2011 16:41:57 +0000
Rating : +1 
"...Is there any different policy for the North-east India? then why they imposed such Act to north-east area?..."

If north-east want to have a voice, want to get its share of respect, then do the following:

a). Educate your current generation and the next. Example: Kerala. This state is surviving in the Indian Union ONLY for the reason that it is able to export educated people, it does not have anything else as a major .... 

b). Create a strong manufacturing sector. Example: States like Gujarat and Maharashtra.

Once you do the above, states in the North-East will become self-sufficient and rich, AND then you will have a voice in the Indian Union.

Warning: Keep away from Hindutva, Marxist and Chinese.
  Commented by  jhallajit, project executive, pico concepts india pvt. ltd.    | 08 25 2011 09:28:59 +0000
Rating : +1 
What is democracy? Is there any different policy for the North-east India? then why they imposed such Act to north-east area? if not then we should get the same right..! Sister Irom Sharmila, struggling for our own Human right as a citizen of India, since 11 years. And Indian people doesn't knows who she is and why is doing protest, but  oversea organization know him.
we support ANNA HAZARE, Anti-corruption. However, firstly need our own right of citizen from central Government. They didnot recognize us as Indian citizen. the problem is this. thanks for ur page..!
  Commented by  ningthoukhongjam lakpati, sales manager, future point    | 08 15 2011 10:19:04 +0000
anna doing a bit round the corner for and issue addressed many a times at different levels however sharmila crusading a lone solitary war against aginst waht we felt in humane during the times of british rule in india. IS THAT A LEGACY WE ARE TI FOLLOW THAT THE INHUMAN COLONIAL RULER HAD GIVEN TO THE GLORIOUS HUMNAN HISTORY OF INDIA???????????????????????????????????????????????????????????










  Commented by  Rathin Deb, Freelance Retail Consultant    | 04 28 2011 07:55:16 +0000
Jayanta you are right in your observation. I think medically no body can stay alive for 11 years without food. May be I am wrong.
  Commented by  SHRIKANT MANOHAR DANKE, Consultant, Project Management Consultancy Firm    | 04 27 2011 08:13:09 +0000
Manipulation.
  Commented by  Rohit Thakur, Sr. MEP QA/QC Engineer, QA/QC INCHARGE, CONSTRUCTION SPECIALIST-MEP    | 04 27 2011 04:38:21 +0000
Thanks Jayanta for the information! really i dont know that!
  Commented by  Tanmay Gaur, Freelance Software Developer    | 04 26 2011 20:51:33 +0000
Thank you for the post, Jayanta. If not the national media, people who know about it should post it on internet and blogs like these. We know the incompetency of our system in handling the situation there. We need more stories from the north-east about the the life of people there.
Add your comment on "ANNA HAZARE vs IROM SHARMILA."

Rate:
Submit
Leading recruitment Firm
Leading recruitment Firm
Viewers also viewed
It has been debated in the Press stating that Anna Hazare is black mailing the government. One...
 
1732 referals 92 arguments, 3626 views
Yes vs No
 
7 referals 10 arguments, 413 views
Yes vs No
 
831 referals 27 arguments, 740 views
more...  
Recent Knowledge (109)
  A day after he resigned, Santosh Sarode (31), a software engineer, allegedly strangled his...
1600 referals 32 comments, 1538 views
The following is a reproduction of from an article I wrote in 2004. 1.  Harnessing the vast...
 
735 referals 18 comments, 325 views
Isn't it amazing, that Indian Government has miserably failed to handle a major issue like this,...
 
0 referals 2 comments, 153 views
more...  
More From Author
very interesting and funny.....thanks for referring Rajeev sir..
The traditional role of a mother as the HOME-MAKER is no more the same today.....but has come a long way coupled with her personal achievements outside home....so lets discuss such a phenomenon on the society as a whole and child bearing in...
Nepotism is nothing but favoritism shown by a company to relatives or friends of authority figures in the form of granting a new job , promotion or higher career opportunity regardless of merit...
more...