Build your professional network on facebook via our app Go to app
 
 1 of 10 in Topic  Next >>
Topic : India Shining ??
  Rate : 
 
By : chitra bannerjee, Consultant, Shining Consulting
Industry : Public Sector/Government Functional Area : India
Activity:  11 comments  433 views  last activity : 05 19 2011 16:41:16 +0000
 Refer 550
Share
 
 
 

Quoting from an Indian Express article by Shombit 

CM Championship Trophy: Panchayat election was the league matches, Parliament election the quarter finals, municipal election the semi-finals, and the final assembly election for the CM Championship Trophy started 18 April to conclude on 10 May. The winner will be declared on 13 May 2011. As part of this election game we’ve witnessed serious shenanigans, political travesty, hatred and meaningless murder, unsportsmanlike rivalry and mudslinging that bordered on drollery. Let me share with you the nuances I could follow due to my Bengali origin.

We’re fortunate the idiot box reveals such juicy, blow-by-blow election debates among other entertainment. Exceptional in Bengal’s election matches is unexpected stories that keep emerging from the two leading parties. Other parties have added salt and pepper from time to time to increase or diffuse the taste. Every cricket match in a series is never thrilling, but in this election, each episode has been rousing, except the violence. I’m sure the public enjoyed them all. Actually the only similarity with World Cup Cricket is the suspense of who will win.

Peculiar election model: Entrusted with free polling and fair elections, the Election Commission undoubtedly made serious security arrangements to achieve voter turnout from an electorate of 5,60,91,973 in West Bengal’s 88752 sq km area for 294 seats. It’s perfectly understandable that voting was staggered into 6 phases to avoid turbulence.  But aren’t rules like stoppage of election activity 48 hours prior to polling a little archaic when electronic and cyber media command the airwaves today? In compliance, on-ground electioneering stopped at voting locations. But where’s the question of not influencing voters when TV telecast of party speeches, debates and advertisements continued, even as voters were standing in queue? In fact after votes were cast in a phase, different political parties further stimulated the next phase electorate by releasing poll results of hypothetical numbers of seats they are about to win. Such influencing factors do not help standardize electioneering procedures. 

If 6 phases are inevitable and the rule to be abided, shouldn’t campaigning have stopped 48 hours before the first phase until the sixth phase in all media? But election is great business, low cost drama production vis-à-vis the exorbitant cost of producing TV serials. It’s well established that the more you spend to advertise any brand, the better its penetration and product purchase, at least for a trial. A democratic practice in Western countries is equal time on TV and radio for all political parties 3 weeks prior to elections. Doordarshan does that too, but how many watch DD? There’s no balance in Indian TV channels that are unabashedly aligned to their favourite political parties. Cyber media hasn’t entered election rule books yet possibly because it’s not involuntary viewing, people choose to go there.

You can read the complete article here 

Share your views

Best

Chitra

 Top Comment : Santosh Kumar Mohanty   | 05 19 2011 16:41:16 +0000
I remember news that Jyoti Basu was annoyed with his party man when Mamata mam was attacked in broad day light. The Statesman covered the news in detail with photographs. He said that you have created leader with such activity. His wards become true and now she changed Bengal.
 
TrackBack URL:
11 comments on "Hi West Bengal! Blood or prosperity?"
  Commented by  Santosh Kumar Mohanty, Civil Engineer-Municipal, Sambalpur University    | 05 19 2011 16:41:16 +0000
Rating : +1 
I remember news that Jyoti Basu was annoyed with his party man when Mamata mam was attacked in broad day light. The Statesman covered the news in detail with photographs. He said that you have created leader with such activity. His wards become true and now she changed Bengal.
  Commented by  NATTERAJA R. ARIKRISHNAN, AREA SALES MANGER, UNIFLEX CABLES LTD    | 05 13 2011 18:54:06 +0000
A good article Ms.Chitra Bannerjee.
  Commented by  manish kumar, SEO | Web-cms Developer | Freelancer-- shoot me an email, SEO | Web-cms Developer | Freelancer-- shoot me an email    | 05 12 2011 16:48:10 +0000
well said ma'am Thanks for sharing :)
  Commented by  SHRIKANT MANOHAR DANKE, Consultant, Project Management Consultancy Firm    | 05 12 2011 12:11:26 +0000
Rating : -1 
Thanks for this beautiful article, Chitra.
I support for Ms. Banerji.Best of Luck for her new inning of C.M. of West Bengal.
  Commented by  JAYANTA KUMAR BORAH, B.Tech/B.E.,fresher, Annamalai university    | 05 10 2011 16:58:09 +0000
A good article ....thanks for referring Joydeep sir and Chitra madam.
  Commented by  Rathin Deb, Freelance Retail Consultant    | 05 10 2011 05:25:53 +0000
Chitra I fully agree with your point of view. The election may take place in as many phases as required for a particular state. All the canvassing must be stopped with the starting of first phase other wise canvassing may result in sewing.

What I have observed starting with north Bengal the voting %age has followed almost the same pattern as in north Bengal.  
  Commented by  Raju V P, Head of Finance Information Systems, an International Bank    | 05 09 2011 15:33:42 +0000
Bengalis are basically by nature, very emotional.  So all this drama is perfectly understandable.  The big pain point is that the Bengalis have to choose between the devil and the deep sea - just like Tamil Nadu - or for that matter the whole of India.  
  Commented by  S. Muralidharan, Head, Project Planning/Strategy, Knowledge Foundation    | 05 09 2011 15:24:54 +0000
I endorse your view Chitra.  In the lighter vein, we can say that Lalu moved from the State as CM of Bihar to Centre as Railway Minister - he did well as Railway Minister.  Nitish Kumar moved away from Centre as Railway Minister to CM of Bihar.  CM of Bihar is doing exceptionally well - cutting across party lines he gets praise for his good work in Bihar.  Similarly, if Mamta disowns Railway Portfolio and move to West Bengal, I think, as the history repeats, WB is really going to usher in progress!  We hope, in her regime, one more Nandigram episode will drive away Industrial leaders.  To woo the industrialists to the State, she is betting on Mr. Mitra, the Secretary General of FICCI!  I think she would do better in WB this time.  
  Commented by  Mohammad Bakhsh, Project Leader/Managing Consultant, Freelancer    | 05 09 2011 11:54:27 +0000
 Chitra's rue on the election process is understandable.There is no doubt that Jyoti Basu is the architect of stability.The problem with Bengal was that the communist chose misplaced economic agenda and could not carry forward on path of development.The alternative with Bengal is also not promising.The people are good and intelligent,hard working,innovative.There is no dearth of expertise in any field.In my opinion,these people should gather courage and blunt the revenge politics in the times to come.
  Commented by  Srinivas suravajhala, Secretary to the high ranking police officer, Law Enforcing Agency    | 05 09 2011 11:54:19 +0000
Well Said Chitra.  Bibi successfully utilised the TATA Nano plant, Nandigam issue.  Political leaders better know how to politicse an issue.  They dont bother the long run affects.  After the sad demise of Comrade Basu, Communists seems to have losing ground. People are desperately looking for an alternative till date.  They have hopes on Bibi.  Can she deliver? She utterly failed in handling Ministry of Railways.  She pushed the profit making organisation to huge losses.  How can she handle a state like West Bengal? The media imposing its own opinions on the general public.  Media lost its credibility.  They have their political leanings.  Political parties are floating their own channels as seen in Tamilnadu and Andhra Pradesh.  How can we expect a balanced news.  It become distant dream for the audience.
  Commented by  Joydeep Dasgupta, Business Development Manager, New Horizon    | 05 09 2011 11:14:36 +0000

After independence East Bengal became East Pakistan leading to huge refugee influx to West Bengal once again in 1971 after the creation of Bangladesh. From 70 to 77 West Bengal witnessed Naxalite a ultra communist movement, Majority were from the east Bengal displaced population, they had no faith on democratic process (the ballot) they believed in bullets, (“the absolute power resides inside the barrel of the gun”) Charu Majumdar .  It was Mr Joti Basu who actually showed the cream within democracy he remained a Chief Minister for 24 years though a “communist” via electoral process. Only reason they had no opposition as Congress had lost its foot hold beyond 1977.

It was Nehru who partitioned the country and his daughter Indira, created Bangladesh, Nehru wanted to become the first Prime Minister of Independent India he was least bothered about Bengal, his daughter wanted to be a distinguished International figure equal to the American President Nixon in 1970, she hardly bothered about West Bengal she sent Army to create Bangladesh.  In 77 the communist regime came to power by the ballot, ruled for 35 years, now they are facing opposition; if communist loose in this election west Bengal will become violent resulting to huge bloodshed as this tribe is a ultra militant free launchers or homo parasites.
Add your comment on "Hi West Bengal! Blood or prosperity?"

Rate:
Submit
Leading Health Care Recruitment Firm
  • Create a confidential Career Profile and Resume/C.V. online
  • Get advice for planning their career and for marketing of experience and skills
  • Maximize awareness of and access to the best career opportunities
Viewers also viewed
In India we seen the instances where bigger states are sub divided in to smaller states like...
 
3 referals 9 arguments, 3256 views
Education in India is growing and also the method of education. But as we know 35% of Indian...
 
877 referals 115 arguments, 5611 views
Who was responsible for the Partition of India, in 1947 ??? Mr. Jaswant Singh writes in his...
 
116 referals 26 arguments, 11342 views
more...  
Recent Knowledge (12)
Watching TV causes Obesity, Diabetes and Sleeplessness Watching TV is an ideal way to pass time...
 
379 referals 7 comments, 173 views
Why the pen is mightier than the keyboard: Children who write by hand 'learn better than those...
 
382 referals 10 comments, 205 views
Facts about "Jana Gana Mana" - Just a thought for the National Anthem! How well do you know...
 
770 referals 31 comments, 22186 views
more...  
More From Author
Let’s watch a Broadway show called “Times Square circus and crime.” Act 1.   Overflowing with digital billboards and neon lights, New York’s Times Square at night looks like Las Vegas, the vibrant US gambling city. An amphitheatre seating gallery...
  About 2.5 billion people in the world have no access to safe sanitation, and half of South Asia suffers the indignity of open defecation. This lack of hygienic facilities is a fundamental cause of disease leading to 1.5 million children dying...
:-) Thanks Rathin, Virag and Sairam
more...