Build your professional network on facebook via our app Go to app
 
 
Posted in Community :

Social and Community affairs

 
Activity:  8 comments  231 views  last activity : 09 09 2011 14:45:19 +0000
 Refer 411
Share
 
 
 

Quickly implement workable Solutions to overcome Terrorism:

For the kind attention of Hon. MOH and others.

1. It is almost impossible to take adequate and appropriate action in case of terror attacks that  happen in a thickly populated country like India. Prevention of terrorism by looking into its root causes is the only way out. According to me the most effective way for India to get over the problem of terrorism is to have the courage to stand up and acknowledge and openly seek apology for the mistakes we have done as a nation in the past, mend our ways and ensure these are not repeated in the future. For this, first of all it is necessary for us to get immunized ourselves from various forms of anti-secular activism within; before looking to the threats from outside. To prevent internal anti-secular activities, it is necessary for all political factions to join hands and take stern and decisive action against breeding communal violence and prevent disruptive tendencies within the country.  There shall be zero tolerance to any form non secular organizations and anti-secular activities of any form by anyone however big he or they may be.

The other options like setting up of mass participation as envisaged in various paras below though cumbersome, could help to eliminate terrorism initiated, inculcated and practiced by fundamentalists.

 2. Prevent terrorism from external forces.

Find out and eliminate the root cause of increased hostilities against us from terrorist groups abroad. India was the first country to recognize Palestine and right of Muslims to have their home land back. India also took the courage of joining the nations in severing diplomatic ties with Israel. India is one of the nations which condemned a unilateral decision of war in Iraq. India give moral and physical support for Afghanistan in it’s strive to bring in democracy. India continues to support Iran in its legitimate actions and entered into cooperation in many areas of trade and sharing of resources even at the risk of friendship with America. India had contributed much for the development of many Gulf countries and Arab nations.By and large common mass in Islamic countries were friendly to Indians.

Introspection is very much required to know what changed.  There can be genuine reasons for discontent among various religious / ethnic groups. It is painful to see no one including media and the so called secularist politicians, dare to stand up and condemn the anti secular activities and problems being caused by various religious fanatic groups within the country breeding feeling of hatred of one community against the other for the fear losing votes of one group or other.  Unless we change ourselves in our attitude, Hippocratic approach and double standards; terrorism in one form or other against India is likely to grow further and become very UN-manageable. It is time people rise together to defeat political groups using the religious and communal cards to come into power. 

3. Strengthen defense systems and Crisis Management:

Manufacture enough quantity indigenous sophisticated weapons, arms, armor and tools in the ordinance factories and set up systems and other infrastructure, and make available to the army and anti-terrorist personnel. 

Build up an effective Crisis / Disaster management system and establishment with the back borne of highly trained and equipped army and Para-military personnel in every city and towns and villages.

Set up exclusive GPS / GSM Wireless Telecom Network for Crisis Control and Disaster Management. Quick means of communication is one of the vital needs at the time of major crisis and disaster. The irony is that public telecom networks become useless when it is most needed. The normal telecom networks are designed for normal optimum busy hour telephone use of a routine day. In case of a calamity, Telcom systems and networks systems get choked due to over usage. It is impossible to design a public telephone network that is capable of handling the sudden spurt of telephone traffic of sporadic nature that happen at the time of any major events, crisis and disaster. 

It was pitiful to see that while the 26/11 terrorists were able speak to the perpetrators unhindered,  there were no clear communication happened between the Police HQ and their various men in field. Even the police control rooms did not bother to get information from large number of media persons present in the vicinity who had first hand information of what was happening. This is very much evident from the fact that Mr. Karkare and others with him had no idea of the situation as to the where about of the terrorists and the weapons they had with them due to lack of communication. Death of those three fine policemen caused a terrible turn of the whole events.

When few gas masked security men could have put the terrorists out of action within minutes of their invasion in Taj and other places and apprehended them using some neutralizing gas grenades. it was just fool hardy to order them to go and face those mindless AK 47 rifles and Grenades wielding terrorists, without even having bullet proof vests. Had there been proper communication things would have ended in an entirely different way.

The way out  is to have exclusive private GPS / GSM Wireless telecom network as being used in other countries for  essential services such as security, army, police, ambulance, hospitals, road transport & traffic control, air traffic control, railways and important persons/ organizations and local administration, that are vital in the crisis control/disaster management system.  By design, these shall be non-blocking, full availability systems for congestion free service at the switching centre level as well as at the access network levels. Interconnects to Public networks could be available on normal situation, but it would be capable to filter or block these to avoid flooding of calls from other networks during emergency situations.

With these systems and network set up across the country in place, it would be possible to keep up fail proof communication between the vital points to receive information and pass on orders immediately from central control to various points to take appropriate action in case of cyclone, flood, fire, earthquake, terrorist activities, bomb scare, mob violence or major traffic hold up situations. It shall be possible to access the communications systems of Suburban railway and road transport from this network to contact and pass orders for immediate actions. Bomb scare alarms and announcement system shall be available in every railway compartment.

The network and systems in different cities shall be linked for integrated action of security needs and events and crisis of national importance.  It is possible to have centralized database and control servers in one of the systems and shared by other networks. In addition to such private GSM Network, other infrastructures for crisis management also shall be in place.

Vital things needed are:

i) A centralized administrative body to take over and exercise over all control and coordination.

ii) A research and consultant group to constantly improvise the systems in every sphere, technology, strategy, administration etc., according to changing needs. 

iii) A contingent of specially trained persons in every city and towns.

iv) Necessary infrastructure such as modern weapons, armor and ammunition.

v) Protected vehicles, helicopters, airplanes, fire tenders and etc., pre-loaded and fully equipped in operational ready condition. 

vi) Provide CCTVs at every crucial areas and network it with central control rooms. Even if some of these are not working, the physical presence of it will deter many miscreants.

4. Establish joint mechanism of Para military & Civilian administration:

To realize public participation in prevention of terrorism; there need to have a joint mechanism of Para military & Civilian administration in the state, urban cities and rural village level.  

Make the Army join the mainstream of rural growth. 

Move the Army to Villages and strengthen and diversify the defense establishment for the rural development revolution.

Without trifling the splendid service and the valuable efforts and sacrifices of the men safeguarding the nation in the boarders and elsewhere, we still need to ponder whether it is necessary for most of the defense infrastructure remain embedded in developed cities occupying prime lands. It is also worthwhile to examine, such exorbitant existence of the army establishments eating out of the central exchequer, have matching contribution during the days of peace for the over all growth of the nation. For the sake of nation building, it will be apt to move the army set up out from the cities and re-locate distributed in rural areas, strengthen them further and diversify their activities deploying them for national development, working hand in hand with the local administrative bodies and local population.

Restore peace in border and redeploy the military for nation building: Resolve the issues and bring in good relation with the neighboring countries, so that attention can be concentrated on nation building. India has a mammoth and strong army. It is told that about half a million of India’s military are involved in handling the boarder conflicts between India and Pakistan. If a peaceful settlement is achieved, most of it can be deployed for nation building. So start the reforms from Kashmir. People in Kashmir have suffered enough. The army shall be used for the uplift of the region, not to create more hardships. Anyone trying to incite communal tension there or anywhere should be dealt with severely.  

 Provide opportunity for the army personnel to lead family life in the villages along with the civilians giving them the opportunity to lead a peaceful and stable social life in healthy situations with the local population and at the same time taking part in the nation building process.

This establishment shall function in the style of Corporate with the Federal (MP) and State Legislative Representative of the constituency (MLA), the District collector and one delegated Army personnel of Brigadier level as board of Directors supported with capable administrators taken in from open market. The working of the corporate shall be extended over the district with Lt. Cornell with the Tahsildars at Tahsil level and Lieutenants / Captains with the local executives at Village / Panchayat at level, each supported by units of Military and Para military personnel and supporting staff.

 5. Participate the rural mass in nation building process:

General development of the rural area and uplift of the people there by implementing centrally drawn out development programs making use of locally available and other manageable resources shall be the joint responsibility of the local administration and the army units with close co-ordination of Bureaucracy, Law enforcement supported by the Judiciary and NGOs.

All able bodied un-employed persons in the 21 to 45 years age group of the local population shall be compulsorily enrolled to form human resources units in every Village / Panchayat.

Enrollment and training shall be a continuous process. All persons in the units shall be given compulsory basic education, training in agriculture, trades and other vocational training. The eligible ones shall have opportunity for free higher education.

Paramilitary training shall be given for all those are physically fit. There shall be facility for giving short term para-military training for the youth from the urban areas and it shall made mandatory for all job seekers to have undergone at three months para-military training. All employed persons without exception, shall undergo at least a 45 days para-military training, once in two years. Everyone should be trained on anti terrorism awareness programs and prevention methods.  Imagine the potential of a country with 250 to 350 million mentally and physically disciplined and well-organized persons available in the across the country that could be mobilized and used in case of any national emergency or external threats. The mobility achieved with more roads, highways, railways and infrastructure across the country will make the defense potential much stronger. Moreover, this will be best way, may be the only way to bring self discipline and prevent youngsters falling prey to extremists and the only way to fully eradicate terrorism.

 6. Quickly Implement  Automatic Personal Identification system and make it compulsory.

Personal Identification of every inhabitant and visitors in the country shall be done. With so much IT capability and techno-savvy environment in India, it shall be possible to develop and implement a system  which can generate and provide identity cards with an intelligent chip with DNA map and finger print code embedded in it and once activated it will remain logged in to a GPS controlled network. This could be done by ISRO setting up Geo-stationery satellites for GPS network needed and networked across the country.

The information is loaded via GPS link to into central system which gets updated periodically.  The data is deleted from the system at the death of the person. 

Safeguards against tampering can be envisaged by various inbuilt features. Tamper or removal of the card will permanently damage it as the permanent discontinuity which will be detected and reported by the system. 

In built features and applications safe guard against fraud, non-compliance, misuse and tampering.

The system envisaged will cover every person in entire country.

A ready method to have the record of day to day Census, scope for automatic updating it, collection and use of various information, which could be used for ensuring full scale voting, payment of taxes.

Every visitor entering the country shall be given a temporary ID card at the point of entry and made to carry it with them.

7. Allow the mass to continue to stay and prosper in own villages. 

Instead of running away to crowded cities, the local population shall be encouraged to stay in the units in their own villages, by providing them, basic amenities, with the objective of utilizing the trained mass for the rural development projects in local area.

Everyone shall be given adequate minimum wage for a comfortable living for themselves and their defendant family. Those who acquire higher education and training and skill sets shall be given jobs at appropriate levels within the units or send to occupy jobs in other units. Lastly the political master who are ignorant and incompetent to take decisions on technology related issues should leave it to specialists and make them responsible for its proper implementation.

 Top Comment : Munshi Ramchand   | 07 15 2011 08:08:11 +0000
Paul, .....there were no clear communication happened between the Police HQ and their various men in field... This will happen as the police is a government organization(lack of accountability where it is necessary). ...Safeguards against tampering can be envisaged by various inbuilt features... Technology can act only up to a point. What is the use of technology when people are corrupt, law enforcement is in the hands of people. ....21 to 45 years age group of the local population shall be compulsorily enrolled to form human resources units in every Village / Panchayat.... That is a very good suggestion - better to enroll in the armed forces,probably in the territorial army or something similar.
 
8 comments on "How to revamp the security and reduce terrorist activities. "
  Commented by  Munshi Ramchand, Chief Muni/CMD/CEO, Agastya Muni Inc    | 07 20 2011 04:19:31 +0000
Rating : +1 
Julio Francis Ribeiro is a retired police officer famous for his courage, integrity and common sense.

He was honoured with the Padma Bhushan. Mr Ribeiro has been commissioner of Mumbai (then Bombay) police, and played a key role in tackling the Punjab insurgency in the 1980s. Later he served as India’s ambassador to Romania.

In this email interview with Dippy Vankani, he accords the pivotal role to developing better human intelligence to deal with the issue of terrorism, especially in a city like Mumbai.

Why is Mumbai targeted again and again?

Mumbai is targeted again and again because terrorists only choose places that are internationally known and where they will garner the maximum publicity. Terrorism is sustained on publicity. Publicity is like oxygen for terrorism.

After the 9/11 attacks, there have been no terror attacks in America because of its policing apparatus, but Mumbai continues to face terror strikes time and again. How different are we from Karachi, Kabul or Baghdad?

You cannot compare the situation of Mumbai with that of the United States. We live in a very dangerous part of the world whereas the US is far away from the hub of the Islamic world. We are as vulnerable as Karachi and Kabul since the epicentre of jihad terrorism is now in South Asia.

Is there any mechanism that can make the city immune to such attacks in the future?

Unless terrorism is laid to rest, as happened in Punjab, we will continue to experience such attacks. In Punjab, terrorism ended when the Jat Sikh farmers turned against the terrorists who belonged to their own community. When our Muslim brothers in Mumbai will give information to the police about suspicious movements or suspicious persons in their localities, that would sound the death knell of terrorism of the jihadi variety in our city.

Do you think that the underworld and terror outfits make a lethal combination in the current terror scenario?

The underworld and terror outfits are intrinsically different, though some criminal elements do join the ranks of the terrorists after some time. The underworld flourishes by bribing and corrupting the police and politicians. Terrorists only pump bullets into both. They do not bribe.

How powerful do you think is the Mumbai police commissioner, now with units like the Anti-Terrorism Squad (ATS) going out of the purview of that position? How different is the role of the commissioner now from it was in your time?

I did not know that the ATS has got out of the purview of the Mumbai police commissioner! This is news to me. The ATS has to keep the police commissioner in the loop and keep him informed of their findings at all times. This is happening even at present.

The difference between my time as commissioner and now is that over the years values have changed and politicians have also changed. New parties like the Shiv Sena have emerged and at one stage even formed the government in the state.

They had a different — and I may say a totally unconventional — view of governance. It did not do the police force much good. The police in my time was under my control. The control of the commissioner at present cannot be as total because the power centre has shifted to the home department. This is not a good thing for security concerns and for the public in general.

The High Court has recently asked officers to refrain from planting theories in the media in sensitive cases. What is your view on this?

I am happy that the High Court has asked officers to refrain from planting theories in the media in sensitive cases. The problem is that there is proliferation of electronic media in particular, and everybody is in search of stories and sound bytes. Even junior officers are now being approached and they find it very thrilling to have their faces on TV. This has caused a lot of confusion and speculation about investigations of crime. Also, many anchors have become detectives and are examining witnesses even before they are cross-examined in the court. The High Court should come down heavily on them.

Too many agencies are now involved in investigation, including Central agencies like the National Investigation Agency and the National Security Guard. Do you think that too many cooks might spoil the broth?

I agree that the number of Central agencies has increased tremendously over the years. Every time there is a crisis, which the government finds difficult to explain to the people, the only answer is to constitute a new organisation.

More people are of course employed, but the results are never apparent. So, too many cooks are spoiling the broth. They are getting into each other’s hair, and egos are clashing all the time. This is not good for the public cause.

The police is now equipped with technological assistance like CCTV footage and mobile phone surveillance. Do you think that the focus is now shifting from human intelligence and the police is relying more on these scientific resources?

Technological intelligence can never substitute human intelligence. Both are required. CCTV and mobile phone surveillance should be left to Central agencies, but police stations should concentrate on human intelligence and should befriend the minority community, in particular by treating them with dignity and respect that is the right of every citizen. When that happens, terrorism will be dealt a death blow.

Do you think recommendations of the Ram Pradhan Commission, set up to review the government’s response to the November 26, 2008, Mumbai attacks, came to grips with the issue and would help foil attacks, if implemented? Could Wednesday’s attacks have been averted in the light of these recommendations?

The Ram Pradhan Commission largely dealt with the issue of sharing of intelligence inputs between various agencies. They had found that the inputs were not shared or, if shared, were not considered important.

That was the main problem during the 26/11 attacks. So they made several recommendations on that, which are now followed by the agencies.

They had also made several recommendations on acquiring certain equipment to deal with terror attacks, and most of the equipment has been acquired by the state. Some of the equipment might not have been acquired so far only because of procedural delays like getting quotations etc.

But the commission’s recommendations would not have helped in averting the attacks on Mumbai. The only way it could have been averted is through human intelligence.
  Commented by  S. Muralidharan, Head, Project Planning/Strategy, Knowledge Foundation    | 07 20 2011 02:42:54 +0000
Mr. Abraham, your concerns are very valid.  Our attitude, in general, is tilting towards complicating simple matters.  Mostly, we do microscopic analysis of macro-issues and we play "penny-wise pound foolish" game! A simple re-structuring, here and there, could do wonders.  For instance, police is the State subject.  If we take this out from State subject to Concurrent List, where necessary, Centre can intercede and can provide better cover.  Our intelligence is too weak and we fail in pre-empting attacks.  Though the modus operandi of the recent Mumbai blasts look like an unorganised attempt from certain divisive forces, it comes to light that they have a very strong network in six Indian cities and was the very planned and orchestrated attempt.
As far as our youngsters in professional site like toostep are concerned, many a times we see bickering and mud-slinging exercise on "non-issues"!  Its a sorry state of affair!  We lose focus on key issues and digress on issues of less importance.  The earlier they realise, better it would be for our future generations, as they are going to be the torch-bearers of this magnificent country!  
  Commented by  Abraham Paul, Senior Telecom Consultant, FCOMNET- Future Groups    | 07 19 2011 19:08:50 +0000
Dear Mr. Mathew Cherian and others, Thanks for your nice rejoinders. 
According to me, I was believing so far that the resolution to the problem is simple. The situation we are in is mostly our on making. It is not very late to make amends and seek apology for our misdoings. 
I am 73 +. I had great belief in youngsters to outgrow the negative bias that had cropped up in Indian humanity post independence. Alas! to my utter dismay it had not happened. 
Look what is happening of late in this forum itself. I an one of the early birds in Toostep.com It was mostly a mind refreshing experience for elderly ones like me to have the opportunity to openly interact with youngsters and learn from their views and ideas.  A cursory glance through the contents of toostep.com from its predominance of many fine people with professional approach, of alte it has to some extent denigrated to space for vending personal vendetta of political and communal issues with visible intolerance. 
Though it is unfair to mention, I am slowly loosing faith in my on convictions that real change can come with change of generations by true to self introspection by all of us young and old in our sincere attempt to make amends and apologize openly for the mistakes we committed in the past which I thought was the simplest way out of the current muddle we are in. So like Mr. Cherian said, things are getting more complex day by day needing new definition for a whole lot of things like terrorism, corruption, secularism, democracy, liberty, equality and righteousness in governance and opposition etc. making persons like me to withdraw to our own holes. 
    
  Commented by  Mathew Cherian, Research Associate/Analyst, Western Michigan University    | 07 17 2011 18:14:37 +0000
Rating : +1 
"One need to catch the Tiger by the tail" so too the case with terrorism. As long as so many poor people roam around the street and the economy is ill administered one has to live with the violent act of others. Terrorism is not the likes we saw in Bombay, it is everywhere in India even before this happened. Any inhumane activity is terror and we have it in plenty in India.
A Hong Kong university professor of Indian origin gave a good article in Business Line a decade back where he clearly directs Indians to think of making the environment and economy more efficient to avoid terrorist threat. 
Direct solutions won't work. Look in America they had to be terrorized from Air, since if they tried to plant a bomb in an affluent area the game would have been up even before it started. Contrasting elements are easily spotted and reported in such areas. So building affluence and more efficient welfare environment is the most crucial agenda that can reduce the threat of violence.
 Direct solutions don't work and we Indians are used to 'organic' thinking which we feel will deliver but hasn't for the past 50 years, it has created more problems than what it solves. So one has to start thinking 'mechanistically' to solve the problems including violence. Holism without a structure is a non starter.
  Commented by  Munshi Ramchand, Chief Muni/CMD/CEO, Agastya Muni Inc    | 07 15 2011 08:08:11 +0000
Rating : +1 
Paul,

.....there were no clear communication happened between the Police HQ and their various men in field...

This will happen as the police is a government organization(lack of accountability where it is necessary).

...Safeguards against tampering can be envisaged by various inbuilt features...
Technology can act only up to a point. What is the use of technology when people are corrupt, law enforcement is in the hands of people.
....21 to 45 years age group of the local population shall be compulsorily enrolled to form human resources units in every Village / Panchayat....

That is a very good suggestion - better to enroll in the armed forces,probably in the territorial army or something similar.

  Commented by  S. Muralidharan, Head, Project Planning/Strategy, Knowledge Foundation    | 07 15 2011 04:58:45 +0000
Very valid suggestions Mr. Abraham, if implemented, India an emerge as Super-Power in year 2020. However, India is presently posited with a number of both internal and external challenges.  The present UPA-II government crippled with multi-faceted challenges to tackle with, mainly to handle the number of scams, coalition compulsions, ramifications from political allies on actions taken, anti-corruption bill, uprising by the civil society organisations to control corruption, Pakistan stepping up collaboration strategy with China, problems from naxals and maoists, bickerings on portfolio allocation from within, to uproot the present incumbent of UP in the ensuing State Assembly Elections, etc. etc.   
  Commented by  Arun Singh, Astt.Manager,Business development,Abhijeet Projects Ltd    | 07 15 2011 04:27:02 +0000
Need very efficient team to coordinate and execute such disaster management..If policy makers are listening..and very clear and genuine suggestions..
  Commented by  Vipin Bhasin, Private Equity/Hedge Fund/VC-Manager, Indian Investment Co.    | 07 14 2011 17:29:33 +0000
Excellent suggestions by Mr. Abraham. And it is now become a need for India & Indians. 
Add your comment on "How to revamp the security and reduce terrorist activities. "

Rate:
Submit
Leading Recruitment firm in Bangalore
jobs in SAP-NetWeaver-Process Integration (PI) Pune
jobs in SAP-Financials Corp Serv & SEM Bangalore
jobs in SAP-SD-Sales Order Management Bangalore
Viewers also viewed
Information technology (IT) is a concept that many companies today depend on.Moreover few...
 
0 referals 22 arguments, 833 views
1. Get up 15 minutes earlier 2. Prepare for the morning the night before 3. Avoid tight fitting...
 
21 referals 13 answers, 469 views
in my view the aviation security,particularly airport security,should be funded from from the...
 
28 referals 4 comments, 31 views
more...  
Recent Knowledge (106)
Anna Hazare Ends Latest Fast The United Progressive Alliance government heaved a huge sigh of...
 
87 referals 7 comments, 196 views
Floods deluge Pak With Strategic Problems   The Zardari government's inefficient handling of the...
 
35 referals 4 comments, 57 views
India is ruled By Amma in south, Didi in east, Behen in north, Aunty in capital, Madam in center...
1951 referals 30 comments, 633 views
more...  
More From Author
"The Bitter Pills for India Reprieve" I wrote this in this community in  toosteps.com few years back. The article is available in two parts in the following links in wordpress.com   http://wp.me/p1ZsI2-1O    http://wp.me/p1ZsI2-1S    
100% FDI should be welcome but only in Infrastructure and manufacturing sectors.
100% FDI should be welcome but only in Infrastructure and manufacturing sectors.
more...