Build your professional network on facebook via our app Go to app
 
 
 
By : Rashmi Chawla, Cust. Service Manager, Leading Bank
Industry : Investment Banking Functional Area : India
Activity:  8 comments  513 views  last activity : 02 14 2011 08:50:06 +0000
 Refer 885
Share
 
 
 

India has topped a list of the most "over-regulated countries in the world" in a survey on Asian business and politics by Hong Kong-based Political and Economic Risk Consultancy Ltd (PERC).

The survey used responses from American executives about regulatory conditions in the United States to provide a benchmark against which to assess the Asian scores.

India was rated worst in terms of over-regulation, scoring 9.16 points out of 10, followed by China with 9.04 points, Japan in third position with 3.28 points and the US at fourth with 1.51 points.

Hong Kong received the best score in the survey of 0.98 point, while Singapore was second with 1.08 points, according to the survey done in the last quarter of 2010, based on responses from 1,370 executives.

In general, regulations were complex and non-transparent, while standards and certifications procedures were onerous in India, according to the PERC survey findings.

Foreign exchange, capital transactions and some credit operations were subject to approvals, restrictions and additional requirements that went far beyond what most other countries require, concluded the survey.

Even procedures for something as simple as getting a tourist visa were more cumbersome in India than was typical elsewhere, it pointed out.

It also cited specific examples from the World Bank's Doing Business Survey of why India's regulatory system deserves to be graded as poorly as it was. It can take a month-and-a-half to register property, almost 200 days to obtain a construction permit, over 1,400 days to enforce a contract and seven years to close a business.

"Documentation requirements for both exports and imports are onerous," the PERC survey pointed out.

"Labor requirements are strict and companies lack flexibility on hiring and firing workers," it concluded.

Regulations in the country were frequently not enforced, which raised the question of why they were on the books at all, noted the survey.

"In a recent scandal involving the telecommunications ministry's mishandling of a landmark allocation of mobile telephone spectrum, as many as 85 of 122 new licences which were bundled with the bandwidth allocation were issued to companies that did not have the required capital to seek bandwidth," the survey pointed out.

These companies "suppressed facts, disclosed incomplete information and submitted fictitious documents", according to the survey.

"Of course they could not have done so without the complicity of bureaucrats at the ministry, who overlooked qualification shortcomings and arbitrarily moved forward the cut-off date for applying by one week to favor some companies that had applied earlier, while leaving others out," it said.

 
TrackBack URL:
8 comments on "India is most over-regulated country in the world: Survey"
  Commented by  S. Muralidharan, Head, Project Planning/Strategy, Knowledge Foundation    | 02 14 2011 08:50:06 +0000
REGULATIONS are meant to be broken, as we have a number of loopholes in our system! The problem with us is we are not contemplating for one window clearance for business activities.
  Commented by  Nilesh Pawar, Legal & Secretarial, Valencia Professional & Management Services LLP    | 02 14 2011 08:44:49 +0000
We have so many regulations but only on papers. They are not followed in spirit. Govt. should relax some regulations to prevent corruption and make the business possible for common man. 
  Commented by  s.baalu, Consultant, XYZ LTD    | 02 12 2011 08:11:31 +0000
Think of the capabilities of our people in spite of so called over regulated status so many scams are coming out.
  Commented by  Rachamadugu Pramod, Business Analyst, ICICI Bank Ltd    | 01 29 2011 06:24:30 +0000
If its overregulated, there wouldnot be many scams and money laundering. India is not properly regulated..
  Commented by  kannan, Head/VP/GM-Accounts, own office    | 01 27 2011 13:24:58 +0000
of course rashmi,   many of the business man donot likes these formalities which is fixed by government to license and other matters.  these are all, waste of time.  if u invest some money to officials (invest in business is next) and get easily fulfil these formalities. 
  first of  all we have to reduce the paper work, and huge verifications. 
   in general, government  has to give a valid id card to all the indians which is to connected a data base.  all the informations and verifications are stored in right manner  like income tax PAN card.   
 not only in business, also every work with government is huge paper work and lot of confirmations and corruption,  
   many of the laws in india, were came into force in british rule, at that time they put over regulations on indians.   the government has to take step to correct all the laws to be repealed as per the current indian situation.  
    atleast important laws are to be amended. to reduce  these over regulations.   
  Commented by  kanukurthy sudershanrao, Operations Manager, Andhra Bank    | 01 27 2011 13:18:48 +0000
if it is so overregulated how is it indians are stashing their loot in swiss banks is the overregulation for inflow not for outflow
  Commented by  S D Manjunath, Senior Manager, Axis Bank Ltd    | 01 27 2011 13:11:28 +0000
Yes, India is over regulated country but unfortunately, these regulations seldom practiced strictly OR followed selectively !!!.  And, what Krishna has said is right, this over regulation in finance/banking sector helped us sawy through tough times of economic slowdown.

Manju
  Commented by  Krishna Burli, Freelancer, Insurance    | 01 27 2011 11:51:46 +0000
This over-regulation only saved us from the recent sub-prime crises.
Krishna Burli
Add your comment on "India is most over-regulated country in the world: Survey"

Rate:
Submit
Leading recruitment Firm, Permanent Staffing, Temporary Staffing, Executive Search & Selection, and RPO
TSYS Consultant, Teamware Solutions
Openings for Graduate Freshers For Junior HR Executives., Teamware Solutions, Bangalore
Viewers also viewed
YES vs NO
 
679 referals 38 arguments, 2333 views
With Fifa world cup starting from today, I had this feeling whether India can ever qualify for...
 
686 referals 95 arguments, 6241 views
i support the steel building vs i don't support steel buildings
 
494 referals 24 arguments, 2177 views
more...  
Recent Knowledge (13)
What could be the size of Indian Switch market ( Low Voltage)
4 referals 15 comments, 526 views
Military Strength: Comapre India and Pakistan Manpower and Ground Forces India has the second...
49 referals 9 comments, 67492 views
Facts about "Jana Gana Mana" - Just a thought for the National Anthem! How well do you know...
 
770 referals 31 comments, 22186 views
more...  
More From Author
I agree to this question that intra day must be stopped....if it resembles betting. Even IPL is also a betting process that is glorified...but no action is taken by the govt. Thus ...its clear that whatever the govt. does for profit is good and...
India has topped a list of the most "over-regulated countries in the world" in a survey on Asian business and politics by Hong Kong-based Political and Economic Risk Consultancy Ltd (PERC). The survey used responses from American executives about...
I agree that we live in a inflated market which exist only in our perception banks are responsible for it....
more...