Build your professional network on facebook via our app Go to app
 
 1 of 20 in Topic  Next >>
 
Activity:  1 comments  500 views  last activity : 07 06 2010 20:18:04 +0000
Share
 
 
 

Strategic Intellectual Property Commercialization and Methods

This research paper describes the “Strategic Intellectual Property Commercialization and Methods”. Commercialization is basically done to earn profits from the technology or the invention by bringing that technology or invention in the public domain after protecting it with the help of legal means. Various strategies and techniques can be followed to commercialize an IP. Companies may adopt a number of commercialization strategies, ranging from direct sales to the outright sale of their technology.

 Commercialization methods which can be used by the industries or companies to effectively implement their business goal are as follows  

 

A.      Licensing

B.     Cross Licensing

C.     R & D growth

D.     Sale / Merger / Acquisition

E.     Patent pool

F.      Donation

G.    Dump  

 

IP Commercialization Methods

A. LICENSING   A licensor may grant license under "intellectual property" to do something (such as copy software or use a patented invention) without fear of a claim of intellectual property infringement brought by the licensor.

How to License Your Patented Invention:   If you have a patent or have applied for a patent (patent pending) you can attempt to license your invention. Technically, it is called licensing your patent rights, rather than licensing your invention. Non patented inventions can be licensed as well and the methods would be similar, however, extra steps would be taken that are not covered in this how to.
  • Create a list of potential manufacturers who may be interested in your product. Aim for a list of at least 50 or more.
  • Find manufacturers by looking in stores and magazines for similar products. Visit product related tradeshows. Your local library should have great reference material on manufacturers.
  • Use "Online Manufacturer Databases" such as the Thomas Register to search for companies that make a product like yours. You can do an Internet search for manufacturers by using the keywords of your product.
  • Send a brief individually tailored and professional looking marketing letter to each company on your list. The letter will state that, you are willing to consider selling or licensing the patent rights to your invention.
  • With your marketing letter, it is superior to include a professional looking brochure and a website address connected to your product.
  • Wait one month, if a company has not replied you can then telephone them to see if they are interested in your product.
  • Before discussing your invention in greater detail with a company, sign a non-disclosure agreement. You should consider having a lawyer draw one up for you.
  • If you have the opportunity to negotiate for a licensing agreement, use an experienced lawyer. It is not advisable for you to negotiate the contract on your own.
  • The license agreement will include provisions for upfront payments, royalty percentages and infringement issues.
 Example –
  • Suzuki licenses his technology to Maruti.
  • Mahindra and Renault
      B. CROSS LICENSING   A cross licensing agreement is a swap of access to companies patent portfolios: in essence it says "you can use my patents and I can use yours".
  • Cross-licensing of patents is a defensive strategy used by companies to protect itself from the patents of its competitors.
  • The goal of cross-licensing is mainly the freedom to continue to compete in the marketplace.
  • By cross-licensing their patents to each other, companies share the rights to use their respective patents, each with the permission of the other.
  • Cross licensing provide competitive benefits to both parties by integrating complementary technologies, reducing transaction costs, clearing blocking positions, and avoiding costly infringement litigation.
 Case Study   - Microsoft and JVC Enter Into Patent Cross-Licensing Agreement to Foster Mutual Innovation and Collaboration REDMOND, Wash., and TOKYO — Jan. 15, 2008 — Microsoft Corp. and Victor Company of Japan Ltd. (JVC) have signed a patent cross-licensing agreement to further the development of each company’s current and future product lines, which will expand technological innovation and enhance the overall customer and consumer experience. The agreement, recently signed by representatives of both companies, expands the relationship between JVC and Microsoft to promote the exchange of valuable information and the incorporation of patented technologies in their respective products. The agreement covers a broad range of consumer products each company manufactures and sells. Although the contents of the agreement, including the specific financial terms, are confidential, the parties indicated that Microsoft is being compensated by JVC. “When technological industry leaders collaborate through intellectual property licensing, we foster greater innovation that will benefit the customer, the consumer and the overall IT ecosystem,” said Horacio Gutierrez, vice president of intellectual property and licensing at Microsoft. “We are proud of the quality of our broad, global patent portfolio, and we look forward to continuing to work with JVC and other industry leaders to develop new and exciting technologies through our collaborative licensing program.”   

 

C. FUTURE R&D GROWTH 

 

  • Commercialization of inventions and R & D results must always begin with an in depth assessment and evaluation of their technological and market potential as R&D plays a major role in IP Commercialization for development of new technologies which in turn, bring out new & improved product for consumers.
 
  • On realization of ideas into a final product, further growth and  improvement of the product is needed for development of improved & more efficient product, here R & D faculties come into play as they help in future growth of product. Various Strategy used by R&D managers & companies are given below
 R&D Strategy - The R&D strategy used for IP management includes: 
  •  
    • New development driven by market requirements 
    • Internal R&D  with/ without outside consulting 
    • Cooperation with universities 
    • Purchase of small technology companies 
    • Use of R&D partnerships 
    • Association or alliance with local companies 
    • Copying a product of a competitor 
    • Purchasing of Patents
    • Contracting for development by R&D firms 
    • Purchase of technology from large companies 
    • Contract R&D to foreign development organizations 
    • Purchase of foreign technology &/or patents 
    • Use of high-tech incubators for new R&D organizations 
    • Government developed technology or patents
 Case Study

·         Procter & Gamble, invented a new plastic wrap called Impress™ which was then branded by Glad JV as Press ‘n Seal™.

·         The company did not participate in the plastic wrap category and, after developing its business case, determined that a joint venture with Clorox (its direct competitor in cleaning products and water purification) would produce a higher, more immediate return, saving P&G the time, money and resources necessary to establish itself as a new brand in an already competitive category.

·         In the transaction, Procter & Gamble obtained a 10 percent stake in Clorox’s Glad® business and an option to buy another 10 percent stake, which it recently exercised, as well as cost effective entry into the plastic wrap business.

·         In return, Clorox gained access to Procter & Gamble’s new technology and its substantial R&D pipeline for new products in the plastic wrap, bags and containers business.  

 

D. SALE / MERGER / ACQUISITION - One of the methods to commercialize IP is the direct sale which is the simplest and most useful method, mainly used by the independent inventor or the companies which usually don’t want to continue their R&D in the same field of science.  
  • After the globalization the merger and acquisition is also become the key component for the companies to grow their business. Companies are looking for the organic as well as the inorganic growth to execute their business strategies to have competitive edge in the market. IP portfolio asset transferred play a vital role during company merger or acquisition. Whether your company is buying or selling, and whether the transaction involves the sale and purchase of business assets or company shares, you will need to consider and assess the IP aspects of the transaction.
 
  • Companies having more IP asset are being considered as more valuable and preferred for merger or acquisition. Complete due diligence need to be done before going for the merger or acquisition which includes key patents, life of patent, any legal implications, patent protection coverage, R&D plans and  transaction related to other forms of IP. Complete competitive analysis based on the existing technology and future market demand need to be study based on the IP portfolio of the member companies to successfully implement the effective IP transfer strategy.
 Example –
  • AlliedSignal Inc. and Honeywell Inc. announced today that they have received clearance from the European Commission to complete their merger. Year-1999.
  • Acquisition - NVIDIA to Acquire AGEIA Technologies Year-2008
    E. PATENT POOL  - Patent pool is an association of at least two companies that agrees to cross-license patents relating to a particular technology.
  • Thus, its formation can save patentees and licensee’s time and money by reducing mutual negotiations of cross-licenses.
  • Patent pools are only one example of cases where members of other competitive industry join in common interest to create some product that is to their combine benefit.
  • Pooling is basically done to reduce risk and coordination costs.
 Examples:-

Ø      the insurance industry pools claims data to collectively reduce risk;

Ø      the catalog sales industry pools sales data to better model their customers;

Ø      the auto industry collaborates to standardize components;

Ø      the software industries open source collaboration. 

 Case Study   

 DVD/MPEG Technology  - This is related to the field of Consumer Electronics (CE).
  • Everyone knows the use of compact cassette or video cassette used in the recorder, or a CD in the CD-player.
  • Since the last decade, DVD has been the successful commercialized standard of CE for data storage as it can store 6 times more data than CD.
  • DVD is a popular optical disc storage media format that is used for video recordings and data storage in computers.
  • MPEG technology is important for storing the actual video data on DVD discs as it uses various compression formats.
  • For that reason, they combined both the technologies into a single one.
  F. PATENT DONATION   - Patent donation means “to give away” the inventions to universities, hospitals or nonprofit institutions based on certain conditions.
  • Tax Exemption benefit by the use of the patent donation.
 Benefits:-   Ø      Donation reduces the cost of maintaining patents. Ø      Rids them of known liabilities.

Ø      Causes goodwill.

Ø      And in some cases, future research and development favor with the recipient entities. 

 

 Considerations:- 
  • Your company must be profitable and have tax liability.
  • Your company must give up all ownership of the technology.
  • The value assigned to the donation is critical.
  • The recipient must be a qualified non-profit.
  • The technology must be viable.
 Case Study - Most donors are large companies that have treated the tax savings as too small to report separately to investors. But Lubrizol, a specialty chemical company based in Wickliffe, Ohio, said in April that its $22.4 million gift of 38 patents to a local development group called the Cleveland Advanced Manufacturing Program would help cut its tax rate this year from 33 percent to 30 percent.   G. Dump  - It is not exactly the commercialization method but mainly used to save the renewable fee for the unutilized patent.     Case study -  IBM has made another patent dump, this time granting universal access to over 150 patents meant to assure that software can interoperate.  

 

 Author by -      Deepesh Pareta

IIT Khargapur

 Top Comment : ROOP JALUTHARIA   | 09 03 2009 21:17:16 +0000
Thanks for this wonderful article-sharing. But it may take some time to see proper commercialization-insurance,& licensing of IP products in India. Right now, even the basic information and awareness about IP rights among the business community and common public is missing, leave apart protection and commercialization !
 
1 comments on "Strategic Intellectual Property Commercialization and Methods"
Rating : +1 
Thanks for this wonderful article-sharing.

But it may take some time to see proper commercialization-insurance,& licensing of IP products in India.
Right now, even the basic information and awareness about IP rights among the business community and common public is missing, leave apart protection and commercialization ! 
Add your comment on "Strategic Intellectual Property Commercialization and Methods"

Rate:
Submit
Leading staffing and human resources consulting firm
  • Create a confidential Career Profile and Resume/C.V. online
  • Get advice for planning their career and for marketing of experience and skills
  • Maximize awareness of and access to the best career opportunities
Viewers also viewed
Biotechnology V/s Intellectual Property   Intellectual Property is the term used to describe the...
 
9 referals 3 comments, 477 views
When it comes to importing, an international trade entrepreneur seeks to derive significant...
 
1 referals 2 votes, 380 views
WE HAD A GOOD NUMBER OF INVENTORS WITH GREATER VISION ABOUT THE SOCIETY. INVENTORS HERE NEED NOT...
 
2 referals 2 arguments, 97 views
more...  
Recent Knowledge (78)
The subject should be rather in form of a statement. A bold statement . Yes!! Yes!! When you get...
 
1386 referals 8 comments, 104 views
Accounting of revenues costs in Entertainment Ind. 13 May 2010 2,927 views No Comment   A common...
 
0 referals 1 comments, 286 views
Excerpt from the Book “Unposted Letter” by T. T. Rangarajan ’10 minutes early’ means I can live...
 
2078 referals 27 comments, 357 views
more...