Build your professional network on facebook via our app Go to app
 
 
 
Functional Area : Religions and Atrocities
Activity:  9 comments  505 views  last activity : 06 12 2011 02:31:23 +0000
Share
 
 
 

'Sanathana Dharma' thinking has had some great exponents of peace and harmony as its seers. The profundity of its preachings has driven many a sociologist in the world to bode a great future for the concept. The essence of 'Pantheism' put forward by the preachers of the 'Sanathana Dharma' principles, maintains the concept that there exists no difference between God and his creations that include the Universe itself and among the lesser entities – Man. This has also been the impetus for the lives of the saintly ones such as Gautam Buddha, Valmiki who had cried 'Ma Nishada' to the hunter, and Mahathma Gandhi that history and myth aver having lived in this part of the world, practising as well as preaching Ahimsa, the great value of non-violence.

The Biggest Animal Sacrifice in the WorldIt has been but a travesty of that history that last day a part of the same region that gave birth to more noble souls such as Swamy Vivekananda, Vardhamana Mahaveera and Sri Narayana Guru witnessed a ruthless, remorseless and pre-diluvian act of slaughtering around twenty five thousand dumb creatures in the name of satiating God. Even here the savage perpetrators were seen to be resorting to sort of symbolic racism as they chose the hebetudinous buffaloes for the carnage instead of the holy cows. Any being with brains and a bit of audacity – effrontery for the conservatives – would absolutely not refrain from impugning the logic behind this discrimination besides chastising the nefariousness of the act. More so, considering the fact that both the animals belong to the bovine group with four gastro-intestinal chambers. Buffaloes, much like their sacred counterparts serve the human beings by providing commodities such as milk, hide, fuel, manure for their crops and agricultural labour. Furthermore, if the divinity of the cow is linked to the heavenly Kamadenu and the legend of Krishna, the buffalo does not trail as well, being depicted as the sacred vehicle of Yama, the God of Death.

So back to the ghoulish event that bore a dastardly tint for its nature of wasting some more of the timidest beings on the earth's crust such as goats, rats, pigeons and poultry, this animal sacrifice that began in Nepal on Tuesday is undoubtedly the largest animal sacrifice in the world in terms of the number of subjects. The carnage took place in the Nepali village of Bariyapur in the vicinity of the country's border shared with India. It is understood that the event that takes place every five years in the honour of a Hindu Goddess of power, Gadhimai, began with the decapitation of a couple of rats (the vehicle of Lord Ganesha), a couple of pigeons (symbol of peace), a boar (an incarnation among Lord Vishnu's Great Ten) a lamb and a rooster.

It is intriguing that the popular news portal of the United Kingdom, The Guardian has quoted a Nepali driver as saying that if they wanted something and they went there with an offering to the deity, all their dreams would be fulfilled within five years. This certainly leaves the concerned populaces of the more developed parts of the world with a ghastly reflection of Hinduism itself. Could they be blamed if they consider this religion as just a clandestine military arrangement for defending the like forces of other religions such as Islam and Christianity? Could they be blamed for wondering why such powerful deities seldom save the land from terrorist atrocities and natural calamities, despite devotees wasting tens of thousands of lives – of both animals and people – in the name of sacrifice performed in their honour?

Coming back to the gore carried out at the blessed village premises in Nepal, where frightened calves were found galloping around in vain – even the wildest buffaloes and wildebeests of Serengeti and Kruger sailing clear of lions, seldom feel such depths of despair – as the task of decapitation of ten thousand buffaloes with little compunction was being carried out meticulously by the traditional kukri knives, in a dusty enclosure guarded by armed police and high walls. What next? Anyone can bet that the revenue from the selling of the dead beasts to firms that profit from the sale of hide and bone besides meat, would never go to the people who brought the poor creatures to the slaughter-place. If so, if not the profits reach the coffers of the conductors – let us refrain from blaming the priesthood - what is the fun in all these?

Furthermore, the heroes of the high-voltage drama – the holy butchers that pursue the panic-stricken beings, wearing red bandanas and armbands - of course for the sake of the Godmen behind the curtains that virtually feast on the carcasses that even makes the profligate, debauched, merciless and avaricious emperors of the Roman Empire with their abject gladiators blush - are more than content as they are copiously lauded by the priests such as Chandan Dev Chaudhary of the locality after the bloodshed. Chaudhary too appears satiated as he hysterically puts it, “The Deity needs blood and the person that helps her get that, makes his wishes come true”.

My heart really overflows for the buffaloes (along with the other wasted creatures), for at least this time they are not soldiers and obviously there is no Bob Marley as well to croon and win for these ill-fated creatures of the same creator, the world's sympathy.

 Top Comment : Inani Sarkar   | 11 30 2009 11:04:16 +0000
I had seen this news earlier in the Guardian and Reuters website, and felt really bad for those animals which were slaughtered like anything, and 250,000 is a huge number and Governments should ban these inhuman acts. Though people consume the meat, but then to slaughter like this, just to praise the lord is nonsense, god doesn't require blood, its just sheer superstition that is driving this festival where thousands of buffaloes and other animals are slaughtered. Feels really bad:(
 
9 comments on "They don't Really Care about the Buffaloes"
  Commented by  pruthviraja pande, Professor, Bangalore University    | 12 02 2009 12:45:09 +0000
Good content for debating, the fact remains is as shyam said, it is only a exploitation in the name of superstition, we slaughter the innocent, helpless and dumb animals.  when we see into their eyes before slaughtering them, their innocence and silence does it not impact the slaughterer's wicket intention to finish it for his gain in the name of either "Sacrifice" or "allah"? it is nothing but un-organised sector of KFC running since decades!! God should save poor animals? and the fact is even the god in whose name these slaughtering is on and on, comes on land and say "Please do not sacrifice poor animals-for my sake, for heaven sake" might be the slaughter would sacrifice the god itself?? 
  Commented by  SHARATH CHANDAR REDDY, Business Development Manager - Insurance, I T C Ltd    | 12 02 2009 09:59:38 +0000
I read in detail the article and various comments & views. I appreciate Gavaz for sharing this article, Shyam for further updations and Inani, Shiulu, Priya, Makrand for vriety of views. I can only add that any sensible individual feels bad about killing any living being. That is why sanatana dharma is an invaluable asset!!!
Rating : +1 
there will be some who will b'live in animal acrifice and there will be some who wont b'live it it. poles of opposite will exit in this world on any issue or aspect. its all about our individual principles coupled will relegious, ethinic influences. as along as it is not rampantly againt nature...,
as far as the issue killing the animal goes... this world has been always about survival of the fittest. and human beings are most inhuman.
  Commented by  Shiuli Mukherji, Film Producer, Global Films Malaysia    | 12 02 2009 07:46:36 +0000
Rating : +2 
The question is in Animal Kingdom, Are Bovines equal in Value to Humans?
In the big picture of earthly existence, are the lives of bovines and other animals any value to humans? Just thinking aloud not as an animal rights activist, nor as a philosopher nor an intellectual who is immune to personal hypocrisy. In fact, in plainspoken, opinionated, homespun English. 
From a view of a consumer, capitalist and religious bigots. Bovines are raised for sale to provide meat on the dinner table for hundreds of human families, they are also slaughtered to bring good Faith in Human soul.
Gavaz, what do you say to people who accuse you of reading your own human emotions and perspective into what you're witnessing with this kind of act? Wildlife biologists may say that one is speculating with conjecture and staking out a subjective position rather than an objective one that is based on the gathering of peer-reviewed empirical evidence. And some in the religious community argue that equating the value of humans to animals is heresy. If you want your paradigm shift to be taken seriously by public land managers and private property owners, how do you prove what your gut is telling you?
To my knowledge, anthropomorphize means “to attribute human form or personality to things not human”. But there is no opposite term in Webster’s Dictionary. If there is, I have never heard it used in scientific circles. Without the opposite view being presented or identified, I have to attribute the origins of the term, anthropomorphism, to the bias of superiority humans assert over everything else in the world.
Superiority is a “Catch-22” in the biological science world. We assign life judged against our own, but this bias keeps us from actually seeing what life is. Anthropomorphism, and its resulting sense of superiority, doesn’t stop at animal vs. human comparisons. To conquer and kill, people have to justify their actions. Thus we get the words “sub humans”, savages, slaves, Aryan Race and Holocaust. 

More subtle and insidious is what this attitude creates when we manage, domesticate or control other living things.
  Commented by  Makrand Bhave, Marketing & MICE, WIZCRAFT INternational    | 12 01 2009 11:21:56 +0000
Not to take away the emotion and the sacred nature attached to the bovine family... I wish to ask all of you here to look at it a little differently!!
It is now a known fact that these bovine creatures emit METHANE as a gnas that they belch out after their digestion process called rumination. These are secreted a@ 1/2 (half) a pound per minute!! Methane is a highly inflammable gas and is also not useful for our breathing process. Nor is it useful for the plants in anyway. But Methane has the capacity to double its presence in the atmosphere in 10 years and also it can trap heat 20 times more than Carbon does!! Its higly dangerous to our very existence!!
So please look at this a little more practically. The reason why I would condone this festivity is for the sheer murderous nature of these lovely animals under the pious garb, but if done for the reasons of greener environment.... It would be a different cause altogether!! Please do not take this as an argument but use this info as awareness... 
Thank you.
  Commented by  Gavaz Kanjiramnilkkunnathil, Chief of Bureau/Editor in Chief, VAC Media Pvt Ltd    | 12 01 2009 10:59:52 +0000
Thank you Shyam for the sympathetic response. Alongside I deeply regret the shortcomings in the article. I hope you would with a broad mind condone those considering the fact that I am not that consummate a writer.

However, with people such as Shyam and Inani and definitely even more, taking pain to ponder over such subtleties of human social life, the difference would be certainly visible, or the gaps left by me would be bridged more efficiently.
  Commented by  Shyam Sundar Mishra, Project Leader/Managing Consultant, Mentor Graphics    | 12 01 2009 05:21:20 +0000
Nice of you to bring up such a subject in this professional forum.
However, in your attempt to discuss about sanatan dharma, you missed out the very essence of  the reasons behind such weird behavior mankind.
Why do human beings kill after all ? Whether it is for your "chicken sandwich" or  for  "bakrid" or for  "Devi-pujan" its all the same isn't it ?
Human beings kill because they desire to exploit the nature for their fulfillments.
There is no limit to human greed.

I don't see how KFC is any better than those who "Sacrifice" in the name of God : whether they call Him Allah or  just  "Devi".
The fundamental problem remains the same : the desire to exploit.
In this regard, I would like to point out that you missed out the greatest exponents of sanatan dharma in your message: The vaishnav acharyas : Ramanuja, Madhva, Nimbarka, Vallabhacharya and of course, Gauranga Mahaprabhu.
The divine message given by those Acharyas  far transcends the plane of exploitation (as well as  false renunciation).

But this is a professional forum and to say much about this here would seem out of place.
We should also wonder why we are slaughtering this animal : this human life, by engaging in worthless pursuits of exploitation (and sometimes of false renunciation).
First we should try to correct ourselves. We can't do much for animals that are slaughtered in thousands of factories around the globe. The fair in Nepal is just an open factory and you see it being done in the name of "Devi". You will find more such "open factories" where millions of animals lose their life to some other false idea. The basic problem is exploitation.
  Commented by  Gavaz Kanjiramnilkkunnathil, Chief of Bureau/Editor in Chief, VAC Media Pvt Ltd    | 11 30 2009 15:45:39 +0000
Nice of you Inani. See that you act as well....somewhere....sometime...
  Commented by  Inani Sarkar, Sales/BD Manager, Aricent    | 11 30 2009 11:04:16 +0000
Rating : +1 
I had seen this news earlier in the Guardian and Reuters website, and felt really bad for those animals which were slaughtered like anything, and 250,000 is a huge number and Governments should ban these inhuman acts. Though people consume the meat, but then to slaughter like this, just to praise the lord is nonsense, god doesn't require blood, its just sheer superstition that is driving this festival where thousands of buffaloes and other animals are slaughtered. Feels really bad:(
Add your comment on "They don't Really Care about the Buffaloes"

Rate:
Submit
Leading Health Care Recruitment Firm
Leading Hearth Care Recruitment Firm
Viewers also viewed
The world's biggest social networking site Facebook faces a unique challenge next week when it...
 
1089 referals 21 arguments, 366 views
The rainy season is here and this is the time we need to take utmost care because this beautiful...
 
1740 referals 11 votes, 929 views
Air Pollution Education Is Necessory vs Air Pollution Education is Not Necessory
 
945 referals 16 arguments, 184 views
more...  
Recent Knowledge (106)
A Sufi Story Once upon a time, a fox that lost its legs lived in a forest. A forester who used...
 
294 referals 8 comments, 168 views
The English language has some wonderfully anthropomorphic collective nouns for the various...
 
87 referals 5 comments, 82 views
If we analyse the nature of students' demand, what they want as customers are: Expert Teaching...
 
245 referals 17 comments, 262 views
more...