| Topic : Increasing the likelihood of project implementation success |
|
|
Energy Professionals |
International Oil & Gas Professionals Hub |
My vision |
2 more ...|
|
Activity:
Question posted: 05 07 2009 10:43:17 +0000,
6 answers, 201 views, last activity
07 06 2010 20:18:08 +0000
|
|
According to my thinking....
1. We are not the the appropriate research track to find its feasibility.....
2. Every research and project is haffazard and there is no systematic approach...
3. We are not creating any future vision and just focussing on resources available at present but not thinking of alternatives that can replace present fuels and can be used in future without giving much impact on Environmental abnormilities created by man.
4. No proper designing for proper implementation or maintenance of project undergoing at present in India creating a feeling of non-acceptance for the biofuel programme and boosting opinions that project is not appropriate for India...
5. Biggest controvery is that biofuel plants can grow on wasteland but all wasteland are not suitable or avialable for mass plantation (environmental parameters also affect the finalization of project implementation)
These are my views and opinions.....
If i m wrong then please clear me with the fact and if i m right then how can we tackle this situation....
Thank you for participating....
Mr. Siddhartha.....u were askin that
what do you think Mr. Kaustubh is Biofuel the real alternative...or is it possible for India to implement biofuel as the alternative?? what are your views on this.........and even i have seen the debate where people are saying biofuel crops can be grown on wasteland...is it true that it can only be grown on wastelands.....and what are the type of biofuel crops that are there.....
First of all i want to clear u that biofuel crops gives much more better results on fertile land...it is not the thing that it can just be grown on wasteland....the concept of growing biofuel plants on wasteland has come in limelight because....
1. The biofuel plant which is selected for biofuel cultivation (i.e. Jatropha Curcus L. is the species) is basically a xerophyte...thus it can comfortably grow anywhere as it doesnt require much water....
2. Due to above point, there is mis-conception that as its an xerophyte it doesnt require any nutrients and can grow on it own...but this is not true.....if u just want green cover and want to control soil erosion then the above concept works but here we are concerned with max. seed yield...so for Jatropha plantation, for 1st three years we have to give the plant full nourishment by supplying water, fertilizer, etc... after that it becomes self sustaining and can give yield...but for initial years we have to take care....
Due to above 2 reasons...the project is failing in India and at present i can say that we can have biofuels as alternatives and to be more precise as an additive... But if project is implemented well and planned well that yes it has got the potential to replace present fuel.....
Also i want to convey that all wastelands are not appropriate for plantation as it also depends on geographical features and other source availability like water, fertilizers etc.Also Jatropha Curcus L. is an exotic species from Latin America and so we dont have that much knowledge of its consequences of plantation/introduction of such species in India(i m much more worried for this).....
Species other than jatropha that can be used for biofuel plantation are all kind of oil producing species...But the thing is we cant use edible oil producing species as already there is pressure on production and availability of edible oil in market so we cant divert it towards this side...some also are medicinal ones like neem, olive oil etc... so cant take them... Other species that can be taken are Pongamia pinnata(Karanj in marathi) and Mahua tree.
I HOPE I HAD GIVEN U THE INFORMATION U WANTED.....IF ANY QUERRY PLS DONT HASITATE...THANK YOU....
Hello Kaustubh,
I am not very much convinced with your statements.It is not like that research and projects are not going on the right path, but the problem is of the globally economization. In Brazil, America and European countries, people are relying on single source like Brazil is dependent only on sugarcane bagasse, america is dependent on corn and European countries are mainly dependent on sugar beets, but in india we can not rely on a single crop. Here, neither we have enough land or enormous amount of crops that we can use for biofuel production.
However, Department of Biotechnology, Govt of India and CSIR, Govt of India has now switched over to lignocellulosic biomass as a feedstock for biofuel production. Here they are using wastes such as cotton stalk, bagasses, weeds, groundnut shells, waste papers etc to use their carbohydrate part for biofuel production.
Now, the need of the hour is to economize the process by producing indigenous enzymes, cheaper raw material and subsidies on various parts.
Great kaustubh you have cleared my doubts....but then will it be able to match up the volume that is there in the case of fossil fuel and as Beena has said we can produce different variants through Tissue culture and i guess by this we can make sure that with minimum investment we can produce these biofuel crops and make them grow in different conditions with the resistant variants...what do you say....
Yes I agree fully with Kaustubh as the project needs proper plannig as this is a project which needs vast land with plants which produce highest yield of seeds producing biofuel ; just for information following parameters are necessary to follow up;
1) Finding out land as much in ones reach
2) Contract farming with buy back agreement of seeds
3) Select high yielding plant and produce saplings of that particular plant by tissue culture method
4) Distribution of T.C. raisedplants
5) seed collection centres
6) crude oil extraction
7) Refineries
N.B. One has to consider at least 10,000 hectares of land for continuous production of a definite amount per day.
your views are right Mr. kaustubh...i think it has to do with like people are just satisfied with the current resources that are available and not planning anything for the future...and even the government is not interested to take any initiative regarding this...and what do you think Mr. Kaustubh is Biofuel the real alternative...or is it possible for India to implement biofuel as the alternative?? what are your views on this.........and even i have seen the debate where people are saying biofuel crops can be grown on wasteland...is it true that it can only be grown on wastelands.....and what are the type of biofuel crops that are there.....
Great Issue you have bought up Kasutubh......already our farmers facing worst situations & they cannot simply just start using crops for biofuels though. They still need food for themselves and to sell. Status quo crop production is not nearly sufficient to meet these uses so if any advancement is to be made, a substantial increase in productivity must occur. Several major impediments to such an increase exist, including the current climate situation and water scarcity, and other natural resource depletion and degradation such as deforestation and poor uses of land such as to render them less fertile. These are already big challenges in themselves to tackle if production had to be increased for food alone. With the addition of biofuels though, that makes the task that much harder and if not done carefully and thoughtfully, growing crops for biofuels could make the situation even worse.......
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
hello shikha, Now the thing is every one is saying about harnessing renewable technologies for the surplus requirement of energy. But looking at the pace of development it doesnt seem true for atleast next 25 years. You are telling that our T D losses... |
This is the answer to every1 questions... Meaning of Vande Mataram as translated by Shri Aurobindo:I bow to thee, Mother, richly-watered, richly-fruited, cool with the winds of the south, dark with the crops of the harvests, the Mother ! Her nights... |
Dear Ankit Gandhi and Bindu Narayan....u r telling that greenfuels are generated from fossil sources...!!! then please explain me by giving example to ur justification because as much i know fuels from fossil resources are termed as Fossil fuels which... |