|
Activity:
Question posted: 05 30 2011 09:54:31 +0000,
2 answers, 85 views, last activity
05 31 2011 03:38:52 +0000
|
|
|
|
I understand that Central Information Commission (CIC) has asked the Supreme Court (SC) to explain the rationale behind a certain judgement. When Supreme Court gives a judgement, we consider it as final and binding. The judges normally express the rational behind giving such judgement.
Do you think CIC has a right to ask SC to explain the rational behind a judgement. Does it not amount to interefering in the functioning of the Supreme Court ?
There is nothing worng in CIC asking Supreme Court to give rational behind a Judgement. Even you and I can ask them. We call it by different Name to respect the Judiciary. Normally COurts give eleborate reasoning nehind a judgement while delivering it. if they dont and or you are not satisfied you can file rvivew petition. and ask for a full bench to go throigh it again and the courts doesnot get offended by it. it is the duty of the courts to give such explanations and normally it is part of a judgement. So one need not make an issue out of such things. COurts always accept such things if you have a reason behind it or you have knowledge of more information. They welcome it.
When the judgement is read, in toto,all the details (Iincluding the genesis, arguments,reason and rationale in coming to certain assumptions and conclusions etc. etc) are either included or appended in a systematic and laborious manner. Normally, it is final. Sometimes, S C may review its own position. But, that is rare.
|
|
The Hon'ble SC overreached its domain vs The Hon'ble SC stood tough on corrupt practices |
|
|
136 referals
17 arguments,
591 views
|
|
|
borrower alone should be liable as he is the only beneficiary vs Guarantors should repay when... |
|
|
1187 referals
19 arguments,
421 views
|
|
|
|
Criminals and Politicians vs Common Public |
|
|
0 referals
7 arguments,
83 views
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
202 referals
1 answers,
21 views
|
|
|
Hello! Mr.Dinesh. I have done my PG in MBA Finance (Chandigarh Business School affiliated to... |
|
|
1 referals
0 answers,
0 views
|
|
|
I am writing to introduce myself to you as Varun Sivakumar, who has... |
|
|
1 referals
0 answers,
0 views
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Vinoy Ji a learned and pragmatic person should not have joined the debate on the wrong side. Let us give the fair sex, the freedom, security and support and see what happens. Nothing is going to change in a day! Let us support them for their fight in... |
In India - Religion must stay away from politics. No place for religion or religious gurus in politics. No second thought about it !! |
I am not fluent in Hindi. Being a Sanskrit student (in my child-hood days) I am able to read it and grasp the essence of it. Good and nice poem !! |