Build your professional network on facebook via our app Go to app
 
 
 
Industry : Radio, TV & Films
Functional Area : Politics
Activity: Question posted: 08 02 2009 05:46:15 +0000, 12 answers, 322 views, last activity 07 06 2010 20:18:08 +0000
 
 Refer 96
Share
 
 
  Rate : 
 
 

Even 62 years after independence, the virus of communalism is alive in India. Discrimination at every level is a serious problem plaguing the country. 

As the Bollywood actor Emran Hashmi alleged he had been denied a house he wanted to buy in the upmarket Pali Hill area of Mumbai because he was Muslim. 

Earlier Shabana Azmi and Javed Akhtar had faced problems in getting a house in Juhu and TV actor Aamir Khan filed a litigation after being refused a house in Lokhandwala. 

It is strange that they don't tell you on your face that you can't avail because you are a Muslim.

All the time we are talking about secularism but with such incidents what secularism are people talking about?

 
 Top Answer :
Rating : +6 

Shahid, the issue is not secularism, it’s the comfort level of a buyer and a seller as far as the case of Emraan Hashmi is concerned.

Now it’s a completely different issue that as he happens to be a Celebrity, his ego is ruffled and thus he wants to give a minority -religious- connotation. To top the matter, the media also plays the tune.

Now Secularism:

  1. Please do not blame all social ills in India on Hindus. All communities have their quirks and cultural notions and sensitivities. How can beef eating Muslims stay with Hindus in the same society?
    1)Gau mata or Cow is holy for Hindus, while you eat beef which is against our religious sensitivities?
  2. Pork is haram for Muslims and so will they allow Pork eating Christians or others to live amidst them? A few days back I had a delegation representing Hongkong, and few of my Islam colleagues, were asking for Halal meet in Honkong which was an alien term for Honkies.
  3. Many Muslims owe their allegiance to Mecca rather than India is this fair?
  4. Compared to Pakistan and Middle Eastern terror exporting states India is a haven for all religions
  5. And finally India is democratic, secular republic coz you can express your views and thoughts, had it been any Islam country, this right of expression would not have been there. Like in Malaysia ( where there are 60% Malays, 30% Chinese and 10% Indians) one would be barred under ISA act if one happens to express any anti-islamic views.



[ Delete ]
[ Edit ]
Report Abuse
by   Shiuli Mukherji, Head Strategy Plan- , Region SEA  | 08 03 2009 14:24:05 +0000
  Answered by     Ajay Ziz, Dy. Registrar,, University of Jammu  | 12 19 2009 05:50:20 +0000
[ Delete ]
[ Edit ]
Not Rated

pandey your shot is on target ... and IIM A keep it up for selecting such quality kids..

[ Delete ]
[ Edit ]
Not Rated

Respected Shahid Siddiqui are you aware of the fact that there are some areas where Hindus are brutally slaughtered by the people of your mass as they think that in that area it is the monastery of them and not the Indian government if you are not aware then the rest is worthless talks also if you don't agree then I will show you those places

[ Delete ]
[ Edit ]
Rating : +2 

Its a pity that celebs like Imran Hashmi raise these kind of vague issues knowing the fact that they have been made a so called star by

a majority community without any discrimination and above of all, his all box office ventures are being undertaken by a person hailing from

 different community. The only reason seems is that he is just doing it for some cheap gimmick. And to my utter surprise now u can find

 him keeping himself away from all these allegations and playing safe. Now wat has happened Mr. Hashmi..

  Answered by     Rakesh Chakraborty, Sr. Associate, ING  | 08 04 2009 12:50:01 +0000
[ Delete ]
[ Edit ]
Rating : +3 

Mr.Shahid, may I ask you one simple thing? you said they don't tell you on your face that you can't avail because of religion. Then how can you decide problem is only because of religion not some other reason? and why you are mixing nationalism with religion. This problem is not only in one side but both the side. In states like West Bengal, still there are districts like Puruliya and Dinajpur where the minority Hindus feel afraid of celebrating Durga Puja since it falls at the times of Ramzan, Why nationalism of singing Vandemataram was taken with that of Religion.?..well, I won't take this issue further but would like to say only this much that every time the problem is not religion. In the recent days Indian nationals have become too much afraid because of growing terrorism and contact of celebrities with underworld. Thats why may be they are too much concerned.

There may be other issues like the security of the celebrity.Maybe the landlord wants to keep himself away from media because these type of problem not only happened with Muslim stars but with Hindu stars as well.

Anyways, this is only my view. It may differ....

  Answered by     Hrudanand De, Area Sales Manager (Modern Trade )  | 08 04 2009 10:13:24 +0000
[ Delete ]
[ Edit ]
Rating : +2 

India is a secular country irrespective of several caste ,creed and religion we are unique in compared to those muslim countries where thinking this is a Utopia.

We are still paying respect to other religion and lives as a single entity inspide of the several terrorism creted mostly by Muslim country or minority.

 

  Answered by     Sayan Chakraborty, Senior ERP Consultant, International Business machines  | 08 02 2009 19:40:48 +0000
[ Delete ]
[ Edit ]
Rating : +5 

Yes--I feel if secularism atall exists then it exists in India

Though the idea of secularism is little confusing to many

Secularism does not mean sacrifice by Mejority to uplift minority

we India atleast say it is secular---Bangladesh,Pakistan,Afghanistan,Iraq,Saudi dont even think of it

Why go to so far---just see if Kashmir in India feels secular way? So imagine it is example how secular rest of the india is....

  Answered by     Satish Verma, Senior Technical Lead, HCL Technologies  | 08 02 2009 14:57:30 +0000
[ Delete ]
[ Edit ]
Rating : +1 

If you are bachelor and searching house for rent, in 9 out of 10 apartments/home it gets denied.

There might be different reason for some issue.  And someone just can't blame India's secularism for all their personal issue.

Some of the people of India, achieved lot in their life respective of cast/religion and they did not remember secularism and when any problems comes due to any ABC reason they start blaming, it’s because of  their religion or cast.

This type of incident brings more distance between people when make hue and cry from nothing and make any issue as religious issue.

  Answered by     Satish Verma, Senior Technical Lead, HCL Technologies  | 08 02 2009 14:56:48 +0000
[ Delete ]
[ Edit ]
Not Rated

If you are bachelor and searching house for rent, in 9 out of 10 apartments/home it gets denied.

There might be different reason for some issue.  And someone just can't blame India's secularism for all their personal issue.

Some of the people of India, achieved lot in their life respective of cast/religion and they did not remember secularism and when any problems comes due to any ABC reason they start blaming, it’s because of  their religion or cast.

This type of incident brings more distance between people when make hue and cry from nothing and make any issue as religious issue.

 

[ Delete ]
[ Edit ]
Rating : +3 

Secularism is a very broad term and defined differently by different people.

Imraan Hashmi remembers "Secularism" when he is denied a Flat. That too, after he is given stardom by the society.

Mohmad Ajharuddin remembers "secularism" when he is denied captaincy. That too, after so much of name and fame in cricket.

So, Secularism is a very convenient term. Used by many people, for short term gains.

Before Emraan Hashmi, Housing society might have denied flats to many people. But that does not become a case of Secularism.

Secularism, to its true definition is "equal opportunities to all in society irrespective of religion, caste." Secularism is totally opposed to the concept of Reservation based on caste. Yet, the people, who seek reservation, talk of secularism.

Secularism will take roots in India, when all Indians (including majorities as well as minorities) will consider themselves as Indian first, when they will know that, religion is for practicing without intefering in public life. 

 
Part of Randstad, the world’s second largest HR services company
  • Create a confidential Career Profile and Resume/C.V. online
  • Get advice for planning their career and for marketing of experience and skills
  • Maximize awareness of and access to the best career opportunities
Viewers also viewed
Madhya Pradesh chief minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan has said that there would have been no...
 
2216 referals 53 arguments, 1025 views
We need communal harmony for sure. Narendra Modi will be fasting for 3 days for communal...
 
2063 referals 41 arguments, 544 views
West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee's special economic and development package for the...
 
1483 referals 12 arguments, 374 views
more...  
Unanswered Questions (35)
does anyone know why the toostep is not updating ? the last updates on my home page are of 20...
 
0 referals 0 answers, 0 views
if you have a single fsi,how much carpet area can you construct on A 500 SQ METER PLOT,PLEASE...
 
0 referals 0 answers, 0 views
Hi, I want to know what can be a lean project for A Healthcare industry for a SCM personnel. It...
 
0 referals 0 answers, 0 views
More From Author
This prefixing of religion and a holy color of a religion came in the backdrop of wide usage of another word Islamic terrorism, Jihadi terrorism, the words coined by American media and picked up world over. Surely these terminologies Islamic terrorism...
@ Mr. Manoj.....Lets not argue beyond the topic. Don't forget: Every debate is an opportunity to learn. Sometime Debating, make you learning. Nevertheless, debates often go wrong but should by easy to understand. That’s the second reason I use the...
?
more...