Build your professional network on facebook via our app Go to app
 
<< Prev  47 of 121 in Topic  Next >>
Topic : Construction Project Management
  Rate : 
 
Industry : Construction
Functional Area : Project Management
Activity: Question posted: 01 12 2010 05:56:54 +0000, 19 answers, 264 views, last activity 07 06 2010 20:18:08 +0000
 
Share
 
 
 
 

Recently we seen in news that the major constuction sturctures are collapsed in various places of India. Like Balco's chimney, fly over bridges in Utter Pradesh, and Indian capital Delhi.

And all these structures are constructing by well experienced and well deserved companies, even though the there is a failure.

Kindly share your views on this topic, why under-cosntuction structures collapses?

 

 
 Top Answer :
Rating : +2 

The attitude of chalta hai. No one checks thoroughly the complete system, the calculations, their adequacy either due to carelessness or not having the knowledge. The professionalism is lacking and there is compromise in the quality.

This has to viewed seriously and accoutabilty/ responsibility has to be fixed. The reasons should be fully investigated and remidial steps to be taken.

 



[ Delete ]
[ Edit ]
Report Abuse
by   Anil Kohli, Vice President, DIMTS Ltd.  | 01 16 2010 18:02:25 +0000
  Answered by     Aditya Sharma, Insurance Advisor/Analyst, LIC OF INDIA, ICICI LOMBARD  | 02 12 2010 04:30:37 +0000
[ Delete ]
[ Edit ]
Not Rated

The carelessness is the sole reason for the under contruction structures to collapss. Look we have the technology and the expertise to build and run big construction structures. It has been prooved by our engineers so many times. I need not give examples of it. Carelessness is the biggest reason. Greed also creeps in sometimes or I should say most of the times. So according to me Greed and carelessness are the two biggest reasons for our underconstruction structures to collapse.

  Answered by     Anjali Sinha, Construction-Heavy, Sobha Developers  | 02 03 2010 10:23:35 +0000
[ Delete ]
[ Edit ]
Not Rated

Well said Tapan, all the points you have mentioned are valid and are also major reason for the the construction collapses. We should keep in mind and then try to correct it. 

  Answered by     Pragya Kothari, Construction-Heavy, DLF  | 01 29 2010 12:46:56 +0000
[ Delete ]
[ Edit ]
Not Rated

I agree what Anil said, it is because of the carelessness and improper investigation. And like to throw some light, I think we are lacking behind in technology especially in construction sector. So to overcome this issue we should adopt good technologies.  

  Answer modified by     Mathew Cherian, Research Associate/Analyst, Western Michigan University  | 01 19 2010 18:25:22 +0000
[ Delete ]
[ Edit ]
Not Rated

The theory of beam  loading originated from the ideas of yester year Mathematician Euler. When beams are loaded  the weights acting on it cannot create sustained oscillations,  or over damped oscillation, instead it should be designed for "under damping" meaning loads that create oscillations must bring the started oscillation to rest as soon as possible. This is affirmed by selecting proper materials with the right "torsion" and "shear" charecteristics and deploying them at proper distances between the pillars. If this calculations go wrong "over damped" oscillations of the structure can occur and create rupture which destabilise the loading and the structure collapses.

  Answered by     Thilak , Director on Board, KCCB CIVIL CONSTRUCTIONS  | 01 18 2010 11:22:51 +0000
[ Delete ]
[ Edit ]
Not Rated

Most construction accidents occur in the under construction structures as one of the most important aspect of construction is either being ignored or under valued.

FORMWORK.

Just like a concrete structure, form work being a temporary structure has to be properly designed by experienced designers to withstand the concrete loading and after pour behavior of concrete structures. Not only form work but also the method of assembling and dissembling the form work has to be designed properly to ensure that the concrete structure is not prematurely loaded before attaining its intended strength.

Only rarely do companies give importance to form work and this may be one of the biggest reasons for under-construction structures collapses.

As far as quality of structure is concerned, the degree of safety used for construction in india is too high that even if we use 75 % of actual materials intended to be used, still the structure will stand.

  Answered by     Chandresh Kumar, Planning Engineer, H L EQUIPMENTS  | 01 17 2010 06:12:46 +0000
[ Delete ]
[ Edit ]
Not Rated

It is also a side effect of cost cutting. Mgmt wants to complet the work with new machinary with new man power with new ideas but less experties. This happens from a labour class to managerial class

  Answered by     Tapan Kumar Chakravarty, Executive Director, Reacon Engineers(I) Pvt.Ltd.  | 01 17 2010 06:06:13 +0000
[ Delete ]
[ Edit ]
Rating : +1 

1 partialy faulty design.2.poor quality control.3 proper supervision & 4.corruption in the system.

  Answered by     Mohammad Bakhsh, Project Leader/Managing Consultant, Freelancer  | 01 17 2010 04:50:25 +0000
[ Delete ]
[ Edit ]
Not Rated

Most of the failure are due to handling machinery.Any project should start and close out with safety measures in tact.It is never meant that failure will happen but it is the only retrograde steps in construction industries.The detailed project report pay only lip service to safety.The second most important aspect is use of heavy machinery.The competency of operators and fitness of machinery are never taken care of.

  Answered by     sinnappapillaiganesan , architect,interior designer, consulting architect  | 01 16 2010 19:00:29 +0000
[ Delete ]
[ Edit ]
Rating : +1 

Inadequate curing period of concrete structures,Lack of supervision on reinforcement 

fitment causes the structures collapses during construction.

 
 
Viewers also viewed
Most of the buildings in Mumbai are not constructed in right way. After completion, they start...
 
9 referals 5 votes, 138 views
I always add a query on my mind that when we consider the effectiveness in understanding and...
 
1 referals 22 arguments, 1385 views
Who has more chances of being succesfull in a Project Manager's Role in Construction Projects...???
 
104 referals 58 arguments, 1559 views
more...  
Unanswered Questions (81)
 
0 referals 1 answers, 84 views
Life is meaningless only if we allow it to be. Each of us has the power to give life meaning, to...
 
187 referals 4 answers, 94 views
 
19 referals 0 answers, 0 views
More From Author
Absolutely, we never get a job which is dreamed. and what we got is to self motivated to do that because of family problems and and surviving in the society.
Yes, nothing achieved, most of the employors and educational institutions declared holiday. some of the employees had taken holiday. Now the issue is who were suffered with this bandh and who were benefitted? The first suffered person is daily wage...
Trust in yourself is absolutely correct. Just fulfill ur duties as a employee thats all. If our employer is supports us we get double promotion and more increments, if not we cannt any thing just only salary or we shift to other emplyor. But our work...
more...