Build your professional network on facebook via our app Go to app
Sumanta Mukherjee Product Development Manager, Tata Motors
 
Create knowledge [?]
 
(rate this)
Yes, huge sales will add to traffic problems  
8
VS
14
 No, it is Local Government's Failure/Responsibility.
Nikhil  |  Argues in support of  "No, it is Local Government's Failure/Responsibility."  |  2 years ago
Traffic is issue of govt and not TATA, govt has to provide aods which are wide, smooth and traffic / conjestion free
Sumanta Mukherjee  |  Argues in support of  |  3 years ago
yes even i agree with pradeep here that its the failure of the government for not providing proper infrastructure in the cities where more number of people are coming in search of jobs and this has created to an unprecedented growth of population in...
MAJETY CHANDRA SHEKHAR  |  Argues in support of  "No, it is Local Government's Failure/Responsibility."  |  3 years ago
Yes, the dream of a middle class man will be true by TATA NANO. But the company shall see not only the profits but also see that the government takes step to improve the infrastruer in the cities where the percentage is only 6% - 8% . The said...
 support: 
 
 
Debate: "Do you think Launch of TATA Nano & possible huge sales, add to Traffic problems of cities??" deleted from your view.
Undo
 
(rate this)
INFLUENCE 
13
VS
5
 NOT INTERESTED
mvaravind  |  Argues in support of  "INFLUENCE"  |  1 year ago
Since there is no enough fine resourses....
Sumanta Mukherjee  |  Argues in support of  |  3 years ago
The country being corrupt from top to bottom one can see that no body wants to have a alternative fuel where they think that they might be deprived from their benefits that they are having now so, they are not really thinking about the future and not...
Bellala Gopinatha Rao  |  Argues in support of  "INFLUENCE"  |  3 years ago
iT IS THE ATTRACTION OF BENEFIT TOP BUROCRETS GETTING FROM PETROLIUM AND AUTOMOBILE INDUSTRY INFLUENCES THE ADMINISTRATOR , OTHERWISE WHAT OUR RESEARH AND DEVELOPEMENT DEPT IS DOING? fRIENDS WHAT IS YOUR OPINION ? OR ELSE IS THERE ANY OTHER REASON..?
 support: 
 
 
Debate: "WHY STILL NO ALTERNATIVE FOR FUEL?" deleted from your view.
Undo
 
(rate this)
Yes 
3
VS
3
 No
Parag Arora  |  Argues in support of  "Yes"  |  3 years ago
India being a booming economy, introduction of F1 race can pump in real bucks from the perspective of an economist. Such high net worth events should open opportunities for development of our infrastructures and investments. I am not sure how it...
Sumanta Mukherjee  |  Argues in support of  |  3 years ago
India has come a long way in terms of technology and some of the best minds in the world are right here in India. There are just too many political and other influential people standing in the way of getting something done. The ones who do want to be...
 support: 
 
 
Debate: "Is India ready for Formula 1?" deleted from your view.
Undo
 
(rate this)
Yes 
1
VS
3
 No
Sumanta Mukherjee  |  Argues in support of  |  3 years ago
With this the world would not be seeing meaner machines any more because when it comes to such bikes the only thing with which they can compete is speed and now the have to restrict it. Take the example of Hayabusa, it can go upto 500Ks an hour but as...
Ramakrishna Ganji  |  Argues in support of  "Yes"  |  3 years ago
Yes, this race for speed was generating a lot of wastage of resources and also this was giving the anti-social elements of the society a chance to get ahead in their wrong doings, so I think is is a good decision.
Ted Green  |  Argues in support of  "No"  |  3 years ago
why? Motorbikes are made for racing, and racing needs as much speed as possible. Does not make any sense to me at all. My answer is no, I dont think its justified at all.
 support: 
 
 
Debate: "The motorbike companies are not allowed to exceed a certain speed limit. Is is justified?" deleted from your view.
Undo
 
(rate this)
Yes 
6
VS
5
 No
alok sapre  |  Argues in support of  "No"  |  2 years ago
In india non of the tax implemented to depricate use of product was effective. Take example of tabaco products or liquer etc. Government had lavied hefty taxes on these products but it never helped in reducing consumption of this products. Better...
Phani Mohan krishna  |  Argues in support of  "Yes"  |  2 years ago
yes it helps as by human nature we fear Penal actions and when there is a tax on excess carbon foot print you try to minimise and look for alternates. india should stride this path.
BEENA AGARWAL  |  Argues in support of  "Yes"  |  3 years ago
Yes of coursee carbon tax is essential for all industries which emits CO2 gas as well as other toxic corbn gases.To reduce global wrming and pollutionit is neccessary .  Obviously there are parameters to reduce carbon emission as plantation of...
 support: 
 
 
Debate: " Can carbon tax can help in the plans to combat global warming?" deleted from your view.
Undo
 
(rate this)
Yes 
3
VS
3
 No
shuvankar dey  |  Argues in support of  "Yes"  |  1 year ago
mamta banerjee first time new project tata vista place singur
andyappan  |  Argues in support of  "No"  |  3 years ago
TATA IS  INDIA   NOT  MARUTI  ,JAPANESE  TATA  NANO  Vs andy  nano volume  200 cc  fuel 1.0 Lit @ 5 Lit/hr/1000 cc andy engine 1/3 volume for same HP   vol=630/3=210 cc say 200 cc fuel cost per hour =  $1/Lit* fuel/hr= 1*1=1 fare cost/hour= fare...
 support: 
 
 
Debate: "Is Mamta Banerjee right on Tata Nano's Singur Project?" deleted from your view.
Undo
 
(rate this)
GM and other leading global automakers are setting up factories around St. Petersburg, Russia, while Ford is expanding its plant for the third time in six years to meet the growing demand in the country. Auto sales have tripled in the past five years here. If this is not enough then the global market ratings are a full proof indication of how the russian auto market is doing. General Motors Corp.'s half-built plant on the muddy outskirts of St. Petersburg won't roll out its first vehicle until November, but the new Russian hires are already hard at work. In a warehouse near the factory entrance, young men and women drill bolts into car-sized wooden crates, spray-paint them and practice spot...
 
 
Trends: "Russian revolution: The world's hottest auto market" deleted from your view.
Undo
 
(rate this)
Ramakrishna Ganji  |  Answered  |  3 years ago
A new milestone, yes but it's very early days yet. What if there are serious production issues that require a recall?
 
 
Answer: "Will the launches of the Bajaj and Tata small cars signal the coming of age of the Indian auto industry?" deleted from your view.
Undo
 
(rate this)
Ted Green  |  Answered  |  3 years ago
I beat one of those security systems 15 years ago, I sure hope they have improved. Now with SATcom based two way technology, yeah they can disable the auto remotely, or start it, and even unlock the doors.
Ramakrishna Ganji  |  Answered  |  4 years ago
I think Early Warning System is better, It lets you know when an intruder is attempting to get away with your vehicle, allowing you to check on it immediately. Car owners carrying a Early Warning system has a Key Pass that sends a signal to the...
 
 
Answer: "With more of vehicle thefts going around I think it time to look for the best anti-theft device. So Which anti-theft..." deleted from your view.
Undo
Follow me on
TooStep
 
 
Contributions and Connections
 
 
88 Contribution Points
0
0 Expert Badges
[?]
1
Connections
1
Following
1
Followers
[?]